DeiRenDopa
Master Poster
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2008
- Messages
- 2,582
The motivation for this thread again comes from the Black holes thread, specifically this post.
Clocks at different elevations (or altitudes) do not stay synchronized.
GPSs (the systems) require 'clock adjustments' in order to function as intended.
Radio signals passing near the Sun suffer delays (the Shapiro time delay), on their way to and from bouncing off Venus, compared with when the signals do not pass near the Sun.
Gamma rays of a very precise frequency emitted vertically upward will be seen, by a detector some distance above, to have a different frequency (gravitational redshift).
All four effects have been observed, in multiple, independent experiments, in many different physical settings and environments. In every case the observed effect matches that predicted/expected by GR, quantitatively, to the estimated experimental/observational uncertainties (some of which are quite small).
My question: to what extent can we say these four are, in fact, independent tests of GR?
For example, are there different parameters, in GR, that need to be set, in order to make predictions (other than the various masses, and how they are distributed)?
Clocks at different elevations (or altitudes) do not stay synchronized.
GPSs (the systems) require 'clock adjustments' in order to function as intended.
Radio signals passing near the Sun suffer delays (the Shapiro time delay), on their way to and from bouncing off Venus, compared with when the signals do not pass near the Sun.
Gamma rays of a very precise frequency emitted vertically upward will be seen, by a detector some distance above, to have a different frequency (gravitational redshift).
All four effects have been observed, in multiple, independent experiments, in many different physical settings and environments. In every case the observed effect matches that predicted/expected by GR, quantitatively, to the estimated experimental/observational uncertainties (some of which are quite small).
My question: to what extent can we say these four are, in fact, independent tests of GR?
For example, are there different parameters, in GR, that need to be set, in order to make predictions (other than the various masses, and how they are distributed)?
