God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Are you going to ever stop with the geometric nose business?

"She"? :boggled:

Guess again.


I have not abandoned this thread. I have a job. I'm an Engineer-in-Training (it's a North American thing). I work. I'm busy. I occasionally post from work, when I have 2 minutes here and there. But part of my job right now is introducing process changes to a whole lot of parts, which involves me spending considerable amounts of my time on the floor overseeing trials. By considerable, I mean more than the 50% I normally spend on the floor. I started at 0700, it is now just past 1700. I managed to bold down a bag of chips and a Root Beer in lieu of lunch. I don't get breaks, and being on salary I don't get overtime, either.

But I'm supposed to be here for your convenience?

I don't think so.

When have I ever attacked you for posting on a different schedule than me? I know you're not Canadian, so I don't expect you to post the same timetable as me. Further, I extend you the courtesy of assuming you have a life outside of this forum, and don't expect instant responses. I would appreciate it if you did the same, and didn't try to project motivations on to me.



Finally, to address your latest posts, I have already given my reasoning for assuming a geometric basis to your "beginning and end of the nose" example. I made it clear in subsequent posts (after your protestation that you meant a temporal basis) that such a change only removes one fallacy from a sub-conclusion which rests on three fallacies. Ultimately, nothing changes and your argument is still fatally flawed. I honestly cannot understand why you nitpick on that one insignificant point, ignoring the fatal flaws in your "proof".

And I have not insisted that you have not given your "proof" since you provided it. I have pointed out it's flaws, though.



Are you going to ever stop with the geometric nose business?


Will you just so that we can move forward understand the nose in the face as the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that by beginning and ending of the nose I am talking about time duration of the nose's existence.


Now, can you give me some examples of things in the universe which are existing but do not have a beginning?


Or you still want to dwell on the geometry of the nose?




Yrreg
 
Are you going to ever stop with the geometric nose business?


Will you just so that we can move forward understand the nose in the face as the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that by beginning and ending of the nose I am talking about time duration of the nose's existence.


Now, can you give me some examples of things in the universe which are existing but do not have a beginning?


Or you still want to dwell on the geometry of the nose?




Yrreg



Please read my post again; you seem to have missed my point.
 
Will you just so that we can move forward understand the nose in the face as the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that by beginning and ending of the nose I am talking about time duration of the nose's existence.


It's actually an interesting thing to pick when talking about temporal beginnings and ends. There's obviously a time before which one's nose never existed and a time in which it does exist. However, there's no "moment" at which the nose starts. For that matter, there's no moment at which the nose ceases, either.

Obviously, this has nothing to do with Gerry\s argument. The analogy between "things in the universe| and "the universe itself" fails as a matter of pure logic. And then the name-calling is a whole thing unto itself.
 
Now, can you give me some examples of things in the universe which are existing but do not have a beginning?
As far as we can tell, energy.

In physical terms, the formation of the nose is simply a rearrangement of energy (in this particular case, matter). Nothing gets added to the universe when a nose begins, and nothing gets removed from the universe when a nose ends.

In theological terms, the example you give is creation ex materia. For your definition of universe that you supplied, you need either creation ex nihilo or creation ex deo. You're trying to establish that creation ex materia is evidence for creation ex nihilo and/or creation ex deo, but it's not. It's an entirely different sort of thing. Creation ex materia neither makes nor destroys "stuff"; and the universe is the collection of all "stuff".

In fact, "creation ex materia" isn't much of creation at all. It's more like transformation. What you are arguing is something akin to the fact that since a sculptor made a toy dinosaur out of clay, and since that dinosaur then began to exist, then it follows that some sculptor made clay out of thin air, and/or chewed off his leg and made clay out of that (or something along these lines).

None of that follows. The beginning and end of a nose is only evidence that certain rearrangements of matter are sufficiently interesting to give them particular names. It has nothing to do with where all of this clay came from.
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg



I'm going to pull a Complexity here, but long thread, don't want to read it all.................. basic reply -- that is why theologians in the Middle Ages adopted the Via Negativa. They realized they could not describe God and so could only try to describe what God was not.

They kind of neglected the fact that there is no thing that God is not if one wants to take the Ontological argument seriously.
 
As far as we can tell, energy.

In physical terms, the formation of the nose is simply a rearrangement of energy (in this particular case, matter). Nothing gets added to the universe when a nose begins, and nothing gets removed from the universe when a nose ends.

In theological terms, the example you give is creation ex materia. For your definition of universe that you supplied, you need either creation ex nihilo or creation ex deo. You're trying to establish that creation ex materia is evidence for creation ex nihilo and/or creation ex deo, but it's not. It's an entirely different sort of thing. Creation ex materia neither makes nor destroys "stuff"; and the universe is the collection of all "stuff".

In fact, "creation ex materia" isn't much of creation at all. It's more like transformation. What you are arguing is something akin to the fact that since a sculptor made a toy dinosaur out of clay, and since that dinosaur then began to exist, then it follows that some sculptor made clay out of thin air, and/or chewed off his leg and made clay out of that (or something along these lines).

None of that follows. The beginning and end of a nose is only evidence that certain rearrangements of matter are sufficiently interesting to give them particular names. It has nothing to do with where all of this clay came from.



I've been wondering lately about fundamentals. I don't know how much you've thought about this -- knowing you probably quite a bit and I'm just way the heck behind -- but whatever is seems to be even more fundamental than energy. We've got vibrating strings of energy and we've got space-time. Whatever is should be more fundamental than both of those such that space-time and energy are expressions of it. That just strikes me as incredibly weird.

I have no idea where to take that, but damn.
 
No need to read again, I have to be harsh with you, just tell me your point.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Are you going to ever stop with the geometric nose business?


Will you just so that we can move forward understand the nose in the face as the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that by beginning and ending of the nose I am talking about time duration of the nose's existence.


Now, can you give me some examples of things in the universe which are existing but do not have a beginning?


Or you still want to dwell on the geometry of the nose?




Yrreg​






Please read my post again; you seem to have missed my point.



No need to read again, I have to be harsh with you, just tell me your point.


Are you going to answer my question, give me some things in the universe that exist but do not have a beginning.


And don't bring in again the nose's geometry.




Yrreg
 
Why don't you just address my post?


As I have stated multiple times, my basis for assuming you meant "beginning and end" as physical features was because the nose is a physical object, and part of a greater whole. It does not have a clearly-defined beginning of existence or end of existence. You chose to use the nose as your example, yrreg. Don't get mad at me because it was a poor choice. If you recall, I did suggest using something like a train trip or the life of a flower as a better example.

The point you keep missing is that the geometric/temporal nose thing is utterly irrelevant. The proof of god you posts is based on flawed logic, unsupported premises and undefined terms. Even allowing for a time-based beginning and end, your argument is still fatally flawed in many ways. So were I you, I wouldn't bother worrying about it, and instead would concentrate on the fundamental flaws of logic which are liberally scattered throughout your proof. These flaws have been pointed out by myself and others (see below). I even went to the trouble of giving you suggestions for improvement. But you obsess over the nose and ignore everything else. I cannot understand why.

We are not going to play your game until you honestly and sincerely address Bruto's post (link), my post (link), Kid Eager's post (link), Sun Countess' post (link), Slingblade's post (link), Dancing David's post (link), and Loss Leader's post (link).


Until you answer the criticisms present in the posts linked in my quote, yrreg, we will refuse to act like the sycophantic followers you demand we be.
 
Are you going to answer my question, give me some things in the universe that exist but do not have a beginning.

You ignored this before and I expect that you will likely ignore it now, but this is definitely something in the universe that does not have a beginning.
 

Attachments

  • circle.gif
    circle.gif
    4.8 KB · Views: 191
You ignored this before and I expect that you will likely ignore it now, but this is definitely something in the universe that does not have a beginning.


It's not really a fair comparison. Yrreg has clearly been talking about a temporal beginning and end. Your circle came into being at some point and will cease to exist at some point in the future.

However, your analogy between a physical circle and a temporal universe is as valid as Yrreg's analogy between things in the universe and the universe itself - in that they're both hopelessly flawed.
 
It's not really a fair comparison. Yrreg has clearly been talking about a temporal beginning and end. Your circle came into being at some point and will cease to exist at some point in the future.

However, your analogy between a physical circle and a temporal universe is as valid as Yrreg's analogy between things in the universe and the universe itself - in that they're both hopelessly flawed.

I was hoping to remind Gerry of the point, so often presented to him, that many, if not most cosmologists think that it is highly probable that space/time is finite yet boundless, thus have no meaningful beginning or end, so that saying, "The universe began at the Big Bang" may be a bit like saying, "The Earth begins at the North Pole". But Gerry's argument relies on the assertion that there was a time before the universe existed, so he cannot afford to acknowledge possibilities that invalidate his absolute assertion that the universe had a beginning.

He's bogged down once more attempting to force others to agree to his definitions, but I suspect that the arc of his argument goes something like this:

[English translation]

1. The universe, like the nose on your face, has a beginning.

2. The universe must therefor have been created by something that is not part of the universe.

3. I define (the Christian) God as the creator of everything that is not himself, therefor (the Christian) God created the universe.

4. The universe is therefor evidence that (the Christian) God exists.

5. [The punchline] (The Christian) God is as plain as the nose on your face!

Ha ha ha ha ha! Gotcha!!!
 
Last edited:
I was hoping to remind Gerry of the point, so often presented to him, that many, if not most cosmologists think that it is highly probable that space/time is finite yet boundless, thus have no meaningful beginning or end, so that saying, "The universe began at the Big Bang" may be a bit like saying, "The Earth begins at the North Pole". But Gerry's argument relies on the assertion that there was a time before the universe existed, so he cannot afford to acknowledge possibilities that invalidate his absolute assertion that the universe had a beginning.

He's bogged down once more attempting to force others to agree to his definitions, but I suspect that the arc of his argument goes something like this:

[English translation]

1. The universe, like the nose on your face has a beginning.

2. The universe must therefor have been created by something that is not part of the universe.

3. I define (the Christian) God as the creator of everything that is not himself, therefor (the Christian) God created the universe.

4. The universe is therefor evidence that (the Christian) God exists.

5. [The punchline] (The Christian) God is as plain as the nose on your face!

Ha ha ha ha ha! Gotcha!!!


No fair! You've seen this movie before!
 
No fair! You've seen this movie before!
That's me in the middle.
manos1.jpg
 
He's bogged down once more attempting to force others to agree to his definitions, but I suspect that the arc of his argument goes something like this:

[English translation]

1. The universe, like the nose on your face, has a beginning.

2. The universe must therefor have been created by something that is not part of the universe.

3. I define (the Christian) God as the creator of everything that is not himself, therefor (the Christian) God created the universe.

4. The universe is therefor evidence that (the Christian) God exists.

5. [The punchline] (The Christian) God is as plain as the nose on your face!

Ha ha ha ha ha! Gotcha!!!

^^
This is spot on. Gerry thinks he's so clever "working" the argument that way. Now that you have made a preemptive strike in his punchline, he's going to come back with tortured English and perhaps some more Latin verbiage.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom