German Chancellor cool to the idea of Obama speaking in Berlin

chipmunk stew

Philosopher
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
7,448
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has sparked a debate in Germany about Obama's plans to give a public speech about Trans-Atlantic relations in front of Brandenburg Gate, the highly symbolic site of Kennedy's "Ich bin ein Berliner" and Reagan's "tear down this wall."
A spokesman for the chancellor said his choice to hold the speech at the historic setting was "odd" and that Merkel has "little sympathy for the Brandenburg Gate being used for electioneering and has expressed her doubts about the idea."

Obama is very popular in Germany, but Merkel, a Bush ally, and other politicians have known McCain for years and are reluctant to give Obama such a backdrop.

This whole trip Obama's planning has many potential pitfalls, and making the trip with such high visibility carries a lot of risk. If he pulls it off and things go smoothly, it could give him a big boost, but if makes even a small misstep, it will be amplified and could erase any potential benefit.
 
Seems like a mistake to me. It feeds the perception that he has some sort of inflated ego. Senator, you're no Jack Kennedy. At least not yet.
 
From the news report:

Furthermore, any indication that Berlin is over-eager to see the end of the Bush administration is not likely to play well in Washington.

Indeed, Deputy Treasury Secretary Robert Kimmitt told the mass circulation tabloid Bild that "it would be nice if the German government would focus on strengthening its contacts to us rather than already beginning to look for our successors."

ha ha ha ha ha. Bite me, lame-ducks.
 
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has sparked a debate in Germany about Obama's plans to give a public speech about Trans-Atlantic relations in front of Brandenburg Gate, the highly symbolic site of Kennedy's "Ich bin ein Berliner" and Reagan's "tear down this wall."

Not true. Kennedy was speaking from the balcony of the Rathaus Schöneberg.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ich_bin_ein_Berliner

Clinton was the other US president who gave a speech at the Brandenburg Gate.
 
Being a kraut, I remember the time when you could not walk through the Brandenburg Gate. Quite weird. The iron curtain dividing west from east right in the center of a big city. Imagine a twelve year old boy wondering why entering the other part of Germany, then Eastern Germany, was such a big deal.

1) As an American, Obama has every right to speak at the Brandenburg Gate. The Brandenburg Gate (and Berlin) would not be what it is today without America.

2) On the other hand, he is indeed planning to speak at a historic place which might, I don't know how to say this in English, be one size of shoes to large for him. Maybe a place in Berlin not so uber-important in history might better suit his purpose. Dunno.
 
and she probably said 'as long as you promise never to touch me again!'
 
Why is Obama so wildly popular in Germany? Other than their belief that his presidency would be the end of the American empire?
 
Why is Obama so wildly popular in Germany? Other than their belief that his presidency would be the end of the American empire?


No offence, corplinx, but you're being prejudiced. It's not that they believe "his presidency would be the end of the American empire", because they don't. I don't know why you apparently think Germans by and large are biased against the USA; they're not.

It's that they believe that Obama (or practically anyone else) wouldn't bugger things up quite as stupidly as Bush.
 
Seems like a mistake to me. It feeds the perception that he has some sort of inflated ego. Senator, you're no Jack Kennedy. At least not yet.

Being a kraut, I remember the time when you could not walk through the Brandenburg Gate. Quite weird. The iron curtain dividing west from east right in the center of a big city. Imagine a twelve year old boy wondering why entering the other part of Germany, then Eastern Germany, was such a big deal.

1) As an American, Obama has every right to speak at the Brandenburg Gate. The Brandenburg Gate (and Berlin) would not be what it is today without America.

2) On the other hand, he is indeed planning to speak at a historic place which might, I don't know how to say this in English, be one size of shoes to large for him. Maybe a place in Berlin not so uber-important in history might better suit his purpose. Dunno.
I'm inclined to agree that this could stoke feelings that Obama is arrogant and overly ambitious. Apparently the venue is not finalized yet, so we'll see what happens.
 
2) On the other hand, he is indeed planning to speak at a historic place which might, I don't know how to say this in English, be one size of shoes to large for him. Maybe a place in Berlin not so uber-important in history might better suit his purpose. Dunno.

I think the phrase you are looking for is "too big for his boots".

I do actually see what you mean. When do you Germans get to vote for him by the way?
 
Obama apparently will be speaking at the Victory Column a stone's throw from Brandenburg Gate.

Still not a bad backdrop:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601100&sid=acBhUENDprU4&refer=germany

edit:
s-BERLIN-large.jpg
 
Last edited:
Obama apparently will be speaking at the Victory Column a stone's throw from Brandenburg Gate.

Still not a bad backdrop:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601100&sid=acBhUENDprU4&refer=germany

edit:
http://images.huffingtonpost.com/gen/30728/thumbs/s-BERLIN-large.jpg


While I still wonder what Merkel's Bush-Appeasing critizism of the "Brandenburg-Gate speech" was all about since he's virtually gone already anyway, I'm happy that they finally settled this stupid non-controversy as long Obama gets the chance to speak to a broad audience over here. He will get much more enthusiasm and attention than W.McCain anyway.
 
While I still wonder what Merkel's Bush-Appeasing critizism of the "Brandenburg-Gate speech" was all about since he's virtually gone already anyway, I'm happy that they finally settled this stupid non-controversy as long Obama gets the chance to speak to a broad audience over here. He will get much more enthusiasm and attention than W.McCain anyway.
Are you going to be there when HE speakes?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom