Ear candling burning

Skiltch

Scholar
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
99
I have a question about ear candling. I know it doesn't work, but why doesn't it burn the ear? It would seem to me that sticking a flame up your ear canal would light it on fire, but apparently it doesn't.
 
Of course, now the question becomes "if it's just the base, why the hell would anyone ever think that this would take impurities out of your ear?"

And my answer to that question is "I have no idea."
 
I have a question about ear candling. I know it doesn't work, but why doesn't it burn the ear? It would seem to me that sticking a flame up your ear canal would light it on fire, but apparently it doesn't.

I'll be honest. I thought your question was a little odd at first.

I had always thought that putting the base of the candle in the ear was self-evident because putting it in wick first would be just plain stupid. Now that I think about it...it's woo medicine. All question are fair game.

Welcome btw.
 
I have a question about ear candling. I know it doesn't work,
As far as I understand it, it does work. Exactly the same way a candle does.

The wax in your ear is warmed and drawn up through the candle, in exactly the same way the wax in the candle is warmed and drawn up through the wick. Which is why you have to use a hollow candle. If you stick a birthday cake candle in your ear, you'll just look silly(er).

Of course, you could just use a Q-tip. But your Chakra Practitioner can't charge you $60 an ear for a Q-tip with a straight face. They aren't that good at acting.
 
As far as I understand it, it does work. Exactly the same way a candle does.

The wax in your ear is warmed and drawn up through the candle, in exactly the same way the wax in the candle is warmed and drawn up through the wick.
Your understanding is incorrect. It does not draw up ear wax.

A normal candle doesn't draw up its own wax, the candle simply gets shorter to make that wax available to the flame.

The ear candle does nothing beneficial.
 
As far as I understand it, it does work. Exactly the same way a candle does.

The wax in your ear is warmed and drawn up through the candle, in exactly the same way the wax in the candle is warmed and drawn up through the wick. Which is why you have to use a hollow candle. If you stick a birthday cake candle in your ear, you'll just look silly(er).

Of course, you could just use a Q-tip. But your Chakra Practitioner can't charge you $60 an ear for a Q-tip with a straight face. They aren't that good at acting.

I didn't realize they actually let the candle burn low enough to even affect your ear.
 
The candle magician may be putting a flame retardant gel in his ear prior to the performance, so his ear doesn't burn. Or maybe he just sticks ice cubes in his ear and doesn't leave the flame in there very long.
 
REAL woos put the wick end in, then push the candle all the way through and light it when it comes out the other side.

(see also: mental floss)
 
They don't use candles, the hot melted wax could drip and burn the "patient". They use a piece of rolled up paper, nothing to drip but ashes. Then they put the flame out. It is when they unroll the paper stub that there is a yellowish residue inside it- sort of like the nicotine stains around a cigarette butt. My guess is that the "patient" never sees what was rolled up in the first place. A dead earwig could make the candlero look like a lifesaver...
 
They don't use candles, the hot melted wax could drip and burn the "patient". They use a piece of rolled up paper, nothing to drip but ashes.
IIRC, it is usually a wax-impregnated type of paper.

This insures that there is an icky residue at the bottom when done, which they then claim was "pulled up" out of the ear, when in fact it is from the paper itself.
 
The idea is that the vacuum provided by the flame, acting through the hollow tube or candle, sucks wax out of your ear. A hilarious concept. And the need for this service is? :confused:

A vacuum cleaner, besides bursting your eardrum, probably wouldn't remove anything but the loosest earwax. Anyone want to do a calculation of how much heat would be necessary to provide that kind of updraft?
 
apparently hot wax can also drip in and damage the ear drum, and damage can also be done if the candle's pushed too far in - http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/candling.html There shouldn't be much risk of that, though, so long as the person doing the procedure is competant and has a bit of common sense. And I'm sure you can trust that a person doing this procedure, in the belief that by lighting a cone and sticking it in someone's ear they can suck out the wax and cure a whole range of problems, would be entirely compet... Oh, right.
 
Thanks. I hadn't realized that they use the base; that makes it make more sense (that is to say, I understand how someone can use an ear candle and not burn their head off, though they won't get any wax out either).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom