Ed Examples of How Intelligent Design Helps Science Generate New Knowledge!!

About Wowbagger's "Dust Bin Theory," I remember reading a science fiction novel in high school that posited the same basic idea.

The book was by Robert Silverberg. The story was set in the 1990s or 2000s as I remember, though I may be wrong. It involved a man from the far future named Vornan who traveled back in time to the "present" time of the novel. As I recall, the Vornan character had mistakenly time-traveled to the wrong era and ended up stranded.

So as he made friends with the present-day humans, he let slip a few details of things his future society had learned about the Universe through their time explorations. One of the facts Vornan was reluctant to reveal, was that life on Earth had actually evolved out of microbes living within a load of biological waste that had been dumped here by some aliens en route to a more important part of the galaxy. The story went that these extraterrestrials were passing through the Solar System on a long interstellar journey, and they took the opportunity to empty their waste tanks in the atmosphere of the nearest uninhabited planet, which turned out to be Earth.

This news is received with mixed reactions, but eventually a slogan grips the public imagination, "We are all Trash, and the descendants of Trash."
 
Last edited:
Yawn. You've never read any of their papers on information, specified complexity, etc,.....have you?

You just assume smears that they offer no clear definitions of information are true, but haven't looked into it for yourself.....just repeating dogma you're told, eh?

You mean this one?
http://www.arn.org/docs/dembski/wd_idtheory.htm

In here he mentions open and closed systems and then derives pretty spurious conclusions from closed systems to apply to open systems. This is the exact same error as creationists claiming evolution cannot happen because entropy must increase. In fact, if you distill down his rather confused, and incidentally mostly information free explanations, it becomes a personal argumentum ad ignorantiam.

The innocent explanation for Dembski's confusion is his inability to see that you cannot do science from a fixed belief and then ignore the facts. And I know, you have levelled that accusation at biologists, but as usual, it isn't borne by the facts.

Of course, it must be totally a coincidence that Dembski's papers and ideas were roughly laid out in a document authored by the creationists. I mean the idea that creationists have an agenda to "defeat scientific materialism" is wrong, isn't it Randman?
 
How is [antibiotic resistance] a problem?

It's a demonstration of evolution by natural selection in real time. That's a problem for ID.

This comment among many others just shows critics of ID have never even bothered to learn what it is.

I, for one, certainly have. There may be some who simply giggle at ID's obvious inanity, but I prefer to get to the details. There is so much more inanity there than is visible on the surface.

Shallow and absurd comments such as suggesting antibiotic resistance is a problem for ID or even creationism for that matter just speaks to the ignorance of the critics of ID.

Have you ever noticed how few ID'ers have ever grasped what evolution by natural selection is? They simply reject any idea which might contradict their rather infantile belief that the Life, the Universe and Everything revolves around them.

You guys just make one unsubstantiated claim after another.

No substantiation will ever persuade a true believer. While many (if not all) of the IDEA screed's bullet-points have been substantially demolished here, you make no attempt to shore them up. Going by this comment, I doubt you've even able to register the criticisms.
 
Yawn. You've never read any of their papers on information, specified complexity, etc,.....have you?

You clearly didn't look into the IDEA screed before citing it. After all, you've been told that it supports your belief, so why would you?

[quoe]You just assume smears that they offer no clear definitions of information are true ...[/quote]

You're assuming that.

... but haven't looked into it for yourself.....just repeating dogma you're told, eh?

That describes your citing of the IDEA screed.
 
I tried clicking on the bold blue type in the "FAQ" thinking it must be a link - a link that would detail exactly how intelligent design contributed to the instigation of said research.

Since the claims were not backed up it seemed to me you could substitute "skepticism about intelligent design" for "intelligent design" and conclude skepticism contributed to these discoveries. Then, in a way, you could say they were inspired by "intelligent design."

It's all a red herring to me. Couldn't you say, "A strong belief in intelligent design inspired Charles Darwin to devote much of his life to the study of the natural world as he sought insight into creation ..."

I'm not a biologist or cosmologist and propose no "theory of everything" but ID vs. evolution seems like - a false dichotomy? The Big Bang theory can't explain what happened before the Big Bang; the theory of evolution does not pretend to explain why any kind of life existed to begin with. These mysteries - how a tiny dot expanded to encompass all matter in the universe, how a complex molecule was transformed into a living system - these mysteries leave me in awe, wondering if there is a designer, but the awe does not proscribe investigation into determining what mechanisms are at work.

Which is I think compares somewhat to Darwin's lifelong investigations and his eventual recognition of the limits of literalism.
 
I'm not a biologist or cosmologist and propose no "theory of everything" but ID vs. evolution seems like - a false dichotomy?
Well, that's part of the problem. ID can only poke holes in evolutionary theory--until they propose a mechanism (a Designer, how that Designer designed life, where it happened, etc) they have no theory, and therefore are left with poking holes in the dominant paradigm. ID and Creationism treat this debate as a case of "To prove me right, I just have to prove you wrong".

Second, it's not a matter of ID vs. Evos. It's more fundamental than that--it's an issue of what science IS. Evolution presents a testable hypothesis, a precise mechanism, and a great deal of evidence. ID has, and can, provide none of that. It's a question of whether we can accept as a scientific theory a concept that violates all of the rules of science.
 
A lot of the progress in civilization is some thinker responding to an absolute statement such as "You can't get there from here"... and by thought, and then action, gets there.
The ID'ers just look for places you can't get to... and lo and behold, we find we've been there, or can finger how to get there in a couple of fell swoops or so.
 
Never read that one. But, I am pretty sure Intelligent Design does not provide any manner by which it can demonstrate that its ideas are more accurate than anything in that book. What do you think, since you've read it?

I'm not sure the Trash theory is particularly relevant, since it merely displaces the hypothesised design to the aliens who left the trash.

(If this is exactly the book I recall, Bob Silverberg was being deliberately iconoclastic in a US American sense. This would be from the late 60's, when SF was quite "alternative" when it wasn't actually drug-inspired ...

Vornan-19's sexual mores, for instance, were similar to Torchwood's Jack Hargreaves's, as I recall. I may have a copy kicking around, I'll see if I can look it out.)
 
It's all a red herring to me. Couldn't you say, "A strong belief in intelligent design inspired Charles Darwin to devote much of his life to the study of the natural world as he sought insight into creation ..."

Not really. Darwin (like most scientists) was searching for an explanation of an observed reality. He wasn't at all religious. He (and Wallace, who was engaged in the same pursuit) arrived at the same explanation, which has, of course, stood the test of time very well.

ID already existed, in the Watchmaker theory - if you find something as complicated as a watch you infer design and a maker, and ditto for life. Darwin was certainly unimpressed by that idea.
 
Last edited:
ID already existed, in the Watchmaker theory
Minor quibble: This was a Creationist theory, NOT an Intelligent Design theory. At best, ID is a more generalized theory, in that it doesn't specify the Designer. When the Watchmaker theory was first proposed, it was assumed that the Designer was the Christian God. I mean, the ID advocates use the same (flawed) arguments, but historically the Watchmaker Argument was pure Creationism.
 
Minor quibble: This was a Creationist theory, NOT an Intelligent Design theory. At best, ID is a more generalized theory, in that it doesn't specify the Designer. When the Watchmaker theory was first proposed, it was assumed that the Designer was the Christian God. I mean, the ID advocates use the same (flawed) arguments, but historically the Watchmaker Argument was pure Creationism.

As I see it, the essence of the argument is that there was an Intelligent Designer : that this was the Christian God was taken to be implied, but isn't actually part of the argument. Not worth arguing about, though :). The "ID isn't creationism" line itself is only worth a "Puhleeease :rolleyes:!"
 
Randman provided this link. I have not looked at all the examples, yet.

But, since this is the "best" answer I have seen for the question "How does Intelligent Design help science gain new knowledge?" I figured it deserves its own thread:

http://www.ideacenter.org/contentmgr/showdetails.php/id/1505

What does everyone else think? Do any of these examples actually invoke a designer?

The 'Articles' page at that site is infested by the inane ramblings of Casy Luskin.
It's a waste of 1's and 0's if you ask me.
 
Not really. Darwin (like most scientists) was searching for an explanation of an observed reality. He wasn't at all religious.
I thought he leaned toward the idea of a Creator as a young'un, if only by default
 
By default? Do you mean "because he was taught that as a kid", or something different?
More, there was no other option in the culture. Linaeus had some doubts, and a few ideas on how organisms change through time were floating around, but nothing had any real traction in the culture. They were esoteric academic arguments, or personal concerns in the case of Linaeus.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom