Very good!
I am happy that we agree that Hamas, Israel, the US are all responsible.
Now, leaving aside Hamas (since we agree that they are guilty as well), I have not read may of your comments calling Israel and the US guilty of war crimes.
Or atrocities.
Call it as you want.
Nor I have heard you criticize other people writing comments in defence of the position of Israel, an opinion I have now understood you do not share.
May I know the reason why you are so silent and do not address comments like
(a lie of Aridas who said taht the Israeli accepted the two-state solution based on 1967 borders)
..and many more..
as all the comments above seem to me to whitewash, minimize, or even support the military actions of Israel, that now I have understood you do not support, is it right?
So why your silence?
Because they are all about this latest military crisis, where I think Israel has been (mostly) right.
To paint with a broad brush: I think Israel has been right in Gaza since they pulled out in 2005.
And I think Israel has been wrong in the WB with their settlement policies.
Israel has IMO been dishonest in how they handled the peace process.
Where the various Palestinian leaders have sort-of openly screwed up the peace process, Israel has done so in a much more underhanded way.
After Arafat started to co-operate after the Oslo accords, Israel has often taken actions that were arrogant and humiliating to the Palestinians. Thus making pro-peace leaders in the Palestinian camp looking like fools to their own people and making them revert to hard-line positions.
Imagine being Palestinian leader who commits to talks, but during those talks, more settlements are built or other actions are taken that are humiliating. This is compounded by the fact that Palestinians have more masculine culture (in sociological terms) where pride and honour are deemed very important.
Israel isn't one block, but a complex coalition of parties and its (flawed) democratic system gives disproportionate power to small hard-line parties. Leaders like Netanyahu need to throw these idiots a bone once in while and that bone usually comes in the form of building more houses in settlements. This in turn makes Pal leaders who look like they are Israel's bitch.
The smart thing would have been to make Arafat look like a winner for co-operating. Not making him look like got short-changed and treated like a fool.
Although I think that Hamas is going in the offensive now because they are isolated (losing support from Egypt, Syria and Iran). they got a great chance for escalation when Netanyahu responded in the usual heavy-handed way to the kidnapping of those three teenagers.
Ironically, Bibi has been a good politician since the crisis.
-When that Arab kid got murdered by that bunch of Jewish psychos, he put a lot of effort into getting the guilty arrested, he personally called the parents of that kid, the murder has officially been classified as terrorism, the family will get financial support just like Jewish families who lose loved ones to terrorism.
-He didn't really have a choice to respond militarily, but tried de-escalating the situation by giving Hamas 48 hours to stop firing.
-Although they had to go in and many lives have been lost, I think genuine efforts have been made to reduce civilian casualties. if fact they have been much more successful than NATO in Yugoslavia or Afghanistan.
-He unilaterally accepted the cease fire.