• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more
Hate crimes shouldn't exist. All crimes are hate crimes.

Well, except crimes of passion. They're luuuurve crimes.
 
Hate crimes shouldn't exist. All crimes are hate crimes.

Well, except crimes of passion. They're luuuurve crimes.

Motivation has always been considered an aggravating or mitigating factor in crimes tried under common law systems. When the motivation and effect of a crime is to intimidate or oppresses a group of people wider than the immediate victims I don't see a problem with a harsher sentence. When local legal systems proved unable to bring the perpetrators of these crimes to justice I don't see a problem with trying them at a federal level.
What's your argument against the concept of a hate crime?
The name?
 
And there's one less Aryan Brotherhood member breathing our air.
 


If you see an article you think is worth sharing, it's a good idea to quote or summarize the parts you think are worthy of people's attention. Links expire; and when they do, an OP consisting simply of a link is of little value. That's why tags are based on thread content rather than link content.

You're right: this is a good story. Here are some of the key details:

In the three weeks following the 9/11 attacks, Dallas white supremacist Mark Stroman set out on a mission to kill Muslim men. Later he said he was angry that government officials "hadn't done their job, so he was going to do it for them." Four days after the World Trade Center fell, Stroman killed Waqar Hasan, a 46-year-old Pakistani man, with a gunshot to the head in Hasan's convenience store. Six days after that he shot Rais Bhuiyan in the face at a gas station. Bhuiyan went blind in one eye, but survived. Lastly, on October 4, Stroman shot Vasudev Patel, an Indian immigrant who was Hindu, killing him instantly. Stroman was caught after killing Patel and has since pleaded guilty to his crimes.

Under Texas' notoriously strict capital punishment laws, Stroman was sentenced to death. He is set to be killed by lethal injection on Wednesday. It turns out, however, that one of the biggest opponents of his death sentence is also the most unlikely: Bhuiyan, Stroman's sole surviving victim...


There are a couple of good diaries about this at Daily Kos: 9/11 Hate Crime Victim Takes A Stand (a brief summary of the case by Amnesty International), and Oh. My. GOD!!!, a user diary which made the recommended list. There's also an excellent write-up of this at ThinkProgress (which is what the rec list DK diary draws upon).

Tanya Somanader at ThinkProgress said:
On September 21, 2001, a 41-year old white supremacist from Dallas walked into a gas station and opened fire on people he believed to be Arabs. Enraged by the 9/11 attacks, the shooter, Mark Anthony Stroman, killed an Indian man who was Hindu and a Pakistani man who was Muslim.
Rais Bhuiyan, a 37-year old Muslim Air Force pilot from Bangladesh, was Stroman’s third victim. Shot in the face at close range with a double-barrel gun, Bhuiyan survived the attack, suffering now from partial blindness. After admitting to the attacks, Stroman is scheduled to be executed tomorrow in Texas.

Bhuiyan, the lone survivor of Stroman’s attack, is now trying to save his life. After the attack, Bhuiyan told the New York Times that he spent his time “simply struggling to survive in this country.” But pulling on his profound capacity for forgiveness, he has spent the last several months petitioning Texas to spare Stroman’s life. When asked why, Bhuiyan said his Islamic faith taught him not to seek vengeance and that what Stroman “did was out of ignorance” about Islam:

Q Mr. Stroman has admitted trying to kill you. Why are you trying to save his life?

A I was raised very well by my parents and teachers. They raised me with good morals and strong faith. They taught me to put yourself in others’ shoes. Even if they hurt you, don’t take revenge. Forgive them. Move on. It will bring something good to you and them...​


The ThinkProgress piece includes excerpts from New York Times interviews with Bhuiyan (by telephone) and with Stroman (by letter). Longer versions of these interviews can be found in the New York Times article The Hated and the Hater, Both Touched by Crime


There! Now I tag the thread.
 
Last edited:
I admire his moral convictions and his willingness and ability to stick to them.

Hey, did anybody consider the possibility that this is an elaborate suicide attempt?
 
Hey, did anybody consider the possibility that this is an elaborate suicide attempt?
I'm glad the State of Texas helped Stroman complete the task of offing himself. It is really the most effective cure for what is most wrong with his kind.
 
What's your argument against the concept of a hate crime? The name?

That it is punishing, not for a crime against any particular person, but against the effect it might have on groups.

When local legal systems proved unable to bring the perpetrators of these crimes to justice I don't see a problem with trying them at a federal level.


As sympathetic I am to this, it *did* have a downside: the growing federal power made state and local governments in effect its servants, thus de facto destroying federalism, making the USA one large state run from Washington, DC. (I am exaggerating for effect but you get the idea). This might lead in time to despotism, since a major guarantee of limited government had been removed.
 
Last edited:
A hate-crime victim demanding mercy for his attacker, is a beautiful thing.

However, this man committed murder simply due to the supposed ethnicity of his victim. He was found guilty by a jury of his peers and sentenced to death by said jury.

Justice was warranted and justice was done.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom