Drinking alcohol in Malaysia: legal for Christians, illegal for Muslims

Ladewig

I lost an avatar bet.
Joined
Dec 4, 2001
Messages
28,828
I just saw this CNN story about a Muslim woman who is going to be caned for drinking beer in public.

Malaysia, which considers itself a moderate Muslim country, forbids alcohol consumption by Muslims -- even those who are visiting.

The country has a dual-track justice system, in which Islamic courts operate alongside civil ones.

The law forbidding alcohol applies only to Muslims, who make up about 60 percent of the population. The country's Buddhist, Christian or Hindu population can drink freely.

Kartika's case has caused an uproar, with many citing it as another example of growing fundamentalism in the multiracial country.

A dual track legal system. That strikes me as so strange. The idea that all are equal before the law seems so fundamental to me, that I am having a hard time accepting this model.
 
Malaysia has a secular legal system based on the British legal system for non-muslims and for crimes. However, family, sexual and dietary facets are based on Muslim Shariah Law. They also have a "Morality" police that raid bars looking for muslims and hide in dark dating sites for "close proximity" events by Muslim couples. Some of the fumiest stories are "Morality" police raiding a house for an adulterest man...who turned out to be a real cop who pulled his gun and shot at them.
 
Remember, only a tiny percentage of Muslims support such things, it's just that that tiny percentage somehow gets control of the governments in Muslim countries without any popular support. And Christans did the same thing 500 years ago and George Bush turned the US into a theocracy so what's the problem?
 
I just saw this CNN story about a Muslim woman who is going to be caned for drinking beer in public.

A dual track legal system. That strikes me as so strange. The idea that all are equal before the law seems so fundamental to me, that I am having a hard time accepting this model.
Hi:

Your title is somewhat misleading. The correct statement is as follows:
Legal for non Muslims, illegal for Muslims.

Yes, I agree, it's strange, the Church Police whacking people on their backsides for having a beer. Heck, now that I think of it, that's rather uncivilized.

I've been to Malaysia. Lucky me, not being a Muslim, I was able to boost the local economy a bit by buying and swilling down a few pints to wash down the food: a pile of spicy and delicious stuff on rice.

DR
 
Last edited:
When collecting stories for Whatstheharm, I came across a similar legal situation.

In the 1960s, two immigrants from some African country living in Saudi Arabia (or was it Dubai?) were caught in bed with one another. I think she was a never married woman in her 40s and he was married with children and in his 30s and his wife and kids were in the home country. Something like that. They came over separately and happened to meet while working menial jobs.

Since adultery was punishable by death at the time for Muslims and they were both Muslims, they were executed. The article mentioned that if they had happened to be Christians living in a Muslim state, they'd both only serve a short prison sentence or even walk away with a fine.
 
I am resident in Malaysia and can assure all of you that if any Muslim wanted to drink (and plenty do) they just go ahead and do so. Morality police - never seen them. Beating people with sticks O(rattan) does not and would never happen arbitrarily, only a conviction would lead to that.

Malaysian Muslims are, in my experience, the most tolerant of all. I've lived and worked in India and the Middle East and there is no comparison.
 
Wildcat said:
Remember, only a tiny percentage of Muslims support such things, it's just that that tiny percentage somehow gets control of the governments in Muslim countries without any popular support. And Christans did the same thing 500 years ago and George Bush turned the US into a theocracy so what's the problem?

I am resident in Malaysia and can assure all of you that if any Muslim wanted to drink (and plenty do) they just go ahead and do so. Morality police - never seen them. Beating people with sticks O(rattan) does not and would never happen arbitrarily, only a conviction would lead to that.

Malaysian Muslims are, in my experience, the most tolerant of all. I've lived and worked in India and the Middle East and there is no comparison.

Remember, blues is probably lying here. Only news reports of particular incidents are good for getting an idea of a country and the viewpoints of a billion Muslims.
 
Last edited:
I am resident in Malaysia and can assure all of you that if any Muslim wanted to drink (and plenty do) they just go ahead and do so. Morality police - never seen them. Beating people with sticks O(rattan) does not and would never happen arbitrarily, only a conviction would lead to that.

Malaysian Muslims are, in my experience, the most tolerant of all. I've lived and worked in India and the Middle East and there is no comparison.

I don't doubt Malaysia is much more tolerant than most but, as with most Christian nations, there are ways in which it is liberal and ways in which it is not.

After all, the Malaysian government (if memory serves) wanted to censor The Passion of the Christ when it came out because it was a Christian film being shown in a majority Muslim nation. I believe it eventually was released there- but this even got debated in Malaysia's equivalent of Congress!
 
Is apostasy also illegal for muslims?

I suppose one could say that one volunteers to be subject to these laws by identifying as a muslim, but that depends on how voluntary such identification is.
 
Remember, blues is probably lying here. Only news reports of particular incidents are good for getting an idea of a country and the viewpoints of a billion Muslims.
I grew up there, have family there and still visit there regularly.

Ask him about the State of Kelantan and the Taliban-lite party they have there where they segregate men and women on supermarket lines. The capital city and many of the urban areas are more cosmopolitan but the government and society is still conservative and very much muslim.
 
Last edited:
I don't doubt Malaysia is much more tolerant than most but, as with most Christian nations, there are ways in which it is liberal and ways in which it is not.

After all, the Malaysian government (if memory serves) wanted to censor The Passion of the Christ when it came out because it was a Christian film being shown in a majority Muslim nation. I believe it eventually was released there- but this even got debated in Malaysia's equivalent of Congress!
Malaysia is officially a muslim country. It is in the constitution. It gives a local Malay Muslim special rights over non-muslims or even non-malays. The official government has been rather secular for years but is conservative, rather authoritarian and very patronizing.
 
Yes, I agree, it's strange, the Church Police whacking people on their backsides for having a beer. Heck, now that I think of it, that's rather uncivilized.

DR

The only place I have ever openly seen religious police is Saudi.

Someyimes in Glasgow you are shouted at in the street by nutters with bibles telling you that you are a sinner and you will burn in hell if you do not accept christ. They dont hit you with big sticks though and I dont think they are police;)
 
Remember, blues is probably lying here. Only news reports of particular incidents are good for getting an idea of a country and the viewpoints of a billion Muslims.
Who to believe, some random guy on the internet or a documented story from reliable news sources.

Damn, that's a toughie! :rolleyes:
 
Yes, and a sarcastic asshat is definitely an extreme expert for judging 1 billion Muslims, and totally isn't "a random person on the internet".

Yawn. Anything new to this, or should I just remove my subscription?

Yeah, I think I'll go do something more productive with my time.
 
Last edited:
Remember, only a tiny percentage of Muslims support such things, it's just that that tiny percentage somehow gets control of the governments in Muslim countries without any popular support. And Christans did the same thing 500 years ago and George Bush turned the US into a theocracy so what's the problem?

Essentially so.

Any other view is Islamophobic, of course, proving one is a idiot fundamentalist redneck.

To the point, the barbaric punishment aside (it is Islamic law, after all), this is what happens when religion is in the government. Of course the effects are not always that drastic. For example, historically, in Israel Jews and Muslims were not allowed to sell pork, while Christians were. On passover, Jews were not allowed to sell bread, while non-Jews (Muslim and Christians mostly) were. The sole result was, naturally, a business windfall for those who were in the religion that lucked out, as everybody bought from them...

Incidentally, to this day, the Israeli rabbinate ceremoniously "sells" all of the bread in the country to a non-Jewish person every year, he "selling" it back to the state after the holiday. I believe it is, in fact, the same man for years who had this job.

To show how efficient the whole thing is in preventing passover from being desecrated, he was on TV a few years ago, and another guest asked him:

--"So, all the bread in the country is yours this week?"
--"Officially, yes..."
--"Including all the pita bread?"
--"Yes."
--"I don't know how to tell you this, I'm eating your pitas all day without your knowledge, sorry about that..."
 
Yes, and a sarcastic asshat is definitely an extreme expert for judging 1 billion Muslims, and totally isn't "a random person on the internet".

Yawn. Anything new to this, or should I just remove my subscription?

Yeah, I think I'll go do something more productive with my time.
If you have nothing to offer but to project your emotional baggage via a strawman claim about something that no one here has done; maybe you should do something more appropriate with your time instead of making a fool of yourself.
 
To the point, the barbaric punishment aside (it is Islamic law, after all), this is what happens when religion is in the government. Of course the effects are not always that drastic.
Agreed. Malaysian politics and law is more complicated than just having this weird segregation between secular and shariah law.

There is not only religious issues at play but also legal racial rights that are spelled out in the Malaysian Constitution. The Malaysian Constitution places Islam as the official religion but also gives the "local"(well mostly decedents from the Malaccan Sultanate who are people mostly from what is now Indonesia) Malays* above other races. It gives them land rights, university, business quotas etc. This leads to 1/3rd(mostly Chinese but also Indian and some other groups) having less rights than the Malay population. Note that Indian Muslims or Muslims of other races do not have these rights.

What is also sad about this situation is that Malaysian Islam is derived from Saudi Arabian with many Imams training in Saudi Arabia. This leads to them taking a very puritanical stance against many traditional Malay traditions and cultural arts. Several kinds unique Malay traditions such as shadow puppet theater(based on folk tales), traditional dances(some involving Male crossdressers) traditional dresses(a traditional Malay dress was basically body hugging) and other arts are slowly dying in Malaysia because they are "un-Islamic".

Basically with many more Saudi Arabian trained Imams coming back and bringing back their brand of Islam, Islam in Malaysia is becoming more puritanical.

*local tribal inhabitants also have these "special" rights but are a significant minority compared to the Malays.
 
Last edited:
But she wants to be spanked, and soon! :eek:
Kartika was sentenced to six strokes of a rattan cane by the Shariah court in July in what was considered a warning to other Muslims to abide by religious laws.

In an interview with the AP last week, Kartika said she wanted to be caned because "I want to respect the law."
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/32534618/ns/world_news-asiapacific/
They are making her wait until Ramadan is over to get her spanking, the heartless curs!
Mohamad Sahfri Abdul Aziz, a state legislator in charge of religious affairs, later said the Attorney General's office advised that the caning should be delayed for compassionate reasons until after the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan, which began Saturday.

"The sentence is not being canceled," Mohamad Sahfri told The Associated Press.

Reminds me of an old joke:

This Masochist meets this Sadist at a club, and they go to her apartment. She looks him in the eye as the close the door and says:

"Spank me and whip me, big fella! Make me hurt!"

He says:

"No!"

DR
 
A dual track legal system. That strikes me as so strange. The idea that all are equal before the law seems so fundamental to me, that I am having a hard time accepting this model.

Well, it's one way to allow some people to be free, while allowing vicious thugs who will mess things up if they can't lord over somebody to have their tin pot dictatorship-in-partial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom