Halton Arp Replacing Big Bang Creationism

Sillygism:

1) I don't care what Creationists think.
2) Jeffrey is a Creationist.
3) Therefore, I don't care what Jeffrey thinks.

I really object to the title of this thread. he title, Big Bang Creationism,
strongly implies that the Big Bang model is a subset of Creationist theory.
Obviously, it is not.

I would love to argue the point. However, I see that you agree with me.

I may be stating the obvious (to me) or I could be completely wrong, but I think Jeffrey has created the combined term simply as an epithet toward astronomers/astrophysicists and not as any reference to religion or YECs.
 
I think you're misunderstanding Jeffrey's reference to "Big Bang Creationism." There's no separation there; to Jeffrey, proponents of the BB theory are Creationists. I think it's supposed to be scathing; it really just comes across as a childish strawman, since the methodologies are complete opposites.

I was confused wrt the reference. If its supposed to be pithy I'd suggest that "pith" is pronounced without the lisp.
 
I may be stating the obvious (to me) or I could be completely wrong, but I think Jeffrey has created the combined term simply as an epithet toward astronomers/astrophysicists and not as any reference to religion or YECs.

I present the following evidence that Jeffrey is a Creationist. Jeffrey's in another thread claimed that 'Stephen J. Caruthers is a badass'. He lauded him for 'disproving Black Holes, Big Bang and other woo'. It turns out that 'Stephen J. Caruthers' is YEC. Caruthers video suggests that he is extremely ignorant YEC. So on the assumption that only a YEC would take another YEC seriously, Jeffreys is a YEC.

Which doesn't answer my questions as to where the blue-shifted quasars are. Hey, I am willing to play. Show me a blue shifted object that could be a quasar and I will discuss it. I won't discuss it in terms of YEC, though.
 
It turns out that 'Stephen J. Caruthers' is YEC. Caruthers video suggests that he is extremely ignorant YEC.
I am not sure that is correct, Darwin123.
The video is Jeffrey's where all he does is spout nonsense about a list of crank papers by Stephen J. Crothers.
I think that Stephen J. Crothers is just a half-educated, anti-relativity crank.
Stephen J. Crothers (born 1957) is a handyman/gardener and part-time amateur scientist who claims that black holes do not exist, and are neither predicted by nor compatible with General Relativity.[2][3] His body of work consists primarily of vanity-published articles that he posts at his personal website;[4] thus steering clear of the peer-review process. He has also been a guest speaker at several informal conferences held by the Electric Universe crowd.[5][6]
 
Yes but they say he's always been there. Can the Big Bang have been banging for all eternity?
I think "all eternity" is redundant; it's an infinity so some of it is either a finite time or a proportion of an infinity, which is infinity anyway. I think. Infinities are tricksy.

The past can't be infinite (an eternity) because if it was it wouldn't have passed yet. The creator can't have an eternal past because it would never have been time for him to create anything. No event can happen if it requires an eternity to pass before it does, since an eternity never passes, by definition.

Therefore, what's the story on this creator? Inquiring minds want to know.

All this is with reference to time as we understand it, not whatever bizarrity goes on inside a singularity or whatever place a creator might exist in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom