UCLA Suspends Body-Donor Program After Alleged Abuses
Medical school's actions follow accusations that cadavers have been sold illegally to outsiders.
March 10, 2004|Charles Ornstein and Alan Zarembo | Times Staff Writers
The UCLA medical school announced Tuesday that it would indefinitely suspend, and perhaps permanently close, its body-donor program in response to a burgeoning scandal over the allegedly illegal sale of hundreds of cadavers.
The decision by top medical school and university administrators came amid a court hearing in which lawyers representing relatives of cadaver donors sought to force the closing of the program, arguing that it was in such disarray it could not function properly.
UCLA had contended, both in court papers and at a news conference Monday, that closing the program, the oldest in the nation, would impair medical education and research.
But officials abandoned that position as disclosures mounted about the scope of the scandal.
"Partly because it's gotten so much widespread negative press, it seemed like it maybe made better sense" to suspend the program than operate it under a cloud, said Dr. Alan G. Robinson, UCLA's associate vice chancellor for medical sciences.
In other developments Tuesday, a major pharmaceutical company, Johnson & Johnson, acknowledged that a subsidiary had bought body parts from UCLA cadavers through a middleman, Ernest V. Nelson, who was arrested over the weekend on suspicion of receiving stolen property.
The subsidiary, Mitek, "did not knowingly receive samples that may have been obtained in an inappropriate way," Johnson & Johnson said in a written statement. "We are sensitive to the need that all samples are appropriately and properly obtained, stored and shipped."
Lawyers for the families of cadaver donors on Tuesday filed suit against Johnson & Johnson, alleging that the company should take responsibility for "accepting stolen parts."
Medical school officials said they wouldn't decide whether to reopen the willed-body program until they received suggestions from former Gov. George Deukmejian, who has agreed to oversee an administrative investigation and suggest reforms.
In the meantime, bodies that had been scheduled to go to UCLA were being sent to UC Irvine, which itself was embroiled in a scandal involving stolen body parts in 1999. At that time, the director was fired after allegedly selling six spines to a Phoenix research company for $5,000. Campus officials there say their program now runs well and they keep better track of bodies.
Phone calls to the UCLA program to report a death were being transferred to UC Irvine, said Michael Godsey, director of UC Irvine's program. That campus received its first UCLA cadaver Tuesday, but Godsey said UC Irvine would not use the UCLA cadavers unless the families give them permission.
"The only services we're providing is a place for the bodies to be taken and held in storage until the use can be determined," Godsey said.
At UCLA, the bodies in the refrigerator will remain there under lock and key, officials said. They could not say how many there are.