Evidence that meditation reduces violence

But this means that you can only research the kind of prisoners who would lend themselves to meditating, right? Or does it reduce violence in general, even among those who did not participate in the meditation?

Presumably if a violent person decided to do meditation and it was effective then the violence they would have done without it would mean a drop, but OTOH, if other prisoners decided he was no longer violent then they might beat him up more often, raising the level back up :). It could even make the others more violent if they all take extra turns beating him because his meditation annoys them. Or maybe, if it was the 'chief' thug, he could influence the others into meditating too, eradicating violence.

Basically, I'm saying there are so many factors that without a detailed study of the results of an experiment you can't be sure of what they are saying.
 
Basically, I'm saying there are so many factors that without a detailed study of the results of an experiment you can't be sure of what they are saying.
Yes; an aggressive alpha or high status individual who becomes less aggressive in his interactions might well have the effect of reducing the overall level of aggression within his range of contacts. OTOH he might not...
 
Yup, the TM organization has been making this claim for decades, even way back when I was part of it. I'm not sure we're getting anywhere.

~~ Paul
 
Presumably if a violent person decided to do meditation and it was effective then the violence they would have done without it would mean a drop, but OTOH, if other prisoners decided he was no longer violent then they might beat him up more often, raising the level back up :). It could even make the others more violent if they all take extra turns beating him because his meditation annoys them. Or maybe, if it was the 'chief' thug, he could influence the others into meditating too, eradicating violence.

Basically, I'm saying there are so many factors that without a detailed study of the results of an experiment you can't be sure of what they are saying.

I thought they were saying that the meditation has some kind of "supernatural" effect on the region. That's just plain hooey -- no "detailed study" required.
 
But this means that you can only research the kind of prisoners who would lend themselves to meditating, right? Or does it reduce violence in general, even among those who did not participate in the meditation?

No, there's no fallout effect.

And no, meditation cannot be applied to people.
 
When kicking someone’s arse I generally free myself of my own thoughts by focusing on a repeating the mantra ‘I’m kicking your arse’. I find it very relaxing.
 
I have no idea what you mean by that. You mean a meditator cannot influence other people?

Oh, sorry, I meant to say that I agree with you... or what I thought you were implying, anyway... that any study showing a reduction in violence for meditators is inherently self-selecting, therefore not randomized, because subjects have to volunteer.

That's what I meant by "you can't apply meditation".

I think you were saying pretty much the same thing, but perhaps I was wrong about that.
 
You know, a nuclear weapon would decrease the crime rate in it's area of effect by >99%.

... assuming that setting off a nuclear weapon is both illegal and a single crime, of course.

I suppose if the guy setting it off was meditating at the time that may mean something.

;)
 
Alright mister John Hagelin Ph.D, you think you're so smart then answer me this: If meditation reduces violence, then how do you explain premeditated murder?
 
Alright mister John Hagelin Ph.D, you think you're so smart then answer me this: If meditation reduces violence, then how do you explain premeditated murder?

If anything, violence "pre" meditation only proves the point. If only they killer had premurder meditated it might not have happened at all.
 
John Hagelin Ph.D. claims that we can immediately reduce violence, war deaths and terrorism in the surrounding region by more than 70% by meditating in groups.

Although this sounds far fetched enough to dismiss with ease, he also claims that he has conducted several scientific studies that confirm this hypothesis. Plus, he claims that these studies have been independently replicated and published in mainstream scientific journals. See for yourself by visiting: permanentpeace.org.

I kind of want to believe it, yet, I wonder if anyone has any evidence to the contrary or sees any deadly flaws in these experiments.

Thank you, Michael

Hi Michael.

These are some bold claims. No wonder you're skeptical, as am I.

Here's the link to the 'evidence' at that website:

http://permanentpeace.org/evidence/index.html

Let's look at one of their claims - that their meditation efforts created world peace:

For three years, from 1988 to 1990, at a location just outside New Delhi, in India, a single philanthropist supported a group of 8,000 experts in the Transcendental Meditation technique and the advanced TM-Sidhi program, including Yogic Flying). Over those three years, every major conflict in the world peacefully resolved. First, a war of seven years between Iraq and Iran that had claimed millions of lives finally came to an end. Then, after five years, the Soviet Union’s brutal invasion of Afghanistan was called to a halt. Most encouraging, in 1989 the Berlin Wall fell, the Soviet Union dissolved, and forty years of Cold War simply melted away.

Someone really should let Israel and Palestine know that their conflict has been resolved. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom