Split Thread Has your country ever done anything that you objected to?

1. saying sorry for torture we never actually performed.
2. buyed F/A 18's, wants to update the F/A 18's already
3. Sold our Goldreserves
4. Indirectly murdered Jews in WWII
 
1) Selling Alaska to the US
2) Not joining the US in Iraq
3) Not building more nuclear power plants
4) Not building a bridge from Vancouver to Victoria -- $1100 for my trucks to cross by ferry is too much!
5) Letting US pressure determine recreational drug policy


2 through 5 apply to Canada - but 1 would apply to Russia would it not?

Are you Russo-Canadian?

and I agree with 3 through 5 but number 2 is a reason I'm proud of my country..;) Only wish we did the same with Afghanistan!
 
2 through 5 apply to Canada - but 1 would apply to Russia would it not?

Are you Russo-Canadian?

and I agree with 3 through 5 but number 2 is a reason I'm proud of my country..;) Only wish we did the same with Afghanistan!

1) is a gaff on my part. That was something I heard a long time ago and never did look it up.
 
Well Britain never should have caved as much on the Oregon settlement.

Bc should be bigger!
 
Oh lord, we've just been downhill ever since that silly War of Independence. The real question is has it ever done anything good? I can think of killing Hitler and going to the moon. Every other good thing was just to solve the crap we had done before.
 
We keep sending refugees back even when that puts them in severe danger. We tend to bend over backwards for major powers even though allying ourselves with smaller nations would often not just be better for humanity, but also in our own self interest (equal partners make the best deals). We keep exporting weapons to countries where they are used for illegal wars, civil wars, or contribute to a cycle of military escalation. Our arrests (unlike our prisons) are frequently not up to acceptable humanitarian standards. Our foreign minister previously sold his political influence for money by fronting a company that had close ties with the Sudanese government, aiding them and giving them motives for perpetrating crimes against humanity, and then we allowed him back in our highest political echelons.
 
2) Not joining the US in Iraq
and I agree with 3 through 5 but number 2 is a reason I'm proud of my country..;)
You know, I can certainly understand someone being opposed to the Iraq invasion, for a number of reasons. (Lack of proof of WMD, risk of civilian deaths, etc.), and I can also understand why someone would be happy Canada sat out of the invasion.

But is that actually a reason to be proud of Canada?

After all, its not like Canada actually sacrificed anything through its decision. And its not like were were some lone voice standing up against the 'evil' of the Americans.

And its not like the decision to stay away from the invasion was some grand far-sighted action. From reports I had heard, the government of the day was actually planning on joining the invasion, until they realized that there might be negative political ramifications in a Quebec election that was upcoming.

You can't even claim that Canada's decision was in support of some free, open democracy facing overthrow. By all accounts, Saddam was a rotten b*stard, and I expect you'd find anyone with even the tiniest shred of civilized behavior who will think his actions in persecuting groups like the Kurds and Marsh Arabs was something to be condemned, not praised. A free and open democracy is a better system of government than an oppressive dictatorship; the only question is whether the invasion A) would have accomplished that, and B) would have been worth the risk to the civilian population.

So, you have a decsion that was likely made for crass political purposes, that had the side effect of suggesting that its OK for dictators like Saddam to slaughter innocent civilians.
Only wish we did the same with Afghanistan!
So you think its perfectly OK for women to be forced to where Burkhas, be forbidden from working outside the home, and for young girls to be banned from advanced education.

Sounds good to me.
 
I think the Iraq war was an massive waste of money. If it was just the money I would still be mad but what really pisses me off is the death and maiming of some many people. Saddam was a brutal dictator but it's obvious the people had the government that would work for them at the time.

I object to our lack of investment in space technology. We should immediately put a 100 year ban on all taxes related to development of space technology. All industrial processes harmful to the environment need to be moved off planet with preferably finished goods being dropped from orbit. Power would be beamed down from solar power satellites. Bottom line, we need the resources available in space for our long term survival. I say tap them as soon as possible...

I object to the needless criminalization of people in our society who use drugs for recreational reasons. Legalize!

I object to the massive federal bureaucracy that continues to invade our lives. For example the IRS, dept. of homeland security, ATF, etc. etc. Taxes are too high because they waste huge portions of our money on crap. We also shouldn't have income tax as I consider this an invasion of personal property. I am in favor of a consumption tax (with exemption for those in poverty) which means that companies will have to disclose sales but I don't think companies should have the same rights as people anyway. Bottom line, I want a smaller or at least a more efficient government overall.

Anyway I object to a lot of stuff. I think our government is pretty stupid and wasteful. I will also admit that there are many countires FAR FAR FAR worse. This place is awesome to live if you want to work hard and make your mark.
 
I don't object to anything my country has ever done.



(anyone got any spare vaseline?)
 
Out of curiosity I'd like to know what make you think it was illegal? I mean I can understand opposition to the war, even if I disagree with it, but it seems talking about degrees of legality in the context of international wars is rather nebulous.

If you want the very short and imprecise version, you can legally fight a war if the other guy starts it, if the other guy is about to start it, or if the UN security council says you can.

The US government did its best to pretend that the war was legal on the basis that Hussein was about to start it, which was provably bollocks and they knew it. They've also got the usual net stooges out in force pretending that the UN security council said they could, which is also total bollocks. Absent such a justification it's simply an illegal war of aggression.
 
I don't object to anything my country has ever done.

I was born in Costa Rica and my family moved out of the country when I was one year old. Haven't kept up with affairs back home so I join you there. Ignorance is bliss. :covereyes
 
If you want the very short and imprecise version, you can legally fight a war if the other guy starts it, if the other guy is about to start it, or if the UN security council says you can.

So an American intervention into Rwanda or Sudan (to stop the genocides) would have been illegal?
 
So an American intervention into Rwanda or Sudan (to stop the genocides) would have been illegal?

It is doubtful that America would intervene anywhere for such purely altruistic reasons.

(Happy Birthday to you, Travis!)
 
You know, I can certainly understand someone being opposed to the Iraq invasion, for a number of reasons. (Lack of proof of WMD, risk of civilian deaths, etc.), and I can also understand why someone would be happy Canada sat out of the invasion.

But is that actually a reason to be proud of Canada?

After all, its not like Canada actually sacrificed anything through its decision. And its not like were were some lone voice standing up against the 'evil' of the Americans.
Since Canada was always considered as the USA's lapdog, I'm proud my country for this decision because Chrétien actually stood up to the USA for once.

And its not like the decision to stay away from the invasion was some grand far-sighted action. From reports I had heard, the government of the day was actually planning on joining the invasion, until they realized that there might be negative political ramifications in a Quebec election that was upcoming.
What reports are those? Chrétien was near the end of his mandate, on his way out. He had nothing to lose. On the contrary, you could argue that it's the only good decision Chrétien ever made because it was the only decision not done out of fear of elections.

So, you have a decsion that was likely made for crass political purposes, that had the side effect of suggesting that its OK for dictators like Saddam to slaughter innocent civilians.
What complete disingenuous BS!

So you think its perfectly OK for women to be forced to where Burkhas, be forbidden from working outside the home, and for young girls to be banned from advanced education.

Sounds good to me.
I support the invasion of Afghanistan, but really, these disgusting strawmen have to stop. They say a lot more about you than they do about Praktik.

And for what it's worth, the expulsion of the Taliban did very little in helping women in Afghanistan. They are only slightly less worse-off than before. Baby steps, I suppose, but it's not as if they are suddenly free women with decent quality of life just yet.
 
Saved France - Twice!!

Next time, let the Germans have it.

Besides, I like German wine better.

DDWW
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom