HAHA, GOTCHA! Let's investigate atheists instead of atheism.

Okay, fine. Let's just get this out there so that yrreg can't use it against anyone. How many of you ascribe to a view of morality that links virtue and happiness (aka eudaimonism)? What kind of relationship is there between virtue and happiness? Do hedonism and satisfaction of desire lead to what is good and virtuous?

Yes I know those sound rhetorical, but this is basically what yrreg is accusing atheists of.

I suspect the "plan" is more like this:

Research shows that atheists are less happy than theists? HAHA! GOTCHA! Atheists obviously only deny God out of misery and bitterness.

Research shows that atheists are happier than theists? HAHA! GOTCHA! Atheists are hedonists who only care about their own pleasure.

Research shows that atheists are equally happy as theists? HAHA! DOUBLE GOTCHA! Atheists are hedonists who only care about their own pleasure, and can't even succeed at that!
 
http://midus.wisc.edu/miduspis/ryff.php

An actual answer to your question. Someone who investigates Eudaimonia by, age, gender, socioeconomic status, ethnic/minority status as well as by the experiences, challenges, and transitions individuals confront as they age.

Ah, but even this may be ineligible according to the terms of the OP. Is the standard of the investigation so lax as to be not even approximately forensic, or has it been done with such rigour that it would have to be described as entirely forensic? The OP specified "almost forensic", which is a narrow window to hit.

Dave
 
I guess I'm a little unclear on all this. Since atheism is the default state of human beings when they're born (to the best of my reckoning, anyway), doesn't it make more sense to study the effects of religion on the efforts of humanity to reach the aforementioned "eudaimonia"? From my limited understanding, I'd say the results on that one are mixed, to say the least. However, I could also say that about atheism, I imagine, and not be too terribly wrong.

In any case, Gerry, I'd say you have a long way to go to make much of a case about anything. Judging from the frequency and quality of replies to your posts thus far, I'd say you have a long way to go in making any case about anything. Of course, if you're simply a troll, I suppose you've succeeded.

Bravo?



If you enjoy humor, I do also and even more than you anyone, to the nth degree.


You did not read my insight (last week to another atheist who brought up babies born atheists) into that stock answer you have taken from your masters in obsolete atheism who are worthy subjects for investigations.

You say that babies are born atheists.

Haha, gotcha!

And again a second time to a previous atheist poster who brought up that shallow non-brainer.

Not now attending to babies and their knowledge of God in their infancy, I will just say this for the erudition of atheists here -- as I already said last week (one can't never repeat too much for the sake of pedagogy in regard to one's fellow posters here of the atheist me too fad):

You guys don't seem to have ever reached the age of reason, traditionally reckoned at seven years of age.​

Of course kids are nowadays much more precocious than when Kant was talking about the categorical imperative.

But give it to atheists to never ever reach the age of reason, much less intelligence, which reason and intelligence is what makes man different and better qualified to know God, from ants and monkeys.




Yrreg
 
humor..But give it to atheists to never ever reach the age of reason, much less intelligence, which reason and intelligence is what makes man different and better qualified to know God, from ants and monkeys...

You think you have reached the age of reason. Think again, you clearly haven't. You argue muchlike a confused adolescent, railing against concepts she has no intellectual equipment to understand. A confused bufoon, a strident gainsayer contending against logical arguements.
Grow up.
 
Last edited:
You think you have reached the age of reason. Think again, you clearly haven't. You argue muchlike a confused adolescent, railing against concepts she has no intellectual equipment to understand. A confused bufoon, a strident gainsayer contending against logical arguements.
Grow up.


When people write like that, it is a testimony that I am making headway and getting nearer to paydirt.



Yrreg
 
I'm looking for research into the mental state of combative anOdinist trolls. Looks like I'm in the right place.
 
When people write like that, it is a testimony that I am making headway and getting nearer to paydirt.



Yrreg


Galileo fallacy (AKA appeal to pity)

As Carl once said:

...the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
 
Last edited:
To a child, mother is God.

Yrreg said:
Not now attending to babies and their knowledge of God in their infancy, I will just say this for the erudition of atheists here -- as I already said last week (one can't never repeat too much for the sake of pedagogy in regard to one's fellow posters here of the atheist me too fad):

You guys don't seem to have ever reached the age of reason, traditionally reckoned at seven years of age.

Of course kids are nowadays much more precocious than when Kant was talking about the categorical imperative.

But give it to atheists to never ever reach the age of reason, much less intelligence, which reason and intelligence is what makes man different and better qualified to know God, from ants and monkeys.

So brainwashing is a sign of maturity?
 
No it means the atheist is right and the theists are wrong.

If one defines "atheist" in such a way (merely lacking a belief) as to include newborn babies, then there's nothing for an atheist to be right about.
 
Last edited:
Not the "are babies atheists" thing again.

Infants don't believe in God any more than they vote for the Democratic party, put faith in horoscopes, or understand that the Earth is round. We're talking incredibly simple lifeforms here. A newborn does not have self-awareness. He or she can't comprehend that a ball doesn't seize existing when it goes outside your field of vision. It doesn't understand that 1+1=2. You can do this experiment at home, yourself. Put a sheet up and put one ball after another behind it. Remove one of the balls covertly and remove the sheet, revealing only one ball. Up to a certain age, the baby doesn't understand that if you have a ball and add another, the result should be two balls, and finds nothing amiss. I could go on and on, and I've even been told that humans don't reach the intelligence level of dogs until the age of two.

But they understand God, and believe in Him? I somehow doubt it.
 
Last edited:
yrreg said:
It's almost impossible to talk with God's deniers, viz., atheists, about what they are denying, because they are bent on tergiversation ...
Ask me anything. I promise not to tergiversate.

~~ Paul
 
If one defines "atheist" in such a way (merely lacking a belief) as to include newborn babies, then there's nothing for an atheist to be right about.


Good answer.

I know about 1/3 of all internet threads end up being a debate over semantics*, but this response shows why this is often necessary.



* - And 83% of all statistics are made up on the spot.
 
When people write like that, it is a testimony that I am making headway and getting nearer to paydirt.



Yrreg

See, this is why we need atheist buses. Fundamentalists won't be capable of looking at them, and will swiftly become eligible for Darwin awards.
 
Ask me anything. I promise not to tergiversate.

~~ Paul



Okay, why do you or do you really take Madalyn Murray O'Hair for a person of emulation by you atheists and consequently for your babies once they reach the age of reason?


That is why I am now concerned with investigating atheists instead of atheism.

To fair evaluation she did not seem to have retained any residual ethical values even though she got born and grew up in a traditional theist society of the Christendom West, specifically in the Christian by great majority, USA.


You look up to people like Madalyn and then complain why the vast majority of Americans look at you as the most untrustworthy minority in America bar none.



Yrreg
 
You look up to people like Madalyn and then complain why the vast majority of Americans look at you as the most untrustworthy minority in America bar none.

Gee gerry, the search function tells me you're the first person to mention her name on this thread. You wouldn't be being dishonest again would you? I hear god hates that.

eta: You'll notice I did not compare you to David Waters.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom