Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Micheal, I'm wondering if you have read this paper from UCLA. http://plasma.physics.ucla.edu/papers/POP-colliding-plasmas.pdf

From the summary and conclusions;
"two magnetic “bubbles” collide. The collision produces turbulent local magnetic fields...

FYI, it's going to take me awhile to get through this paper, mostly because it's an EXCELLENT paper and I want to enjoy it. From what I've read so far they described CURRENT and INDUCTION based processes. I haven't been through the whole paper yet, but I'm definitely enjoying it. It's a bit busy at work so bear with me a bit. I will get back to you, but I do want to finish the whole paper. As far as I can tell so far, they are using the term "reconnection" consistently with the way that Somov uses the term. Specifically it's an induced field generation process caused by 'magnetic flux' and particle movements. Cool paper. Thanks again for the reference.
 
In part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, I proved that Dungey's X-shaped magnetic field can occur within a vacuum, with no plasma present and with virtually no electrical field.

FYI, BALONEY you did. Dungey's arrows in the middle of his diagram relate to MORE THAN JUST B LINES in a vacuum, they include plasma "processes" that are not related to the B lines directly. I can't really comment on your personal arrows in your diagram yet because you haven't provided any math,
:dl:

but at first glance you look to have botched the job because the arrows in the middle "should be" (at least in theory) one directional arrows of the magnetic field from one of your poles. The arrows in and out of the center point of your diagram are TOTALLY FUBAR as far as I can tell so far (with no math).
With no math, you can't tell.

With math, plus a smidgeon of freshman (or even high school) physics, you'd know that what you wrote above was laughable.

But you don't bark math, so you have no clue.

You've proven NOTHING yet except your tendency to handwave in absence of a published work to support your claims.
My simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is chock full of math. To you, it looks like hand-waving because you can't tell the difference between math and BS.

I showed how a little freshman-level math allows us to reproduce the figures published by Dungey, by Yamada, and by many others who have written papers on magnetic reconnection. You don't understand such advanced math, so you don't understand what my posts have to do with magnetic reconnection or with plasma physics.
 
With no math, you can't tell.

Which of your MATHS show a magnetic B line "reconnection" Clinger? Which one results in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in a vacuum? All you've done so far is wave around a little circuit theory, wave around a couple of diagrams related to PLASMA physics and you've shown no actual B field line reconnection that might explain million degree solar flares, nor have you shown that any field BEGINS in your X point nor ENDS in your X point. So far the math you have provided is CHILDISH.
 
Last edited:
In the paper is an image of magnetic field line reconnection, the magenta highlighting the reconnection.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254eb8c96cc2330.gif[/qimg]

This is an empirical experiment creating magnetic re-connection in the lab using helium plasma and lasers.

This is a LONG paper, but I pulled a line from the abstract that applies here:

A reconnection event is triggered by the collision and the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current, which is the first step in the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.

I'm totally fine with the concept of "current reconnection', or even "field aligned current reconnection" as long as there is SOME MENTION of the current that does the 'reconnecting". This paper thus far is 100 percent consistent with Somov's presentation of field aligned current reconnection in chapter 16. This is essentially "standard stuff", but it's also directly related to a "current system", not just simple magnetic B lines. I'm fine with their use of INDUCED E fields. It seems to be another EXCELLENT presentation from UCLA. It's a great paper, but it's more based upon induced currents. I"m not quite done yet, but I don't think this actually helps your case.
 
No, not at all. In chapter 16 of "Fundamentals of Cosmic Electrodynamics" Somov relates the whole process back to the E orientation, and uses the term "field aligned currents". In fact the chapter itself is entitled "Reconnection of electric currents". As I've said all along, I'm fine with that view of the process. I'm fine with "current reconnection" or "circuit reconnection".

I don't have that book, I only have plasma astrophysics, in which electical discharge is never useds.
And yes there are currents in the reconnection region, and no they cannot create the change of topology of the magnetic field as in reconnection.
I notice that everything is again in quotation marks, so it could be your own definitions.
At one point you really have to give a complete description of what you think is happening.

I'm not fine with the term "magnetic reconnection" because it implies something that is misleading, specifically it implies B line reconnection, when in fact that is not the case.

And in fact it is the case, and the whole of Somov's book is showing reconnecting B lines, if you like it or not. But keep in your denial, it is more than a river in Egypt.

I'm trying to look for a rational way to bridge our differences here. Let's start "easy". Would you agree that *BEFORE* the reconnection process begins, the plasma is flowing in two field aligned currents?

That all depends, if you have a two currents like in Geemacks figure then there is a current along a rod or a field in the lab. and then you have to look at the superposition of this field and the generated circular field giving a spiral. Between the two spirals (separating them for the moment) there is also plasma and that is flowing perpendicular to the field as it should because of Maxwell.

However, that is not easy at all. The easiest way is the Earth's magnetotail where oppositly directed field is on top of eachoter separated by a current sheet perpendicular to the magnetic field. Then you have the simple petchek reconnection and unless you understand what happens in such a simple model, you cannot even start to understand what is happening in the more complicated lab set-up.
 
Notice what happens when someone (Clinger) uses real math and physics. They convince people of things!

Dungey used math. That didn't convince GM that electrical discharges occur in flares. Alfven used math to do away with the whole need for 'magnetic reconnection" theory in current carrying plasma and that didn't convince anyone. Unfortunately all the math in the world is at their fingertips, but none of them understand it or bother reading it. Ask Clinger if electrical discharges occur in solar flares? He's been riding Dungey's coattails with this so called "experiment". Does he also agree with Dungey that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and solar flares? Does RC agree? What use is math when none of them are even interested in reading a book on plasma physics? They have all the math in the world at their feet. The refuse to read or comprehend any of it.
 
I don't have that book, I only have plasma astrophysics, in which electical discharge is never useds.
And yes there are currents in the reconnection region, and no they cannot create the change of topology of the magnetic field as in reconnection.

Could you start by explaining to me why it's impossible for one electron or charged particle from one field aligned current to physically jump current streams and "reconnect" with the other one? IMO from your last response, this is our basic area of disagreement. I'd rather we focus on one issue at a time.
 
Notice what happens when someone (Clinger) uses real math and physics. They convince people of things!

FYI, Clinger also convinced him that solid magnet reconnection was the same thing as an electrical discharge in a plasma too. People in herd mentalities tend to convince each other of just about anything and everything. Math is optional in my experience, particularly when dealing with "haters" (hate being wrong, hate EU theory/evolutionary theory/whatever).
 
FYI, forget my earlier comments about that most recent paper by W. Gekelman, A. Collette, and S. Vincena being "basic stuff". Wow. This is REALLY an INCREDIBLE paper. The images they create are absolutely fabulous, and the depth of this paper is REALLY impressive. Two thumbs up! (Still doesn't help your case though). :)
 
How ironic considering the fact that everything you've said about "reconnection" is wrong, wrong, HORRIBLY wrong, starting with the fact that solar flares occur in PLASMAS, not "vacuums".
How ironic considering the fact that everything W.D. Clinger has said about magnetic reconnection is right, right, HORRIBLY right.

Where you go wrong, wrong, HORRIBLY wrong is in your inability to read:
...nothing about solar flares or magnetic reconnection in plasma...
Come to think of it, everything you have ever written about magnetic flux is wrong.
 
This is a LONG paper, but I pulled a line from the abstract that applies here:
...
This is a MEDIUM SIZED paper, but I pulled a line from the abstract that applies here
A reconnection event is triggered by the collision and the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current, which is the first step in the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.


I also can read English so we have
  1. A reconnection event
  2. the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current
  3. and then the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.
A pity that you did not understand this basic English.
There is SOME MENTION of the 3D current system that does not do the 'reconnecting". The reconnection event comes first, then an induced electric field (during the event) and then the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.
 
Not me. I'm fine with Dungey's electrical discharge and solar flare paper. GM is in pure denial that electrical discharges occur in flares and plasmas. Ask him.
I'm also fine with Dungey's electrical discharge and solar flare paper.
He states that
  1. Magnetic reconnection is the cause of solar flares.
  2. The term 'electrical discharge' in the context of his paper means a large current density.
  3. Large current densities ('electrical discharge') happen during the MR that cause solar flares.
Thus in the 1950's , MR caused 'electrical discharges' to happen in solar flares.

But this is a 60 year old use of the term. It is no longer used.
Thus in 2011, MR causes high current densities to happen in solar flares and there are no 'electrical discharges'.

According to your rather unique point of view, somewhere between the 1950's and today, 'electrical discharges' ceased to to happen in solar flares :jaw-dropp!

What really happened is that scientists realized that using the term 'electrical discharge' to mean a large current density was confusing because it already had a standard definition (see Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge). So they now use current density instead as far as I have seen.

Dungey's 'electric discharge' = large current density in magnetic reconnection!
Originally posted on 13th January 2011 by D'rok!
 
How ironic considering the fact that everything W.D. Clinger has said about magnetic reconnection is right, right, HORRIBLY right.

Since he's riding Dungey's coattails, handwaving away like crazy, talk to me again when he produces an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption and he provides us the additional math we're waiting on.
 
I'm also fine with Dungey's electrical discharge and solar flare paper.

So you now agree that solar flares are in fact "electrical discharges" in the solar atmosphere.

Magnetic reconnection is the cause of solar flares.

The term "reconnection" relates to an inducement of an E field due to FLUX and an ensuing electrical discharge. It has NOTHING to do with reconnecting B lines!

But this is a 60 year old use of the term. It is no longer used.

Who cares? Talk about pathetic rationalizations. Somehow the PROCESS is different today I presume?

Thus in 2011, MR causes high current densities to happen in solar flares and there are no 'electrical discharges'.

Wow, a new logical low for even an EU hater. :( Congrats on that.

According to your rather unique point of view, somewhere between the 1950's and today, 'electrical discharges' ceased to to happen in solar flares :jaw-dropp!

WTF? That's YOUR CLAIM RC, not mine! Holy cow. YOU can't even keep your own BS straight.
 
Wow. This is REALLY an INCREDIBLE paper. The images they create are absolutely fabulous, and the depth of this paper is REALLY impressive. Two thumbs up! (Still doesn't help your case though). :)
A pity that you cannot read - this INCREDIBLE paper is about an MR experiment :)!
It mentions reconnection 30 times.
Abstract:
A reconnection event is triggered by the collision and the electric field induced in this event generates a field-aligned current, which is the first step in the development of a fully three-dimensional current system.
...
As local currents move, small reconnection “flares” occur at many locations throughout the volume, but they do not seem to affect the overall system dynamics.
​

Introduction:
​

In the present experiment, colliding plasmas produce effects not seen in a single lpp expansion. An intense current channel generated by magnetic field reconnection occurs when the plasmas collide.​


Since you are impressed by the images, you will really be impressed by Fig 8: "The field lines are colored according to the local magnetic field in G. Two reconnection regions are visible above and below the central current channel."
(emphasis added).​
​
​
​
​
 
A pity that you cannot read - this INCREDIBLE paper is about an MR experiment :)!
It mentions reconnection 30 times.
Abstract:

Introduction:[/LEFT]


Since you are impressed by the images, you will really be impressed by Fig 8: "The field lines are colored according to the local magnetic field in G. Two reconnection regions are visible above and below the central current channel."
(emphasis added).​
​
​
​
​

What exactly don't you understand about the word "current"? They are clear that what "reconnects" are "field aligned currents". I have no idea what you think they said, but there is no way in hell you've been through that paper yet and actually UNDERSTAND it.
 
So you now agree that solar flares are in fact "electrical discharges" in the solar atmosphere.
Wrong: I agree that 60 years ago Dungey used the term 'electrical discharges' in papers to mean
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = large current density in magnetic reconnection!
Originally posted on 13th January 2011 by D'rok

The term "reconnection" ... It has NOTHING to do with reconnecting B lines!
You are lying: Dungey's paper is about magnteic reconnetion. It has everything to do with reconnectiong B lines!

Who cares? Talk about pathetic rationalizations. Somehow the PROCESS is different today I presume?
Depending on a term used 60 years ago that is no longer used is a pathetic rationalization.
Your presumption is wrong.
The PROCESS (MAGNETIC RECONECTION) is the same today.

Wow, a new logical low for even an EU hater. :( Congrats on that.
Wow, a new logical low for even an ignorant internet physic crank. :( Congrats on that.
Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule)
Michael Mozina's delusion that permeability is inductance!
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length").

WTF? That's YOUR CLAIM RC, not mine! Holy cow. YOU can't even keep your own BS straight.
WTF? That is not MY claim, MM. Holy cow. You cannot even think about the implications of your own BS.

You claim that 'electrical discharges' happen in solar flares because you can cite a 60 year old paper where the term 'electrical discharges' was used for the large current density caused by the MR that causes solar flares.
But this term is no longer used in the modern papers about MR as a cause of solar flares. So 'electrical discharges' no longer happen in solar flares. The term has been replaced by large current densities.

One more time:
In the 1950's some authors desccibed large current densities caused by MR in solar flares = 'electrical discharges' caused by MR in solar flares.
Today there is no sign of any author using the term 'electrical discharges' in the context of MR causing solar flares.

Thus my coment:
According to your rather unique point of view, somewhere between the 1950's and today, 'electrical discharges' ceased to to happen in solar flares :jaw-dropp!

What really happened is that scientists realized that using the term 'electrical discharge' to mean a large current density was confusing because it already had a standard definition (see Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge). So they now use current density instead as far as I have seen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom