Eyeglasses and retail optometry are scams

C'mon Tippit. I'm genuinely curious.

You're
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
trying to trap me with word games. I win though, because the truth prevails.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You're
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
, trying to trap me with word games. I win though, because the truth prevails.

Word games?!

I've quoted you directly.
Essentially, by undercorrecting your prescription to about 20/50, and practicing good visual hygiene (20-20-20 rule, taking significant computer breaks, engaging distance vision outdoors as a matter of habit), you can reduce your myopia by about .25 diopters every 3-4 months. Since most people are overprescribed, you can reduce your first prescription by as much as 0.5 diopter, and you will see significant and rapid results within even a month or two. That's all there is to it.

Read your post above. You stated two pieces of advice that you said would reduce myopia. You said "That's all there is to it". You've stated this more than once.

How did you determine that these two steps, out of ALL the information Jake has put out there, were the only two steps needed for anyone to reduce their progressive myopia?

Maybe YOU'RE the one being disingenuous.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You're a disingenuous troll, trying to trap me with word games. I win though, because the truth prevails.
Here's the problem.

You have repeatedly stated that progressive myopia can be stopped/reversed/fixed by following two simple pieces of advice you've supposedly plucked from the mountains of information that Jake has out there.

1. Under-correcting your prescription to about 20/50
2. Taking breaks from near visual work (20-20-20 rule, every 20 minutes stare at an object 20' away for at least 20 seconds), going for walks, taking hard breaks after a few hours of computer use, and generally spending more time outside engaging your distance vision and allowing your ciliary muscle to relax.

This means you've either been disingenuous about what you actually did to improve your eyesight or Jake's dissemination of all his information is a complete scam. A scam that deliberately makes it hard to find these "two simple steps to end progressive myopia" that you've supposedly found. He deliberately makes particular advice hard to find so he can bilk people out of their hard earned money by charging them a exorbitant fee to syphon out the "best possible resources" for them. He even states as much on his class site.

Jake said:
If you want a more structured approach with personal support, I do provide the best possible resources and tools to help you eliminate your lens dependence.

You mean to tell me he's holding out the "best possible resources" from his free content and you only get those if you pay?

Yet he says it's not about the money.

Riiiggghhhtttt....
 
The highly touted (by Tippit) post no 264 links to a trial in adult presbyopes to determine whether defocus leads to choroidal thinning or thickening. The motivation for the study is that SFCT thinning is linked to reduced blood flow and to resulting diseases of the eye, and the hypothesis is that uncorrected defocus in the developing world scenario can be linked via SFCT to increased prevalence of these diseases (age-related macular degeneration and diabetic retinopathy)
Tippit said:
This is a lie, conceived out of your own bias, and lack of understanding of what you've read...I defy you to find a single instance in the study, where it is proposed that such changes are transient, or not permanent.
First of all I don't know why you have to be so damned rude to everyone all the time.

Secondly, it is clear from the paper that the same experimental eye in subjects was subjected to the process (with opposite defocus on successive days). In spite of the fact that choroidal thinning or thickening was observed on Day 1, the paper states "The mean baseline SFCT in the 37 experimental eyes (before application of defocus) was not different from that in contralateral control eyes", which clearly indicates that the thinning /thickening on Day 1 does not carry over to Day 2.

Third, the paper clearly states: "Defocus-induced changes in choroidal thickness were somewhat unexpected in presbyopic subjects because in developing eyes they have been regarded as indicative of precursor signals to decreases and increases in subsequent eye growth,15 mediated by changes in the sclera. Because there is little evidence of changes in eye growth in presbyopia, the presence of these sign-of-defocus–dependent choroidal thickness changes suggests either that the sclera in presbyopic eyes no longer responds to these signals, or that the choroidal thickness changes are associated with some other function." And there you have it - no change in axial length expected in the adult presbyopic eye.

Fourth, the thinning or thickening of the SFCT was of the order of 10 microns after 60 minutes. A change in posterior axial length of 10 microns would have a minimal effect on defocus - for a 2mm pupil the defocused circle of confusion for a 10 micron defocus would be less than 1 micron (the linear spacing of cones on the retina is several microns - 30,000 per square mm).

So much for the suggestion that this paper provides evidence of persistent changes in axial length in adults.
 
Last edited:
Here's the problem.

You have repeatedly stated that progressive myopia can be stopped/reversed/fixed by following two simple pieces of advice you've supposedly plucked from the mountains of information that Jake has out there.

1. Under-correcting your prescription to about 20/50
2. Taking breaks from near visual work (20-20-20 rule, every 20 minutes stare at an object 20' away for at least 20 seconds), going for walks, taking hard breaks after a few hours of computer use, and generally spending more time outside engaging your distance vision and allowing your ciliary muscle to relax.

This means you've either been disingenuous about what you actually did to improve your eyesight or Jake's dissemination of all his information is a complete scam. A scam that deliberately makes it hard to find these "two simple steps to end progressive myopia" that you've supposedly found. He deliberately makes particular advice hard to find so he can bilk people out of their hard earned money by charging them a exorbitant fee to syphon out the "best possible resources" for them. He even states as much on his class site.

No, there are other possibilities
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First of all I don't know why you have to be some damned rude to everyone all the time.

You and your band of know-it-alls are the rude ones. I am merely holding my own on the dogpile. Maybe if you step back for a moment, and realize that you don't know everything, you would take a more humble approach, and learn something. I'm not holding my breath.

Secondly, it is clear from the paper that the same experimental eye in subjects was subjected to the process (with opposite defocus on successive days). In spite of the fact that choroidal thinning or thickening was observed on Day 1, the paper states "The mean baseline SFCT in the 37 experimental eyes (before application of defocus) was not different from that in contralateral control eyes", which clearly indicates that the thinning /thickening on Day 1 does not carry over to Day 2.

No it doesn't mean that at all. It means that the average baseline for the 37 experimental eyes was not different from the control eyes when they were first measured, before defocus. They are confirming that there was no difference between the aggregate sums of the lengths of the eyes of the participants in the study, for each eye, before the study began. That's it.

Third, the paper clearly states: "Defocus-induced changes in choroidal thickness were somewhat unexpected in presbyopic subjects because in developing eyes they have been regarded as indicative of precursor signals to decreases and increases in subsequent eye growth,15 mediated by changes in the sclera. Because there is little evidence of changes in eye growth in presbyopia, the presence of these sign-of-defocus–dependent choroidal thickness changes suggests either that the sclera in presbyopic eyes no longer responds to these signals, or that the choroidal thickness changes are associated with some other function." And there you have it - no change in axial length expected in the adult presbyopic eye.
It's odd how you can make the exact opposite deduction from the actual facts. First, the changes in SFCT are by definition, changes in axial length. Second, they were unexpected because it was assumed that changes in the SFCT only occurred in the developing eyes of juveniles, when this study proves, in fact, that they aren't limited to juveniles, and the changes are significant. You should work on your reading comprehension, or try to be more honest, or both.

Fourth, the thinning or thickening of the SFCT was of the order of 10 microns after 60 minutes. A change in posterior axial length of 10 microns would have a minimal effect on defocus - for a 2mm pupil the defocused circle of confusion for a 10 micron defocus would be less than 1 micron (the linear spacing of cones on the retina is several microns - 30,000 per square mm).

This isn't exactly shocking. What would you expect after only 60 minutes? I was using lenses to impose myopic defocus for nine months, and then, after much success, I removed the lenses. From then to now, the myopic defocus I have in the absence of lenses, which was caused by decades of wearing lenses, is enough to provide the signal for my eyes to shorten - and it's still working.

So much for the suggestion that this paper provides evidence of persistent changes in axial length in adults.

Use of the goalpost moving word "persistent" is again noted. While the study doesn't suggest whether or not this phenomenon is permanent (or at least, non-transient), it does prove that defocus is a stimulus that causes the adult eye to change length, which is obviously enough to warrant further studies.

Here is the conclusion from the abstract, again, emphasis mine:

Conclusions: In presbyopic subjects, imposed myopic retinal defocus caused thickening of SFCT, while hyperopic defocus caused thinning of SFCT. This implies that uncorrected presbyopia, which is associated with hyperopic retinal defocus for near objects and which is highly prevalent in the developing world, would likely be associated with choroidal thinning and possibly reduced choroidal blood flow with prolonged periods in a near visual environment.

You can dance around this all you want, express doubt about the implications, or try to weasel around the facts, but the conclusion of the study speaks for itself.
 
Last edited:
C'mon Tippit. I'm genuinely curious.


How did you come to the conclusion that the two steps/pieces of advice below are "all there is to" reducing/correcting/fixing anyone's myopia? Is there a pool of Jake's advice that you plucked these two pieces of advice from?

1. Under-correcting your prescription to about 20/50
2. Taking breaks from near visual work (20-20-20 rule, every 20 minutes stare at an object 20' away for at least 20 seconds), going for walks, taking hard breaks after a few hours of computer use, and generally spending more time outside engaging your distance vision and allowing your ciliary muscle to relax.
Thanks for summarising.
 
What I don't get is the leap from "it worked for me" with "evidence shows that this will substantially correct myopia in a statistically significant number of patients."
 
Use of the goalpost moving word "persistent" is again noted.
There is no moving of goalposts. I have said from the outset, and I continue to maintain, that there is no published evidence that the procedure you have followed can produce persistent changes in axial eye length sufficient to do what you are claiming.

Surely you are not making the rather silly claim that changes in SFCT (the source of the "length" changes in the only study of adults that you can find) are sufficient to correct myopia absent changes in the overall length of the eye which result in changes to the length of the vitreous chamber (the mechanism by which the growing eye in juveniles achieves emmetropy).

The study resulted in only 10 micron change to SFCT. The total baseline SFCT averaged 230 microns with a range of 117 microns to 396 microns. The correction of 1D of defocus requires a change in posterior eyelength of about 0.6mm or 600 microns. The correction of a 2D myopic defocus would require thickening of the SFC nearly five tiimes the mean baseline thickness. It's a non-starter. Mrs Hecd2 is myopic and her correction for distance is -7D. Her SFCT would have to increase by over 4mm to correct her vision if the mechanism reported in this paper is at all relevant to your claims.

Until you can show published evidence that the human adult eye can have persistent (long lasting) changes in length of the order of 0.6mm per dioptre, your claim stays in the waste basket.
 
Bearing in mind that 'properly' means that it was successful (the Witch-doctor Principle), what do you think?
The problem being is that proper advice/steps haven't been defined, which is what I'm trying to understand.

Tippit has provided two steps (below) that are supposed to be the only things that anyone with progressive myopia needs to do to reverse it.
1. Under-correcting your prescription to about 20/50
2. Taking breaks from near visual work (20-20-20 rule, every 20 minutes stare at an object 20' away for at least 20 seconds), going for walks, taking hard breaks after a few hours of computer use, and generally spending more time outside engaging your distance vision and allowing your ciliary muscle to relax.

Jake states on his website, under the Classes and Support link, that there are "over 1,200 free articles, how-to guides, many improvement reports, diopter discussions, as well as our FB group and private forum." How did Tippit determine, out of all that information, that those two steps are the only thing anyone needs to do in order to reverse their progressive myopia?

Jake then goes on to say "If you want a more structured approach with personal support, I do provide the best possible resources and tools to help you eliminate your lens dependence." If what Tippit claims is true, then why does Jake need to charge people exorbitant fees for him to provide the best possible resources? Why is the snipe hunt for information needed when it's simply two steps?
 
20/50 seems impractical for daily life. 20/30 or .5 diopters is comfortable for most people and they'll still be able to drive safely at night, etc. That would still be pointless if you're not using reading glasses for close work. Undercorrecting by 1.0 then staring at a cellphone screen all day, where you might need +3.0 or +3.5 of correction from distance-neutral to achieve neutral focus would be missing the point. You should choose reading or computer glasses to achieve neutral focus at reading or computer distance, not to use the minimum strength that allows clear focus (at my age, those are almost the same thing).

Not that I think you can reverse significant myopia by doing this, but I do believe it would slow progression for most people, not to mention reducing eyestrain and eyestrain-induced headaches in people who are prone to those.
 
20/50 seems impractical for daily life. 20/30 or .5 diopters is comfortable for most people and they'll still be able to drive safely at night, etc. That would still be pointless if you're not using reading glasses for close work.

No, because temporary myopia and pseudomyopia is mostly the result of ciliary muscle spasm, not axial elongation. Since staring at screens up close for extended periods of time without distance lenses doesn't induce peripheral hyperopic defocus, you could improve simply by under-correcting your distance prescription (and your differential prescription, if you are unable to see a computer screen without minus lenses). Taking breaks from near work enough to reduce/eliminate the muscle spasm along with the reduced distance lenses would be enough.

There is definitely plenty of evidence that myopic defocus does reduce axial elongation, and thus, plus lenses will likely improve myopia by axial shortening. I personally think there are probably some side effects to this (peripheral myopic defocus?) so I only use .2 diopter gaming glasses with blueblocker lenses at night, and somewhat sparingly.

It's important to realize that there are numerous causes of myopia, optical, neurological, and most commonly muscular. Even people who never wear glasses will experience occasional blurriness after staring at screens for extended periods of time, this is the ciliary muscle spasm. As long as they never start wearing minus lenses, axial elongation should not occur, and thus the optics of the eye will remain emmetropic.

Under-correcting by 1.0 then staring at a cellphone screen all day, where you might need +3.0 or +3.5 of correction from distance-neutral to achieve neutral focus would be missing the point. You should choose reading or computer glasses to achieve neutral focus at reading or computer distance, not to use the minimum strength that allows clear focus (at my age, those are almost the same thing).

The problem with reduced lens therapy, is that there is a sweet spot for under-correction that must be achieved. If there is too much under-correction, there is far too much blur, and the brain doesn't send the proper signals to shorten the eye. Steiner calls this "blur adaptation". The brain essentially gives up in front of the wall of blur, and progress either doesn't occur at all, or extremely slowly. This is why moderate to severe myopes can't simply stop wearing glasses and hope to regain emmetropia. Maybe they could, but it might take decades.

Also, even moderate myopes cannot view a computer monitor functionally using even low diopter plus lenses. My worst prescription was OD -2.00 and -0.75 CYL, and there was no way I could function with plus lenses in front of the computer, since I could barely see the computer using large fonts from an ergonomic distance as it was without glasses when I started this process.

Severe myopes will need not only reduced distance lenses, but also reduced differential lenses specifically for computer/near use, since there is no way they can function with plus lenses at all, for any application. Plus lenses are probably a decent prophylactic for emmetropes who want to avoid/lessen ciliary spasm and generally reduce eyestrain when viewing computers for extended periods.

Not that I think you can reverse significant myopia by doing this, but I do believe it would slow progression for most people, not to mention reducing eyestrain and eyestrain-induced headaches in people who are prone to those.

I assure you you can. Not only does it slow progression, it reverses it! It shortens the axis over time! Not only that, we know the approximate rate, which is about +0.25 diopter per 3-4 months.

I do not know what the optimal under-correction is for the fastest results. I think Steiner claims it is somewhere around 20/40 or 20/50. There needs to be enough clarity for the brain to attempt accommodation, but enough blur for there to be a "challenge" and to impose the myopic defocus. I never got into the weeds with his methods, because my myopia was fairly moderate. I just watched a few of his videos and decided to order some cheap custom reduced lenses from Zenni, and nine months later i was eyeglasses free (though still not emmetropic). I made a few mistakes by dropping my cylinder correction completely. I should have just reduced it by .25 diopter. This resulted in my left eye improving much more rapidly than my astigmatic eye, causing a significant differential between the two eyes, and necessitated me to do more patching than was necessary, and may have cost me a year or more.
 
While overprescribed eyeglasses undoubtedly make everyone see better, and in some cases very happy, they also create a physical handicap, a lifelong dependency, and a lifetime of unnecessary wasted time and money. You have been informed!

Very true.
 
I don't have this ability to get my vision tested so often nor get glasses made to meet each new set of numbers.
I doubt many of us do as good optometrist types like to get paid for providing a service.
As does just about every trained professional.

I don't think paying a professional his due wages is outrageous or unexpected.
 
Very true.

What if something is very, very, VERY true? Does that make it so true it can never be any more true? Or can we keep adding veries if it gets even truer than it was?

Conversely, if something is just pretty true, or fairly true, or kinda true, can we specify what percent true it is? Like maybe 34.5% true? 94.44%? 19.56%, rounded to 20% for the evening news?

Thing is, I want to know just how much very true Tippit is. Lotta wordagery in his posts, know what I mean?

Thanks in advance for all the help you're going to give me.
 
What if something is very, very, VERY true? Does that make it so true it can never be any more true? Or can we keep adding veries if it gets even truer than it was?

Conversely, if something is just pretty true, or fairly true, or kinda true, can we specify what percent true it is? Like maybe 34.5% true? 94.44%? 19.56%, rounded to 20% for the evening news?

Thing is, I want to know just how much very true Tippit is. Lotta wordagery in his posts, know what I mean?

Thanks in advance for all the help you're going to give me.

Gibberish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom