Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Very good!
I am happy that we agree that Hamas, Israel, the US are all responsible.
Now, leaving aside Hamas (since we agree that they are guilty as well), I have not read may of your comments calling Israel and the US guilty of war crimes.
Or atrocities.
Call it as you want.
Nor I have heard you criticize other people writing comments in defence of the position of Israel, an opinion I have now understood you do not share.

May I know the reason why you are so silent and do not address comments like






(a lie of Aridas who said taht the Israeli accepted the two-state solution based on 1967 borders)





..and many more..

as all the comments above seem to me to whitewash, minimize, or even support the military actions of Israel, that now I have understood you do not support, is it right?
So why your silence?

Because they are all about this latest military crisis, where I think Israel has been (mostly) right.

To paint with a broad brush: I think Israel has been right in Gaza since they pulled out in 2005.
And I think Israel has been wrong in the WB with their settlement policies.

Israel has IMO been dishonest in how they handled the peace process.
Where the various Palestinian leaders have sort-of openly screwed up the peace process, Israel has done so in a much more underhanded way.
After Arafat started to co-operate after the Oslo accords, Israel has often taken actions that were arrogant and humiliating to the Palestinians. Thus making pro-peace leaders in the Palestinian camp looking like fools to their own people and making them revert to hard-line positions.

Imagine being Palestinian leader who commits to talks, but during those talks, more settlements are built or other actions are taken that are humiliating. This is compounded by the fact that Palestinians have more masculine culture (in sociological terms) where pride and honour are deemed very important.

Israel isn't one block, but a complex coalition of parties and its (flawed) democratic system gives disproportionate power to small hard-line parties. Leaders like Netanyahu need to throw these idiots a bone once in while and that bone usually comes in the form of building more houses in settlements. This in turn makes Pal leaders who look like they are Israel's bitch.

The smart thing would have been to make Arafat look like a winner for co-operating. Not making him look like got short-changed and treated like a fool.

Although I think that Hamas is going in the offensive now because they are isolated (losing support from Egypt, Syria and Iran). they got a great chance for escalation when Netanyahu responded in the usual heavy-handed way to the kidnapping of those three teenagers.

Ironically, Bibi has been a good politician since the crisis.
-When that Arab kid got murdered by that bunch of Jewish psychos, he put a lot of effort into getting the guilty arrested, he personally called the parents of that kid, the murder has officially been classified as terrorism, the family will get financial support just like Jewish families who lose loved ones to terrorism.
-He didn't really have a choice to respond militarily, but tried de-escalating the situation by giving Hamas 48 hours to stop firing.
-Although they had to go in and many lives have been lost, I think genuine efforts have been made to reduce civilian casualties. if fact they have been much more successful than NATO in Yugoslavia or Afghanistan.
-He unilaterally accepted the cease fire.
 
Because they are all about this latest military crisis, where I think Israel has been (mostly) right.

To paint with a broad brush: I think Israel has been right in Gaza since they pulled out in 2005.
And I think Israel has been wrong in the WB with their settlement policies.
[blaj] [blah]

Contradictory statements
Israel has been wrong in the WB but right on the latest crisis

Since it is Israel who kills most people (civilians) and they have been wrong in not addressing the problem in the WB before, how can they be right in killing Palestinians now?

Your position
1) they have not recognized the 1967 two-state solution and they are wrong for that
2) they are killing a lot of civilians
3) but they are still right, as they had no other option (accepting the two state solution on the 1967 borders is apparently not an option)

I do not understand the "logic" here
 
Well, have you ever heard a Garth Brooks song?
He's not totally wrong.

Heh, hence the "poorly justified." The US is involved, in a dramatically weaker and more complex way than he tries to portray, because it doesn't fit his rather hate focused narrative. Or, to say it a bit differently, he keeps trying to blow the US' involvement in general drastically out of proportion, as well as dramatically misrepresenting American attitudes, culpability, actions, and the actual support that's been given, despite having his claims demonstrated to be wrong at practically every turn.

I actually don't have a problem with KumarS' hate on for the US. I do have a problem with the fallacious arguments and false claims that he keeps employing, though.

ETA: Incidentally, to add to this a little, Palestine has indeed received large amounts of foreign aid from the US and Europe, which is just one of the fatal flaws in KumarS' accusations. In fact, to quote the link,

2010

The lion's share of the aid comes from the European Union and the United States. According to estimates made by the World Bank The Palestinian Authority received $525 million of international aid in the first half of 2010, $1.4 billion in 2009 and $1.8 billion in 2008.[51] Foreign aid is the "main driver" of economic growth in the Palestinian territories.[51]
 
Last edited:
Contradictory statements
Israel has been wrong in the WB but right on the latest crisis

Since it is Israel who kills most people (civilians) and they have been wrong in not addressing the problem in the WB before, how can they be right in killing Palestinians now?

Your position
1) they have not recognized the 1967 two-state solution and they are wrong for that
2) they are killing a lot of civilians
3) but they are still right, as they had no other option (accepting the two state solution on the 1967 borders is apparently not an option)

I do not understand the "logic" here

That's why separate the current fighting from the bigger political issue.

Their current response boils down to game-theory:
Can they not react? No.
So they have to act? Yes.

Hamas creates a situation that they HAVE to react to with military means.

Do they take great effort to reduce civilian casualties. Yes.

For context look up the Russians engaging in urban warfare in Grozny, that's what you get when the army just shells the hell out a city.

I'm quite interested in military history and I cannot think of one example where a superior army takes such great pains to reduce civilian casualties.
The 'roof knocking' for instance is big trade-off where they give up killing adversaries in exchange for warning civilians.

The disparity in casualties between Israel and Gaza has been discussed ad nauseum in this thread. I see no need to go over it again.

What's more: Israeli diplomatic failures in the WB are no excuse for shooting rockets from Gaza.
The West Bank is under leadership of Abbas, who has asked them to stop and asked what they hell they think to achieve.

The conditions in Gaze are mostly to blame on years of bad policy, most recently by Hamas.
Israel did the right thing and pulled out.
The blockade is made necessary by the rocket attacks, claiming the rocket attacks are aimed at forcing Israel to lift the blockade are nonsensical.
I also don't hold Israel responsible for how densely populated Gaza is. 300.000 Palestinians ended up in Gaza in 1968. They went in maximum baby-making mode with the highest fertility rate outside Africa to out-breed the Jews. Now it's crowded.

( these are all not in response to claims you made, but i encounter them a lot)

Gaza's problems should be solved with diplomacy and contraceptives. Not rockets.
 
Last edited:
That's why separate the current fighting from the bigger political issue.

Why separate?
I do not think we should separate

Their current response boils down to game-theory:
Can they not react? No.
So they have to act? Yes.

Hamas creates a situation that they HAVE to react to with military means.

You still have to explain why Israel can not react by first accepting the two state solution on 1967 borders
This is a question I have asked repeatedly and went unanswered

Do they take great effort to reduce civilian casualties. Yes.

For context look up the Russians engaging in urban warfare in Grozny, that's what you get when the army just shells the hell out a city.

I'm quite interested in military history and I cannot think of one example where a superior army takes such great pains to reduce civilian casualties.
The 'roof knocking' for instance is big trade-off where they give up killing adversaries in exchange for warning civilians.

The disparity in casualties between Israel and Gaza has been discussed ad nauseum in this thread. I see no need to go over it again.

Totally beyond the point
You still have to explain why Israel can not react by first accepting the two state solution on 1967 borders
This is a question I have asked repeatedly and went unanswered

What's more: Israeli diplomatic failures in the WB are no excuse for shooting rockets from Gaza.
The West Bank is under leadership of Abbas, who has asked them to stop and asked what they hell they think to achieve.

I would still say that I can understand why Hamas, seen the failures of Abbas in the WB, does not trust Israel
But leave this point
I agree with what you say

The conditions in Gaze are mostly to blame on years of bad policy, most recently by Hamas.
Israel did the right thing and pulled out.
The blockade is made necessary by the rocket attacks, claiming the rocket attacks are aimed at forcing Israel to lift the blockade are nonsensical.

It looks like the blockade included by far more things than just rockets.
Basic goods were also blocked

Finally, did Israel recognized Hamas like the legitimate leader of Gaza and Gaza as a part of the two-state solution in 1967?
As this is the point I am asking you
If not, why not?
The failure of Israel to recognize the Palestinian state based on 1967 borders has NOTHING to do with Hamas rockets. So do not even TRY to blame Hamas for Israeli refusal of the two-state solution based on 1967 borders
 
Last edited:
Why separate?
I do not think we should separate



You still have to explain why Israel can not react by first accepting the two state solution on 1967 borders
This is a question I have asked repeatedly and went unanswered



Totally beyond the point
You still have to explain why Israel can not react by first accepting the two state solution on 1967 borders
This is a question I have asked repeatedly and went unanswered



I would still say that I can understand why Hamas, seen the failures of Abbas in the WB, does not trust Israel
But leave this point
I agree with what you say



It looks like the blockade included by far more things than just rockets.
Basic goods were also blocked

Finally, did Israel recognized Hamas like the legitimate leader of Gaza and Gaza as a part of the two-state solution in 1967?
As this is the point I am asking you
If not, why not?
The failure of Israel to recognize the Palestinian state based on 1967 borders has NOTHING to do with Hamas rockets. So do not even TRY to blame Hamas for ISraeli refusal of the two-state solution based on 1967 borders

There are currently no negotiations about going back to the 1967 borders.
this issue should have been addressed ages ago.
The current crisis demands immediate response to stop or reduce the rockets.

Abbas isn't wildly successful, but he isn't failing either.

He focusses on building international support for a Palestinian state.
Netanyahu can bitch and moan about this, but he is essentially impotent to stop Abbas from putting the Palestinian issue on the agenda with international organisations.
Abbas is getting good PR out of this, all the wile looking like a good politician instead of some mad terrorist. It took the PA/PLO decades to learn to project a moderate image. Arafat addressed the UN dressed like a movie-villain. These days Palestinian spokespeople look like actual humans.

This reminds me: the Palestinians threw away their best political and PR asset in Hannan Ashrawi. I think she got sidetracked because of internal politics.
 
There are currently no negotiations about going back to the 1967 borders.
this issue should have been addressed ages ago.
The current crisis demands immediate response to stop or reduce the rockets.

Negotiations are not necessary to accept the two state solutions on 1967 borders.
Nethanyahu, if sincere, could go on TV right now and say: "Hey, we have decided to accep the two-state solution based on 1967 borders with some limited mutually agreed land swaps. We also accept East Jerusalem as capital of the Palestinian state".
There is noone, certainly not Hamas, who prevents Nethanyahu from doing this.
So why Nethanyahu is not doing this?
And why the US keeps give Israel billions in military aid per year, why is not Obama pushing more Nethanyahu to accept the two state solution based on 1967 borders?

Abbas isn't wildly successful, but he isn't failing either.

He focusses on building international support for a Palestinian state.
Netanyahu can bitch and moan about this, but he is essentially impotent to stop Abbas from putting the Palestinian issue on the agenda with international organisations.

Why should Nethanyahu stop Abbas to put the Palestinian issue on the agenda?

Abbas is getting good PR out of this, all the wile looking like a good politician instead of some mad terrorist. It took the PA/PLO decades to learn to project a moderate image. Arafat addressed the UN dressed like a movie-villain. These days Palestinian spokespeople look like actual humans.

This reminds me: the Palestinians threw away their best political and PR asset in Hannan Ashrawi. I think she got sidetracked because of internal politics.

Totally beyond the point.
Again, I am asking you now.
Since we agree that the two-state solution based on 1967 borders is the right thing to do and since Abbas agrees on this, and since Hamas can not do anything to prevent Nethanyahu to go out and accept the two-state solution on 1967 borders, why Nethanyahu does not just do that?
 
Negotiations are not necessary to accept the two state solutions on 1967 borders.
Nethanyahu, if sincere, could go on TV right now and say: "Hey, we have decided to accep the two-state solution based on 1967 borders with some limited mutually agreed land swaps. We also accept East Jerusalem as capital of the Palestinian state".
There is noone, certainly not Hamas, who prevents Nethanyahu from doing this.
So why Nethanyahu is not doing this?

<snip>

Again, I am asking you now.
Since we agree that the two-state solution based on 1967 borders is the right thing to do and since Abbas agrees on this, and since Hamas can not do anything to prevent Nethanyahu to go out and accept the two-state solution on 1967 borders, why Nethanyahu does not just do that?

A Palestinian State created by a unilateral declaration of Israel would very likely not be accepted by either Israel, or by the Palestinians.

Some would view it as conceding too much to the other side.

Others would see it as not going far enough.

And both sides have legitimate issues that they would want resolved prior any such declaration, if only because some issues such as border security, passports, travel and work requirements, the actual physical location of the borders,etc. then need to be resolved NOW. In addition, you also have to consider other nation states - Egypt and Jordan in particular, as you are now unilaterally changing their border and security arrangements without consulting them.

Both Palestinian and Israeli governments would need to deal with internal politics as well - Israel being a parliamentary democracy such a treaty, etc would need to be ratified in the Knesset, and if you had not taken the time before such an announcement to get a broad consensus that this was a good thing for Israel then you are in real danger of any unilateral decision not being ratified and that deal falling through.

In the Palestinian Territories you essentially have two separate governments, one in the West Bank that might accept such a deal, if it was negotiated, but unlikely if it was the result of a unilateral declaration by the other side. And in Gaza you have Hamas, who does not recognize the legitimacy of Israel and would therefore be much more inclined to claim that any such declaration to be of no force or effect.

So, Nethanyahu isn't going to make such an announcement unilaterally because it would create more problems than it would solve for both parties.
 
SPeaking of Warmongers,I would say firing missiles into a neighboring country is a damn good example of "Warmongering".
I wish some of these people here would just shout "DEATH TO ISRAEL" and be honest about it.
 
A Palestinian State created by a unilateral declaration of Israel would very likely not be accepted by either Israel, or by the Palestinians.

I guess you are playing dumb here.
The Palestinians have already accepted the two-state solution based on the 1967 borders

And both sides have legitimate issues that they would want resolved prior any such declaration, if only because some issues such as border security, passports, travel and work requirements, the actual physical location of the borders,etc. then need to be resolved NOW. In addition, you also have to consider other nation states - Egypt and Jordan in particular, as you are now unilaterally changing their border and security arrangements without consulting them.

Excuses, excuses..
Issuing a new passport has never been a problem and the borders of Jordan and Egypt will be untouched
Let alone all this, which one of this "problems" would prevent Nethanyahu to go out in the Knesset and say "We accept th two state solution on the 1967 borders"?
This is just lie that hypocrite people bring forward as they do not want peace in first place.
And this makes them guilty of children murder (along with Hamas)

Both Palestinian and Israeli governments would need to deal with internal politics as well - Israel being a parliamentary democracy such a treaty, etc would need to be ratified in the Knesset, and if you had not taken the time before such an announcement to get a broad consensus that this was a good thing for Israel then you are in real danger of any unilateral decision not being ratified and that deal falling through.

OK
So you mean that in all the past 5-10 years the Knesset did not have the time to study and accept the two state solution on 1967 borders as they were too busy with.. more impotrant things?

In the Palestinian Territories you essentially have two separate governments, one in the West Bank that might accept such a deal, if it was negotiated, but unlikely if it was the result of a unilateral declaration by the other side. And in Gaza you have Hamas, who does not recognize the legitimacy of Israel and would therefore be much more inclined to claim that any such declaration to be of no force or effect.

ButbutbutbutHAMAS! We are speaking about the Israeli now

ISo, Nethanyahu isn't going to make such an announcement unilaterally because it would create more problems than it would solve for both parties.

Yeah!
There might be the big hurdle about how to issue new passports, a real pain in the a**.
So big problm compared to the nuisance of killing 200 civilians
 
Last edited:
SPeaking of Warmongers,I would say firing missiles into a neighboring country is a damn good example of "Warmongering".
I wish some of these people here would just shout "DEATH TO ISRAEL" and be honest about it.
Several in here have done pretty much this already. They may not spell it out, but then again, they do not need to.
 
200 dead at the end of the day is a drop in the water compared to how other leaders such as Napoleon, Ivan the terrible, tamerlane, Alexander the Macedonian and Hernan Cortez would have behaved in their position.
 
I guess you are playing dumb here.

One of us is - you asked a question and I believe my response qualifies as a reasonable answer to the question "Why doesn't Nethanyahu just go on TV and say, "Hey, we have decided to accep the two-state solution based on 1967 borders with some limited mutually agreed land swaps. We also accept East Jerusalem as capital of the Palestinian state".

Nothing actually prevents Nethanyahu from doing that, except the reality of the political situation that he and the Palestinians would have to face. That and the troubling fact that Nethanyahu is NOT an absolute ruler whose every pronouncement has the effect of law. Any leader - Israeli or Palestinian - who made such a pronouncement would have to deal with their own constituency first, in addition to the other side.

Agreements need all the parties involved to be in at the solution - and if they aren't then all it does is make problems on a grand scale for the everyone else.
 
Agreements need all the parties involved to be in at the solution - and if they aren't then all it does is make problems on a grand scale for the everyone else.

False.
I never spoke about agreements, I simply said that Nethanyahu (along with the Israeli government) can simply accept Palestine proposal of a two state solution based on the 1967 borders.
While it is true that it may take time for any government to take such decision, it is also true that there has been years for taking this step.
The Israeli government is not interested in this solution
And therefore, they, along with the people who do not denounce them, and Hamas who is also not interested in peace, are guilty of the death of the children
 
One of us is - you asked a question and I believe my response qualifies as a reasonable answer to the question "Why doesn't Nethanyahu just go on TV and say, "Hey, we have decided to accep the two-state solution based on 1967 borders with some limited mutually agreed land swaps. We also accept East Jerusalem as capital of the Palestinian state".

Nah...Netenyahu would never say that. Instead, he should just say the truth - which would go something like this:

Yeah...there is no way Israel is giving back any land, and we're eventually going to take it all...because God says it is ours. It may take us decades more to come, but we will make life so miserable for the Palestinians that they will eventually leave. However, until then, we'll keep "Annexing Land" Ha Ha! And infuriating the Palestinians the best we can while pretending to negotiate in good faith. And we'll continue to hammer then with F-16s periodically...but not so bad that we lose support from the US, who has played our sucker...I mean Benefactor...for decades.

Shalom. And don't forget that Israel is the Victim here!
 
Last edited:
False.
I never spoke about agreements, I simply said that Nethanyahu (along with the Israeli government) can simply accept Palestine proposal of a two state solution based on the 1967 borders.
While it is true that it may take time for any government to take such decision, it is also true that there has been years for taking this step.
The Israeli government is not interested in this solution
And therefore, they, along with the people who do not denounce them, and Hamas who is also not interested in peace, are guilty of the death of the children

How is the statement: "Agreements need all the parties involved to be in at the solution - and if they aren't then all it does is make problems on a grand scale for the everyone else." In any way false?
 
How is the statement: "Agreements need all the parties involved to be in at the solution - and if they aren't then all it does is make problems on a grand scale for the everyone else." In any way false?

Hey...Israel can unilaterally give back all that land they stole and I don't think the Arabs will complain a bit about not being involved in the decision.
 
How is the statement: "Agreements need all the parties involved to be in at the solution - and if they aren't then all it does is make problems on a grand scale for the everyone else." In any way false?

I think KumarS means accept a two state solution based on 1967 borders *in principle*. Not as a unilaterally declared solution.
I just realised this when he compared it to Hamas changing it's charter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom