Gravitational Time Dilation, Shapiro, GPS, Gravitational Redshift, etc

DeiRenDopa

Master Poster
Joined
Feb 25, 2008
Messages
2,582
The motivation for this thread again comes from the Black holes thread, specifically this post.

Clocks at different elevations (or altitudes) do not stay synchronized.

GPSs (the systems) require 'clock adjustments' in order to function as intended.

Radio signals passing near the Sun suffer delays (the Shapiro time delay), on their way to and from bouncing off Venus, compared with when the signals do not pass near the Sun.

Gamma rays of a very precise frequency emitted vertically upward will be seen, by a detector some distance above, to have a different frequency (gravitational redshift).

All four effects have been observed, in multiple, independent experiments, in many different physical settings and environments. In every case the observed effect matches that predicted/expected by GR, quantitatively, to the estimated experimental/observational uncertainties (some of which are quite small).

My question: to what extent can we say these four are, in fact, independent tests of GR?

For example, are there different parameters, in GR, that need to be set, in order to make predictions (other than the various masses, and how they are distributed)?
 
Have a read of The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment by Clifford M Will. See this on page 65:

"Furthermore, the predictions of general relativity are fixed; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing can be changed".

It's well worth reading, not just for the information on the various tests and how other theories predict similar or distinct results, but for the history too. Whilst not directly related to your question, IMHO it is important when discussing relativity to know that the history has been rewritten in popular media. See this on page 5:

"Although special relativity itself never benefited from the kind of 'crucial' experiments, such as the perihelion advance of Mercury and the deflection of light, that contributed so much to the initial acceptance of GR and to the fame of Einstein, the steady accumulation of experimental support, together with the successful merger of special relativity with quantum mechanics, led to its being accepted by mainstream physicists by the late 1920s"

The above concerns SR rather than GR, but concerning the latter, see the mention of "Hibernation" on page 2 and this on page 4:

"We now regard the principle of equivalence as the foundation, not of Newtonian gravity or of GR, but of the broader idea that spacetime is curved. Much of this viewpoint can be traced back to Robert Dicke, who contributed crucial ideas about the foundations of gravitation theory between 1960 and 1965".

The Golden age of general relativity on wikipedia reiterates this:

"The golden age of general relativity is the period roughly from 1960 to 1975 during which the study of general relativity,[1] which had previously been regarded as something of a curiosity, entered the mainstream of theoretical physics...

Other paradigm shifts included a growing appreciation of the:
* Role of curvature in general relativity
* Theoretical importance of black holes..."
 
:popcorn1

Page 65 of the actual paper
http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/0510072v2.pdf

We find that general relativity has held up under extensive experimental scrutiny. The question
then arises, why bother to continue to test it? One reason is that gravity is a fundamental
interaction of nature, and as such requires the most solid empirical underpinning we can provide.
Another is that all attempts to quantize gravity and to unify it with the other forces suggest that
the standard general relativity of Einstein is not likely to be the last word. Furthermore, the
predictions of general relativity are fixed; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing
can be changed. Thus every test of the theory is either a potentially deadly test or a possible probe
for new physics. Although it is remarkable that this theory, born 90 years ago out of almost pure
thought, has managed to survive every test, the possibility of finding a discrepancy will continue
to drive experiments for years to come
 
Last edited:
Have a read of The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment by Clifford M Will. See this on page 65:

"Furthermore, the predictions of general relativity are fixed; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing can be changed".

Note, though, that they consider a version of GR in which the cosmological constant ΛC is zero, as they point out in section 3.1.1:

Throughout this article, we ignore the cosmological constant ΛC. We do this despite
recent evidence, from supernova data, of an accelerating universe, which would indicate either a
non-zero cosmological constant or a dynamical “dark energy” contributing about 70 percent of
the critical density. Although ΛC has significance for quantum field theory, quantum gravity, and
cosmology, on the scale of the solar-system or of stellar systems its effects are negligible, for the
values of ΛC inferred from supernova observations.

So while that quoted claim is fine for the purposes of their paper, in a more general context I'd say that ΛC counts as a parameter of the sort that DeiRenDopa mentioned.
 
Last edited:
Have a read of The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment by Clifford M Will. See this on page 65:

"Furthermore, the predictions of general relativity are fixed; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing can be changed".
Wow, Farsight, you really quote mined that review. So here is the context
We find that general relativity has held up under extensive experimental scrutiny. The question then arises, why bother to continue to test it? One reason is that gravity is a fundamental interaction of nature, and as such requires the most solid empirical underpinning we can provide. Another is that all attempts to quantize gravity and to unify it with the other forces suggest that the standard general relativity of Einstein is not likely to be the last word.Furthermore, the predictions of general relativity are fixed; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing can be changed. Thus every test of the theory is either a potentially deadly test or a possible probe for new physics. Although it is remarkable that this theory, born 90 years ago out of almost pure thought, has managed to survive every test, the possibility of finding a discrepancy will continue to drive experiments for years to come.

Their point about "no adjustable constants" seems to be that a given solution posesses a certain set of predictions that are not adjusted by changing a constant in the Einstein field equations (EFE). This is true for a fixed cosmological constant.
However the act of deriving a solution from the EFE introduces parameters such as mass and density.
 
My question: to what extent can we say these four are, in fact, independent tests of GR?

For example, are there different parameters, in GR, that need to be set, in order to make predictions (other than the various masses, and how they are distributed)?

In GR proper there aren't any parameters other than G_N, the constant that defines the overall strength of gravity. You could regard the cosmological constant as another parameter, but you can also think of it as a vacuum energy (and therefore on the same footing as things like the positions of masses), and in any case if it is non-zero it is far too small to affect the experiments you mention.

The lack of parameters makes GR a good (easily falsifiable) theory, and every such test is independent in the sense that some putative alternative theory might make the same predictions as GR for some of those experiments, but different predictions for others.

Of the four specific tests you mention, the first two are more or less the same, at least if you accept special relativistic time dilation as already established. Shapiro time delay is a good test that probes more than one aspect of GR. Redshift of gamma rays is pretty much a consequence of conservation of energy - still a good test, but perhaps slightly less sharp than the others (unless the redshift is very large, then you're getting into the non-linear regime and it's quite interesting).
 
Last edited:
"Although special relativity itself never benefited from the kind of 'crucial' experiments, such as the perihelion advance of Mercury and the deflection of light, that contributed so much to the initial acceptance of GR and to the fame of Einstein, "

Huh? Michaelson-Morley?
 
Thanks everyone, for your various responses.

In Earth-based labs, and within our solar system, tests of one-parameter GR are relatively straight-forward, although they probe only weak field limits (as I understand it anyway).

When it comes to astronomy (or if you prefer, astrophysics), the tests are necessarily less simple; after all, the electromagnetic radiation we detect (and that's all we've got, so far) doesn't come with clear unambiguous labels! Nonetheless, some strong field conditions may be testable (binary and double pulsars, SgrA*'s and the M87 SMBH event horizon, in-spiral GWR, to take just a few examples). At larger scales, the challenge comes with the label 'dark matter' (short for 'cold, dark, non-baryonic dark matter'). Overwhelmingly, the observational evidence favors a 'cold' form of mass which couldn't care less about photons (as we don't know of any baryonic form of matter like this, we call it 'non-baryonic'); but ... maybe what these observations are telling us is that GR needs some tweaking, or a dramatic overhaul.

At even larger scales, the observational results favors a 'cosmological constant'. But the constraints are much less stringent than for 'dark matter'. And the 'tension' with quantum theories - 120 orders of magnitude!! or, perhaps, a mere ~60! :p - if Λ is 'vacuum energy', is vastly bigger than any which an experimentalist, here on Earth, has ever had to contemplate. But there's nothing new there; GR and quantum theory are desperately, drastically, mutually inconsistent. Pity is, the regime in which that conflict is most dramatically manifest is far, far, far, far, far beyond the reach of any lab-based experiments ...
 


No.

My mommy taught me to be careful what garbage I let into my head.

I've learned not to pay any attention to your recommendations.


It's a very good paper, and it's relevant to this thread.

Its section 2.1 describes a wealth of experimental evidence in support of the Einstein Equivalence Principle.

Clifford M Will said:
The Einstein equivalence principle is the heart and soul of gravitational theory, for it is possible to argue convincingly that if EEP is valid, then gravitation must be a “curved spacetime” phenomenon, in other words, the effects of gravity must be equivalent to the effects of living in a curved spacetime.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom