Debunk-liners

You do not really know much about 9/11 do you? (you did not know 3 of the planes turned of the transponder?)

You can look up transponders. Why do you ask, and what is the purpose of derailing this tread with stupid question you can look up yourself? http://www.public-action.com/911/transpon/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transponder_%28aviation%29

What is your problem? Post to the thread or start you own, I do not know anything about 9/11 thread and ask for help.

This thread is about one-liners that debunkers would say. "Exactly what frequency is the Beam weapon on?"

Try it.
The question was rhetorical. In fact I brought up the transponder.
 
When reviewing the radar tapes, the secondary returns could be tracked until such time as the transponders were deactivated. From then on, the primary returns could be tracked until the planes reached their targets. That’s one way.

Show me where it's claimed they could and did do that. Also if it's true then why did the hijackers bother to turn them off?

Does this guy not know what he's talking about? Compared to you that is.

Commander Ted Muga, BS CE, U.S. Navy (ret) – Retired Pan-Am commercial airline pilot. Aircraft flown: Boeing 707 and 727. Retired Civil Engineer. Retired Naval aviator. Aircraft flown: Grumman E-1 Tracer and E-2 Hawkeye.

"And also in all four planes, if you remember, none of the planes ever switched on their transponder to the hijack code. There's a very, very simple code that you put in if you suspect that your plane is being hijacked. It takes literally just a split-second for you to put your hand down on the center console and flip it over. And not one of the four planes ever transponded a hijack code, which is most, most unusual. ..."
 
There's a very, very simple code that you put in if you suspect that your plane is being hijacked. It takes literally just a split-second for you to put your hand down on the center console and flip it over. And not one of the four planes ever transponded a hijack code, which is most, most unusual. ..."
I would refer you to the case of FedEx Flight 705 for an example of an attempted hijacking where the crew had no chance to inform ATC what was happening until several minutes after the incident had started.
 
It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.
Buildings that are demolished with explovies can be brought down right within the buildings footbrint without any damage being brought upon buildings even if they are a block away. You really haven't watched that much controlled demolitions if you think that 9/11 had any sense of control.
 
Last edited:
Show me where it's claimed they could and did do that. Also if it's true then why did the hijackers bother to turn them off?


Please do not try to move the goal-posts. You asked me how investigators could have made sure that they had located and tracked the right plane. I explained a way in which they could have done so. The hijackers, as I’ve already pointed out, deactivated the transponders to impede efforts to locate and track the planes. If you’ll recall, their only concern was reaching their targets without being intercepted. Whether or not they could be successfully tracked appreciably after the fact by investigators with practically unlimited time to examine the radar tapes probably didn’t concern them all that much.

Does this guy not know what he's talking about? Compared to you that is.


The quotation in question is not in contradiction with anything that I have said.
 
Please do not try to move the goal-posts. You asked me how investigators could have made sure that they had located and tracked the right plane. I explained a way in which they could have done so. The hijackers, as I’ve already pointed out, deactivated the transponders to impede efforts to locate and track the planes. If you’ll recall, their only concern was reaching their targets without being intercepted. Whether or not they could be successfully tracked appreciably after the fact by investigators with practically unlimited time to examine the radar tapes probably didn’t concern them all that much.

I'm not moving anything it's all part of the same thing. What I've been saying all along is if the transponders were turned off to impede identification maybe they did just that and what was really tracked was a different aircraft. If they have proof that they don't need the transponder then where is it and why have it in the first place and why turn it off?

The quotation in question is not in contradiction with anything that I have said.

It's in relation to the transponder and how they seemed to go off or were changed exactly at the time the pilot should have switched to hijack mode. Four times.
 
What I've been saying all along is if the transponders were turned off to impede identification maybe they did just that and what was really tracked was a different aircraft. If they have proof that they don't need the transponder then where is it and why have it in the first place and why turn it off?


They do not have proof that they didn’t need to turn the transponders off. As I have already said, the deactivation of the transponders successfully impeded efforts to locate and track the planes while the attacks took place. Via careful examination of the radar tapes after the fact, however, they could be successfully located and tracked.

It's in relation to the transponder and how they seemed to go off or were changed exactly at the time the pilot should have switched to hijack mode. Four times.


I know what it is in relation to. However, you sardonically asked me if I thought I knew more than this Ted Muga. Yet nothing in his statement is in contradiction with anything that I have said.
 
Last edited:
Show me where it's claimed they could and did do that. Also if it's true then why did the hijackers bother to turn them off?

Does this guy not know what he's talking about? Compared to you that is.

Commander Ted Muga, BS CE, U.S. Navy (ret) – Retired Pan-Am commercial airline pilot. Aircraft flown: Boeing 707 and 727. Retired Civil Engineer. Retired Naval aviator. Aircraft flown: Grumman E-1 Tracer and E-2 Hawkeye.

"And also in all four planes, if you remember, none of the planes ever switched on their transponder to the hijack code. There's a very, very simple code that you put in if you suspect that your plane is being hijacked. It takes literally just a split-second for you to put your hand down on the center console and flip it over. And not one of the four planes ever transponded a hijack code, which is most, most unusual. ..."
You have no idea what the thread is about. Do you?

The pilots were killed before they were able to put in the code. Go ahead try to put the code in with your throat cut. Come on big strong pilot, put the code in while the warm blood runs down your neck. You can squawk emergency with a quick button but since your throat is cut you did not have time. Did you hear the one tape where the pilots are being killed? Do you even try to look up stuff on your own. I find your lack of knowledge and posting stupid question most disrespectful. The pilots would squawk the hijack code or emergency code if they had time. They had to be killed or they would have take the plane back. This is very sore subject, anyone can cut your or my throat without us able to stop it. Unless you are prepared, you are lost, what are you prepared for, not discussing 9/11.

The scope on 9/11 were all unusually in secondary mode. It takes more work to track the primary target, ask our experts who worked the scopes. It is harder to track the primary targets, that is why we have code and transponders. The target now has lost its altitude unless the system is set up to calculate the attitude but I think they had to do that after 9/11 with the tape.

The terrorist should have squawk the hijack code, and then ATC would think they were going back to land! This would have delayed the NORAD response. But no hijacked code and turning off the transponder made every think they crashed until they were found on primary, and the changing code made it seem even more suspicious. But then I am just and old pilot. What makes you ask so many questions, you are beginning to sound like the fact less Dylan Avery, or JDX.

Go ahead try to set the hijack code as your throat is cut.
 
I'm not moving anything it's all part of the same thing. What I've been saying all along is if the transponders were turned off to impede identification maybe they did just that and what was really tracked was a different aircraft. If they have proof that they don't need the transponder then where is it and why have it in the first place and why turn it off?



It's in relation to the transponder and how they seemed to go off or were changed exactly at the time the pilot should have switched to hijack mode. Four times.

Assume for the moment that the transponders had been left on. Since a pilot can set the transponder to identify as any of the 4096 codes, what would that prove? Transponders are not unique identifiers of an aircraft. Many, many aircraft are squawking 1200 even as I type this.
If, on the other hand, you go back through a tape and correlate skin-tracking data with the transponder data recorded, then continue to track that target using only skin-tracking after the transponder is disabled, then it's a unique identifier in the sense that the aircraft that launched as Flight xx was the same aircraft that crashed.
 
Show me where it's claimed they could and did do that. Also if it's true then why did the hijackers bother to turn them off?

Does this guy not know what he's talking about? Compared to you that is.

Commander Ted Muga, BS CE, U.S. Navy (ret) – Retired Pan-Am commercial airline pilot. Aircraft flown: Boeing 707 and 727. Retired Civil Engineer. Retired Naval aviator. Aircraft flown: Grumman E-1 Tracer and E-2 Hawkeye.

"And also in all four planes, if you remember, none of the planes ever switched on their transponder to the hijack code. There's a very, very simple code that you put in if you suspect that your plane is being hijacked. It takes literally just a split-second for you to put your hand down on the center console and flip it over. And not one of the four planes ever transponded a hijack code, which is most, most unusual. ..."



"Spilt-second" is quite an exaggeration. I also don't know what he means by "flipping it over" - it's not a TV remote. There is no "hijack" channel that can be selected by the push of a button.

There are four knobs, two outer knobs and two inner knobs, and in most cases all four knobs would have to be adjusted to broadcast the hijack code. Let's say the transponder was set at 2454. The left outer knob would have to rotated counter-clockwise for 3 "clicks"; the left inner, clockwise 3 clicks; the right outer clockwise 3 clicks; and the right inner counter-clockwise(or clockwise) 4 clicks....

(767 ATC/Transponder panel photo for reference)

990246db6e3522d68.jpg



If you think that can be done in a "split second" without any errors or fumbling around, when there are knife wielding maniacs hell bent on slitting your throat, well I don't know what else there is to say. Also, you should understand that setting the ATC panel to 7700 wouldn't exactly be the highest thing on the pilot's priority list in the event of a violent takeover attempt.
 
Last edited:
I'm asking how the four planes that were lost were accounted for with the transponder off on three and code changed on the forth?

They were accounted for by the wreckage and passengers being identified. Also, you get 4 flights missing and 4 crashes. not hard to figure out.
 
Zen, Zen, Zen,


This is one of those threads that make you have to decide just how much you want to hold on to your fantasy...
 
Assume for the moment that the transponders had been left on. Since a pilot can set the transponder to identify as any of the 4096 codes, what would that prove? Transponders are not unique identifiers of an aircraft. Many, many aircraft are squawking 1200 even as I type this.
If, on the other hand, you go back through a tape and correlate skin-tracking data with the transponder data recorded, then continue to track that target using only skin-tracking after the transponder is disabled, then it's a unique identifier in the sense that the aircraft that launched as Flight xx was the same aircraft that crashed.

Where's it claimed they went back through a tape and correlated skin-tracking data with the transponder data recorded?

besides...

http://www.911timeline.net/

The controllers still have a skin paint, or passive echo from the airframe, but the blip now shows up on all consoles for that sector, not just the original one that was handling the altitude range of the flight. If that same flight loses communication with the controllers as well, the controller workload takes another giant step upward. Keep in mind that this is in an area that is normally stretched to the breaking point with controller overload. This flight is now a hazard to air navigation, and the controllers primary function of separating the planes is in jeopardy.
 
"Spilt-second" is quite an exaggeration. I also don't know what he means by "flipping it over" - it's not a TV remote. There is no "hijack" channel that can be selected by the push of a button.

There are four knobs, two outer knobs and two inner knobs, and in most cases all four knobs would have to be adjusted to broadcast the hijack code. Let's say the transponder was set at 2454. The left outer knob would have to rotated counter-clockwise for 3 "clicks"; the left inner, clockwise 3 clicks; the right outer clockwise 3 clicks; and the right inner counter-clockwise(or clockwise) 4 clicks....

(767 ATC/Transponder panel photo for reference)

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/990246db6e3522d68.jpg[/qimg]

Well that's well thought out and convenient huh? Does he also have to dance an Irish jig and sing the star-spangled banner?

If you think that can be done in a "split second" without any errors or fumbling around, when there are knife wielding maniacs hell bent on slitting your throat, well I don't know what else there is to say. Also, you should understand that setting the ATC panel to 7700 wouldn't exactly be the highest thing on the pilot's priority list in the event of a violent takeover attempt.


Ok so you don't think he knows what he's talking about. This is ridiculous. Let me ask you something how do people usually hijack planes do they just politely ask for the pilot to not make any sudden moves? Again is this just one more thing that no one ever imagined?

'Oh you want to hijack the plane? Sure hold on a second I just need to..."
 
Did it happen four times in an hour?
What relevance does that have? Each hijacking was a separate event in a separate aircraft. In the FedEx case, it was one man attacking a three-man flight crew, and in spite of those odds the crew were still not able to communicate what had happened until minutes afterwards. What do you think the chances are of a flight deck crew getting off a warning on 9/11 when it was two or three attackers against two pilots?

Military folks will tell you that surprise can be a very useful tactic in overcoming your enemies.
 
Last edited:
Difference between secondary and primary radar:

Viewing this web page vs Viewing the source code.
 
What relevance does that have? Each hijacking was a separate event in a separate aircraft. In the FedEx case, it was one man attacking a three-man flight crew, and in spite of those odds the crew were still not able to communicate what had happened until minutes afterwards. What do you think the chances are of a flight deck crew getting off a warning on 9/11 when it was two or three attackers against two pilots?

Military folks will tell you that surprise can be a very useful tactic in overcoming your enemies.
What are the chances?

http://www.911timeline.net/

53) 9:00 a.m.: United Airlines systems operations transmitted a system wide message, warning its pilots of a potential "cockpit intrusion". United Airlines Flight 93, flying over Pennsylvania replies "Confirmed".

65) 9:10 a.m. to 9:20 a.m.: United Airlines Flight 93 was hijacked.
 
Difference between secondary and primary radar:

Viewing this web page vs Viewing the source code.
Right and they had trouble on 9-11. In fact when flight 77 made the crazy turn the air-traffic controllers assumed it was a military plane.

http://www.flatplanet.net/truth911/oldsite/2020_011024_atc_feature.html

"The speed, the maneuverability, the way that he turned, we all thought in the radar room, all of us experienced air traffic controllers, that that was a military plane," says O'Brien. "You don't fly a 757 in that manner. It's unsafe."

"And it went six, five, four. And I had it in my mouth to say, three, and all of a sudden the plane turned away. In the room, it was almost a sense of relief. This must be a fighter. This must be one of our guys sent in, scrambled to patrol our capital, and to protect our president, and we sat back in our chairs and breathed for just a second," says O'Brien.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom