Deutsche Bank staff in mass sackings

You do know, don't you, that fixed and variable interest rates, as a rule, shadow each other?
For the lifetime of any particular swap contract that's exactly what they don't do, the fixed leg is, well, fixed and the floating leg floats, and every settlement date the fixed payer and receiver settle the difference with each other that is due to the rates not "shadowing each other". The only way the two sides can "shadow each other" is if floating rates don't move between settlement dates, in which case there is no profit/loss on the swap, and ex-post no reason to have traded it in the first place.

If that were not so, then it would be simple to carry out a form of arbitrage using interest rate swaps.
There isn't an arbitrage unless a rate swap has been incorrectly priced, but that would be a mathematical error made using known quantities. A bet on the future direction of rates isn't arbitrage.
 
OTC derivatives are 'over the counter'.

Don't confuse normal hedging with swaps. OTCs such as forward contracts and futures (options) are perfectly safe.
Swaps are OTC derivatives. Futures generally are not. Interest rate swaps are also widely used as hedging instruments either to lock in a fixed rate in stead of a floating one, or the reverse; there are many hedging reasons to do that. Other swaps trade floating interest rates for the return stream of another financial asset or index.

Probably the BIS data has more granularity concerning how much of the derivatives space is specifically swaps I have not looked but I suspect it is either the second largest chunk after FX or the largest.
 
I was referring to swaps in which variable rates were swapped for fixed rates. As fixed rates pre-2008 were around the 8% - 9% and variable rates as low as 1.5% - 3%
In Germany (well the euro zone) official ECB short term interest rates were around 4% and German sovereign ten year bond yields a bit above that.

As interest rates are still low why would anyone in their right mind go for a higher fixed rate?
By trading a swap as either fixed rate payer or receiver you don't "go for a higher fixed rate" you take a view on whether floating rates are gonna move differently to what is priced in (today) to expectations. Nothing about what rates were in 2008 has any relevance to this. If you become a fixed rate payer (you buy a "payer swap") then you are essentially compelled to borrow at the fixed rate and if interest rates increase (=more than is expected, from today's level) you win and otherwise you lose. Reverse that for the other side of the trade.
 
Bottom line on Deutsche Bank: I tend to think that if a bank in trouble is not rescued by the relevant government ("socialised losses"), then it isn't a systemic risk.

(Of course it has been bailed out in the past to the extent that almost all banks were, and many would say they still are being, but a few thousand bankers losing work isn't likely to move the needle)
 
Last edited:
Swaps are OTC derivatives. Futures generally are not. Interest rate swaps are also widely used as hedging instruments either to lock in a fixed rate in stead of a floating one, or the reverse; there are many hedging reasons to do that. Other swaps trade floating interest rates for the return stream of another financial asset or index.

Probably the BIS data has more granularity concerning how much of the derivatives space is specifically swaps I have not looked but I suspect it is either the second largest chunk after FX or the largest.

I didn't say they were not available, merely not used nearly as widely as they once were pre-2008.

For example, it used to be a compulsory long number-crunching question in accountancy exams, with a suggested calculation proforma consisting of two vertical lines down the page labelled the start and end date of the period in question; the top representing Company X with the first line showing, say, the fixed interest rate on its financial instrument, and the second line its variable interest rate instrument hedge. At the bottom of the two vertical lines is marked Company Y showing its variable rate financial instrument followed by its fixed rate hedge. This works well initially for company X & Y as the variable rate fluctuations cancel out the fixed rate, causing gains and losses (the whole point of a hedge is to iron out losses). As soon as there is an imbalance and a constant loss can be calculated on all sides throughout the period - losses outweighing the gains - both Company Y and Company X to put it simplistically find it profitable do a 'swap' which has the aim of gaining a more favourable rate, which works for both as they have hedges opposite the other. This worked when variable interest rates were often worse than fixed rates, and as is inherent in their name, they fluctuated according to the markets. You had to wok out the gains and losses over the period and design a way of a good swap. When the markets plunged in 2008 suddenly variable rates were almost alwayslower, thus came a frantic stampede to offload the fixed rate instruments but unfortunately many were stuck with them as could not find a swap and the hedges were losses. The long-number crunching questions were dropped from accountancy syllubuses and are now merely an 'explain' type question rather than any complex 30-pointer, if it appears at at all. This is because 'nobody touches them any more' in terms of running a business. Of course they still exist. But nowhere near as standard and prolifically as they were once relied on.
 
You said "nobody touches swaps these days" which is not the case. In fact . . . well I will just quote:
In fact, the swap market is one of the largest and most liquid global marketplaces, with many willing participants eager to take either side of a contract. According to the most recent statistics, the notional amount outstanding in over-the-counter interest rate swaps was more than $542 trillion.
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/trading/11/introduction-swap-market.asp
(although this seems to pull the BIS number for all OTC derivatives into it)

No idea if swaps are in accounting syllabuses, as far as IFRS is concerned they are investments in financial assets and IIRC required to be reported at fair value on balance sheets which means than unrealised P/L is recorded in net income every period, learning how to value swaps doesn't seem to be a core part of accounting. I am pretty sure that rate swaps remain part of the derivatives section of the CFA curriculum as they have been for years, along with currency swaps (same thing but two different currencies and usually fixed-for-fixed), equity swaps, other total return swaps and most forward commitments.

Warren Buffet might not use them (although he did), but many others do.
 
As soon as there is an imbalance and a constant loss can be calculated on all sides throughout the period - losses outweighing the gains - both Company Y and Company X to put it simplistically find it profitable do a 'swap' which has the aim of gaining a more favourable rate, which works for both as they have hedges opposite the other.
I don't know what this means. A swap is priced so that it has zero value at initiation, that is how the fixed rate is computed, and after that point up to the first settlement date one party's gain is the other's loss, then it is reset to zero again.
 
Anybody remember Ryan Gosling in the film 'Big Short' based on Deutsche Bank bond salesman Greg Lippmann .?

I just want to tiptoe between all the banking jargon to say what a marvellous film The Big Short is. They manage to describe a genuine disaster unfolding from the point of view of people the audience can actually engage with because they're neither the hubristic idiot perpetrators nor the helpless victims. And they manage to explain stuff at an audience level, even though they hilariously accept they literally need Margot Robbie in a bubble bath to hold your attention while she tells you.
 
For the lifetime of any particular swap contract that's exactly what they don't do, the fixed leg is, well, fixed and the floating leg floats, and every settlement date the fixed payer and receiver settle the difference with each other that is due to the rates not "shadowing each other". The only way the two sides can "shadow each other" is if floating rates don't move between settlement dates, in which case there is no profit/loss on the swap, and ex-post no reason to have traded it in the first place.


Oh yes, obv that's true - but I wasn't talking about charting the rates through the duration of any one particular swap. Rather, the (not specifically related to swaps) point I was making was that if one charts floating rates vs the available fixed rate at every given date, then over time those two lines will tend to follow the same shape, albeit at different levels on the y axis. It was in response to something Vixen had written about "why would anyone engage in the swaps market when variable rates are low but fixed rates are high....



There isn't an arbitrage unless a rate swap has been incorrectly priced, but that would be a mathematical error made using known quantities. A bet on the future direction of rates isn't arbitrage.


Totally - but again, I was responding specifically to Vixen's (incorrect) contention that for some reason fixed rates would never respond to variations in the underlying variable rate.
 
Francesca, as you seem to know your stuff could you comment on the assertion in the end credits of "The Big Short" that a Bespoke Tranche Opportunity is "basically another name for a CDO"?

My understanding is that it wasn't supposed to be as risky but Trump has since rolled back the legislation that oversaw it - the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom