General questions from a new member...

Two questions for you.

1. Where did you get the above information.
2. Have you spent any time trying to validate the above from non CT sites or searching this or any other debunking site. If so how much time did you spend and what sources have you tried.?
He was corrected today on the 100,000 dollar payment and he still uses it. Remember Stickman?
 
Out of interest, which are the "anomalies" which suggest to you "full media complicity with the TV Fakery angle"?

Well the reason Im not completely sold on that angle is because I don't know if that footage has been doctored by the people who made the documentaries.

And I remain skeptical because the world would never be the same if I accepted that angle.

If the media is that corrupt then there is no hope whatsoever.


But if that footage is legit then there was def TV fakery because of there are completely inconsistent flight paths of those planes and the nose out angle would really be damning
 
Good question

1)Standard protocols that would have prevented the attacks were not followed

2)At least 6 separate drills or "wargame" scenarios were being run on the morning of 9/11/01 during the time of the attacks. These drills included the insertion of fake radar "inputs" and had the effect of confusing and distracting first responders, as well as diverting available aircraft away from the area.

3) Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Instruction given in June 2001 requiring the intercept orders be issued by Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld personally? [CJCS13610, June 1, 2001]

4)CIA and MI-6 were running an AL Qaeda training camp until as late as 1995

5)Shortly before 9/11 the then head of the ISI, General Mahmood Ahmed wired $100,000 to the lead hijacker, Mohammad Atta. This was confirmed by the FBI investigation and Indian intelligence officials tracing the financial ties of the hijackers. [Wall Street Journal 10/10/01, Times of India 8/15/02]

6)Head US Consular Official was told to Issue Visas to mujihadeen terrorists.

Wow, you got every single one wrong. Yer a true truther, alrighty!
 
Sup lee5.

If our suspicion is unfounded, forgive us. We have had dozens of experiences with people coming to this forum under the pretense of "just asking questions" and then end up calling us all "sheeple" for not believing in invisible planes carrying nuclear death rays. Perhaps you are genuinely "just asking questions", as the fakes would have been calling us sheeple by now.

Many of the people here don't trust conspiracy theorists. Just be patient with them, and show respect and courtesy. And above all, ask questions, but RECOGNIZE ANSWERS. We know a "just asking questions" person is being phony when they distrust all answers they are given. This is why you are being met with hostility. Although, you have shown at least some willingness to do further research, and that is good.

Be nice to us and we'll be nice to you; it's that simple. Some of us will take more work than others, but they'll come around eventually.

Now on to some of them questions:

It seems that the CIA has a record of pretty shady operations and that bothers me. I think the first step is to understand the truth of the past before anything said about 9/11 can even hold water. If we can determine that past wars were caused by false pretenses, then maybe we can make a good argument that something was false about 9/11.

So, thats where I am stuck. I hear about things like the gulf of Tonikin (sp?) incident and it makes me wonder how silly of an idea that "inside job" really is.

I know that a person is judged by his criminal past. If I am a convicted murderer, you probably wouldn't put it past me to kill again right? Well, if the government is a proven liar, then what make you think they are not now?

Sure, sure. But remember two things. First, there has to be a trial for each individual crime. We don't automatically convict a murder suspect simply because he's already murdered once. Secondly, when have any of these secret CIA ops resulted in the deaths of 3000 innocents? Comparing the government's known lies to 9/11 is like comparing misdemeanor shoplifting to Cho Seung Hui.

As far as a one world government being a good thing... thats possible. But, when you figure that the same people that push this agenda also seem to create wars, you got to stop and think, is this a good thing these people are trying to do?

Now says who? Who's creating wars who wants a one world government? And are they creating those wars deliberately and sadistically? You can't jump to conclusions based on minor suspicions.

What about Ptec?

What about it? Which Ptec are you referring to?

you say the "scientific facts" that are in the official story. What makes them the right facts but other experts have wrong facts? Who is to decide what scientist is right if both contradict each other? Oh... the word "official"?

Like I said, evidence is in the eye of the beholder. I might not have worded that right but one persons evidence is another persons garbage and there is NO supreme person to say what is right and what is not. Thats why a jury has 12 people (not sided with any one view), the majority is the deciding factor.

Point is, mate, many of the arguments of the Truth Movement are demonstrably false (like freefall speed). So this is like asking "who is to decide whether or not Flat Earthers are right or wrong?"

Yea yea, I know you have Scientific proof and all but I am going off my own feelings.

Whoa there, buddy. Since when do feelings trump scientific proof?

what about these 226 architectural and engineering professionals...

http://www.ae911truth.org/

?

What about them? AE911Truth is very misleading when they say 226, because they include things like software engineers in that number, and a software engineer isn't going to know jack squat about building design or collapse mechanics. They have maybe 20 people who have relevant expertise, and even that number is questionable because their petition is so vaguely worded that even people who don't believe in the Controlled Demolition myth might find themselves *technically* agreeing with it.

Well, my common sense has served me well as a mechanical engineer so far

You're a MECHANICAL engineer. Do you design buildings, let alone skyscrapers? My understanding of "MECHANICAL engineering" is that you work on machinery. No offense but how does that qualify you to make judgments on whether WTC7 was a controlled demolition?

is this the best picture we have showing the damage to WTC 7?

We got plenty right here: http://www.debunking911.com/pull.htm

You're not gonna get much better than that because as you can see, the damaged side is covered in thick smoke. But you can pretty well see that the building's in bad shape, and the firefighters agreed.

Did any of the building fall at free fall speed?

If no, how far was the time off from being what would be called "free" fall speed?

Fall times were almost TWICE freefall on all buildings.

Why did this not suffer from "global collapse"?

I can tell you that, if you tell me what it's made out of, how it was damaged, and how long it burned for. Oh, and how many stories is it, and what are the building codes in that area.

Please define a "clunkity-clunk".

It's an inside joke. Here's the reference so you can laugh at it too: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1661234396051243299&q=%22clunkity+clunk&total=2&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=1
 
And unlike most criminal cases the circumsantial evidence isn't supported by a wealth of physical evidence, corroborated eyewitness testimony, or undoctored photographs... or ANYTHING ELSE AT ALL BESIDES THEORY AND SUPPOSITION!!

There would be more than enough testimony from people who's investigations in men were thwarted and the testimony of those individuals who could speak of the spoliation in the official investigation.

Not to mention the witness who could support the demolition hypothesis with the explosives.


Maybe not enough to get to the head of the snake, but certainly at least someone would be held responsible for this widespread "incompetence"
 
But if that footage is legit then there was def TV fakery because of there are completely inconsistent flight paths of those planes and the nose out angle would really be damning
Wow, you're also an impossible TV fakery proponent! Buh-bye, and good luck with your problems!
 
Maybe not enough to get to the head of the snake, but certainly at least someone would be held responsible for this widespread "incompetence"
The guys who hijacked the planes and the organization who trained and funded them aren't the head of the snake? :confused:
 
The guys who hijacked the planes and the organization who trained and funded them aren't the head of the snake? :confused:

If 9/11 is an inside job I hardly doubt that Atta is the head of the snake.

It would have to be individuals with more in the means department.

The most tangible organization is the PNAC group.

But even that has to be a level of compartmentalization

Wow, you're also an impossible TV fakery proponent! Buh-bye, and good luck with your problems!

A free thinker who hasn't ruled it out as a possiblity. No way am I going to say that is definite when that footage could be doctored by the people who made the documentaries.

Their evidence is convincing but to make such an extraordinary claim I'd have to confirm that one for myself with original footage
 
Last edited:
Stickman:
What's so complicated about the OS?

I think those terrorists wouldn't have had the means and opportunity to pull it off without some help on the other side.

But disregard that as an argument from ignorance because maybe those SOBs could outsmart the CIA, FBI, MI6, etc.

The problem lies within all the coincidences that are documented that ALLOWED them to get away with it.

These coincidences make it look a lot more like they didn't have the means and opportunity
 
Good lord, what is this, a damn tag-team match? The same old tired, utterly debunked claims, recycled over and over. The only difference is the style of poster. First it's the "I'm a respectful inquirer simply seeking the truth" type. And when that person gets called out and reveals their true self, let's send in the insulting one who mistakes sarcasm for sophistication. What's next, someone from the batcrap-crazy "realistice" camp? Or the pseudo-intellectual who tries to befuddle us with spurious math and talk of quantum mechanics? Or the "you'll all die on the scaffold" thug? It's like a bunch of lame comedians endlessly repeating the exact same joke.
 
Good question

1)Standard protocols that would have prevented the attacks were not followed

What were these?

2)At least 6 separate drills or "wargame" scenarios were being run on the morning of 9/11/01 during the time of the attacks. These drills included the insertion of fake radar "inputs" and had the effect of confusing and distracting first responders, as well as diverting available aircraft away from the area.

I only know of one drill and it hadn't started yet. What were the others?

3) Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Instruction given in June 2001 requiring the intercept orders be issued by Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld personally? [CJCS13610, June 1, 2001]

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=CJCS13610&btnG=Search

What's your source for this?

4)CIA and MI-6 were running an AL Qaeda training camp until as late as 1995

Gonna need a source for this too.

5)Shortly before 9/11 the then head of the ISI, General Mahmood Ahmed wired $100,000 to the lead hijacker, Mohammad Atta. This was confirmed by the FBI investigation and Indian intelligence officials tracing the financial ties of the hijackers. [Wall Street Journal 10/10/01, Times of India 8/15/02]

Weren't you already corrected on this?

6)Head US Consular Official was told to Issue Visas to mujihadeen terrorists.

Again, What's your source for this claim?
 
I think those terrorists wouldn't have had the means and opportunity to pull it off without some help on the other side.

But disregard that as an argument from ignorance because maybe those SOBs could outsmart the CIA, FBI, MI6, etc.

The problem lies within all the coincidences that are documented that ALLOWED them to get away with it.

These coincidences make it look a lot more like they didn't have the means and opportunity
Like what? Did you ever do much air travel before 01? Security was a joke, I routinely carried a small knife on board (out of Logan no less). Air intercepts were rare and if they did intercept what could they do?

They knew this and exploited the fact that the US is a free an open society.




My son needs help with his homework so it's goodbye for now.
 
Are you joking?

So you don't think there is a single hole in the Official Narrative of 9/11?

Not a single hole?

LOL


First of all, the official narrative has changed several times considering the science behind the collapse of the towers.

But I'll give them a break in terms of preliminary findings and given the unprecedented structural occurence.


But for starters how about the commission even admitted that NORAD gave them a false account. Yet they decided it wasn't important enough to bring this up while compiling the report
Originally Posted by rwguinn
Name 1 (one) (uno), and show evidence (not proof) that it is unsubstantiated.

Just one.
Betcha can't.
still waiting.
Pass the popcorn...
 
Regarding the claims of free fall, here is a do-it-yourself exercise that anyone can do to verify the facts:

1) Get Adobe Premiere or similar program that allows the placement of multiple videos on a timeline.

2) Get these three videos of the South Tower collapse: the ABC video of the collapse that was broadcast live, the street level Camera Planet footage released on "America 911" that shows the South Tower collapse and the East Face perimeter columns striking the ground, and Clip 8 of P200015.mpg on the Moussaoui trial exhibits website. Import them into Premiere and place them on the timeline.

3) Synchronize the three videos using the same features of the collapse, e.g. shape of the dust clouds, position of the debris, etc. The three videos synchronize pretty easily.

4) Use the timeline to inform you the duration of the collapse, particularly with respect to these four events: the moment columns on the 79th floor at the northeast corner of the building began to fall on the ABC video (this was after the upper block of the tower had fallen below the 79th Floor), the moment the first perimeter columns of the East Face hit the ground on the Camera Planet video, the moment the northeast corner at the 44th Floor peals away on the ABC video, and the moment the lower section of the inner core collapses in the Moussaoui trial clip.

I'm not going to say what the results will be, that is up to you to figure out. But you will get a far more accurate idea of how long the collapse sequence took from beginning to finish.
 
Last edited:
Where's lee5?

Did he revert into a Mr. Hyde/Stickman2008 after if was pointed out that he's not an really an open-minded, neutral truth-seeker?
 
What were these?

It is standard operating procedure to scramble jet figthers for any one of the following situations.

1)An aircraft goes off course
2)Radio contact with it is lost
3)The transponder is turned off.

On 9/11 the 4 hijacked aircraft met not just one, but all 3 of these criteria!

The air defense network had, on September 11th, predictable and effective procedures for dealing with just such an attack. Yet it failed to respond in a timely manner until after the attack was over, more than an hour and a half after it had started.

Why were these protocols not followed to prevent the attacks?


I only know of one drill and it hadn't started yet. What were the others?

CIA/National Reconnaissance Office exercise
Simulation of a plane crash into the NRO headquarters (near DUlles Airport, Virginia) -- Not a "terrorism" exercise, resulted in evacuation of most NRO employees just as the "real" 9/11 was taking place.
Effects: made it more difficult for a nation's spy sattelites to be used to track the hijacked planes.

Vigiliant Guardian: Simulated very closely the hijackings of 9/11
Effects: Top NORAD personnel were confused, not sure if the 9/11 hijackings were "real-world or exercise"

Northern Vigilance: Planned months in advance, involved deploying fighter jets to locations in Alaska and norther Canada
Effects: Ensured that there would be fewer fighter planes available to protect the East Coast on 9/11. Confusion from simulated information fed into radar screens.

Vigilant Warrior [Richard Clark, "Against All Enemies"
NOrthern Guardian [Toronto Star, December 9, 2001]
Tripod II [Bio-Warfare exercise scheduled for 9/12/01]
Effects: FEMA was deployed to NYC area on 9/10/01 according to FEMA spokesman Tom Kenny [Dan Rather interview, 9/12/01][Gulliani 9/11 Commission May 2004]
 
Sup lee5.

If our suspicion is unfounded, forgive us. We have had dozens of experiences with people coming to this forum under the pretense of "just asking questions" and then end up calling us all "sheeple" for not believing in invisible planes carrying nuclear death rays. Perhaps you are genuinely "just asking questions", as the fakes would have been calling us sheeple by now.

Many of the people here don't trust conspiracy theorists. Just be patient with them, and show respect and courtesy. And above all, ask questions, but RECOGNIZE ANSWERS. We know a "just asking questions" person is being phony when they distrust all answers they are given. This is why you are being met with hostility. Although, you have shown at least some willingness to do further research, and that is good.

Be nice to us and we'll be nice to you; it's that simple. Some of us will take more work than others, but they'll come around eventually.

Now on to some of them questions:



Sure, sure. But remember two things. First, there has to be a trial for each individual crime. We don't automatically convict a murder suspect simply because he's already murdered once. Secondly, when have any of these secret CIA ops resulted in the deaths of 3000 innocents? Comparing the government's known lies to 9/11 is like comparing misdemeanor shoplifting to Cho Seung Hui.



Now says who? Who's creating wars who wants a one world government? And are they creating those wars deliberately and sadistically? You can't jump to conclusions based on minor suspicions.



What about it? Which Ptec are you referring to?



Point is, mate, many of the arguments of the Truth Movement are demonstrably false (like freefall speed). So this is like asking "who is to decide whether or not Flat Earthers are right or wrong?"



Whoa there, buddy. Since when do feelings trump scientific proof?



What about them? AE911Truth is very misleading when they say 226, because they include things like software engineers in that number, and a software engineer isn't going to know jack squat about building design or collapse mechanics. They have maybe 20 people who have relevant expertise, and even that number is questionable because their petition is so vaguely worded that even people who don't believe in the Controlled Demolition myth might find themselves *technically* agreeing with it.



You're a MECHANICAL engineer. Do you design buildings, let alone skyscrapers? My understanding of "MECHANICAL engineering" is that you work on machinery. No offense but how does that qualify you to make judgments on whether WTC7 was a controlled demolition?



We got plenty right here: http://www.debunking911.com/pull.htm

You're not gonna get much better than that because as you can see, the damaged side is covered in thick smoke. But you can pretty well see that the building's in bad shape, and the firefighters agreed.



Fall times were almost TWICE freefall on all buildings.



I can tell you that, if you tell me what it's made out of, how it was damaged, and how long it burned for. Oh, and how many stories is it, and what are the building codes in that area.



It's an inside joke. Here's the reference so you can laugh at it too: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1661234396051243299&q=%22clunkity+clunk&total=2&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=1


Ok guys... whew, I have allot of posts to look at bashing me. I am kind of busy at work tonight so might not get much time.

First, let me defend myself on some things.

I am typing all of this when I am not busy at work. I don't really feel like reading over my posts to make sure I don't have grammer mistakes. I make them, I don't really care if it bothers you and it certainly doesn't mean I don't know WTF I am talking about.

Second, some of you assume that because I ask a question that you know what I think about that topic. If I ask the question how do you determine the time it would take figure B to fall if figure A fell in 5 seconds that doesn't mean I believe there was damn explosives in the building. I am simply trying to learn the answer to a question that I have not been able to find on the internet yet.

You guys are so damn quick to jump to conclusions it makes me sick. The only person that has answered my questions like I would expect from a smart, honest man is Gumboot. I read what he told me and he has actually got me thinking about those points in a whole different light.

The rest of you that call me an idiot because I don't listen to your "facts" just don't get what I am trying to say. Your "facts" are not "facts" to me. Your "facts" are nothing but a bunch of scattered little theory's to me to justify what we all saw on the day of 9/11.

Like I said, evidence is in the eye of the beholder. Your "engineers" don't have any credibility to me. They just simply don't.

I can show 1,000 people WTC 7 falling that know nothing about it (as most people didn't even know a 3rd building fell) and they will be puzzled as to how that is not a CD. That doesn't mean everyone is stupid because they haven't seen your "facts" yet. Its just the common reaction to something that doesn't seem logical.

I am coming off as the person your are labeling me to be because you seem to force that upon people pretty well. You DON'T know what I believe just by the questions I ask. If you think I am that simple you are mistaken.

Yes I am a damn engineer that just works on ****. I never said it qualifies me for ****. Please don't put words in my mouth.

What I meant by saying I go of my feelings is that I go off my logic and it has never failed me. I fix **** all the time that requires me to go off of basic logic and common sense. Its the most powerfull thing a person has. Education from these "scientist" doesn't mean **** to me if they are a dumbass. I have meet allot of smart stupid people in my life and I think a few of them might be on here as well.

If you feel I am pulling out some kind of "twofer" tactics from some kind of ****ing "twofer" hand book then you guys are seriously off your rockers. I use to think most of the guys at LC were crazy but I am now starting to think the other way around by the way you guys act to what should be simple questions for you to answer.

If you think I am ignoring "facts" I don't agree. I have been givin links to a few places that didn't asnwer my questions. The rest of my questions were answered by your "opinions" based on the conclusions of your "facts".

Some of you got me really shaking my head. Some of you are no better than the twofers.

/defensive rant
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom