Explain consciousness to the layman.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's certainly possible to simulate a time-dependent system with a Turing computational system, but that doesn't mean that they are the same thing.

That is a meaningless statement in the context of this discussion, and nobody cares. You won't ever agree to use the same terms as us, so whatever.

The question with meaning, in this context, is whether or not an entity existing as part of a Turing machine run is capable, even theoretically, of figuring out that its time dependency is in fact merely simulated.

I don't know how many times we have to go over this. And that question is even framed in the precise terms you want to use, so don't whine that it isn't. All you have to do is answer.
 
That is a meaningless statement in the context of this discussion, and nobody cares. You won't ever agree to use the same terms as us, so whatever.

The question with meaning, in this context, is whether or not an entity existing as part of a Turing machine run is capable, even theoretically, of figuring out that its time dependency is in fact merely simulated.

I don't know how many times we have to go over this. And that question is even framed in the precise terms you want to use, so don't whine that it isn't. All you have to do is answer.

For some posters it seems that every post is a brand new experience.
 
What matters is relevant factors. That's what experimental design is all about.
Do you have a method that enables to completely determine the relevancy of a given factor?

If the answer is no, then "That's what experimental design is all about" is at most in-vitro.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a method that enables to completely determines the relevancy of a given factor?

No.

I think this is a good point. For some, reduction to various functions that are then copied seems to be enough to achieve co-called consciousness. My take is that the term consciousness is so vague that absolutely everything can be considered conscious. Therefore, it's no surprise that a computer can be considered conscious. After all, everything can be interpreted as having input / output. Like 'computation', the term 'conscious' is broad enough to be seen universally.

When it comes to system replication, however, I don't think you can reduce things into individual functions and consider that the system has been replicated. The system is a continuum such that any artificial replication is always going to differ from it by virtue of it not having the same continuum. So if you want human consciousness or computation (whatever that is), you need a human.
 
No.

I think this is a good point. For some, reduction to various functions that are then copied seems to be enough to achieve co-called consciousness. My take is that the term consciousness is so vague that absolutely everything can be considered conscious. Therefore, it's no surprise that a computer can be considered conscious. After all, everything can be interpreted as having input / output. Like 'computation', the term 'conscious' is broad enough to be seen universally.

When it comes to system replication, however, I don't think you can reduce things into individual functions and consider that the system has been replicated. The system is a continuum such that any artificial replication is always going to differ from it by virtue of it not having the same continuum. So if you want human consciousness or computation (whatever that is), you need a human.
Do you mean that human consciousness (or computation as an agent of human's consciousness) is some property of a wider thing, called by you "a human", or do you mean that human consciousness (or computation as an agent of human's consciousness) is a particular case of a wider thing called "consciousness"?

Or maybe you think that human consciousness is an agent of a wider thing called "computation".
 
Last edited:
Do you mean that human consciousness (or computation as an agent of human's consciousness) is some property of a wider thing, called by you "a human", or do you mean that human consciousness (or computation as an agent of human's consciousness) is a particular case of a wider thing called "consciousness"?

Both. The former is a subset of the latter. Just as being human is a subset of being. A circle within a circle.

The confusion comes because we can only see 'reality' within our circle of awareness, even though we know our circle of awareness is also within reality. The set and the subset get confused (solipsism).
 
Last edited:
Both. The former is a subset of the latter. Just as being human is a subset of being. A circle within a circle.

The confusion comes because we can only see 'reality' within our circle of awareness, even though we know our circle of awareness is also within reality. The set and the subset get confused (solipsism).

Might I suggest an ontology of being (self) which I suggested at the beginning of the thread. It fits the scenario better and all falls into place.
 
Both. The former is a subset of the latter. Just as being human is a subset of being. A circle within a circle.

The confusion comes because we can only see 'reality' within our circle of awareness, even though we know our circle of awareness is also within reality. The set and the subset get confused (solipsism).
Do you mean that human's consciousness is a particular case of the realm of consciousness, and therefore can't actually completely be aware of the realm of consciousness (in this case computation as understood by human's consciousness is a particular case of the realm of computation)?
 
Last edited:
Please can you give more detail or link to your original post.

Here is the post, are you familiar with atman?

There is a difficulty in explaining what I mean when I use "know" and "being". I have not yet found a language or way of words which you guys will find palatable.

Let me define my meaning in the way I am used to discussing this and perhaps you will see the difficulty.

I consider an ontology in which the primary existence or substance is being or self (atman). In which all other forms in existence are subtle or concrete expressions or manifestations of aspects of atman. As a whole the entirety of existence is one being, all parts in existence are the equivalent of cells or molecules in the body of this being.

From this perspective consciousness is an emergent property of being an entity.
 
Do you have a method that enables to completely determine the relevancy of a given factor?
No human endeavour is perfect, but with suitable care and attention, we can usually achieve 'good enough', judging by the results.

If the answer is no, then "That's what experimental design is all about" is at most in-vitro.
Would you say all biological research is therefore 'in-vitro'? I don't see how that is helpful.
 
No human endeavour is perfect, but with suitable care and attention, we can usually achieve 'good enough', judging by the results.


Would you say all biological research is therefore 'in-vitro'? I don't see how that is helpful.
If a given system is known in terms of NOthing and YESthing (where NOthing and YESthing are absolute and complement opposites) any scientific (abstract or physical) research is in-vitro in the absolute sense w.r.t YESthing, or in-vivo in the absolute sense w.r.t NOthing.

The terms in-vitro and in-vivo are not used here only in terms of biological systems.
 
Last edited:
If a given system is known in terms of NOthing and YESthing (where NOthing and YESthing are absolute and complement opposites) any scientific (abstract or physical) research is in-vitro in the absolute sense w.r.t YESthing, or in-vivo in the absolute sense w.r.t NOthing.
Well that analysis seems about as useful as Doron's Organic Mathematics; care to explain how it helps?
 
Well that analysis seems about as useful as Doron's Organic Mathematics; care to explain how it helps?

I think that the following quotes can help to follow my reasoning of this subject:

Try to understand my answer to you, which is not understood in terms of the standard notion of Set.

...

1) NOthing (is not notated by any symbol) is below membership.

2) YESthing (notated by the outer "{" and "}") is above membership.

3) Membership can have infinitely many levels, where each level is wider (or higher) than the previews levels.

4) The smallest level of membership is level 0, and examples of level 0 are: {}, 2, 236.67, etc...

5) The next level of membership is level 1, and examples of level 1 are: {{}, 2, 236.67}, {{}}, {2}, {236.67}, etc...

6) The next level of membership is level 2 , and examples of level 2 are: {{{}, 2, 236.67}}, {{{}}}, {{2}}, {{236.67}}, etc...

7) No level of membership is reducible into NOthing or extensible into YESthing.

8) There can be several different levels of membership in a given expression, for example: {}, {{}, 2, 236.67}, 2 ,{{{}}}, {{{{{236.67}}, 2}}} , etc ...

(1) to (8) are not understood in terms of the standard notion of Set but they are easily understood in terms of the novel notion of Set, as shown in http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8223955&postcount=1440.

Level 0 of membership can't be but in-vitro (since NOthing is below membership).

The wider (or higher) levels of membership can be in-vivo w.r.t lower levels, or in-vitro w.r.t higher levels.

There is a difference at the level of membership between an object that is not a member of a given set, and the same object as a member of a given set, as rigorously shown at the previous quote.

By understanding the different levels of membership S={...} is a lower level of membership than {{...}}.

Let {...} be the set of all sets that are not members of themselves.

{...} as a member of itself is done at a wider (or higher) level of membership {{...}}, or in other words {...} ≠ {{...}}, and as a result there is no paradox, without any need of special axioms, as done by ZF(C).

By using the principle of Occam's razor, the novel notion of levels of membership provides a simpler solution to Russell's Paradox than ZF(C) solution, and also enables to deal with objects (for example, non-local numbers) that that are not found by ZF(C).

Furthermore, the notion of levels of membership and the fact that NOthing is below membership and YESthing is above membership, enables novel understanding of Entropy (both as abstract and\or physical concept).
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom