Ziggurat
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2003
- Messages
- 64,447
Because your entire argument is that sure, maybe that one "analysis" that Snopes examined was wrong, but they didn't look at other (fictional) "analyses" and therefore they couldn't and didn't rule the notion out.
No, that isn't my entire argument at all. That's a straw man representation of my argument. I've never said that Hillary does have Parkinson's. I've also never said that, even if she does, anyone would be able to determine that without performing an in-person medical examination. Surely you agree that, if she did have Parkinson's, an in-person medical examination would demonstrate that, yes?
When, in fact, in the parenthetical Snopes dismissed the entire idea of what that argument and all similar arguments are trying to say, that the whole thesis that Clinton has Parkinson's lacks any legitimate basis and isn't even really worth addressing.
They also say that they are not claiming that Hillary does NOT have Parkinson's. Given that this is a description of their own argument, they are rather the legitimate authority on their own position. It seems rather strange that there is so much resistance to believing Snopes about the one thing they can be absolutely certain of.