Gahhh! Hillary's trippin'!

You are comparing a single vote in the Senate to the entire Bush/Cheney failed invasion and failed management of the war afterwards. That's what one might call an extreme false equivalency.

Blaming Clinton for the Iraq War disaster is not a rational position.

Momentous votes have consequences. Stupid people shouldn't have guns. People who give stupid people loaded guns are also culpable.
 
Of course Trump is worse. That's not the point. Iraq is just one of the reasons Clinton is doing as badly as she is. Someone like Sanders could have made Trump's support of Iraq an issue. Clinton can't, for obvious reasons.

How long are you going to mourn Sanders' loss?
 
Except there were 21 other Democrats in the Senate (almost half) who did make the right call. Did YOU support Iraq? I didn't. Obama didn't. Sanders didn't. It's not like Clinton would have been a lone voice in the wilderness if she opposed Iraq. Plenty of people opposed it from the start.

And do you think intervening in Libya has been a success? Clinton's fingerprints are all over that one as well.

Why do you give Clinton a pass on this? Bush was stupid for invading Iraq. Clinton was stupid for enabling him. It doesn't take Monday-morning quarterbacking to realize invading a Middle East country wasn't going to end well. Did you honestly think it was a good idea, back in 2003?

And if you flip a coin enough you're bound to get it to come up heads sooner or later. I laugh when people second guess foreign policy decisions as if they had only did it their way things would have turned out right. You're absolutely wrong about 21 other Democrats getting it right because you DON'T know that not supporting regime change in Libya would have had a positive result.

It doesn't work that way. It's not option A is the right choice and option B is the wrong choice. Sometimes all the choices are bad and hopefully you're picking the less bad option. Also the story is not done. Maybe the present turmoil is the price you pay for a long term positive result. We don't know. Has it really been the right choice to support dictators around the world that oppress their people for temporary stability?
 
And if you flip a coin enough you're bound to get it to come up heads sooner or later. I laugh when people second guess foreign policy decisions as if they had only did it their way things would have turned out right. You're absolutely wrong about 21 other Democrats getting it right because you DON'T know that not supporting regime change in Libya would have had a positive result.

It doesn't work that way. It's not option A is the right choice and option B is the wrong choice. Sometimes all the choices are bad and hopefully you're picking the less bad option. Also the story is not done. Maybe the present turmoil is the price you pay for a long term positive result. We don't know. Has it really been the right choice to support dictators around the world that oppress their people for temporary stability?

You don't get to have it both ways. We don't live in a myopia of could-have-beens. It's fair, at this point in time, to categorize Iraq as a fiasco and a terrible decision. Clinton has said her vote was a mistake because it's obvious to everyone now that invading Iraq was not a smart thing to do. I'd rather a politician not make "mistakes" like the Iraq vote, wouldn't you? And if they do make mistakes like that, it's fair to call them on it.

Libya has also been a disaster, and while we might have gotten drawn into by virtue of being a NATO member, we certainly didn't need Clinton pimping regime change to a reluctant Obama.
 
You don't get to have it both ways. We don't live in a myopia of could-have-beens. It's fair, at this point in time, to categorize Iraq as a fiasco and a terrible decision. Clinton has said her vote was a mistake because it's obvious to everyone now that invading Iraq was not a smart thing to do. I'd rather a politician not make "mistakes" like the Iraq vote, wouldn't you? And if they do make mistakes like that, it's fair to call them on it.

Libya has also been a disaster, and while we might have gotten drawn into by virtue of being a NATO member, we certainly didn't need Clinton pimping regime change to a reluctant Obama.

Neither do you. I'm not saying HRC was right or wrong about either decision. Based on what we knew at the time BOTH choices may have been right...AND STILL TURNED OUT WRONG.


IMV
I would argue that invading Iraq was wrong because it was being done under false pretenses. Pretenses that were pure fabrication. Libya is an entirely different as it was coming apart at the seams and France and the UK was going to do it anyway.

One could argue that Obama is the one that failed in Libya by using half measures. But even that is a big second guess.

I don't think any of us have all the answers to these problems. I thought Jimmy Carter made the right decisions with Iran, but I think the results were horrible. How about Eisenhower's decision to overthrow Mossadegh?

I'm not criticizing you , I just think that the idea, that Bernie or Trump or me would make the right decision is absurd.
 
Last edited:
It's hard to avoid comparisons. Calling Clinton incompetent is ludicrous.

I agree and I apologize.

You just took the brunt of my frustration with both sides deflecting, deflecting, deflecting.

No doubt I've done it myself, so glass houses and all that.

I don't care for Hillary, but will stipulate she's highly qualified. My issues with her lie elsewhere.
 
If Hillary was qualified and competent, she wouldn't have voted for Iraq and pushed for regime change in Libya.
I've made mistakes and remained qualified and competent. OK, we called Iraq better at the time and it seemed a no-brainer to us, but Clinton can't be terribly faulted for underestimating the mendacity of the Cheney-Rove administration. It plumbed new depths.

Having decades in politics doesn't necessarily make one qualified to be President.
It presents plenty of opportunity to prove oneself woefully unqualified. Still being on anyone's radar after decades does prove something.

Is John Boehner qualified? Dennis Hastert? Tom Delay? Newt Gingrich?
Who knows or cares? All Papabile at one point but they screwed-up somewhere along the way and haven't recovered yet.

Proof of qualification for office can only come from the holding of it competently. Which is why this is only about Hillary Clinton, because everybody knows Trump would prove himself unqualified as President before he even warmed the seat. As if he hasn't proved it already over and over again.
 
Regarding Clinton "pushing regime change in Libya", Gaddafi was the Libyan regime and his status change from "live" to "dead" was looming. Regime change started through local agency with that reality very much in mind. What the US did was reactive, not determining. Things really do happen that are not about the US.

How the US engaged with it is another matter, but it cannot be ignored that had the Cheney-Rove administration not engineered the invasion of Iraq Obama and Clinton could have put boots on the ground in Libya. As it was the perfectly reasonable demand of the US population, Army and Marines was not to get involved in anything like Iraq again.

Could Obama have provided better security for US personnel in Benghazi without the GOP screeching "Boots on the ground!"? All we can do is make our own judgement on that.
 
Re Libya, it's pure BS to claim in hindsight getting rid of Gaddafi was the wrong choice. Had he not been taken out, and civil war continued, would people still blame Clinton for not recommending action? Of course. They blame Obama for not taking Assad out. Anyone who faults Clinton for the Libya decisions is a poorly informed arse.
 
Re Iraq:

Hillary's vote didn't change a thing as Bush had the numbers without her. She voted to uphold UN Resolution 667, not to invade as Bush did, not to mess up as Bush did.

The Invasion itself was a success, it was the handling of the invasion after Saddam had been overthrown that was a disaster and lead to the total collapse. That's not Hillary's fault and it's crazy trying to put it on her.

Re Lybia:

We can't say that Libya is worse today than it would have been without intervention. Sometimes the best result is the least mess, and this might be it. Had there not been an intervention, Libya could have been Syria Mark 2, that's where it was headed and today we'd be arguing that she was a poor SoS because she allowed the massacre of Benghazi to occur, where the citizens of Benghazi were wiped out man, woman, and child, by Libyan National Forces, all while the US stood by and allowed the genocide they knew was going to happen..
 
Except there were 21 other Democrats in the Senate (almost half) who did make the right call. Did YOU support Iraq? I didn't. Obama didn't. Sanders didn't. It's not like Clinton would have been a lone voice in the wilderness if she opposed Iraq. Plenty of people opposed it from the start.

And do you think intervening in Libya has been a success? Clinton's fingerprints are all over that one as well.

Why do you give Clinton a pass on this? Bush was stupid for invading Iraq. Clinton was stupid for enabling him. It doesn't take Monday-morning quarterbacking to realize invading a Middle East country wasn't going to end well. Did you honestly think it was a good idea, back in 2003?

Doesn't matter at all because she's the only candidate qualified to be POTUS and Trump is insane.
 
Doesn't matter at all because she's the only candidate qualified to be POTUS and Trump is insane.

This really ought to be the response to everything. "But Trump is INSANE." There should be no other argument needed. Balance the claims of "she's a commie crook" that you get from the right with those from the left "she's a corporatist wall street stooge crook". She comes out right in the middle, where the country's been heading.

But in the words of Bill Murray in that summer camp movie, "it just doesn't matter... it just doesn't matter... it just doesn't matter", because Trump is INSANE.
 
Huh? She completely collapsed. Have you seen the video?
No she didn't. Let's leave it that you have your opinion and I have mine.

Also, can you imagine the ferocity of the denials coming from the Clinton campaign if there wasn't a video? The fact that some random shmoe was there recording, and the Clinton campaign wasn't aware of him (and thus couldn't bribe him or threaten him to give up the video) could have been the turning point in the election.

You have an active imagination. Have you tried writing fiction?
 
This is moronic. Would they go under surgery performed by local hobo?

Politics, as with everything else, requires certain set of skills. You want to have them in your politican regardless of your worldview and policies. "Unqualified" as pro instead of very big con is retarded beyond belief.

This election nicely encapsulated. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :)
 
That skillset is not unique to politics. Ike had never held political office before becoming president.
In practice, I disagree. He had to deal with Montgomery and de Gaulle. And FDR. And countless conflicting demands for his time, for resources, etc. At his level, he was more politician than General. Being Supreme Allied Commander was excellent preparation for the Presidency.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom