Discussion of the Pentagon taxi cab driver's impossible account.

He is lying, proving that he is a liar.

Russell says the base is in the air, and Mr. England corrects him and indicates it was down by the hood and to the right.

-Gumboot

Exactly.

Down on the hood.

In the front.

Not the ground or to the side.

Impossible.
 
Roger that... and we can, perhaps.

If Mr. England ever feels the need to take this to court, I'm sure the admissions made here, along with our own analysis, might prove quite useful. We saw this precise situation with Killtown...

So just keep talking, Lyte Trip, and you too, fellow Killclone Skeptic4Sure. We'll give you all the rope you want.

I would give ANYTHING for him to sue us!

That would be a dream come true.

But it will NEVER happen.

That I can guarantee.
 
From that site:




http://www.pentagonresearch.com/images/412.jpg


edit: the author of the site (Russell Pickering?) included the following request at the top of the page:

Since our interview in person Russell has conceded that he was INCORRECT in his guess that Lloyd was referring to the small piece of the pole.

If you notice in the NBC interview linked in Russell's article Lloyd says:

""The plane was so low it hit the light pole," England said. "And when it hit the pole it knocked the light part off and nothing came through the car but the pole itself."

And then when we interview him in person we showed him all the pictures of his cab next to the pole and he repeatedly pointed to the 30 to 40 foot long base of the pole.

What's ironic is the fact that in Russell's artilce from the phone interview he claimed he doesn't "grill" witnesses yet he is the one grilling Lloyd in front of the cab to demonstrate exactly where the pole was located.

Lloyd has been referring to the long piece of the pole since day one.

This has been now established definitively and Russell is still working on an update to his woefully outdated site.
 
I don't know about anyone else, but I'm really pissed at the treatment these CTers have given Mr England. He's an OLD MAN. Leave him alone! :mad:

Moreso even than Val and other previous people that CTers have harrassed, this one is making my blood boil.

-Gumboot

This makes me angry too. He experienced something HORRIBLE and I'm sure has had a rough time getting on with his life. Being BADGERED, especially by the truthers and their RUDE, DISRESPECTFUL antics, is NOT helpful.

PLEASE LEAVE HIM ALONE!!!
 
So, Lyte, help me out here.
If Mr England is lying, what do you think really happened?

How do you get from the conclusion that he is lying to complete verification that the government did the whole thing?

Was he paid by the government to hang about the freeway until a chosen time, when he kicked in his own windshield, sawed down a light pole and then contacted the papers to publicise this dis-information? What purpose did this fulfill?

(No one has commented yet on the terrible example of journalism that was, either. What a load of rubbish the first few sentences alone are. You don't spend anything more than one day trying 'to survive' any one day, certainly not 2 years.)

I have evidence proving his story is not true.

You will all be forced to either retract your statements or else call multiple other witnesses liars.

I don't know if Lloyd is deliberately lying or has been threatened or manipulated but I know for a fact that his impossible story is not true.
 
Since our interview in person Russell has conceded that he was INCORRECT in his guess that Lloyd was referring to the small piece of the pole.

If you notice in the NBC interview linked in Russell's article Lloyd says:



And then when we interview him in person we showed him all the pictures of his cab next to the pole and he repeatedly pointed to the 30 to 40 foot long base of the pole.

What's ironic is the fact that in Russell's artilce from the phone interview he claimed he doesn't "grill" witnesses yet he is the one grilling Lloyd in front of the cab to demonstrate exactly where the pole was located.

Lloyd has been referring to the long piece of the pole since day one.

This has been now established definitively and Russell is still working on an update to his woefully outdated site.
Okay, if Mr. England says it was the big piece, then it was the big piece. It ended up curved across the hood and through his windshield.
 
Yet more despicable accusations against 9/11 victims from our resident chemtrail-huffing Killtown clone?

What a lovely, lovely person Craig, AKA Lyte Trip is.



No, Craig, he said he heard an explosion. You bolded that part of his account in red, remember?


Wow.

Good job "debunking" the part I even concede in the OP could have been misinterpretation by the author of the article.

You will be forced to concede I am right or call multiple other witnesses liars.
 
And then when we interview him in person we showed him all the pictures of his cab next to the pole and he repeatedly pointed to the 30 to 40 foot long base of the pole.

So it might have only been 30 feet? Are you going to tell us what Mr. England was saying when he drew that detail in the pcture with the pole sticking into the back seat? "30 to 40" feet and the end of the pole are important parts of the "see-saw" calculation.
 
I have evidence proving his story is not true.
Put up; or go outside and play hide and go **** yourself.

You will all be forced to either retract your statements or else call multiple other witnesses liars.
False dilemma
This fallacy typically involves asking a question and providing only two possible answers when there are actually far more. It seems to be a favourite of politicians, especially when trying to win support for a none-too-plausible policy. Take this classic example:
You're either with us or against us.​
The implicit argument here is that two possible positions exist with regard to the matter at hand: in favour or opposed. If we are not in favour, then, it follows that we must be opposed; and vice versa. The use of such tactics often give us the opportunity of appreciating fine—if overblown—rhetoric, too, like "do you support this war to defend our way of life or are you a cowardly, treasonous blackguard?" To expose the question as a false dilemma, all we need do is show that an alternative response exits. Other names for the same thing are the black and white fallacy, which immediately calls our attention to the shades of grey that are ignored, or the bifurcation fallacy.
Take another example:
Either you support lowering taxes or you're content to see this country go to hell in short order.​
The person presenting such a choice presumably advocates the lowering of taxes and is offering us a choice of two options. Since the second one seems unpalatable, he or she assumes we will lend our support to the policy. Taking the best possible reading of this situation, we might have the following:
P1: We can lower taxes or the country can go to the devil;
P2: No other options exist;
C: Therefore, a person not agreeing with lowering taxes is content to see the country fall apart.​
Even this does not precisely address the statement as given; for instance, we could hold no opinion at all on the matter, or be insufficiently informed to do so sensibly. These are alternatives, so the choice given is a false dilemma. In the above formulation we could challenge P2, since it seems unlikely that only one policy has been proposed. A single alternative would again make the choice a false dilemma. As before, this is a fallacy of presumption.
http://www.galilean-library.org/int16.html#false_dilemma


I don't know if Lloyd is deliberately lying or has been threatened or manipulated but I know for a fact that his impossible story is not true.
Begging the question.
 
Wow.

Good job "debunking" the part I even concede in the OP could have been misinterpretation by the author of the article.

You will be forced to concede I am right or call multiple other witnesses liars.
You are lying again. Do you constantly lie because you will not, or because you cannot stop?

You said
The strangest part of this account is that he got speared by the pole, stopped the car, got out, was appoached with help, started removing the pole, and THEN heard the impact.

Naturally this is impossible since he was on route 27 about a few hundred feet from the Pentagon and the plane was reportedly traveling around 500 mph.

This could be written off as misinterpretation by the author of the article and Lloyd has never made that claim again so we'll give Lloyd the benefit of the doubt on that one and leave it at that.
There is no "benefit of the doubt" to be given. YOU INVENTED THE IDEA THAT LLOYDE HEARD THE IMPACT AFTER HE GOT OUT OF THE CAR. IT'S YOUR PROBLEM TO DEAL WITH, NOT HIS AND NOT OURS. YOU HAVE A SERIOUS PROBLEM WITH HONESTY, CRAIG. DON'T BLAME OTHERS FOR IT.

Now, do you agree that YOU, and no one else, used the word "impact" to describe the noise Lloyde heard after exiting the car? And do you now retract that claim?
 
Exactly.

Down on the hood.

In the front.

Not the ground or to the side.

Impossible.

LLOYD: The dashboard held it up

From where in this do you get the idea it was on the hood?

RUSSELL: So the curved part comes out here
LLOYD: I don't know, I don't know-
RUSSEL: And the base part is out like this? [Gestures up in air]
LLOYD: No, it was down lower, down this way. [Gestures to right and down]. See it's the, it's the car that held it up.
RUSSELL: Okay.
LLOYD: The inside, the interior of the car that held it up.
RUSSELL: The interior blew [still gesturing upwards]
LLOYD: The dashboard held it up.
RUSSELL: Was it resting on the hood or was it up [still gesturing up]
LLOYD: I can't say, I don't know. But it was out here.
RUSSELL: Okay.

So we have an old man, years after the fact, who admits he was distracted that day, and doesn't remember a lot of the details, being badgered to remember by a bunch of weirdos, who keep feeding him leading questions, despite his efforts to correct them about what little he remembers.

And this is the stuff of conspiracies great and small?

I think Mr. England should be allowed to sue you just for being an annoying young punk. But that's just my opinion.
 
Again, why can't we just call them "wrong"? Or "manipulated"?

Indeed, here's a quote from a post by Crungy on the other thread that bears repeating:

The first psychological issue with witness testimony is "perception" — the question of whether external events are copied into memory accurately. The second is "memory" — the issue of whether initial perceptions, accurate or inaccurate, remain unchanged in the mind.
If human perception is questionable, human memory is at least equally questionable.

The tempting simple assumption is that people have "Flashbulb Memory." That just as a flashbulb fires and imprints an image permanently on film, an event is emblasioned on human memory and remains there unchanged. Alas, that's not the case.

In the first place, people can "remember" things that they could not have possibly seen. One example comes from Daniel Schacter's book Seven Sins of Memory, and concerns the 1992 crash of an El Al cargo plane into an apartment building in the Netherlands.

People throughout the country saw, read, heard, and talked about the catastrophe.

Ten months later a group of Dutch psychologists probed what members of their university communities remembered about the crash. The researchers asked a simple question: "Did you see the television film of the moment the plane hit the apartment building?" Fifty-five percent of respondents said "yes." In a follow-up study, two-thirds of the participants responded affirmatively.

They also recalled details concerning the speed and angle of the plane as it hit the building, whether it was on fire prior to impact, and what happened to the body of the plane right after the collision. These finding are remarkable because there was no television film of the moment when the plane actually crashed.

The psychologists had asked a blatantly suggestive question: they implied that television film of the crash had been shown. Respondents may have viewed television footage of the postcrash scene, and they probably read, imagined, or talked about what might have happened at the moment of impact. Spurred on by the suggestive question.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2148221#post2148221

I also made several posts on that thread quoting sources that indicate the problems with eyewitness testimony, I summarised them into a single post on the norman mineta thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2132245&postcount=225

There are a couple of interesting video clips in there as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom