Do you think VASCO will find any aliens?

Did I say it was? No. but they are strongly implying that it is their ultimate goal.
If the article actually did do that then why did you need to lie about it? You took two pieces (pieces) of two unrelated sentences and combined them in a way that was inconsistent with how the article used those two sentence fragments.
 
If we imagine as a thought experiment that a planet similar to earth, inhabited by creatures similar to humans, and at a stage of technological development similar to our own exists relatively nearby in our own galaxy, say 50 ly away, would we be able to find it with current techniques? Obviously, they would not have a Dyson sphere, because they are only at a similar level of advancement to our own. But would there be a strong enough signal emanating from their home planet in our direction for our most powerful instruments to detect?
Not likely. Our radar beams and TV carrier waves (note that the carrier portion of a TV broadcast does not contain the signal) are probably the only signals that even make it beyond Pluto. And they are either highly focused (radar) or focused to a plane (TV signal) so they aren't likely to be noticed unless you happen to be watching our planet very specifically for an extended period. And even those few examples don't travel very far anyway.
 
If you're starting from the presumption that there are no extraterrestrial civilizations, then of course it seems silly to look for them, but at present we simply don't know one way or the other, so your presumption isn't justified.

Looking seems far more scientific than presuming to already know the answer.


And, further to your point, the authors of the paper are actually proposing to look for life outside our galaxy. We might have some good reason to believe we're alone in the galaxy but the reasons we have for believing that (I'm thinking Fermi paradox) simply don't apply to the entire universe.
 
If the article actually did do that then why did you need to lie about it? You took two pieces (pieces) of two unrelated sentences and combined them in a way that was inconsistent with how the article used those two sentence fragments.
No, I didn't. The abstract made no distinction regarding which objects were 'traditional' and which might be 'evidence of technologically advanced civilizations'. And if these 'technologically advanced civilizations' can harness the power of a quasar 4 trillion times the luminosity of our Sun, why not a supernova? Or perhaps they are even deliberately blowing up stars for some reason that we cannot fathom.

Someone once said "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic". Once you accept that principle unconditionally, no idea is too crazy to contemplate. For example:-

Aliens May Be Rearranging Stars to Fight Dark Energy
"Given the inevitability of the encroaching horizon, any sufficiently advanced civilization that is determined to maximize its ability to utilize energy will expand throughout the universe, attempting to secure as many stars as possible before they become permanently inaccessible," Hooper wrote...

This may seem like a tall order for humans, who are still bumbling around Level I of Kardashev's scale. (Carl Sagan placed us at about a 0.7 in 1973). But some scientists think there could be alien civilizations thousands, or even millions, of years older than ours who are already well into their Level III, star-harvesting phase.

And if another civilization has indeed begun rearranging the stars, it may not be long before Earthlings notice them, Hooper wrote.
Why is such talk not simply dismissed as pure fantasy? Because as humans we see things from a human perspective, giving credence to ideas that we can relate to even when they are highly improbable. What's worse, this kind of fantasizing actually drives scientific research. We want to build colonies on Mars, communicate with alien civilizations, invent faster-than-light drive, travel back in time etc., all sorts of impractical or even totally impossible goals, because if we can imagine it we think we can do it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom