Merged David Chandler (ae911) sez "WTC7 was in free fall part of the time"

If asked to nominate something that needs investigation, this would be it.
As an ex-Ham and electrical engineer, I appreciate the problems and well before 9/11/2001, I knew a retired FDNY communications engineer that
said that people should be in jail for the radio systems the city purchased.


I will agree and disagree. There was quite the stink over the new radios. They sucked. Most went back to the old ones untill the new ones' kinks were worked out.

The problem with WTC 1 & 2, was the signal got lost amungst all the aluminum and steel. Solution?? Repeater. Worked great, unless a big freaking plane crashed into the building, rendering it useless.

Do I think people should be in jail for it?? Nah. Do I personally think someone should have lost their jobs because of it?? ABSOLUTELY!! Those radios are our lifeline. Without them, we're pretty much useless. People can die because of faaulty radios.
 
​
bill smith
Part C nuust be utterly ruined by the meshing of part C and part A. Part A has it's braced giant upstanding core columns anchored in the ground offering their full and constant strain energy against all comers. The falling part C on the other hand, given that the upper and lower core colmns are offset from each other can only offer a sequence of weaker elements such as floor-to-column connections, floor trusses. concrete floors and so on. The constant SE of the upstanding columns will take these ghallenges one at a rime and destroy them over the whole width of the buildng.

Take a floor-to-column connection in part C. It is still attached to a column in part C. It meets the upstanding giant A column. Between the descending piece of core column and the upsatnding column the connection is smoothly stripped of the C column . Then then same happens with the next component/element in line etc etc.

While C may damge A significantly it will be clear that A damages C far more. And C is much smaller than A and can afford the attrition less. A destroys C and collapse is arrested.


(Instructions in back of nano-thermate can)

Notes Apply What Is Proper Way To Put Material:

Your columns are focal point of building. Be sure that columns painting meshing techniques and choice of most flattering to your surreptitiouse purpose when reinstaling.

With color C create the illusion new shapes and discrete sizes. Always mind light colors highlight errors
and dark colors enter in the suspicious of authorities especialy paint not dry to touching.

Recede over when approached by questioners so as to disguise the plaster of reapplication in time for
drying in two coat . It's Aluminum powder color A column shadows be convenient do not hurry when surprised by owner of office says "Hey what you doing in my office" reply with singles or coordinated duos, or quads. A
tested reply assurance OK and go on.

Try to find far away columns that are hily misterious. Simply put, you want material you see in
container to not see after aplycation. When aplying material sweep the stroke over entire area from
illusion edged to neck widow. This sweep will be base application first slowly and is to complete job
reduce strain energy tender forearms. It will prevent creasing etc etc.

After plaster work dry applying base coat, apply second wait dry. Remember plaster removal first steel
paint on upper parts tardy not other way. Its part that most error apply. No.

Third coat be added. Use a deep, dark depth. Apply this along the line, and at the outer drawers
emphasizing the crease of the corner at steel lips. Arrest attrition ,this is more defined receptacles.

How you apply final coat help smaller, wider set or closer together. Key is blend well that attention
still away from recent work arrested not "just applied".

Install ceiling tile.

There done.

___________________________________________________________
"`Contrariwise,' continued Tweedledee, `if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic.' "
- Alice in Wonderland
 
Last edited:
(Instructions in back of nano-thermate can)

Notes Apply What Is Proper Way To Put Material:

Your columns are focal point of building. Be sure that columns painting meshing techniques and choice of most flattering to your surreptitiouse purpose when reinstaling.

With color C create the illusion new shapes and discrete sizes. Always mind light colors highlight errors
and dark colors enter in the suspicious of authorities especialy paint not dry to touching.

Recede over when approached by questioners so as to disguise the plaster of reapplication in time for
drying in two coat . It's Aluminum powder color A column shadows be convenient do not hurry when surprised by owner of office says "Hey what you doing in my office" reply with singles or coordinated duos, or quads. A
tested reply assurance OK and go on.

Try to find far away columns that are hily misterious. Simply put, you want material you see in
container to not see after aplycation. When aplying material sweep the stroke over entire area from
illusion edged to neck widow. This sweep will be base application first slowly and is to complete job
reduce strain energy tender forearms. It will prevent creasing etc etc.

After plaster work dry applying base coat, apply second wait dry. Remember plaster removal first steel
paint on upper parts tardy not other way. Its part that most error apply. No.

Third coat be added. Use a deep, dark depth. Apply this along the line, and at the outer drawers
emphasizing the crease of the corner at steel lips. Arrest attrition ,this is more defined receptacles.

How you apply final coat help smaller, wider set or closer together. Key is blend well that attention
still away from recent work arrested not "just applied".

Install ceiling tile.

There done.

___________________________________________________________
"`Contrariwise,' continued Tweedledee, `if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic.' "
- Alice in Wonderland

Basque,

Cripes, we barely got sooper-dooper nanothermite out of R&D, and it's ALREADY been out-sourced to China...?!!

I hope the manufacturing processes have better quality control than their tech writers.
:)

Tom
 
Last edited:
If asked to nominate something that needs investigation, this would be it.
As an ex-Ham and electrical engineer, I appreciate the problems and well before 9/11/2001, I knew a retired FDNY communications engineer that
said that people should be in jail for the radio systems the city purchased.

Another EE?

Cool...I wasn't sure how many of us there were on this forum...I seem to be surrounded by physicists and MEs...

;)
 
bumpin' an old thread.

BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?
 
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

It's in the final NIST report on WTC 7. It's near the end, where they "admit" the free fall happened. The clarification is pretty simple: roughly 8 stories failed at roughly the same time. The upper part of the building fell those 8 stories before encountering any real resistance.
 
Another EE?

Cool...I wasn't sure how many of us there were on this forum...I seem to be surrounded by physicists and MEs...

;)

EE for the sake of understanding 9/11. I slipped into the computer side and never used the EE education. The school required "Theoretical mechanics 101" (essentially finite element analysis done with a slide rule) which taught me some concepts that I never used until Truthers that knew even less started saying stupid things about the collapse of WTC.
 
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?


The outer frame of wtc7 was attached to the inner structures which began falling first (as demonstrated by the initial motion of the penthouse). By the time the outer walls began falling, they were being accelerated not only by their own weight, but also by momentum transfer (via torque and tension through linkages) from internal structures that were already falling. All the forces involved, essentially weight + transferred dynamic forces - resistance, netted out to approximately mg for a brief period of time.

As an illustration of the general principle, imagine parking two similar cars next to each other on the edge of a cliff. Connect the two cars by 100 meters of 30mm steel cable. Roll one car off the cliff. Once that car clears the cliff it will accelerate at about g ("free fall speed"). But when the cable tightens, the second car will accelerate faster than g at first, for a brief period. It's easy for a falling object to accelerate faster than g if it's attached to something else that started falling first.

NIST's justification is in a way far simpler (though far more complex to actually perform, and far more authoritative): they modeled the entire collapse (which really just means, they did the calculations for what would happen to each piece of the building moment by moment throughout the event based on the laws of physics) and that's what the model shows happening.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

Or, to be precise, a PORTION of the building (i.e., the north & west outer walls) fell:

1. for a short period (~1.75 sec) at a slow, constant velocity,
2. for a short period (~2.25 sec) at (NEAR*) free fall acceleration,
3. for the next visible period (~2 sec) at lower acceleration.

In other words, pretty much as you'd expect from a tall, thin structure that buckles down low.

*unfortunately, NIST blew it & omitted this adjective.

The WHOLE building took a lot longer to fall, of course. Because it met resistance while it fell. Hard (perhaps impossible) to tell how fast the interior of the building took to fall vertically at any given point. But the collapse progressed at a rather leisurely pace horizontally thru the building.

Tom
 
EE for the sake of understanding 9/11. I slipped into the computer side and never used the EE education. The school required "Theoretical mechanics 101" (essentially finite element analysis done with a slide rule) which taught me some concepts that I never used until Truthers that knew even less started saying stupid things about the collapse of WTC.

Thats cool....

There are many aspects and topics that I covered in school that I do not use on a daily basis....and some that I have never (since school) used....

Still...nice to know there are others lurking on JREF :)

As for the truthers knowing less....well yeah...that seems to be a pattern with them...

They constantly talk about stuff they don't understand and haven't researched, which is why they are almost always wrong about every single thing they say....
 
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

Oh don't worry about JS.

He is just a troll. He has had this explained to him many times in many different places, by many different folks.

Still doesn't have a clue.
 
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

[I believe what you say, TL. Just a little experiment.]

JS,

Tell ya what. Why don't you TRY to write, in your own words, what you think that NIST DID say about the "near free fall".

Not what you believe or don't believe. Just try to give an accurate rendition of what NIST concluded. As such, it'll require no attack or defense of your own.

Your grade will not be based on structural engineering.
It'll be based solely on reading comprehension.

If you choose to do this, please don't just cut & paste.
If you're not willing to put out this small effort, you've got a bit of a nerve asking others to do so for you. (Especially if, as TL says, others have already done so in the past.)

Tom

PS. "BSCE". Civil?

"EI"?
 
Last edited:
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

Well I think they said it was a three-stage freefall. Something like that anyway . 'Plummet, plunge, and GONE' if you ask me... lol
 
It amazes me that the thought of the structure simply having no integrity left escapes the thought of these people. But I guess I'm used to it now :\

'Now we find out that WTC7 was designed and constructed with a very unusual technique to insure complete structural integrity even if whole floors were removed. It was one of the most structurally redundant buildings ever built in the history of steel structures.'
http://tyrannyalert.com/wtc7solution.htm The Strength of WTC7
 
Is it true that the reason that NIST is refusing to release the data and assumptions that they used to construct their computer model of the collapse of WTC7 is because 'it would endanger the pubic safety'

What could they mean ?
 
Article in Today's Washington Post. Do you think that maybe they are piquing people's curiousity just a LEETLE too much ?

Are they hindering the Truth Movement or helping it ?

I think they are jumping ship boys, After all if they want to survive they better be seen to serve the public interest wouldn't you say ?

Monday, March 8, 2010
'' YUKIHISA FUJITA is an influential member of the ruling Democratic Party of Japan. As chief of the DPJ's international department and head of the Research Committee on Foreign Affairs in the upper house of Japan's parliament, to which he was elected in 2007, he is a Brahmin in the foreign policy establishment of Washington's most important East Asian ally. He also seems to think that America's rendering of the events of Sept. 11, 2001, is a gigantic hoax.

Mr. Fujita's ideas about the attack on the World Trade Center, which he shared with us in a recent interview, are too bizarre, half-baked and intellectually bogus to merit serious discussion. He questions whether it was really the work of terrorists; suggests that shadowy forces with advance knowledge of the plot played the stock market to profit from it; peddles the fantastic idea that eight of the 19 hijackers are alive and well; and hints that controlled demolition rather than fire or debris may be a more likely explanation for at least the collapse of the building at 7 World Trade Center, which was adjacent to the twin towers.''

Read more...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dy.../03/07/AR2010030702354.html?hpid=opinionsbox1
 
Last edited:
Article in Today's Washington Post. Do you think that maybe they are piquing people's curiousity just a LEETLE too much ?

Are they hindering the Truth Movement or helping it ?

I think they are jumping ship boys, After all ifthey want to survive they better be seen to serve the public interest wouldn't you say ?

Monday, March 8, 2010
'' YUKIHISA FUJITA is an influential member of the ruling Democratic Party of Japan. As chief of the DPJ's international department and head of the Research Committee on Foreign Affairs in the upper house of Japan's parliament, to which he was elected in 2007, he is a Brahmin in the foreign policy establishment of Washington's most important East Asian ally. He also seems to think that America's rendering of the events of Sept. 11, 2001, is a gigantic hoax.

Mr. Fujita's ideas about the attack on the World Trade Center, which he shared with us in a recent interview, are too bizarre, half-baked and intellectually bogus to merit serious discussion. He questions whether it was really the work of terrorists; suggests that shadowy forces with advance knowledge of the plot played the stock market to profit from it; peddles the fantastic idea that eight of the 19 hijackers are alive and well; and hints that controlled demolition rather than fire or debris may be a more likely explanation for at least the collapse of the building at 7 World Trade Center, which was adjacent to the twin towers.''

Read more...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dy.../03/07/AR2010030702354.html?hpid=opinionsbox1

I mean think about it....Just yesterday Iran accused America of carrying out 9/11, Now a top Japanese minister. President Mahatir of Malaysia did just a week or two ago. Minister Michael Meecher in England accuses America, Andreas von Bulow the German Defence minister accuses America, Hugo Chavez of Venezuela accuses America, That Italian minister accuses America...I'm sure I can find more if I bother looking..

Should somebody email the Washington Post and inform them of this ?

You are as guilty as sin. The chickens arre coming home to roost.
 
I mean think about it....Just yesterday Iran accused America of carrying out 9/11, Now a top Japanese minister. President Mahatir of Malaysia did just a week or two ago. Minister Michael Meecher in England accuses America, Andreas von Bulow the German Defence minister accuses America, Hugo Chavez of Venezuela accuses America, That Italian minister accuses America...I'm sure I can find more if I bother looking..

Should somebody email the Washington Post and inform them of this ?

You are as guilty as sin. The chickens arre coming home to roost.

Yep...the world is full of nuts. What you fail to understand, Bill, is that it doesn't matter how many people believe the nonsense...it's a matter of evidence. The entire world could think that 9/11 was an inside jobby-job...the facts and evidence point to it not being.
 
BSCE, EI here

I think the key thing about NIST admitting free fall is that they don't say anything about the ramifications of free fall. They just say it happened and thats about it. Can anybody link to their justification of free fall?

If anyone is unable to deal with the ramifications of freefall, it's the twoofers.

The total collapse time for WTC7 was sixteen seconds, minimum (and that is just from the first visible exterior signs, the full collapse was likely significantly longer). What the 2.25 seconds of freefall means is that to fill up the rest of the sixteen seconds, the remainder of the collapse proceeded at a much slower pace.

Which blows the infamous twoofer talking point completely out of reality.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom