#FeesMustFall - Student Protests in South Africa

DarthFishy

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jan 9, 2008
Messages
1,393
I know there are a couple of South African forum members as well as a number of non-South Africans who are interested in the country (mostly just in our rugby team!), so I thought this might be a topic of some interest.

Currently in South Africa there are wide raging protests at Universities due to a substantial hike in tuition and registration fees planned for 2016.

Some links:

Live News Updates

Some people liken the actions to the Arab Spring

Titter Hastag for the movement

The whole situation is of interest to me because I am (a) a lecturer at a South African University (one that so far has NOT had any protests), and (b) I am a student at another University.

I'm a position to see both sides of the coin, so to speak.

Is anybody else following this?
 
Students at the University of Cape Town marched to the Parliament building to protest. Eventually a number of these students forced their way unto the grounds (which tangentially raises some serious security questions), and have been charged with "assault, contravening the National Key Points Act and treason" according to one reporters tweet.

The first two charges are understandable, but treason seems rather harsh!
 
Just a correction, but it seems that the treason charges were never made. So some incorrect reporting there.
 
What proportion of the full cost are students expected to pay?

In the 70s and early 80s Australia had virtually free university education. Sounds fine until the penny dropped that taxpayers (including low income taxpayers) who never had the opportunity to attend university were funding free education to high earning lawyers, doctors, engineers etc etc. We now have a Higher Education Contribution Scheme where graduates (including my kids) pay off part of their education debt when they reach a certain income threshold.

This scheme, while not wildly popular with students, is well accepted.

So is the call for students to pay part of their debt? If so, suck it up students.
 
First of all the Universities are subsidized to varying degrees. Based on the subsidies and income the Universities determine the study fees. Students are expected to pay the full amount of the fees unless they qualify for government assistance or a bursary.

No the problem is really twofold.

Firstly its the increase in current fees of 10% (which is a much higher increase than inflation at 6%). Students as well as their parents are already struggling to pay for university fees so this increase is unmanageable for many parents/students.

Secondly only a small percentage of South Africans can afford tertiary education. If the number of graduates do not increase significantly it will be very difficult to improve the economic situation in the country. Combined with that the government only spends 0.75% of GDP on Tertiary education, much less than most other African countries (never mind other developed countries).

The main thrust of the movement is that there needs to be a major change in the way funding of tertiary education is approached.

Some students are campaigning for free tertiary education, which I believe is a noble, but highly unrealistic goal. Others are campaigning for a decrease in the increase of fees for 2016, which is a lot more sensible in my opinion.
 
In the 70s and early 80s Australia had virtually free university education. Sounds fine until the penny dropped that taxpayers (including low income taxpayers) who never had the opportunity to attend university were funding free education to high earning lawyers, doctors, engineers etc etc. We now have a Higher Education Contribution Scheme where graduates (including my kids) pay off part of their education debt when they reach a certain income threshold.

I think this kind of scheme would work very well. We do have a serious problem with only about 40% of the country actually paying income tax and shouldering the majority of the tax burden.

It doesn't help though if the current government is regularly accused of corruption and mismanagement of funds. Then the ire of students whose fees go up, while the Cabinet members all get fancy new German cars, is understandable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom