Ear candle Kills Nurse

AK-Dave

Muse
Joined
Oct 27, 2003
Messages
586
From the KTUU (an NBC affiliate TV station) web site:

An ear candle could have been the cause of last Thursday's fatal apartment fire in Bethel. The Jan. 27 blaze injured four and killed Bethel nurse Ardean Selby.
Full article here.


(insert witty commentary about how harmless and effective ear candling is here)
 
What I found most disappointing was this quote from a state official - a deputy fire marshal:
How safe can it be to have burning wax paper inches from your face? Cuthbert is not just an ear candle aficionado but also a deputy state fire marshal. Cuthbert says follow the directions and always have help
 
I occasionally listen to "Dr. Zorba" on NPR. One caller asked him about ear candling, of which he had never heard.
When the caller explained the thing to him, he started laughing uncontrollably.
It was kind of like the old Newhart "Sir Walter Raleigh" sketch. "Wait, Walt, let me guess. You put the burning leaves in your ear, right?"

BTW, Zorba puts out some mostly-decent advice, but he's a bit soft on altenative medicine. He'll dutifully tell the callers that there is no scientific evidence to support the whatever they're calling about, but then say something to the effect of "If there's no science, you have to go with the anecdotal evidence. If you know several people who use whatever and they say it works for them, go ahead and try it."
 
Oh boy, I think I've seen "Ear Candling" advertised downtown here...

Does this mean I can report them?
Report any complaints or concerns about ear candles, or any other medical devices, to Health Canada through a toll-free hotline at 1-800-267-9675.

*evil grin*

At Calgary's Scentorini Spa, their Wellness Day Spa stresses the body-spirit-wellness triangle reinforced by a vast menu that includes everything from a chocolate nutty scrub to a serenity stone facial and ear candling as well as dozens of more traditional treatments.
http://www.scentorinispa.com/

Prema Sai Wholistic Living
2713 14th St SW, Calgary, Alberta
Telephone: 403-243-4040
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.premasai.ca

Prema Sai Wholistic Living
Health Food Store & Wholistic Clinic. Services - Massage, Bowen Therapy, Chakra/Energy Balancing, Cranio Sacral, Ear Candling, Iridology, Blood Analysis, Nutrition, Psychic Readings, Raindrop therapy, Reiki.
http://www.intouchmag.com/directorylisting2-2.4html

Okay, just now I simply emailed both places this quote:
Health Canada maintains that these people are selling the product illegally, for medical purposes, as there is no other reasonable use for ear candles.

and the link the Government page with no comment. I wonder if they will respond?

Should I call the gov't line tomorrow and let them know that these services are advertised? It's late, so I won't be able to even leave a message (they have recordings as to when to call them when they are open).

Ohhhh, I just have to go see if I did see ear candling advertised in my own town!!
 
More on how useless ear candling is and why:

http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/earcandle/statement.html

One test measured the air temperature at a distance of 10 mm from the base of the cone while the candle was burning. At no time did the temperature rise above 22 degrees Celsius. Since body core temperature is 38 degrees Celsius, these tests support our conclusion that the candle produces no heating effect. Another series of tests measured the pressure in a closed vessel attached to the burning candle. The laboratory concluded that "In general, the results observed did not indicate any significant increase or decrease in the ambient pressure of the vessel

Thing is, the candle is hollow. The wax will travel down and land on your ear drum and either just sit there on your eadrum and burn or burn a hole.
http://www.cbc.ca/consumers/market/files/health/earcandle/index.html
This pain can cause panic...drop the candle...cause a fire...etc.

What a moronic thing to do, especially alone.
 
Having burned one of said candles in a test tube as a part of an exercise in applied critical thinking without all the electronic gizmos I can't get my sweaty hands on, and at the exhortations of my chemistry teacher, I conclude that the chances of hot wax falling on the sensative reworked jaw-bits we mammals like to call "ears", is not really that big.

For some reason, the smoke tends to get into the bottom of the candle, or at least it did in an imperfect glass replica of a human ear. It's quite astounding how much the resulting gunk looks like earwax to someone not aware of this fact, and under the power of persuasion. You just lift the candle up, cut it in half and it's filled with... something. The melted wax, of which there isn't that much (it's still a risk though) tends to get stuck in there.

Clearly the fact that said build up can occur sine auribus indicates that smoke particulate... or something... is the primary constituent of the buildup. It's truly far more vile looking than actual earwax.
 
Can anyone explain why (or supposedly why) this candle thing works better than a doctor cleaning out an ear? I had a problem about 9 years ago where I lost hearing in one ear because of wax bulid-up. A doctor was able to go in a very carefully remove the wax. He gave me a prescription or some stuff that would prevent or remove further wax but I didn't need it and never used it. What else could an "ear-candle" do?
 
The exact reason as to why an ear candle is supposed to work varies from source to source. Somehow, by fluids laws that have yet to be discovered, the thing is supposed to "suck" toxins and wax out of the ear, or somehting like that.
 
Go Eos!! This reminds me, I tore down an advert for the practice at work, yet the Australian Magazine, available in the national The Australian Newspaper has a column entitled 'Consider' where they have done everything from hot stone massage to aura photographs... you've inspired me to write to them; it does no good if I just snarl at the page and flip to the next one.
 
neutrino_cannon said:
The exact reason as to why an ear candle is supposed to work varies from source to source. Somehow, by fluids laws that have yet to be discovered, the thing is supposed to "suck" toxins and wax out of the ear, or somehting like that.
No, it sucks out negative energies... which don't weigh very much.
 
No response so far from anybody. I left a message at the gov't number. No replies from the places doing the candling.

I'll try calling again on Monday. I'd like to know if/How I should be reporting these people. Sheesh.

Kiless, I look forward to seeing that letter! People ought to know that we don't swallow codswallop unquestioningly.
 
Bikewer said:
I occasionally listen to "Dr. Zorba" on NPR. One caller asked him about ear candling, of which he had never heard.
When the caller explained the thing to him, he started laughing uncontrollably.
It was kind of like the old Newhart "Sir Walter Raleigh" sketch. "Wait, Walt, let me guess. You put the burning leaves in your ear, right?"

BTW, Zorba puts out some mostly-decent advice, but he's a bit soft on altenative medicine. He'll dutifully tell the callers that there is no scientific evidence to support the whatever they're calling about, but then say something to the effect of "If there's no science, you have to go with the anecdotal evidence. If you know several people who use whatever and they say it works for them, go ahead and try it."

What would he make of colonic irrigation?
 
Eos, I'm glad you are looking into this and trying to get the Gov. involved in shutting down this stuff. I only hope they don't need an injury to get them interested. I'm rooting for you! Yay!
 
Way to go, Eos!

There are all sorts of spas downtown promoting this sort of quackery. Let my know if you want anyone else to help you make phonecalls.
 
Yes please guys, go ahead make some of your own calls. I'm getting the ol' silent treatment. I have to answer the phones at work, and can't make any of my own calls from there. All my calls are after hours. Nice answering machine. Sigh.

Thanks for the encouragement, we all need some to remember to not just give up.

Thank you,

Eos
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom