Cont: Donald Trump has 'dangerous mental illness', say psychiatry experts at Yale... Pt 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

SOdhner

Graduate Poster
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
1,745
Location
Arizona
We're setting a precedent that a very, very, very small number of mental health practitioners can claim that a politician has a mental disorder, without having followed the appropriate procedures to form a diagnosis... and can use that as a means to remove that politician from office.

In what possible universe does some people saying he has a personality disorder result in him actually being removed from office? That would be like suggesting that if I say he stole my wallet he's going to be dragged away and thrown in jail.

The most it could possibly be, the most drastic and consequential result, is that if all the right people found it plausible they could force him to undergo a direct evaluation and then maybe, possibly, use the result of that as part of the evidence needed to lawfully remove him from office. But that's a pretty extreme case and frankly isn't going to happen.

So no, I'm not at all worried about that.


Thread continued from here. You may quote and respond to post from previous parts.
Posted By: zooterkin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
In what way are their opinions "well supported?"

No matter what spin you put on it, all you have is an elaborate argument from authority. "We are well respected experts who agree with each other so we know," is not very convincing in my book.



The “architects and engineers” that say 9/11 was an inside job number 2000. Take that, long-distance shrinks!
 
In what possible universe does some people saying he has a personality disorder result in him actually being removed from office? That would be like suggesting that if I say he stole my wallet he's going to be dragged away and thrown in jail.



The most it could possibly be, the most drastic and consequential result, is that if all the right people found it plausible they could force him to undergo a direct evaluation and then maybe, possibly, use the result of that as part of the evidence needed to lawfully remove him from office. But that's a pretty extreme case and frankly isn't going to happen.



So no, I'm not at all worried about that.



What if they came out before the election? If he runs again, you don’t think they might get a little louder? How do you separate political attack from sound analysis?

And that points at another, bigger danger here: the erosion of trust in the medical profession.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
So if we laypeople are competent to reject her opinion, it opens up the possibility that we're competent to reject the opinion of the Yale group.

A medical professional is not always competent to diagnose mental disorders. From Ginger's own description, she is a professional, but not a mental health specialist. Thus, her opinion matters a lot less than the opinion of the Yale group.

But I tend to side with xj here. Even the Yale group's opinion goes only so far, since this opinion was not formed consistently with the ethical norms of their society.
 
A medical professional is not always competent to diagnose mental disorders. From Ginger's own description, she is a professional, but not a mental health specialist. Thus, her opinion matters a lot less than the opinion of the Yale group.

But I tend to side with xj here. Even the Yale group's opinion goes only so far, since this opinion was not formed consistently with the ethical norms of their society.
That is the same crap that demonstrates someone with little expertise, looking at a single ethical position paper and/or a single diagnostic standard without a clue how to apply such positions.

The evidence in the public sphere of Trump's mental illness is overwhelming. Anyone with any medical diagnostic experience could put the 'you need an in-person exam' standard into perspective. You don't need an in-person exam in Trump's case and it was asked over and over in this thread, what would one add in said in-person exam and the question was never answered, because there is no answer.

Then there is the 'ethical' position paper re the Goldwater rule. If you read the discussion by the professionals that chose to go against the ethical standard, they explain why they chose to do that.

The only actual argument against Trump's diagnosis was one professional who set a threshold standard of mental illness that the person must be suffering. Just because one is rich and successful doesn't mean one is not suffering. That issue and arguments against that single professional are well articulated in the thread.

But here we are again, people reading a few things on the internet who don't have the requisite diagnostic education and experience trying to apply a couple simplistic rules as if a couple rules override years of education and experience.

And then there is the attempt to make this about my expertise. I know it's bothersome to hear that Dunning-Kruger applies to someone. The whole issue with Dunning-Kruger is the person it applies to doesn't know what they don't know, so they believe they know enough. But they don't.

There isn't a body of professionals that believe Trump does not have NPD. There is one professional that put forth that argument. The rest are either speaking out that he does have NPD, they don't think any professional should make their clinical opinion pubic, and/or they have not formed an opinion. Not everyone is obsessed with Trump's mental status.

So those who don't get it or who prefer Trump be 'normal', go right ahead and believe that you can tell the diagnosis is wrong or can't be made because you read a couple 'rules' on the internet. I'm sure it seems to you that those couple rules represent years of education and experience and why on earth would such highly respected professionals not pay attention to those two standards/rules/whatever you want to call them.

Why do you think those professionals are not equally impressed about the significance of said 'rules' you read on the internet? Why would such highly respected professionals not think those 'rules' override years of education and experience?
Oh I know, just like Trump claims anything that is critical of him is either fake news or partisan politics. As if no FBI agent, no conscientious news reporter and no medical professional could possibly act within their profession without being partisan.

Damn the world must suck, not a single professional opinion is ever rendered without an overriding partisan influence.

Edited to add, you all don't have professional organizations behind you. You all have what you read on the net. Even if some of those in said organizations reiterated the Goldwater rule and publicly disagreed with the Yale professionals, only one of them have come out actually disagreeing with the diagnosis.
 
Last edited:
If this is only a single position paper, perhaps Skeptic Ginger could post a handful of position papers where the relevant organizations endorse "distance diagnosis" of public figures?
 
I think at this stage, "remote viewing" is still the best term for it.

As opposed to the aura reading of an in-person interview? I'll note again that those who claim there's a "scientific" reason for that requirement have repeatedly failed to make that case -- in fact they haven't even really tried. Such is the nature of dogmatism.
 
As opposed to the aura reading of an in-person interview? I'll note again that those who claim there's a "scientific" reason for that requirement have repeatedly failed to make that case -- in fact they haven't even really tried. Such is the nature of dogmatism.
Resolved: There is no scientific grounds for psychiatric diagnosis of any kind. Now what?
 
If this is only a single position paper, perhaps Skeptic Ginger could post a handful of position papers where the relevant organizations endorse "distance diagnosis" of public figures?
You don't get it. A professional organization's position paper doesn't override one's complete education and experience. The Yale psychiatrists and psychologists explained their reasoning in their paper. Any medical professional with half a brain can see an in-person exam in Trump's case would add nothing to the clinical assessment.
The in-person exam position paper applies to diagnosing and treating a patient and it doesn't apply to all situations. Hallway medicine is never recommended. That's when someone comes up to you and asks you to prescribe something or tell them what their rash is, but you never see them for an actual exam.
 
Last edited:
That is the same crap that demonstrates someone with little expertise, looking at a single ethical position paper and/or a single diagnostic standard without a clue how to apply such positions.
So let's stick to the ethics around a "duty to warn." When a patient expresses to their doctor a specific intent to harm someone there's a real ethical conflict there between the ethical rules about patient-physician confidentiality and a general duty to prevent harm to the threatened person. In that case, the APA and most States recognize a duty to warn the threatened person.

But here, no doctor has specific knowledge about any specific harm. All they have is their own speculation. Educated speculation, perhaps, but speculation nonetheless. Mere speculation is not enough to override a clear ethical rule.

Nothing in the ethical rules prohibits these mental health professionals from speaking their minds as citizens. The problem is that they are speaking as mental health professionals.
The evidence in the public sphere of Trump's mental illness is overwhelming. Anyone with any medical diagnostic experience could put the 'you need an in-person exam' standard into perspective. You don't need an in-person exam in Trump's case and it was asked over and over in this thread, what would one add in said in-person exam and the question was never answered, because there is no answer.
Sticking with the ethical question raised by this situation, an in-person interview might reveal that Trump is considering an unprovoked nuke attack as an extreme example. That would raise the ethical dilemma. But we don't have that. We have educated guesses -not enough to trigger the ethical dilemma.

Even if I grant you that the diagnosis of NPD is more likely than not to be true, there is still no basis on which to say that he is a danger to the world based on that diagnosis.

That brings the standard of care into play. Public domain information may be enough to raise the question of NPD or "malignant narcissism" in a professional's mind. But that question can only be resolved authoritatively by application of standard psychiatric/psychological practice. A professional opinion given in the form of a specific diagnostic label without any disclaimer or caveat isn't represented as an unresolved question in the professional's mind; it's represented as if it's a valid conclusion based on sound practice. In this case, it clearly isn't.

Then there is the 'ethical' position paper re the Goldwater rule. If you read the discussion by the professionals that chose to go against the ethical standard, they explain why they chose to do that.
And their arguments fall short of triggering an ethical dilemma. They cannot know that he is dangerous, they can only suspect it. A suspicion is not enough trigger a justification for an ethical breach -only a strong degree of certainty can do that.

The only actual argument against Trump's diagnosis was one professional who set a threshold standard of mental illness that the person must be suffering. Just because one is rich and successful doesn't mean one is not suffering. That issue and arguments against that single professional are well articulated in the thread.
Well articulated perhaps but not particularly well founded. Dr. Frances' argument is more like what professionals could be saying. I think he erred in stating that he does not have NPD (hasn't examined him so he can't say that) but the way he took Trump down was him speaking as a citizen. Nothing at all wrong with that.
But here we are again, people reading a few things on the internet who don't have the requisite diagnostic education and experience trying to apply a couple simplistic rules as if a couple rules override years of education and experience.
When those "things on the internet" are position papers of major organizations, those "things" have more weight than the other "things we read on the internet:' the opinion of these Yale "conference" attendees and their supporters.

And then there is the attempt to make this about my expertise. I know it's bothersome to hear that Dunning-Kruger applies to someone. The whole issue with Dunning-Kruger is the person it applies to doesn't know what they don't know, so they believe they know enough. But they don't.
Yes, i agree. The thing is that your paragraph here is highly ironic. You say your FNP certification and WA license mean you are qualified to speak on this topic. You introduced those things, not anyone else. You want those things to give your arguments weight. So YOU made this about your expertise. You could very easily have left that out of your arguments. But you didn't. So I would say that the DK argument applies to you a lot more than it does to someone like me who has admitted that he isn't an expert and so relies on other experts to form an argument.

An FNP gets very little formal education on psychology or training in psychiatric practice. You have not indicated that you took any post-graduate education in psychology/psychiatry. A few courses in psychology does not make one an expert.

Then there's the matter of experience. You admittedly have no experience in practicing psychiatry. You didn't do any residency training so you can't even say that you had some exposure to psych practice. Maybe you did a short rotation through the psych department but you can't say that your experience makes you an expert.

I'm perfectly willing to drop your expertise as an issue if you don't rely on it for your arguments. But as long as you continue to raise it AND as long as you continue to use DK as an argument against me. It applies to you too. You have a little bit of knowledge and think that makes you an expert.

There isn't a body of professionals that believe Trump does not have NPD. There is one professional that put forth that argument. The rest are either speaking out that he does have NPD, they don't think any professional should make their clinical opinion pubic, and/or they have not formed an opinion. Not everyone is obsessed with Trump's mental status.
The vast majority of practitioners have not said one peep about Trump's mental status. You cannot conclude that "there isn't a body of professionals that believe Trump does not have NPD."

So those who don't get it or who prefer Trump be 'normal',
This isn't about whether or not Trump is normal. I've certainly indicated that I don't think he's normal in a colloquial, political sense.
go right ahead and believe that you can tell the diagnosis is wrong or can't be made because you read a couple 'rules' on the internet. I'm sure it seems to you that those couple rules represent years of education and experience and why on earth would such highly respected professionals not pay attention to those two standards/rules/whatever you want to call them.

Why do you think those professionals are not equally impressed about the significance of said 'rules' you read on the internet? Why would such highly respected professionals not think those 'rules' override years of education and experience?
For the same reasons that doctors who should know better support all kinds of woo. Hubris, mostly.

Oh I know, just like Trump claims anything that is critical of him is either fake news or partisan politics. As if no FBI agent, no conscientious news reporter and no medical professional could possibly act within their profession without being partisan.
Trump is simply wrong and self-serving.

Damn the world must suck, not a single professional opinion is ever rendered without an overriding partisan influence.
That's a bit dramatic.


Edited to add, you all don't have professional organizations behind you. You all have what you read on the net. Even if some of those in said organizations reiterated the Goldwater rule and publicly disagreed with the Yale professionals, only one of them have come out actually disagreeing with the diagnosis.
I would take silence on the matter by the vast majority of practitioners to mean that the overwhelming opinion of practitioners is that diagnosing people you've never met is unethical.
 
You don't get it. A professional organization's position paper doesn't override one's complete education and experience. The Yale psychiatrists and psychologists explained their reasoning in their paper. Any medical professional with half a brain can see an in-person exam in Trump's case would add nothing to the clinical assessment.
The in-person exam position paper applies to diagnosing and treating a patient and it doesn't apply to all situations. Hallway medicine is never recommended. That's when someone comes up to you and asks you to prescribe something or tell them what their rash is, but you never see them for an actual exam.

Thank you for your reply. I realize that these professors explained their reasons for acting outside of protocol.

Highlighting, bold and ad-homs aren't helping your case here, btw. ;)
 
Ask the Yale group. That's exactly what they say should happen, based on their "diagnosis".
Yeah, a lot of things 'should' be. Doesn't mean they will be.

For example we should stop pumping greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere - but we won't. That doesn't mean scientists shouldn't recommend that we stop.

Personally I don't think we should do anything to remove Trump from office. The longer he stays in power the more damage he can do - and those of us who hate America couldn't be happier (my dream is that he goes full-on insane and nukes California....).
 
Yeah, a lot of things 'should' be. Doesn't mean they will be.

For example we should stop pumping greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere - but we won't. That doesn't mean scientists shouldn't recommend that we stop.

Personally I don't think we should do anything to remove Trump from office. The longer he stays in power the more damage he can do - and those of us who hate America couldn't be happier (my dream is that he goes full-on insane and nukes California....).
Why do you hate America?
 
Thank you for your reply. I realize that these professors explained their reasons for acting outside of protocol.

Highlighting, bold and ad-homs aren't helping your case here, btw. ;)
The ad hom wasn't an ad hom it was hyperbole.

I wasn't trying to insult you, just address that you asked for something that wasn't relevant and has been used in this thread over and over.

How do you frame an argument when someone asks you to address their argument which is not a relevant argument?

carlitos said:
post a handful of position papers where the relevant organizations endorse "distance diagnosis"
That is not the argument being put forward here. Xjx is repeating this nonsense over and over, post the scientific process (it's a diagnosis, not a research paper); support this or support that (Trump is a one-off, you don't dig out studies that support a diagnostic choice to diverge from a standard based on a one-off clinical situation. That is what your expertise and experience are for).

Everything is not in a book, there are not randomized double-blind clinical studies for everything we do.

Here's an example from my own medical file. I have a very weird autoimmune disorder. Neither I, nor my rheumatologist, nor the 5 different specialists I went to could find a single other case like mine. Not one.

So treatment and which tests to order are not in any medical textbook. But one thing that isn't needed is to run every single test that has the most remote possibility of showing something. Those tests might be standard for any one of my symptoms, but there is no standard for the symptom cluster. You make clinical decisions about which labs to run and which meds to try and not everything is addressed by some 'standard'.

Trump is a one-off and an open book. It's stupid for someone, (not necessarily you), to pull out a general standard and wave it around like it overrides anyone's professional judgement about Trump. That's not how medicine works.
 
Last edited:
As opposed to the aura reading of an in-person interview? I'll note again that those who claim there's a "scientific" reason for that requirement have repeatedly failed to make that case -- in fact they haven't even really tried. Such is the nature of dogmatism.
Interestingly because of this thread I spent some time looking at how medical professionals consult other medical professionals on cases, and some of the examples I found were psychiatric consultations and often these are done by providing the case file, so notes and videos not by any one to one interview etc. "remote viewing " diagnostics seems to be quite standard practice in all fields of medicine.
 
I'm not aware of Hitler having had a proper in-person psychiatric assessment performed. Does this mean that having no opportunity to do so invalidates any provisional diagnosis one or a group of professionals might compile today?

If we accept that based on the historic record alone we might arrive at a useful enough first diagnosis for such as Hitler, then can we not do so at least as confidently for a contemporaneous subject pretty wide open to observation in his environment and in real time?
 
Interestingly because of this thread I spent some time looking at how medical professionals consult other medical professionals on cases, and some of the examples I found were psychiatric consultations and often these are done by providing the case file, so notes and videos not by any one to one interview etc. "remote viewing " diagnostics seems to be quite standard practice in all fields of medicine.

Does the consulting physician make a diagnosis?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom