Discovery of a Fifth Fundamental Force of Nature About to be Confirmed?

Gord_in_Toronto

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 22, 2006
Messages
26,940
New particles about to be discovered? Why bother? We already have dozens of them but how about a new fundamental force of nature?

A laboratory experiment in Hungary has spotted an anomaly in radioactive decay that could be the signature of a previously unknown fifth fundamental force of nature, physicists say – if the finding holds up.

Attila Krasznahorkay at the Hungarian Academy of Sciences’s Institute for Nuclear Research in Debrecen, Hungary, and his colleagues reported their surprising result in 2015 on the arXiv preprint server, and this January in the journal Physical Review Letters1. But the report – which posited the existence of a new, light boson only 34 times heavier than the electron – was largely overlooked.

Dark matter may feel a "dark force" that the rest of the Universe does not

Then, on 25 April, a group of US theoretical physicists brought the finding to wider attention by publishing its own analysis of the result on arXiv2. The theorists showed that the data didn’t conflict with any previous experiments – and concluded that it could be evidence for a fifth fundamental force. “We brought it out from relative obscurity,” says Jonathan Feng, at the University of California, Irvine, the lead author of the arXiv report.

http://www.nature.com/news/has-a-hungarian-physics-lab-found-a-fifth-force-of-nature-1.19957
 
Cool, interstellar travel coming up!

And ESP, and ZPE, and a cure for AGW....

If only.
 
Huh?

There are already five fundamental forces in nature:

Gravitational force,
Electrical Force,
Magnetic Force,
Weak Nuclear Force, and
Strong Nuclear Force.
Writing from memory, I believe that the electric and magnetic forces were shown to be manifestations of one and the same force, and that this was demonstrated as early as 1820.

ETA Yes.
On 21 April 1820, during a lecture, Ørsted noticed a compass needle deflected from magnetic north when an electric current from a battery was switched on and off, confirming a direct relationship between electricity and magnetism.​
 
Last edited:
Writing from memory, I believe that the electric and magnetic forces were shown to be manifestations of one and the same force, and that this was demonstrated as early as 1820.

ETA Yes.
On 21 April 1820, during a lecture, Ørsted noticed a compass needle deflected from magnetic north when an electric current from a battery was switched on and off, confirming a direct relationship between electricity and magnetism.​

Indeed, which was BEFORE the concept of fundamental forces was even introduced.

In fact, we only have three (two) fundamental forces: The electromagnetic and the weak force are manifestations of the same interaction. The thing is that most interactions under normal conditions (i.e., not high energy accelerator experiments) don't need the 'electroweak' theory, which is why it's not used as SOP.

There are hopeful theoretical proposes to incorporate the strong force into that, as well. Gravity is more difficult, though.

Grand Unified Theory? Ring a bell?
 
Huh?

There are already five fundamental forces in nature:

Gravitational force,
Electrical Force,
Magnetic Force,
Weak Nuclear Force, and
Strong Nuclear Force.
Eletromagnetic.
Also the W and Z experiments merged EM and Weak forces (into Eletroweak) years ago.
 
Can you explain why those last two are distinct? Seems to me the others have "Strong" and "Weak" as well.

The last two are nuclear forces, but different types of nuclear forces: hence, the different names.

However, I really do not think that there is such a thing as a Weak Gravitational Force and a Strong Gravitational Force.

Or a Weak Magnetic Force and a Strong Magnetic Force.

Or a Weak Electrical Force and a Strong Electrical Force.
 
Writing from memory, I believe that the electric and magnetic forces were shown to be manifestations of one and the same force, and that this was demonstrated as early as 1820.

ETA Yes.
On 21 April 1820, during a lecture, Ørsted noticed a compass needle deflected from magnetic north when an electric current from a battery was switched on and off, confirming a direct relationship between electricity and magnetism.​

My mistake.

When I was going to school, while it was clear that the Magnetic Force and the Electrical Force were different aspects of the same thing, however they were treated separately.

But now, the convention is to discuss the Electromagnetic Force as one thing.
 
Eletromagnetic.
Also the W and Z experiments merged EM and Weak forces (into Eletroweak) years ago.

True.

However, the convention is still to treat the Weak Nuclear Force and the Electromagnetic Force as two different things, which means that there are four fundamental forces of nature.

Also, if one were to treat the Weak Nuclear Force and the Electromagnetic Force as sme thing, then that would mean that there are only three fundamental forces of nature.
 
The last two are nuclear forces, but different types of nuclear forces: hence, the different names.

However, I really do not think that there is such a thing as a Weak Gravitational Force and a Strong Gravitational Force.

Or a Weak Magnetic Force and a Strong Magnetic Force.

Or a Weak Electrical Force and a Strong Electrical Force.

Wouldn't the sun be an example of a Strong Gravitational force, and a soda can an example of a weak one?
 
Wouldn't the sun be an example of a Strong Gravitational force, and a soda can an example of a weak one?

Sure, you could say that for example the sun exerts a strong (or large) gravitational force on the Earth and a soda can a weak (or small) one. That's because the Sun has large mass and the can small mass.

However, the gravitational force itself is the weakest of all forces. It manifests itself as strong as it does, because gravitational charges (mass) always sum up whereas other charges (for example those of the electromagnetic force) tend to cancel each other out on larger scales.

Strong and weak nuclear forces are just names. They are quite different and not a stronger and weaker manifestation of the same force as in the Sun and the soda can example. The strong force is carried by gluons and holds quarks together in particles such as protons and neutrons. It also binds nuclei (which are made up only of electrically positively charged and neutral particles and would not hold together were it for the electromagnetic force only). The weak force is carried by different particles, called W+, W−, and Z bosons. What it does is not as easy to explain, but it is required to describe nuclear decay.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom