(I chose the History Forum for this because I want to avoid the religious side of this and focus on the history as much as possible.)
In various threads over the last six months or so I've been bringing up the ideas of Robert Eisenman. I won't quote the posts, but here's his website:
http://www.roberteisenman.com/
I have to admit that I am fairly new to this world of Biblical Scholarship and Ancient Near East History, compared to some on this forum, but that is why I've started this thread.
I want to learn why so many people find Eisenman's ideas so kooky. I think I got an inkling of what a noob Truther goes through when he quotes Steven Jones or Richard Gage here, when I posted some links to Eisenman's stuff...
Maybe I have misunderstood what Eisenman is saying, maybe I'm missing a large part of it, but if someone could point it out to me, I'd be grateful.
This, in a nutshell, is my understanding of Eisenman:
-That Jesus existed as a real historical Jewish Teacher/Preacher/Rabbi in the first century.
-That the religious community that followed the teachings of Jesus called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.
-That the Ebionites didn't regard Jesus as God, but as a man who preached righteousness.
-That the Ebionites believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.
-That the Ebionites used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history) as a means of spiritual purification.
-That the Ebionites had a conflict with Paul who was telling people to ignore The Law.
I don't think any of that is too controversial so far, the controversy seems to arise when Eisenman says that the community that left The Dead Sea Scrolls are that very same community of Ebionites who we know about from the Bible and other ancient sources. As far as I can tell, he says this because in the Scrolls we read about:
- A religious community that called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.
-A community that followed a doctrine laid down by "The Teacher Of Righteousness".
-A community that believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.
-A community that used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history).
-A community that had a conflict with someone they called "The Spouter Of Lies", who "preached against the Law in the midst of the congregation".
I'm just not seeing why this theory of Eisenman's is so Kooky. The alternative seems kookier to me:
- That there were two distinct religious communities active in the same place, at the same time with identical core principles and the exact same name, but they were somehow not at all related to each other... What?
I'll be happy to try to expand on any of these points as the thread goes along, maybe we should take them on one at a time (assuming of course that anyone is even interested in batting these things around at all...).
Any takers?
In various threads over the last six months or so I've been bringing up the ideas of Robert Eisenman. I won't quote the posts, but here's his website:
http://www.roberteisenman.com/
I have to admit that I am fairly new to this world of Biblical Scholarship and Ancient Near East History, compared to some on this forum, but that is why I've started this thread.
I want to learn why so many people find Eisenman's ideas so kooky. I think I got an inkling of what a noob Truther goes through when he quotes Steven Jones or Richard Gage here, when I posted some links to Eisenman's stuff...

Maybe I have misunderstood what Eisenman is saying, maybe I'm missing a large part of it, but if someone could point it out to me, I'd be grateful.
This, in a nutshell, is my understanding of Eisenman:
-That Jesus existed as a real historical Jewish Teacher/Preacher/Rabbi in the first century.
-That the religious community that followed the teachings of Jesus called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.
-That the Ebionites didn't regard Jesus as God, but as a man who preached righteousness.
-That the Ebionites believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.
-That the Ebionites used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history) as a means of spiritual purification.
-That the Ebionites had a conflict with Paul who was telling people to ignore The Law.
I don't think any of that is too controversial so far, the controversy seems to arise when Eisenman says that the community that left The Dead Sea Scrolls are that very same community of Ebionites who we know about from the Bible and other ancient sources. As far as I can tell, he says this because in the Scrolls we read about:
- A religious community that called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.
-A community that followed a doctrine laid down by "The Teacher Of Righteousness".
-A community that believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.
-A community that used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history).
-A community that had a conflict with someone they called "The Spouter Of Lies", who "preached against the Law in the midst of the congregation".
I'm just not seeing why this theory of Eisenman's is so Kooky. The alternative seems kookier to me:
- That there were two distinct religious communities active in the same place, at the same time with identical core principles and the exact same name, but they were somehow not at all related to each other... What?
I'll be happy to try to expand on any of these points as the thread goes along, maybe we should take them on one at a time (assuming of course that anyone is even interested in batting these things around at all...).
Any takers?
Last edited:
