GoSylviaBrowne

Interesting:



??? I didn't even post or have an account there. I think they're IP banning anyone that signed the guestbook (which means everyone using our proxy forwarding for me). Either that or they've just blanket banned everyone not on some IP whitelist.
But you smell skeptic! They are psychic, after all.

from a poor soul on gosalivabrowne.com's guest book said:
After listening to Sylvia on Hay House radio,I heard about this site and wanted to congratulate you on doing this for all of us who have been inspired by the teachings of Sylvia.
What a coincidence, Hay House, Sylvia's publisher. :rolleyes:
 
How long til # 146 and 146 are deleted? You know that you will be "banned" from the guest book. No truth allowed there.
 
But you smell skeptic! They are psychic, after all.

But I bathed and everything. :) Maybe I need the woo equivalent of deer pee... or perhaps I should simply visit from home where I have a different IP.

What a coincidence, Hay House, Sylvia's publisher. :rolleyes:

Yeah, you might also have noticed that all of the links on the link page are to various Sylvia affiliates, such as Hay House, Novus Spiritus, etc.
 
Lancastr needs to notify people that that site censors anything negative about Sylvia Browne if he links it on his website. Not doing so is simply not a competent thing to do.
 
That's probably why Lancastr linking it on his site isn't a good idea. He's overestimating the critical thinking skills of these people. He thinks they will look at the two sites and judge his site to be better and more accurate and less bias but the fact is they will flock to support her(as you say).
Dustin, I appreciate your concern, but you are making some incorrect assumptions about what I think.

Here's one way of looking at the potential negative impact of my linking to the Go site:

Yes, some people will read the two sites and choose to believe theirs rather than mine.

Of that group of people, how many of them would have believed my site had they not read the other one?

Of THAT group of people, how many of them would never have found the other site had I not linked to it?

That last group of people is the only group which will have been negatively impacted in their decision because of the link on my site. And I believe it is an extremely small group.

Yes, there are going to be people who flock to the Go site. I don't think that my Links page is going to be the cause of more than a tiny fraction of that flock.

Lancastr needs to notify people that that site censors anything negative about Sylvia Browne if he links it on his website.
I will consider doing so, as part of a note discouraging trolling. But it is listed in the "Pro-Sylvia" section of my Links page. To think that they would appreciate and allow negative comments about her is pretty naive.

Not doing so is simply not a competent thing to do.
I don't think my decision on this one way or the other will determine my competence or lack thereof. But I understand that you feel strongly about it.
 
Lancastr needs to notify people that that site censors anything negative about Sylvia Browne if he links it on his website. Not doing so is simply not a competent thing to do.

Yes, having a "Pro-Sylvia Site" list on a skeptic site so people can make their own decisions and weigh the pros and cons of all the different viewpoints is not very competent. If he is going to list pro-Sylvia sites, then he should at the very least urge all of us skeptics to harass the sites to no end. Nothing discourages wooishness like skeptics acting like immature children.
 
All linking to that page does is show that Mr. Lancaster is not afraid of the truth. He is putting out why Sylvia Browne should be stopped, the information is clear as day, you can choose to accept it, consider it, or ignore it. Linking to a pro Sylvia site just shows that he doesn't have some sort of personal vendetta and he justs wants the facts to be shown.

And I think skeptics lose all their power when they begin to act childish, do childish things, and promote behaviour which is wrong. It gets away from our overall goal of finding out what is truth and what is fiction. If you begin to be a child about it, you lose the credibility to judge what is and isn't.
 
Last edited:
Interesting:



??? I didn't even post or have an account there. I think they're IP banning anyone that signed the guestbook (which means everyone using our proxy forwarding for me). Either that or they've just blanket banned everyone not on some IP whitelist.
I appear to be IP banned from the forum too - and I've not even signed the guest book. I did follow the link at the beginning of this thread the first time I got the banned message - but I have a dynamic IP from a significantly large UK provider so I guess a lot of other brits are banned too ...
 
If we all get IP banned then eventually no one, woo or skeptic, will be able to access the site.
That won't matter one bit. It seems patently obvious that only the webmaster can put "stuff" up anyway. I mean, why would they want people they can't control posting their stuff? They have a message to get out! Sheesh. :rolleyes:
 
Dustin, I appreciate your concern, but you are making some incorrect assumptions about what I think.

Here's one way of looking at the potential negative impact of my linking to the Go site:

Yes, some people will read the two sites and choose to believe theirs rather than mine.

Of that group of people, how many of them would have believed my site had they not read the other one?

Of THAT group of people, how many of them would never have found the other site had I not linked to it?

That last group of people is the only group which will have been negatively impacted in their decision because of the link on my site. And I believe it is an extremely small group.

That's not necessarily correct. Have you ever heard of "Google bomb"? That's what we did to get your site on the top lists of Google. Whenever you put their link on your site then you're making their site go much much higher on the Google list. Google crawler that crawls your site will find that site and thus will vastly improve it's ranking.


I will consider doing so, as part of a note discouraging trolling. But it is listed in the "Pro-Sylvia" section of my Links page. To think that they would appreciate and allow negative comments about her is pretty naive.

Any legitimate website would allow critical comments. This site allows them. It isn't against the rules of this site to critique James Randi or this message board. People do it everyday and they aren't banned. The fact that the site censors any critical opposition is proof it's not legitimate and should not be taken seriously. A warning beside the link on your page should warn "This site censors critical viewpoints"
 
Yes, having a "Pro-Sylvia Site" list on a skeptic site so people can make their own decisions and weigh the pros and cons of all the different viewpoints is not very competent. If he is going to list pro-Sylvia sites, then he should at the very least urge all of us skeptics to harass the sites to no end. Nothing discourages wooishness like skeptics acting like immature children.

You're pretty naive if you believe that anyone who holds any supportive views of Sylvia will "weigh" the two sites and pick his. You must not have a lot of experience with these types of people.
 
That won't matter one bit. It seems patently obvious that only the webmaster can put "stuff" up anyway. I mean, why would they want people they can't control posting their stuff? They have a message to get out! Sheesh. :rolleyes:


It does strike me as propaganda created by someone working for Sylvia Browne.
 
That's not necessarily correct. Have you ever heard of "Google bomb"? That's what we did to get your site on the top lists of Google. Whenever you put their link on your site then you're making their site go much much higher on the Google list. Google crawler that crawls your site will find that site and thus will vastly improve it's ranking.
I link to it once, from my site's Links page. I hardly think that constitutes "Google bombing." And that one link will not make their site go "much much higher" inthe rankings. It's probably been linked to more times within this thread than it has from my site.

Any legitimate website would allow critical comments.
So, by your standards, StopSylviaBrowne.com is not legitimate, and I'm incompetent.

The fact that the site censors any critical opposition is proof it's not legitimate and should not be taken seriously.
If it were trying to promote itself as a bastian of freedom of speech, yes.

But it doesn't. It is a celebrity's fan site.

To expect it to be anything else is just silly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom