Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are still wrong even after a year :jaw-dropp!

No, you're still in denial even after a year. :jaw-dropp

Dungey's work was on magnetic reconnection.

Dungey's work was also work on solar flare events and also related to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasma! Get off that denial-go-round already! You can't latch on to only 1/2 his work!

Citing Dungey's work is explicitly (and objectively) disproving your assertion:

No, you just don't own a plasma physics text book, so it's still a big mystery to you.

For the record, Dungey said that a solar flare *IS* magnetic reconnection.

It's reconnection of *CURRENT* in the form of an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE.

It's not even clear anymore if you're lying and aware that you're lying about my positions, or whether you've started to believe your own nonsense RC. You're sounding weirder by the day because you can't seem to separate your own strawman beliefs from my beliefs.
 
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection 'jives' with thousands of references in the literature.

BS. Those all involve PLASMA and CURRENTS. Not one of them relates to "reconnection" in the ABSENCE OF PLASMA! Clinger's presentation was an EPIC KLUDGE of basic EM theory. A NULL is *NOT* (ABSOLUTELY NOT) the "beginning" of any B line. It's just a stupid NULL! B lines do not have a source, a sink, a beginning or an end. They are the result of the flow of CURRENT. They form as FULL FIELDS, not simple magnetic lines as you simplistically imagine in your fantasy world. In the real world of physics, no monopoles, so no beginning or ending, no sources or sinks of B lines, and no "reconnection" process without plasma.
 
Last edited:
clinger said:
if one does not specialize in plasma physics and encounter magnetic reconnection, then one will likely never hear of such a thing and be quite unaware of it. This is the case for the example of myself; I have an M.S. degree in physics, never formally studied plasma physics beyond the "survey" level, and never heard of magnetic reconnection at all until I encountered Mozina and his claims.

This almost describes me. I happened to hear of it because I did my master's at the University of Iowa, where some researchers I worked for were working with data from some satellite, and they mentioned "magnetic reconnection" in their work. Otherwise, I had not heard of this in my studies.

Asides for no particular reason:

I met Gurnett, one of the principal investigators on Pioneer, Voyager and Cassini (and probably some others). He was a good guy from Texas with a heavy accent. He was my plasma instructor for one course. Physics sounds a little different with the accent. ;)

I also met Van Allen, of Van Allen Belt fame. A friend of mine asked him once if he expected to find the belts when they sent the probe up. He responded, "Do you expect to see an elephant when you leave the building today?" He was also a good guy.
 
Other then Dungey's obsolete usage

That's going to remain a ridiculous argument no matter how many times you repeat it. In fact it sounds more ridiculous every time you repeat it. An "electrical discharge" in 1958 is no different than an electrical discharge in 2011. Your denial process is just weird.

you have not found any scientific literature on electrical discharges on plasma

False again. You're still on a denial go-round over Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge *IN* cosmic plasma. Nothing like bending reality like a pretzel to suit yourself, eh RC?
 
This almost describes me. I happened to hear of it because I did my master's at the University of Iowa, where some researchers I worked for were working with data from some satellite, and they mentioned "magnetic reconnection" in their work. Otherwise, I had not heard of this in my studies.

The difference between Clinger and myself is that *AFTER* I heard about it, *THEN* I read 5 or so books on plasma physics about it, not to mention several dozen papers on the topic. Then I FINALLY discussed it publicly. Clinger evidently never heard of the concept before he met me, he's never read a book on the topic of plasma physics, and yet he's intent on teaching *ME* how "reconnection" works. :) Cute. A little weird mind you, but cute. ;)

Asides for no particular reason:

I met Gurnett, one of the principal investigators on Pioneer, Voyager and Cassini (and probably some others). He was a good guy from Texas with a heavy accent. He was my plasma instructor for one course. Physics sounds a little different with the accent.

I also met Van Allen, of Van Allen Belt fame. A friend of mine asked him once if he expected to find the belts when they sent the probe up. He responded, "Do you expect to see an elephant when you leave the building today?" He was also a good guy.

Most scientists that I meet in person and on the internet are really nice people. Clinger just doesn't happen to be one of them. It's therefore somewhat gratifying to watch him hoist himself by his own petard in this thread. :)

http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hoist_by_one's_own_petard
 
Last edited:
BS: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection 'jives' with thousands of references in the literature.
You remain unable to understand that he shows that magnetic field lines break and reconnect which is magnetic reconnection.

No RC it does not. The literature on "reconnection" relates to *PLASMA* physics, not PLASMA-LESS processes! Nothing "reconnects" without plasmas and currents. Nothing could reconnect in Origin the Null because Origin is NOTHING without plasma.
 
No, you're still in denial even after a year. :jaw-dropp
...rant snipped...
Dungey's work was about magnetic reconnection and its role as a cause of solar flares.
This means that only an idiot would assert that Dungey states that solar flares caused by electrical discharges.

The other half that you lie about me ignoring is Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection which was first mentioned in my post Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different on 13th January 2011 (10 months and counting).
This is an obsolete term. Any knowledgeable person wold laugh at anyone using this term today. It is the equivalent of some ignorant person obsessing on the term corpuscles that Thompson used for electronsand insisting on using it today :jaw-dropp!

Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.
 
Dungey's work was about magnetic reconnection and its role as a cause of solar flares.
This means that only an idiot would assert that Dungey states that solar flares caused by electrical discharges.

No, it means that only an idiot would deny the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares.
 
No RC it does not. ...usual rant....
Yes MM it does as shown in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection and Somov's book.

But then we have ... Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV where you show several delusions
 
Yes MM it does as shown in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection and Somov's book.

Somov's example and book *INCLUDE* (do not exclude) non-neutral plasmas! FORGETABOUTIT!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)#Definition_of_a_plasma

Non-neutral plasma

The strength and range of the electric force and the good conductivity of plasmas usually ensure that the densities of positive and negative charges in any sizeable region are equal ("quasineutrality"). A plasma with a significant excess of charge density, or, in the extreme case, is composed of a single species, is called a non-neutral plasma. In such a plasma, electric fields play a dominant role. Examples are charged particle beams, an electron cloud in a Penning trap and positron plasmas.
 
It started in part three (the epic disaster installment) where Clinger claimed that Origin the NULL was a "beginning" of B lines. It went downhill from there.

OK, I will study part three as best as I can, given my limited background in this area, and then consider your objections.
 
OK, I will study part three as best as I can, given my limited background in this area, and then consider your objections.

Keep in mind it's EASY to explain Clinger's vacuum experiments simply in terms of a NULL (with nothing in it) and "magnetic flux changes" in the whole experiment, not just in the MIDDLE, due to the changes in currents through various rods. Since Clinger does NOT have a PLASMA, the NULL remains and NULL. It never "grows up" to become a "neutral" (current carrying filament). No current therefore comes up the Z axis to be converted in equation 17 into "magnetic charge". No plasma, no current, no "magnetic charge", no "reconnection" in Priest's source/sink paper. Adding a new rod in the NULL doesn't turn the null into a "beginning or an ending" of B lines either. It's just another pole, creating another field, without beginning and without ending. The CURRENTS *create* the B fields/lines in the poles, but nothing could "reconnect" without plasma.

The only way one could POSSIBLY get a B line to "begin', or to have a source or sink is to find a monopole.
 
Last edited:
Somov's example and book *INCLUDE* (do not exclude) non-neutral plasmas! FORGETABOUTIT!
Somov's example does not include plasma: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV

Somov's book does include MR in plasma, starting from the next section
  • "4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum"
  • "4.4.3 Reconnection in Plasma"
You can tell the difference between a vacuum and a plasma, MM? :rolleyes:
You do know that section 4.4.2 comes before section 4.4.3, MM? :rolleyes:
 
Somov's example does not include plasma: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV

Somov's book does include MR in plasma, starting from the next section
  • "4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum"
  • "4.4.3 Reconnection in Plasma"
You can tell the difference between a vacuum and a plasma, MM? :rolleyes:
You do know that section 4.4.2 comes before section 4.4.3, MM? :rolleyes:

Nothing "reconnects", and no kinetic energy transfer occurs until he adds particles and CURRENTS RC. It's the CURRENTS that "reconnect". Nothing exists in the NULL. Nothing can therefore 'reconnect' in the NULL or physically "reconnect" in the NULL. No B lines BEGIN or END *ANYWHERE* (NULL OR OTHERWISE) without a MONOPOLE! When oh when are you going to accept that EMPIRICAL FACT OF PHYSICS?
 
Last edited:
That was me, not Clinger

Clinger said:
if one does not specialize in plasma physics and encounter magnetic reconnection, then one will likely never hear of such a thing and be quite unaware of it. This is the case for the example of myself; I have an M.S. degree in physics, never formally studied plasma physics beyond the "survey" level, and never heard of magnetic reconnection at all until I encountered Mozina and his claims. Since then I have made an effort to teach myself plasma physics, and to examine for myself the physics of magnetic reconnection. I have come to the conclusion, as a result of my own study of plasma physics that Mozina is wrong in all of his claims regarding plasma physics, and in particular, magnetic reconnection.


This almost describes me. I happened to hear of it because I did my master's at the University of Iowa, where some researchers I worked for were working with data from some satellite, and they mentioned "magnetic reconnection" in their work. Otherwise, I had not heard of this in my studies.

Asides for no particular reason:

I met Gurnett, one of the principal investigators on Pioneer, Voyager and Cassini (and probably some others). He was a good guy from Texas with a heavy accent. He was my plasma instructor for one course. Physics sounds a little different with the accent. ;)

I also met Van Allen, of Van Allen Belt fame. A friend of mine asked him once if he expected to find the belts when they sent the probe up. He responded, "Do you expect to see an elephant when you leave the building today?" He was also a good guy.


Actually, that quote comes from me, not Clinger; I believe his background is in mathematics rather than physics, but he can enlighten us on that.

There is one and only one exception to the "myth" that magnetic field lines neither begin nor end, and that one and only one exception is the neutral point found in magnetic reconnection. if one does not specialize in plasma physics and encounter magnetic reconnection, then one will likely never hear of such a thing and be quite unaware of it. This is the case for the example of myself; I have an M.S. degree in physics, never formally studied plasma physics beyond the "survey" level, and never heard of magnetic reconnection at all until I encountered Mozina and his claims. Since then I have made an effort to teach myself plasma physics, and to examine for myself the physics of magnetic reconnection. I have come to the conclusion, as a result of my own study of plasma physics that Mozina is wrong in all of his claims regarding plasma physics, and in particular, magnetic reconnection.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line

For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.
 
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom