fuell cell cars vs. electric cars. Who will win the race?

Joined
Aug 6, 2016
Messages
859
So..
For the ones who have been following this, there is a competition as the new technology for cars, that is full electric cars, Chevy Volt, Tesla and so on.. vs. the Fuel cell cars, that is Toyota Mirai and the Toyota-Honda-Nissan axis

Both technologies have their pros and cons, who will win the race (pun intended) on the way to replace gasoline cars
 
I think it will come down to which makes the transition easier. Plug-in G/E hybrids are already commonplace, and allow you to have the advantages of high-power-density fuel while also allowing for grid-power for primary use. There is no similar transition path for hydrogen, meaning it will require a sudden, sizable jump in infrastructure to make it useable.

People like/accept slow changes more than sudden ones. Electric wins in the end.
 
I think it will come down to which makes the transition easier. Plug-in G/E hybrids are already commonplace, and allow you to have the advantages of high-power-density fuel while also allowing for grid-power for primary use. There is no similar transition path for hydrogen, meaning it will require a sudden, sizable jump in infrastructure to make it useable.

People like/accept slow changes more than sudden ones. Electric wins in the end.

Agreed. But we need a world dictator who will determine standards, connections and the like to make quick and easy battery swaps a reality. A 'filling station' loaded with different types of battery with different heavyweight equipment for swapping out hefty batteries is one hell of an investment.
 
The electricity infrastructure already exists and is even more widely spread than the gasoline infrastructure. Fuel cells will remain a very small niche until they can make the hydrogen infrastructure easy to 'piggyback' on the existing fuel infrastructures in some way.
 
The electricity infrastructure already exists and is even more widely spread than the gasoline infrastructure. Fuel cells will remain a very small niche until they can make the hydrogen infrastructure easy to 'piggyback' on the existing fuel infrastructures in some way.

But battery infrastructure doesn't. When an accident causes a major traffic jam in worsening weather then your seemingly adequate nominal 150-mile battery range for that 100-mile journey might leave you with a flat battery at the side of the road and miles from the nearest recharging point. Maybe scores of other vehicles too. You need a battery swap, whereas a conventional 'empty tank' just needs a can of gas.

If every manufacturer of electric cars chooses a different way, however slight, then common standards will have to be retro-fitted. Expensive and contentious.
 
But battery infrastructure doesn't. When an accident causes a major traffic jam in worsening weather then your seemingly adequate nominal 150-mile battery range for that 100-mile journey might leave you with a flat battery at the side of the road and miles from the nearest recharging point. Maybe scores of other vehicles too. You need a battery swap, whereas a conventional 'empty tank' just needs a can of gas.

If every manufacturer of electric cars chooses a different way, however slight, then common standards will have to be retro-fitted. Expensive and contentious.

Who needs battery swaps? Just retain a small gas generator for emergencies. As electric becomes the primary means of motivation, the requirements for gas become small enough that bio-diesel or similarly 'created' fuels can meet demand while being close to carbon neutral. No need for common 'electric' infrastructure other than the existing grid.
 
Who needs battery swaps? Just retain a small gas generator for emergencies. As electric becomes the primary means of motivation, the requirements for gas become small enough that bio-diesel or similarly 'created' fuels can meet demand while being close to carbon neutral. No need for common 'electric' infrastructure other than the existing grid.

Do you mean hybrids all the way, to cope with the occasional emergency/inconvenience? What about the 300-mile journey when you have a 200-mile range (change the figures if you like, for new battery technology). Nobody wants a long layover to recharge. I'm convinced battery swapping will become the norm.

Another thought - if you live in a high density housing area then domestic recharging could be close to impossible (you live on the 15th floor of a block, say), and recharging stations in the street are not that simple a proposition. Finding anywhere to park in much of the UK is a sodding bitch already, let alone finding a recharging point even when they become plentiful. A recharging point for every car-parking spot?

Or maybe just stop for 5 minutes at the battery station on the way to work?
 
Agreed. But we need a world dictator who will determine standards, connections and the like to make quick and easy battery swaps a reality. A 'filling station' loaded with different types of battery with different heavyweight equipment for swapping out hefty batteries is one hell of an investment.
None of these stations exists, but recharging stations do, and getting enough charge to make the rest of the journey home, if you're running out before you reach your destination, is the work of not many minutes.

I'm impressed by the argument that mass use of electric cars can be attained by gradual extension of existing technology and infrastructure, via hybrid cars; with the concept of the primary drive changing from the ic to the electric motor, even in the same vehicle. This could happen as charging points become more common and worn-out batteries are replaced in the same vehicles by more capacious and faster-charging successors. In contrast to this, fuel cells do seem to require a "revolutionary discontinuity" which is hard to achieve.

I think fuel cells may gain more acceptance in managed fleets, like buses, city trams (where their silent running and independence from unsightly overhead power sources will be seen as huge advantages) and door to door goods delivery vehicles (where their non-polluting propellants will be appreciated).
 
More like 30-40 minutes for a full recharge as far as I know
What level of recharge does the average car user need to get to work? Or back from work, more likely, if she or he has plugged in over night? How long would that partial charge require? Anyone know?
 
Or at work is just as likely.
I can envisage electric car chargers in business or parking garages.
Charge your car while working or shopping.

With a critical mass of numbers, this could be quite a viable business.
ETA : I'd be very surprised if this is not already in place.
 
Last edited:
Or at work is just as likely.
I can envisage electric car chargers in business or parking garages.
Charge your car while working or shopping.

With a critical mass of numbers, this could be quite a viable business.
ETA : I'd be very surprised if this is not already in place.
Yes. This looks like a viable business franchising opportunity for eg supermarkets, or even cinemas or churches, that operate car parks. Passing trade would be possible too outside the operator's business hours. Like six days in the case of churches. As soon as the "critical mass" of electric cars is reached, this is what we'll see. And slot machine-paid chargers on lamp posts in residential areas, providing revenue for the local authority operating the street lights.

And multi-storey car parks. Have your car charged while it's in the car park, for a small extra fee. Car wash plus charge. There's no end to the potentialities.
 
Did you see the kind of explosion a small fuel-cell can produce?! I did, in one of the Terminator movies......
 
Did you see the kind of explosion a small fuel-cell can produce?! I did, in one of the Terminator movies......
They should be careful, and slowly recharge Schwarzenegger overnight using only the domestic power supply.
 
What level of recharge does the average car user need to get to work? Or back from work, more likely, if she or he has plugged in over night? How long would that partial charge require? Anyone know?

still a lot of time according to Toyota, and I doubt people want to wait
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom