GoSylviaBrowne

Not in the least.

I just don't think that trolling is the way to convince anyone of anything.

It does nothing to make skepticism look reasoned or intelligent.

It makes it look belligerent and juvenile.

I think it only serves to further alienate those you might want to reach, and to further intrench them in their current beliefs.

That's my thoughts on it.

Your Mileage May Vary.

I completely agree. I am again impressed by RSL's integrity.

So here's a site created because of of RSL's site. RSL expresses that he would rather people not go to the site and mess with them, and yet people do so anyway. Not cool. I guess skepticism does not equal maturity. Sigh.
 
I agree with Robert's stance on trolling, but I did find the following entry in the guest book very funny. It just had to have been posted by a skeptic.

At home, here in England, I am sometimes sad that there is such a space between me and Sylvia. But I have her books, and my Guides often bring me messages from her, in my dreams.
This, one day, saved my life. I fell asleep wondering what flowers to pick for the gazebo the next morning, and my Guide Gwendolene told me that Sylvia wanted me to pick daffodils.
I set out the next day, and as I was bending over with my secateurs, I heard a whooshing noise and a loud crash!
Apparently, (I found out later), a meteorite had just missed me, and smashed into the gazebo! If I hadn't been bending over the daffodils, as Sylvia had warned me, I could have died!
(And I sold the silly rock to a museum man, I joked that I had lots of other rocks in my garden, if he wanted to buy them!)
 
I completely agree. I am again impressed by RSL's integrity.

So here's a site created because of of RSL's site. RSL expresses that he would rather people not go to the site and mess with them, and yet people do so anyway. Not cool. I guess skepticism does not equal maturity. Sigh.
I've never had a reason to question Robert's integrity either, Samantha.

Part of his integrity, though probably little noticed, is the "YMMV" at the end of his post.

Robert stated his thoughts realizing that some people wouldn't agree with him, IMHO.

RSL knows that trying to get agreement on this forum (or among skeptics in general) is sometimes like herding cats. :D
 
Personally, I don't see facetious posts as trolling.

Posting threats, hacking a site and organized disruption to crash the server, now that's trolling.

I guess it's subjective, like humor. One person's witty poster is another's troll.
 
I just sent off an e-mail to one person who left his e-mail address there. Wonder what sort of response I will get? I pointed to Robert's site.
 
Only 91 users at GoSylviaBrowne.com as of 4:50pm PST Mar. 09, 2007.

How many does Randi.org have?

Just curious.
 
Could be more popular.......

Exercise
Chat with friends about all forms of exercise from yoga to running. Create your own forum topic. 0 0 No Posts

Diet
Everyone welcome. Create your own forum topics regarding all forms of dietary intake. 0 0 No Posts

Hobbies
Discuss your favorite past times here. 0 0 No Posts

Movies
Have you seen a good movie lately? How about a terrible one? Post your opinions here. 3 3 Fri Mar 09, 2007 5:46 am

Art
All things related to art. 0 0 No Posts

Music
Everyone loves music, don't they? Discuss your favorite genres here. 0 0 No Posts

Television
What's new on the tube? 0 0 No Posts

Relationships
Rant or rave here. We'll listen. 0 0 No Posts

Travel
Meet people who love to travel. 0 0 No Posts

Religion
Religious topics. 0 0 No Posts

Animals
We love animals!! 0 0 No Posts

Cyberspace
Fellow web surfers unite! 0 0 No Posts

Books/Magazines
Love to read? Read all about it here! 0 0 No Posts

Parenthood
Talk about the joy of parenthood here. Or talk about the pains of parenthood. Your choice! 0 0 No Posts
 
James Randi: 11,667

Sylvia Browne: 91

That's a little over 128 Randi people to every 1 Browne person.

Cool!
 
Give the people a little time. It is a new forum. In a few month's time it could be 100,000 Sylvia fans to our 2.607 of active members (who have posted here in the last month) or 11,669 total members. The reason I post this is that I keep reading from you guys that sceptics are a minority group in USA.
 
However, I must say I am amazed there wasn't already a fan site or several, given her alleged popularity. I am trying to work out why and I'm wondering if it's because she trades almost entirely on new customers rather than repeat business? If she had a huge and dedicated, loyal fan base, why weren't there fan sites before?

Here's an old fan site, apparently down for a while, but working to get back up:

SYLVIABROWNEFANSUNITE

This board was created out of LOVE and pure innocent desire to SHARE the light with others, so we can compare our stories, grow and learn from each others.

But:

This is unmoderated and if we decide you post something that is not acceptable we will remove it. Then we will email you why it was deleted.

They sure have an odd perception of what "unmoderated" means...

There are quite a lot of Sylvianatics (I just made that up) on TVTalkshows. E.g.:

Sylvia Browne Lied That Kidnapped Shawn Hornbeck Was Dead And Charged $700 Per Half Hour To Look For His Body

I think its unfortunate she was wrong. Do you know how many readings she does? ALOT. So for her to be accurate 100% is not true. I just read that stop Sylvia Site and it really pissed me off how maybe 30 readings were inaccurate. They emphasize it a great deal and all of a sudden shes fraud????
Maybe if EVERY single person who got a reading came forth and said she lied.. okay.

But I have seen Alot of positive feedback from her and her sons readings. Do a search... there is many on the internet.

I am saddened for her family. I think the media is looking for a blame and instead of focusing on that jerk of a guy who kidnapped him, they are focusing on Sylvia.

I love Sylvia Browne. I have read all of her books. She cant possibly be 100% right. I also am well educated in the whole spirituality department as I was on my OWN journey for truth and as I am not Psychic, I can HEAVILY relate to 80% of her teachings. I am a huge skeptic and that is why I had to research and experience everything for truth.

I am sorry some of you feel the way you do . Everyone is entitled to their OWN opinions but I am stating my opinion and some facts about her.

Love & Light,

Malisa

The sheer callousness of believers.

Malisa thinks it is "unfortunate" that Sylvia Browne was wrong. Malisa is "saddened" for her family. Malisa thinks the media is not focusing on the "jerk", but on Sylvia. Malisa thinks she is a "huge skeptic". Malisa has even been to StopSylviaBrowne.com, but finds it unfair that Sylvia's false readings and predictions are listed there. Malisa would only consider Sylvia Browne to be a fake if EVERY single person who got a reading thought she lied. Which is understandable, since Malisa herself can "HEAVILY relate" to 80% of her "teachings", thereby making sure that Malisa will never accept that Sylvia Browne can be a fake.

Malisa has all the reasons for wanting - needing - to believe in Sylvia Browne. But she hasn't got a word about the grief and sorrow Sylvia Browne caused the parents of Shaun Hornbeck.

Not a word.
 
I do admit it was a bit of a joke when I wrote it. However a forum called Christian Forums has 181,167 members. These are mostly USA members. Much bigger than JREF. So maybe it is a real possibility.

There are a hell of a lot more Christians then there are supporters of Sylvia Browne.

My guess is that the forum will have maybe a few hundred members when all is said and done. Something like 600 or so members after several months tops.
 
I dont believe the psychic community is all that big. Most of these people want readings, they want to join certain spiritual groups,(kind of like their own religion) but in terms of individual psychics and discussion related to them, it doesn't happen a lot.

We tend to think these forums are slow but there are constantly new posts. I would wager that site averages something like a post every 10 to 15 minutes, which is not all that bad.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom