Eisenman's Dead Sea Scroll Ebionites

Brainache

Nasty Brutish and Tall
Joined
Aug 8, 2006
Messages
17,795
Location
Canberra
(I chose the History Forum for this because I want to avoid the religious side of this and focus on the history as much as possible.)

In various threads over the last six months or so I've been bringing up the ideas of Robert Eisenman. I won't quote the posts, but here's his website:
http://www.roberteisenman.com/

I have to admit that I am fairly new to this world of Biblical Scholarship and Ancient Near East History, compared to some on this forum, but that is why I've started this thread.

I want to learn why so many people find Eisenman's ideas so kooky. I think I got an inkling of what a noob Truther goes through when he quotes Steven Jones or Richard Gage here, when I posted some links to Eisenman's stuff...:boxedin:

Maybe I have misunderstood what Eisenman is saying, maybe I'm missing a large part of it, but if someone could point it out to me, I'd be grateful.

This, in a nutshell, is my understanding of Eisenman:

-That Jesus existed as a real historical Jewish Teacher/Preacher/Rabbi in the first century.

-That the religious community that followed the teachings of Jesus called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.

-That the Ebionites didn't regard Jesus as God, but as a man who preached righteousness.

-That the Ebionites believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.

-That the Ebionites used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history) as a means of spiritual purification.

-That the Ebionites had a conflict with Paul who was telling people to ignore The Law.

I don't think any of that is too controversial so far, the controversy seems to arise when Eisenman says that the community that left The Dead Sea Scrolls are that very same community of Ebionites who we know about from the Bible and other ancient sources. As far as I can tell, he says this because in the Scrolls we read about:

- A religious community that called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.

-A community that followed a doctrine laid down by "The Teacher Of Righteousness".

-A community that believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.

-A community that used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history).

-A community that had a conflict with someone they called "The Spouter Of Lies", who "preached against the Law in the midst of the congregation".

I'm just not seeing why this theory of Eisenman's is so Kooky. The alternative seems kookier to me:

- That there were two distinct religious communities active in the same place, at the same time with identical core principles and the exact same name, but they were somehow not at all related to each other... What?

I'll be happy to try to expand on any of these points as the thread goes along, maybe we should take them on one at a time (assuming of course that anyone is even interested in batting these things around at all...).

Any takers?
 
Last edited:
98 views and not one response.
:p
Maybe I should put some more links in:

... the controversy seems to arise when Eisenman says that the community that left The Dead Sea Scrolls are that very same community of Ebionites who we know about from the Bible and other ancient sources. As far as I can tell, he says this because in the Scrolls we read about:

- A religious community that called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.
http://www.essene.com/History&Essenes/md.htm

This is the rule for all members of the community - that is, for such as have declared their readiness to turn away from all evil and to adhere to all that God in His good pleasure has commanded.

They are to keep apart from the company of the froward.

They are to belong to the community in both doctrinal and an economic sense.


-A community that followed a doctrine laid down by "The Teacher Of Righteousness".
http://www.preteristarchive.com/BibleStudies/DeadSeaScrolls/1QpHab_pesher_habakkuk.html
"I will take my stand to watch and will station myself upon my fortress. I will watch to see what he will say to me and how [he will answer] my complaint. And YHWH answered [and said to me, 'write down the vision and make it plain] upon the tablets, that [he who reads] may read it speedily'" [Hab 2.1-2].

and God told Habakkuk to write down that which would happen to the final generation, but He did not make known to him when time would come to an end.

And as for that which He said, "that he who reads may read it speedily"

Interpreted this concerns the Teacher of Righteousness, to whom God made known all the mysteries of the words of His servants the prophets.

"For there shall be yet another vision concerning the appointed time. It shall tell of the end and shall not lie [Hab 2.3a].

Interpreted, this means that the final age shall be prolonged, and shall exceed all that the prophets have said; for the mysteries of God are astounding.

-A community that believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.

-A community that used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history).
http://www.essene.com/History&Essenes/md.htm
...Only thus can it really be sanctified by waters of purification. And only thus can he really direct his steps to walk blamelessly through all the vicissitudes of his destiny in all the way of God in the manner which He has commanded, without turning either to the right or to the left and without overstepping any of God's words. Then indeed will he be acceptable before God like an atonement-offering which meets with His pleasure, and then indeed will he be admitted to the covenant of the community for ever.
They also seem to have been big on the idea of Heaven and Hell, which I always thought was a Medieval invention:
http://www.essene.com/History&Essenes/md.htm
...these are the things that come to men in this world through communion with the spirit of truth. And the guerdon of all that walk in its ways is health and abundant well-being, with long life and fruition of seed along with eternal blessings and everlasting joy in the life everlasting, and a crown of glory and a robe of honor, amid light perpetual.
...

...The guerdon of all who walk in such [ evil ] ways is multitude of afflictions at the hands of all the angels of destruction, everlasting perdition through the angry wrath of an avenging God, eternal horror and perpetual reproach, the disgrace of final annihilation in the Fire, darkness throughout the vicissitudes of life in every generation, doleful sorrow, bitter misfortune and darkling ruin-ending in extinction without remnant of survival.

-A community that had a conflict with someone they called "The Spouter Of Lies", who "preached against the Law in the midst of the congregation".
http://www.preteristarchive.com/BibleStudies/DeadSeaScrolls/1QpHab_pesher_habakkuk.html

["Behold the nations and see, marvel and be astonished; for I accomplish a deed in your days, but you will not believe it when] told" [Hab 1.5].

[Interpreted, this concerns] those who were unfaithful together with the Liar, in that they [did] not [listen to the word received by] the teacher of Righteousness from the mouth of God. And it concerns the unfaithful of the New [Covenant] in that they have not believed in the Covenant of God [and have profaned] his holy name. And likewise,

this saying is to be interpreted [as concerning those who] will be unfaithful at the end of days. They, the men of violence and the breakers of the Covenant, will not believe when they hear all that [is to happen to] the final generation from the Priest [in whose heart] God set [understanding] that he might interpret all the words of his servants the prophets, through whom
he foretold all that would happen to his people and [his land].
...

I'm just not seeing why this theory of Eisenman's is so Kooky. The alternative seems kookier to me:

- That there were two distinct religious communities active in the same place, at the same time with identical core principles and the exact same name, but they were somehow not at all related to each other... What?

I'll be happy to try to expand on any of these points as the thread goes along, maybe we should take them on one at a time (assuming of course that anyone is even interested in batting these things around at all...).

Any takers?

At least no one said "cool story bro".

ETA: The complete Community Rule scroll is here if you want to try to imagine what life was like for these ancient nutjobs:
http://www.yahwehsword.org/community/c-man-discipline.htm
 
Last edited:
(I chose the History Forum for this because I want to avoid the religious side of this and focus on the history as much as possible.)

In various threads over the last six months or so I've been bringing up the ideas of Robert Eisenman. I won't quote the posts, but here's his website:
http://www.roberteisenman.com/

I have to admit that I am fairly new to this world of Biblical Scholarship and Ancient Near East History, compared to some on this forum, but that is why I've started this thread.

I want to learn why so many people find Eisenman's ideas so kooky. I think I got an inkling of what a noob Truther goes through when he quotes Steven Jones or Richard Gage here, when I posted some links to Eisenman's stuff...:boxedin:

Maybe I have misunderstood what Eisenman is saying, maybe I'm missing a large part of it, but if someone could point it out to me, I'd be grateful.

This, in a nutshell, is my understanding of Eisenman:

-That Jesus existed as a real historical Jewish Teacher/Preacher/Rabbi in the first century.

-That the religious community that followed the teachings of Jesus called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.

-That the Ebionites didn't regard Jesus as God, but as a man who preached righteousness.

-That the Ebionites believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.

-That the Ebionites used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history) as a means of spiritual purification.

-That the Ebionites had a conflict with Paul who was telling people to ignore The Law.

I don't think any of that is too controversial so far, the controversy seems to arise when Eisenman says that the community that left The Dead Sea Scrolls are that very same community of Ebionites who we know about from the Bible and other ancient sources. As far as I can tell, he says this because in the Scrolls we read about:

- A religious community that called themselves "The Ebionites" (ie:"The Poor Ones" as opposed to just a general description of poverty) and lived in communes.

-A community that followed a doctrine laid down by "The Teacher Of Righteousness".

-A community that believed in strict observance of Mosaic Law.

-A community that used daily Baptisms instead of burning sacrifices in the Temple (seems to contradict the above, but wouldn't be the first theological inconsistency in history).

-A community that had a conflict with someone they called "The Spouter Of Lies", who "preached against the Law in the midst of the congregation".

I'm just not seeing why this theory of Eisenman's is so Kooky. The alternative seems kookier to me:

- That there were two distinct religious communities active in the same place, at the same time with identical core principles and the exact same name, but they were somehow not at all related to each other... What?

I'll be happy to try to expand on any of these points as the thread goes along, maybe we should take them on one at a time (assuming of course that anyone is even interested in batting these things around at all...).

Any takers?



I don't think he is kooky, but I'm not so sure how strong his argument is. Personally I find Burton Mack to be a little more kooky, or at least less well supported.

But here is how I would answer.......


There is no evidence from the New Testament that the 'pillars of Jerusalem' believed in daily baptism. We do not know that the pillars were the same group that were later identified as the Ebionites. It's not a huge stretch to say that they were, but it's a bit of a stretch.

What's the evidence of continuity? Some is linguistic. The Ebionites were the 'poor ones'. The only thing that Paul tells us about the Jerusalem group outside of what he seems to want his readers to think (hey, they agree with me) is that they told him to be sure to give to the poor. We also know that there was some controversy over circumcision and holding to the law vs. forgoing the law in favor of belief in Jesus being sufficient for salvation. It's certainly very possible that Peter and James were the forerunners of the later Ebionites. The only thing that anyone could argue against it is that there is no slam dunk to be had in the argument; but I don't have the sense that Eisenman argues for any slam-dunks.


I think it is a bit of a stretch to suppose that Paul was the spouter of lies and Jesus the teacher of righteousness. It is certainly possible that this is the case, but I would imagine that many other people at the time could easily fill the same shoes.

I tend to put this in the not-proved-but-possible category. I think Eisenman makes some OK but not terribly compelling arguments. Where he falls short is with the dating. He tends to argue for the latest dates with carbon 14 exams and he seems to ignore some negative evidence. But I don't think any of that is a slam dunk against him either.
 
Last edited:
I don't think he is kooky, but I'm not so sure how strong his argument is. Personally I find Burton Mack to be a little more kooky, or at least less well supported.

But here is how I would answer.......


...

Thanks for that. It's kind of what I was thinking, that this is possible, but not definite.

I think the most compelling part is the name "Ebionite" ("Ebionim", or whatever), because we know that that is what they call themselves at Qumran and it is also the name given by early church historians to the Jewish Christians in Jerusalem.

As far as I know, religious organisations are usually fairly particular about what they call themselves and wouldn't normally use a name for themselves if it was already being used by some other group...

Again, not exactly slam-dunk, but possible.
 
I remember tha Ehrman mentions the sect in Lost Christianities but not what he said about them; it's been several years...
In Jesus, Interupted, he mentions conflicting versions ov Paul's letters and notes that they have Paul at one point apparently supporting the "old law" and at another denying same....
 
I remember tha Ehrman mentions the sect in Lost Christianities but not what he said about them; it's been several years...
In Jesus, Interupted, he mentions conflicting versions ov Paul's letters and notes that they have Paul at one point apparently supporting the "old law" and at another denying same....

I think another interesting thing about these Ebionites is that they practiced some kind of ancient form of Communism. Everyone who joined up had to give up all of their possesions and share everything in common (except for the Priests running the show, of course, they got to keep their stuff...).

I think that might be part of why so many find this idea controversial; if true, it means Jesus was a Communist. I can imagine that doesn't sit well with a lot of Fundies.

Hear that JudeBrando?

JESUS WAS A COMMIE!!!111!!!!11!!
 
I would tend to find the problem in his assumption of the existence of the jesus person. All the rest comes from that unsupported start. And if an unsupported statement set in unsupported texts is sufficient for historians then where do we find the Tomb of Inki/Enki? (The documents from which loads of stuff was stolen for the bible.)
 
I would tend to find the problem in his assumption of the existence of the jesus person. All the rest comes from that unsupported start. And if an unsupported statement set in unsupported texts is sufficient for historians then where do we find the Tomb of Inki/Enki? (The documents from which loads of stuff was stolen for the bible.)

I didn't really want to get into the Historical Jesus question, because whether or not Jesus existed, we KNOW that Ebionites existed. We know that Ebionites believed Jesus existed, so whether or not he actually existed is kind of irrelevant. Whoever it was they were following said similar things to what the Synoptic Gospels report as Jesus teachings (Obey the Law, Give up your possesions, baptism, etc etc)...

This thread is about a particular Jewish Sect that existed in 1st century Palestine, not the truth or falsity of their theology.
 
I think your post was interesting enough to generate more responses than it got but by posting it in the history section I think some of the usual suspects haven't noticed it yet.

I am unfamiliar with the work of Eisenman but I'll give you my cut on the topic based on your description.

There are two factors that lead to an endless collection of Jesus related theories:
1. There is a lot of interest in the life of Jesus both by secular and religious people.
2.There is no solid information about the life of Jesus and a religious sect that could have existed around him including evidence that they existed. So, anybody with some research and some writing ability can put together a book about Jesus and the Palestinian sect that Jesus would have been a part of claiming almost anything because there is no solid evidence to refute theories.

As to your comment that the Ebionites existed for sure. Actually damn little is known about them. Everything that is known is based on what Christian writers said about them.

My assumption when I first started looking into all this was that the existence of the Ebionites was a solid evidence point that the Jerusalem sect existed and its beliefs spread throughout the middle east as evidenced by the Ebionites, a Jesus oriented Jewish group.

I am now not so sure. The Ebionites might have existed, but been formed outside of the Jerusalem area without any direct connection to a Jewish sect directly connected to Jesus. What is needed to sort this out is evidence of a connection between the Ebionites and a Palestinian Jesus sect. If such evidence existed the case for the existence of an historical Jesus would be strengthened enormously to the point that even the most strident Jesus didn't exist folks in this forum would probably change their minds.

I am fairly sure that Christianity as we know it was formed by a group that predated Jesus of people not Jewish by ethnicity that followed some of the Jewish religion. The Septuagint was a key book for this group and it underpinned their belief system. I believe this group wrote all or most of the key Jesus stories. They were separated by time, distance and language from any actual Jesus. We don't know that anything that they wrote about Jesus was true or what it was based on if it was true. Both ethnic Jews and non-ethnic Jews followed this religion and there may have been mixed congregations. It just isn't clear that the Ebionites represent an independent data point about the life of Jesus. It is conceivable that the Jesus mythology developed in the Ebionite group and moved to the non-ethnic Jewish group without any direct influence from a Jesus Palestinian sect.

Believe me, I would like to be proven wrong. I started on my quest to figure out what had gone on with regard to the rise of early Christianity many years ago because I was curious how and why a small Jewish sect could have been so influential as to initiate a complete new religion amongst non-Jewish people. I think now that the assumptions I made were wrong. Christianity was started by non-Jews who followed aspects of Judaism and who had come to believe a messiah was coming. The question is did they just make one up or were their writings inspired by the existence of an actual Jesus and an actual Jesus sect in Palestine. And the question related to this thread was what role did the Ebionites play in all this? It would be great to find some writing that were unequivocally produced by the Ebionites that clearly tied them to Jews from the Jerusalem area.

Before I would believe that Eisenman represented a credible source on this issue I would need to understand that he isn't just doing the normal write-a-book-about Jesus thing using a few miniscule facts to underpin a book's worth of speculation.

Right now, I'm skeptical. There are just so few facts available with regard to all this that I think it is doubtful that any significant questions about the nature of Jesus and an early Palestinian sect associated with him can be answered with any kind of credibility. Jesus, if he existed, was the probable leader of a small time Jewish sect. And history is probably dotted with hundreds of similar fellows for which any evidence of the nature of their lives as turned to dust. The only thing different about Jesus was that he became the subject of a world religion that spurred great interest in his actual life. The interest did not exist in his own lifetime and it is reasonable that the details of his life would have faded into oblivion just like that of hundreds of other minor Jewish sect leaders.
 
I think your post was interesting enough to generate more responses than it got but by posting it in the history section I think some of the usual suspects haven't noticed it yet.
Thanks. Yeah I expected Piggy at least, maybe Hans Musterman as well.

I kept finding myself de-railing other people's threads with this stuff, so I thought it needed it's own.

It's not dead yet tho'...

I am unfamiliar with the work of Eisenman but I'll give you my cut on the topic based on your description.

A quick bio of Eisenman:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Eisenman

wiki said:
Robert Eisenman is an American Biblical scholar, theoretical writer, historian, archaeologist, and "road" poet. He is currently Professor of Middle East Religions, Archaeology, and Islamic Law and director of the Institute for the Study of Judaeo-Christian Origins at California State University Long Beach.

Eisenman led the campaign to free up access to the Dead Sea Scrolls in the 1980s and 90s, and, as a result of this campaign, is associated with the theory that combines Essenes with Palestinian messianism (or what some might refer to as "Palestinian Christianity") - a theory opposed to establishment or consensus scholarship. He is also well known for his work in the field of Christian origins and, in a general way, introducing the public to the character known as "James the brother of Jesus."

He's not just another nutjob with a blog. (Not that you were implying he was, just info for any casual readers.)

There are two factors that lead to an endless collection of Jesus related theories:
1. There is a lot of interest in the life of Jesus both by secular and religious people.
2.There is no solid information about the life of Jesus and a religious sect that could have existed around him including evidence that they existed. So, anybody with some research and some writing ability can put together a book about Jesus and the Palestinian sect that Jesus would have been a part of claiming almost anything because there is no solid evidence to refute theories.

OK, but can't we take The Bible as some form of at least indirect evidence? I mean the stories came from somewhere. The people who first wrote them in the form that we have them now were not the first to tell these stories. They wrote down their own versions of the important bits. So someone, somewhere, started telling religious Jesus stories. All roads lead to 1st Century Palestine...

As to your comment that the Ebionites existed for sure. Actually damn little is known about them. Everything that is known is based on what Christian writers said about them.

Like this?:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_the_Ebionites
wiki said:
Gospel of the Ebionites is the conventional name given to the description by Epiphanius of Salamis of a gospel used by the Ebionites. All that is known of the gospel text consists of seven brief quotations found in Chapter 30 of a heresiology written by Epiphanius known as the Panarion. The quotations were used as part of a polemic to point out inconsistencies in the beliefs and practices of the Ebionites relative to Nicene orthodoxy.[1] The seven citations are numbered GE 1 to GE 7 in Schneemelcher's New Testament Apocrypha.[2]

The original title of the gospel is unknown. Epiphanius mistakenly identifies it as the "Hebrew" gospel, believing it to be a truncated and modified version of the Gospel of Matthew. The text is a gospel harmony of the Synoptic Gospels composed in Greek with various expansions and abridgments reflecting the theology of the writer.[3] Distinctive features of the text include the absence of the virgin birth and genealogy of Jesus, an adoptionist Christology in which Jesus is chosen to be God's son at the time of his baptism, Jesus' appointed task of abolishing the Jewish sacrifices, and an advocacy of the practice of vegetarianism.[4] The gospel harmony is believed to have been composed sometime during the first half of the 2nd century in or around the region East of the Jordan River.[5] The gospel text was said to be used by "Ebionites" during the time of the early church,[6] however the identity of the group or groups that used the text remains a matter of conjecture...

My assumption when I first started looking into all this was that the existence of the Ebionites was a solid evidence point that the Jerusalem sect existed and its beliefs spread throughout the middle east as evidenced by the Ebionites, a Jesus oriented Jewish group.

You could say that's where I am now.

I am now not so sure. The Ebionites might have existed, but been formed outside of the Jerusalem area without any direct connection to a Jewish sect directly connected to Jesus. What is needed to sort this out is evidence of a connection between the Ebionites and a Palestinian Jesus sect. If such evidence existed the case for the existence of an historical Jesus would be strengthened enormously to the point that even the most strident Jesus didn't exist folks in this forum would probably change their minds.

How about a Palestinian Jewish Apocalyptic Messianic Sect in an around 1st Century Jerusalem who called themselves Ebionites? Would that do?

http://religiousstudies.uncc.edu/people/jtabor/ebionites.html

Dr J. Tabor said:
The Essenes (possibly from 'Ossim, meaning "Doers of Torah"), who wrote or collected the Dead Sea Scrolls, pioneered certain aspects of this "Way" over 150 years before the birth of Jesus. They were a wilderness (out in the Arava, near the Dead Sea--based on Isaiah 40:3), baptizing (mikveh of repentance as entrance requirement into their fellowship), new covenant, messianic/apocalyptic group (they were expecting three redemptive Figures—the Prophet like Moses and his two Messiahs), that saw themselves as the remnant core of God's faithful people—preparing the Way for the return of YHVH's Glory (Kavod) as set forth in Isaiah 40-66. They too referred to themselves as the Way, the Poor, the Saints, the New Covenanters, Children of Light, and so forth...

I am fairly sure that Christianity as we know it was formed by a group that predated Jesus of people not Jewish by ethnicity that followed some of the Jewish religion. The Septuagint was a key book for this group and it underpinned their belief system. I believe this group wrote all or most of the key Jesus stories. They were separated by time, distance and language from any actual Jesus. We don't know that anything that they wrote about Jesus was true or what it was based on if it was true. Both ethnic Jews and non-ethnic Jews followed this religion and there may have been mixed congregations. It just isn't clear that the Ebionites represent an independent data point about the life of Jesus. It is conceivable that the Jesus mythology developed in the Ebionite group and moved to the non-ethnic Jewish group without any direct influence from a Jesus Palestinian sect.

I think the non-Jewishness came from Paul and the Romans he was sucking-up to.

Believe me, I would like to be proven wrong. I started on my quest to figure out what had gone on with regard to the rise of early Christianity many years ago because I was curious how and why a small Jewish sect could have been so influential as to initiate a complete new religion amongst non-Jewish people. I think now that the assumptions I made were wrong. Christianity was started by non-Jews who followed aspects of Judaism and who had come to believe a messiah was coming. The question is did they just make one up or were their writings inspired by the existence of an actual Jesus and an actual Jesus sect in Palestine. And the question related to this thread was what role did the Ebionites play in all this? It would be great to find some writing that were unequivocally produced by the Ebionites that clearly tied them to Jews from the Jerusalem area.

Before I would believe that Eisenman represented a credible source on this issue I would need to understand that he isn't just doing the normal write-a-book-about Jesus thing using a few miniscule facts to underpin a book's worth of speculation.

He has pretty much devoted his career and written several books on this idea. He was the guy who actually managed to wrestle the scrolls out of the clutches of the Catholics.

The story of the way the Scrolls were treated for the first forty odd years after their discovery is just shocking. It's worth its own thread almost...

Right now, I'm skeptical. There are just so few facts available with regard to all this that I think it is doubtful that any significant questions about the nature of Jesus and an early Palestinian sect associated with him can be answered with any kind of credibility. Jesus, if he existed, was the probable leader of a small time Jewish sect. And history is probably dotted with hundreds of similar fellows for which any evidence of the nature of their lives as turned to dust. The only thing different about Jesus was that he became the subject of a world religion that spurred great interest in his actual life. The interest did not exist in his own lifetime and it is reasonable that the details of his life would have faded into oblivion just like that of hundreds of other minor Jewish sect leaders.

I think the ideas put forth by Prof. Eisenman have merit, but what do I know?
I know he annoys the **** out of the Dominicans, that can't be a bad thing, can it?
 
Hi Brainache and thank you for the detailed response.

Let me start with a caveat. I don't reject ideas like Eisenman's, in fact my own views of the situation is that something like what you listed is correct. I base part of my views on this on the acceptance of the credibility of people like Eisenman, however I also think Munsterman is correct when he posits that all this kind of speculation is underpinned by very few hard facts and writers who want to publish need to present what is actually just speculation as fact.

A few comments on what you said:
Paul as the driver of the non-Jewish aspect of Christianity
I doubt this. This is the idea that more or less is the biblical story, but I think that aspect of it is false. My guess is that the people who wrote the NT were not ethnic Jews. Christianity was non-Jewish either from the very start or almost from the very start. The people that wrote the bible were certainly separated from Jesus by time, distance and language. I think they were also not Jewish by ethnicity.

Ebionite view of Jesus
I was aware of the general scholarly thought about the nature of Ebionite beliefs on Jesus. The issue is what was the source of those beliefs. Were they based on the beliefs of a Palestinian sect associated with Jesus? The evidence that I would find compelling was actual Ebionite writings that showed good evidence of a connection to a Palestinian religious sect associated with Jesus. As it is now the Ebionites appear to be a group associated in time, language and location with the people that developed Christianity. The trick is to find evidence that ties them back to a Palestinian sect.

Eisenman and the dead sea scrolls
I was aware of the nature of the work on the dead sea scrolls and the efforts to get them released from the group in Israel that refused to release them. I didn't realize it was Eisenman that was a leader of that effort.
davefoc previously said:
...The Ebionites might have existed, but been formed outside of the Jerusalem area without any direct connection to a Jewish sect directly connected to Jesus. What is needed to sort this out is evidence of a connection between the Ebionites and a Palestinian Jesus sect. If such evidence existed the case for the existence of an historical Jesus would be strengthened enormously to the point that even the most strident Jesus didn't exist folks in this forum would probably change their minds.
How about a Palestinian Jewish Apocalyptic Messianic Sect in an around 1st Century Jerusalem who called themselves Ebionites? Would that do?

http://religiousstudies.uncc.edu/people/jtabor/ebionites.html

This is from the first paragraph of the article you linked to:

Josephus reports four main sects or schools of Judaism: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and Zealots. The earliest followers of Jesus were known as Nazarenes, and perhaps later, Ebionites, and form an important part of the picture of Palestinian Jewish groups in late 2nd Temple times.
"Perhaps later" is a significant part of that sentence. I understand that there might have been a direct link between the hypothetical Nazarenes and the Ebionites, but what is the evidence for that link?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom