Dylan Avery - Earth-Shattering News Coming Soon (again)

IT WAS THE FIRE, CAUSED THE TWIN TOWER COLLAPSE
An analysis of the cause of the collapse of the WTC Towers. & Possible lessons learned to improve high-rise building life safety. March 12, 2002
By: Arthur Scheuerman, Battalion Chief FDNY (Retired), Former Deputy Chief Instructor Nassau County Fire Training Academy and high-rise Fire Safety Director NYC.

"In Tower 1 it appears the top floor or floors began failing first possibly because the top floors were receiving most of the super heated gasses rising up the damaged elevator and stair shafts and other vertical openings such as un-fire-stopped pipe or wire runs, or air conditioning shafts. These fire gasses could have accumulated and heated the entire upper ceiling area or truss voids of one floor, or several floors, starting a softening and sagging of the joists. Or, more likely, after filling the upper floors (mushrooming) these heated gasses could have exploded, and triggered the initial floor collapse. This happens at times in unventilated void spaces at serious fires.
The fact that the collapse began, apparently simultaneously, around the entire upper floor outer ring and possibly the inner core of Tower 1 rather suggests an explosion or rapid combustion of flammable gasses, such as carbon monoxide or vaporized jet fuel, over-pressuring the area."
For the record, this analysis, and particularly the "simultaneous" part of it, is not supported by the NIST investigation or by other investigations. Interesting about the smoke explosions, though. EMT1986 brought this up recently also.
 
Last edited:
It's not circular, it's as solid as a tripod.

All explosives cause explosions.

Some explosions are caused by explosives.

Explosions are evidence of explosives.

Explosions are not proof of explosives.

With the lack of other evidence, explosions provide a preponderance of evidence of explosives.

With the lack of other evidence, explosions provide a preponderance of evidence of __________________ (insert here: Electrical Transformers, Oxygen Cannisters, Aeresol containers, heaving things falling and hitting something, The Collapse itself, other)

TAM:)
 
With the lack of other evidence, explosions provide a preponderance of evidence of explosives.

Are you claiming, there is no evidence, of anything in the towers that could explode? Except, for fictional explosives!
Got ya...nice research skills!

DT

ETA: I see TAM beat me to it. That'll teach me, to answer the phone, while starting a reply. 10 minute lag bad.
 
Last edited:
Are you claiming, there is no evidence, of anything in the towers that could explode? Except, for fictional explosives!
Got ya...nice research skills!

DT

ETA: I see TAM beat me to it. That'll teach me, to answer the phone, while starting a reply. 10 minute lag bad.

Did BarJennings hear a fictional explosion?

When the floor gave way, did that make it a non-fictional explosion?
 
So an explosion is evidence of a snapped steel beam, but not evidence of an explosive?

No, but I think logic dictates that the more simpler answer is the most likely (see occam). In a skyscraper that has just been hit by a jet airliner, had 5-6 floors traversed by material from said plane, and has multistorey fires raging, that things such as steel beams snapping, Oxygen and aeresol cannisters exploding, electrical transformers exploding, and large things falling, might all seem more plausible than explosives...so as Dog says...

NEXT!!

TAM:)
 
So an explosion is evidence of a snapped steel beam, but not evidence of an explosive?

Yes, the beams, bodies striking the ground, etc... Evidence of them making loud noises! NO EVIDENCE OF EXPLOSIVES! Pay attention!
 
So an explosion is evidence of a snapped steel beam, but not evidence of an explosive?
He says snapped steel beams. You say explosive. Me? I think it was done by unicorns with laser beams for horns. All, certainly, are just theories.

But since there's no physical evidence of explosives or unicorns and more than a steel beam or two in the remains of WTC-7 his theory has a lot higher probability of being right than either of ours.

How successfully they've been able to quash open discussion of the unicorn link does mean that SOMETHING shady is going on though. :eek:
 
Of course. It's perfectly obvious that these events are caused by bombs or demolitions explosives:

  • Steam boiler explosions
  • Electrical transformer explosions
  • Volcanic explosions
  • The explosions heard in the Madrid Windsor fire and in thousands of other fires.
  • Any sound that is described as being like an explosion.

So in 1993, when the people in the WTC heard, felt or saw the explosions, they were irrational to think that there might be bombs going off? (I am talking about their initiasl reaction)

Remember, according to you, hearing, feeling, or seeing explosions is not evidence of explosives.

I would argue that the people in 1993 who heard, saw, or felt explosions, had EVIDENCE of explosives, but not PROOF of explosives.
 
So an explosion is evidence of a snapped steel beam, but not evidence of an explosive?

Em no a snapped beam is evidence of a snapped beam. Had you ever heard steel snap, as I have sunbeam,you would know full well that when it goes it goes with a quite loud bang, but hey you would know all about this wouldn't you?

Ps, I hope you don't mind I liked your comments so much I have paid tribute to them by putting them in my signature, please keep them coming, they are classics.
 
Last edited:
Em no a snapped beam is evidence of a snapped beam. Had you ever heard steel snap, as I have sunbeam,you would know full well that when it goes it goes with a quite loud bang, but hey you would know all about this wouldn't you?

Ps, I hope you don't mind I liked your comments so much I have paid tribute to them by putting them in my signature, please keep them coming, they are classics.

What if the beam was snapped with super thermite?

:jaw-dropp
 
So in 1993, when the people in the WTC heard, felt or saw the explosions, they were irrational to think that there might be bombs going off? (I am talking about their initiasl reaction)

Remember, according to you, hearing, feeling, or seeing explosions is not evidence of explosives.

I would argue that the people in 1993 who heard, saw, or felt explosions, had EVIDENCE of explosives, but not PROOF of explosives.

Silly wabbit, NO! Had the expolsion been something other than explosives, YES! Explosives were proven beyond any doubt in 1993! GET IT YET?
Not irrational, just wrong! It happens.
 
So in 1993, when the people in the WTC heard, felt or saw the explosions, they were irrational to think that there might be bombs going off? (I am talking about their initiasl reaction)



No, they weren’t irrational. However, no one is saying that anyone was irrational to initially think that there might have been bombs going off 9/11, so it's irrelevant. Anyone who currently thinks that there were bombs going off on 9/11, on the other hand, is being absurd.
 
Last edited:
What if the beam was snapped with super thermite?

:jaw-dropp
Ahh, the mythical horizontal cutting thermite.

Please provide proof of said "super thermite" which cuts horizontally and include proof that it will keep on burning for weeks.
 
He says snapped steel beams. You say explosive. Me? I think it was done by unicorns with laser beams for horns. All, certainly, are just theories.

But since there's no physical evidence of explosives or unicorns and more than a steel beam or two in the remains of WTC-7 his theory has a lot higher probability of being right than either of ours.

How successfully they've been able to quash open discussion of the unicorn link does mean that SOMETHING shady is going on though. :eek:

SCENERIO:

Someone is seen throwing an object into a crowd, and then people in the crowd hear and feel an explosion. No bomb fragments are recovered.

RESULT:

What evidence is permitted at trial?

1) the eyewitness who saw someone throw the object.

2) Witness testimony from people who heard or felt the explosion.

or

1) the eyewitness who saw someone throw the object.

2) since whatever caused the explosion could have already been in the crowd before the object was thrown, the witnesses who heard and felt the explosion have no evidence and they can't testify.

YOUR TURN
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom