Merged David Chandler (ae911) sez "WTC7 was in free fall part of the time"

I'd invite Bill to NYC with me this year, even pay for his trip out of my OWN pocket, just to see him TRY to go to 10 House and tell those guys that 9/11 was their fault. He wouldn't have the guts. I would post that on YouTube in SECONDS.

But, of course, he wouldn't take me up on that offer. He is a coward.

Well, you have to make sure to take him to the right firehouses. You know, the ones that have the "bad elements". To bill's credit, he only believes it was a "few dozen" members of the FDNY who were in on it, and not the whole department. However, he doesn't specify who those few dozen are, or how they are dispersed among the ranks.

Are there any evil firehouses in New York? Because that might be a good place to start looking.
 
One further note regarding cartioid microphones. To completely debunk Chandler's sloppy and casual dismissal of their ability to pick up 120+ db explosions from 2 blocks away....

A cartioid pattern is shaped like a heart. The most sensitive zone is directly in front (on axis) of the mic, and it gently slopes off as you get off-axis. It doesn't disappear!

Further, in the canyon-like confines of NYC streets, you have large, highly reflective surfaces of glass and metal. These act very efficiently to reverberate sound. A microphone placed off-axis to WTC 7 and any sounds (including explosions, if there had been any) would have easily, without question, picked up either some direct sound or plenty of reverberation off said buildings.

There is zero possibility that a very loud, 120+ report wouldn't have been picked up. It couldn't happen.

Chandler's dismissal fails miserably from a basic scientific viewpoint. But then, when was the last time he consulted with an audio expert? (like me, for example)...crickets.
 
One further note regarding cartioid microphones. To completely debunk Chandler's sloppy and casual dismissal of their ability to pick up 120+ db explosions from 2 blocks away....

The 1993 bombing was several floors below street-level. When it went off, it was heard all over the plaza, possibly 24 acres including side streets, and heard by most occupants of the WTC buildings on upper floors.

Any bomb on any upper floor would be heard by everyone in the street unobstructed by the layers of structural concrete that masked the 1993 bomb. Since that bomb (equal to about 1,000 pounds of TNT) did no immediate structural damage, any bomb(s) on 9/11 would have to be even larger.

IMO something as small as a cherry bomb set off in the middle of the WTC plaza would have been heard over all 16 acres due to all the hard reflective walls.
 
TL,

Howdy. Nice to meet ya.

I mean, when I teach research methods and experimental design, I often tell my students that when you form a hypothesis, you then need to ELIMINATE all possible confounds to their research question.

simple science. But thank you for bringing up the eyewitnesses and debunking fully 1/2 of the truth movement. Because eyewitnesses + EVIDENCE= ironclad case.

Where do you teach. Logic? Science?

BTW, I wouldn't bother much with bill. There is a fundamental, infuriating problem when you are arguing, discussing honestly, but the other person is not.

To bill, it's just a game. If he could somehow figure out how to make the proposition: "2 + 3 = 17" favor the "9/11 inside job", he would.

[What am I saying "... IF he could..." He does. The NYC We Are Change group has had an average of about 7 attendees per meeting for the last year. To bill, "7 attendees + the same 7 + the same 7 + ... = 80% of the population of NYC are truthers".]

So, have fun, speak your mind. But don't expect any thoughtful response.

Actaully Tfk, what most annoyed me about David Chandlers little visit is when he replies to your very indepth smackdown.

he starts off by telling YOU to go and get the NIST DRAFT out of the trash and to read it, instead of saying "Oops, i am using the DRAFT report, I'll look at the FINAL report, thanks."

And then his attempts to be snarky, but notice that on your GRADING of his efforts, he doesn't counter anything before #8... I guess he fully agrees with 1-7 or he just can't reply because he is out of his depth.

Of course, I also love how he completely ignored the post about the demolitions of a building in Las Vegas which had 36,000 feet of DET cord... (and it was what? 30 stories?) So we should have over 100,000 feet of det cord... 20 miles of the stuff in EACH tower....

Yeah, Chandler's a different case altogether.

I am, by nature, positively inclined to teachers. Especially high school science teachers. They do an incredibly important job. It seems clear that he's a thinking human being, on several levels.

And yet...

As you say, I was very disappointed that he addressed none of the technical aspects of what I said to him. Especially the parts that related to his techniques.

And it appears from his comments that he has no idea what an "error analysis" really is in experimental methods. When I asked him about that, he pointed to the standard deviation on his linear regression curve that PTK calculated for him.

Anyway, it is clear that he's been beat about the head & shoulders for what he's gone thru. It also is clear to me that he believes his nonsense. NOBODY would put themselves thru that if they did not. I do feel a bit sorry for him. But DAMN, I wish he'd learn to curb is baseless accusations. He seems sensitive enough about getting criticism. You'd think the old empathy would kick in & he'd moderate his own spraying it around...

I really, really do hope that he is not passing on his anti-gov't paranoia to his students. But perhaps this won't matter all that much. I'm sure that I had some wacky teachers when I was in school, and I don't remember anyone of my friends coming out torqued up because of it...

Anyway, welcome to the fray.

Tom
 
Daave, you know, you are absolutely correct. You know what I would LOVE to do. Have Bill, or any of the other "Truthers" go on camera implicating FDNY of killing thir own. I would LOVE to take that video to FDNY when I go this year, and show them the video tape, and ask their thoughts on this. I would LOVE to get THEIR reactions on video. It would be priceless. But, I don't think it would bode well. I would rather not dredge up painfull memories of my friends. Its just not cool.
 
One further note regarding cartioid microphones. To completely debunk Chandler's sloppy and casual dismissal of their ability to pick up 120+ db explosions from 2 blocks away....

A cartioid pattern is shaped like a heart. The most sensitive zone is directly in front (on axis) of the mic, and it gently slopes off as you get off-axis. It doesn't disappear!

Further, in the canyon-like confines of NYC streets, you have large, highly reflective surfaces of glass and metal. These act very efficiently to reverberate sound. A microphone placed off-axis to WTC 7 and any sounds (including explosions, if there had been any) would have easily, without question, picked up either some direct sound or plenty of reverberation off said buildings.

There is zero possibility that a very loud, 120+ report wouldn't have been picked up. It couldn't happen.

Chandler's dismissal fails miserably from a basic scientific viewpoint. But then, when was the last time he consulted with an audio expert? (like me, for example)...crickets.

Yeah I was going to comment about directional microphones and also just microphones/audio electronics in general since I have some experience dealing with such systems....but I figured that it would do zero good anyway and so I refrained.

I'm glad someone took it up though.
 
That's all for now. I don't have this kind of time very often. A rapid fire avalanche of arguments is not the ideal environment for rational thought. It's been mixed, which is better than I expected on this forum.
--David Chandler
Rational thought; you believe in the nut case theory that explosives were used to bring down WTC 1, 2, and 7 and you can't define how, or who did it. That is not rational thought it is pure delusion based on failed opinions.

The overwhelming evidence proves no blast damage, no sounds of explosives, and no visual blast effects. The primary mover in CD is gravity. The major energy source in controlled demolition is gravity not explosives. On 911 and during inspection of the steel, there were zero explosive effects and zero thermite and this is why the failed conclusions you share with other conspiracy minded people with failed ideas on 911 have not earned a Pulitzer Prize after 7 years and 10 months. Thank goodness the Passengers of Flight 93 could figure out 911 in minutes unlike you and others who support lies you manufacture with your imaginations. Heroes who understand 911 and you still have zero evidence.

Present your evidence for explosives. Where is your overwhelming evidence? You said you have it, or it exists, where did you misplace it? You made the claim present it.

You argue using physics behind your physics teacher facade and ignore gravity, fire, impacts equal to 1300 and 2093 pounds of TNT and more! More impact energy from two jet impacts than most controlled demolitions use in RDX/TNT to bring down building as the impacts alone had more energy than needed to bring down a building properly prepared for months in controlled demolition. Don't be fooled by a physics high school teacher who has failed conclusion and ignore reality.

WTC7 burned uncontrolled without firefighting efforts, no water, and you think it should stand. Buildings fall in fires not fought. Buildings are still destroyed by fire in fires fought. Show us with physics why the beam can't expand. Oops, it was proved the beam can expand and fail. You can't refute science without using it and showing your work. So you ignore the work done by NIST, wave your hands and then say looking at all the massive work you have done and say explosives did it; blast free, silent explosives blew up the WTC but looked like a gravity collapse with no explosives. The funny part of your claims of the people who say the WTC7 with their own eyes on 911 not you come lately flat earth like CTers, not one thinks the WTC7 or 1 and 2 were blown up. The truth is if explosives had been used on 911 we would have found the bad guys in a couple of days and like Tim McVeigh (McVeigh in custody the same day) they would be executed and gone by now. That is reality, you are a conspiracy theorist like those on JFK, Bigfoot, UFOs, flat earth, and other far out failed ideas.

You try to fool others into believing your failed conclusion or you are totally ignorant you have ignored the facts and evidence on 911.

You have to ignore the largest office fires in history set with 10,000 gallons of jet fuel and with large holes and broken windows to supply air for things to burn quickly and destroy the strength of steel resulting in the failure of the WTC. Mechanisms of failure you have to ignore as you focus on nothing of importance as the WTC building fail due to the fires that day, to include the MASSIVE impacts of planes into the WTC 1, 2 and 7 to 11 times greater than Robertson designed for. An order of magnitude greater impact on the towers and Robertson understand why they fell and calls your ideas nonsense. The PRIMARY expert on the WTC towers calls your efforts nonsense. And you ignore that and move on with your failed consolations. You ignore reality and can't challenge Robertson who built the WTC towers, who designed the towers structure, you can't refute his expert knowledge which says your ideas of explosives are nonsense. Reality is your ideas are nonsense and to think you can debate a lie, your conclusions, your opinion based on nothing, is nonsense.

I love the physics of sound you ignore, and the visual absence of blast! You lost this debate on 911 and now your idea is clearly in the flat earth category of nut case conclusions.

Why do 911 CTers fail to grasp gravity and reality? What do you guys do beside ignore thousands of facts and all the reality based evidence? You make up lies based on your failed opinions. It looked like, it sounded like is your tool; is your science simile? The product is failed opinion.
 
I'ts not an area I usually explore but you must admit that there are HUNDREDS of reports of explosions. I can probably find the videos if you need them. Yet those explosions do not appear for the most part on the sudio tracks of the videos.

Very strange you say ? It must hve been some other noise. But where are the noises that the people MISTOOK for explosions then ? They are not there on tape either despite many hundreds of eyewitness reports. Could there have been something about the audio ? Or could the hundreds of eyewitnesses not have heard anything at all ?


What would be the point of reminding you for the thousandth time that things blow up in office fires? I notice that other posters are experiencing the same problems with you that bedevil me. You derive more enjoyment from being smacked around than other people derive from doing the smacking. I simply don't get it.
Everyone here wonders, what doesn't he get? People heard explosions. They reported that they heard explosions. They really did hear explosions. BUT-- they heard RANDOM EXPLOSIONS, things blowing up in the fires. NOBODY HEARD THE SIMULTANEOUS SERIES OF COORDINATED BLASTS CHARACTERISTIC OF A CONTROLLED DEMOLITION--NOBODY.
If a person heard a copier machine or a computer blowing up, that doesn't lend any support to your myth.
 
Tfk (tom)

I live and work in Ras Al Khaimah in the UAE. I teach at a local university. I have taught math, computer science, research methods, and experimental design.

That is the benefits of living and working abroad, it allows you to teach a WHOLE boat load of classes (some of which you may not be "fully" qualified for, but you are there and your degrees are "close enough for government work.")

I took 3 years of engineering courses at Northern Arizona University, but changed my degree when I realized 2 years in that I didn't have the heart or passion for it (and my wife was complaining it was a 5 year degree at 18 credit hours a semester).

The thing that changed my perspective was when one of my fellow engineering students leaned over to me one day and said "C's get degrees man... be happy."

How could I be happy that 30% of what I was doing in class was WRONG? It has made me very concerned every time I have gone across a bridge, driven in a car, or flown on a plane... "what if this was designed by one of those C's get degrees engineers" :)

I will say thank you for your very indepth analysis of the structural engineering behind the collapse. I have read your responses to most of the quack jobs and have been learning MUCH more about the engineering than I ever knew (even with my 3 years of courses).
 
The 1993 bombing was several floors below street-level. When it went off, it was heard all over the plaza, possibly 24 acres including side streets, and heard by most occupants of the WTC buildings on upper floors.

Any bomb on any upper floor would be heard by everyone in the street unobstructed by the layers of structural concrete that masked the 1993 bomb. Since that bomb (equal to about 1,000 pounds of TNT) did no immediate structural damage, any bomb(s) on 9/11 would have to be even larger.

IMO something as small as a cherry bomb set off in the middle of the WTC plaza would have been heard over all 16 acres due to all the hard reflective walls.

Al,

Do you have links to any articles that mention the sound heard by people in '93. That is a great piece of incontrovertible (yeah, right...??) evidence.

Tom
 
I lost the link but it was provided by Gravy, I think, in response to some query I made. When I get a chance I'll search my posts and see if I can find it. It was a post-bombing study that polled people to see who heard it.
 
I am fascinated by the lack of sounds argument used by NIST as a rationale to not even look at other evidence of explosives. There is abundant testimony to loud sounds. There is a loud blast sound captured on at least one video (with the fire fighters around a pay phone). There is evidence of loud blasts when people being interviewed in the street, along with the interviewer, flinch and turn toward the buildings even though the sounds are not captured on the highly directional microphones being used in the interviews. A number of clips run with alternate sound tracks. It is common practice to strip the sound and do voice-overs or other manipulation. In short, the sound data is a very spotty, unreliable form of evidence. It certainly doesn't justify refusing to look at physical evidence.

I first heard the lack of sounds rationale about a month prior to the release of the August WTC7 report. (If anyone can document an earlier discussion of it, please bring it to my attention.) The argument seemed to come out of nowhere and came with such vehemence (in response to one of my videos) that it caught my attention. When this turned out to be the lynchpin of the WTC7 report, I suspected a connection.

Bottom line, the sounds argument is very weak.

--David Chandler


1. Video of South Tower collapse from inside the North Tower lobby 100 feet away. No explosives sounds .
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NzSxSUb0Kk

2. Inside North Tower when South tower collapses 100 feet away. No explosives sounds.
From the “Miracle Survivors”
http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/sept11/2003/n_9189/
Sixteen people survived inside the collapse of the World Trade Center, and they were all in Stairwell B of the North Tower, in the center of the building. The survivors were spread out between floors 22 and 1. A step or two slower meant death, but so, too, did a step or two faster. Captain Jay Jonas and five of his firefighters from Ladder Six, based in Chinatown, had been on the 27th floor of the North Tower when they heard a rumble, felt the staircase sway, watched as the lights flickered off and on. A captain from another company let Jonas know the cause of the disturbance: The South Tower had just collapsed.

3. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds. The wind is the overpressure from the pancaking floors that toppled the exterior columns hundreds of feet.
… That was when the wind started, even before the noise. “No one realizes about the wind,” says Komorowski. The building was pancaking down from the top and, in the process, blasting air down the stairwell. The wind lifted Komorowski off his feet. “I was taking a staircase at a time,” he says, “It was a combination of me running and getting blown down.” Lim says Komorowski flew over him. Eight seconds later—that’s how long it took the building to come down—Komorowski landed three floors lower, in standing position, buried to his knees in pulverized Sheetrock and cement.
… On stairwell B, after the noise of collapse—one fireman said he heard each floor come down, like a drum roll—the narrow space was quiet and almost completely dark.

4. Inside North Tower stairwell B when South tower collapses 100 feet away. No explosives sounds.
From “The Mirace of Company Ladder 6
http://911research.wtc7.net/cache/wtc/analysis/theories/acfd_miraclecompany_6.htm
… While paused in the stairwell for another moment’s rest, something they never thought could happen, did.
John Jonas: “We heard that rumble that nobody’s ever heard before — a 110-story building coming down. And there was a fellow on the 27th floor, another captain, and I looked at him, and I said, ‘Is that what I thought it was?’ He says, ‘Yeah.’ He says, ‘The other tower just collapsed.’

5. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds. The wind is the overpressure from the pancaking floors that toppled the exterior columns hundreds of feet.
Billy Butler: “And that’s when everything hit.”
Stone Phillips: “And when you say, that’s when everything hit. What happened?”
Richie Picciotto: “The noise started again.”
Mike Meldrum: “You heard the rumble. You could feel the rumble.”
Their tower was now disintegrating
. Hundreds of thousands of tons of cement, steel, and glass began to melt away. And Ladder 6 was still in the stairwell.
Matt Komorowski: “The first thing I really felt was the incredible rush of air at my back. And maybe I felt it before everybody else, because I was the last guy.”
Stone Phillips: “Like a gust of wind, behind you.”
Matt Komorowski: “Gust of wind. Wind tunnel. It was the most incredible push at your back, that you can feel.”
Stone Phillips: “A rumbling sound, this gust of wind? And then what happened?”
Sal D’Agostino: “When I hit the fourth floor landing, I remember the plaque on the door. And that’s when the building started shaking. And you heard the rumble. And I said, ‘Oh, here we go. This is it for me.’”

6. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds.
Mike Meldrum: “I remember covering up, and saying, ‘This is it.’ And, you know, my kids, my wife. You know, my family. And it rumbled and rumbled. And it was pitch black. And then the next thing I know, I remember the dust starting to clear some.

7. AFTER the North tower collapses atop them, Jonas hears explosions, rumblings.(same firefighter as #9)
John Jonas: “And we were hearing explosions. We were hearing rumblings right after this happened. And where I was there was like a little hole in that double sheet rock wall and I could see out and all I could see is twisted I-beams and steel. Like, just a big maze of wreckage. …

8. Inside the North Tower when 2 nd plane hits South tower sounds like an explosion
Sal D’Agostino: “We were in the lobby when the second plane hit. And Captain Jay was at the command post. And you could hear a rumble and an explosion. And from the windows in the World Financial Center across the street, the reflection of the explosion came off of that, came off of those windows.”

9. AFTER the North Tower collapse a loud noise is described by Jonas as an explosion.
… John Jonas: The only time she got flustered in the whole thing was maybe about 20 minutes after the collapse we heard a secondary explosion.

There are many more descriptions like this, but adding to them will not convince those who ignore facts that contradict what they wish to believe.

1. There are no explosives sounds at the time of the collapses of the two towers, only rumblings.
2. Loud noises at other times distant from the collapse are described as explosions.
3. There is no explaining away the unmistakable deafening multiple >160db explosions that would have been heard and recounted by those present inside both towers during the collapses.
4. No explosives sounds at the time of collapse = no explosives.


_________________________________________________________
You can’t reason someone out of something that they were never reasoned into.
 
Last edited:
If this video upsets you guys too much just watch it between 4 minutes and 5 minutes 20. Who can explain the fireman who says don't worry about it'. Why does he seem to know what is happening when the explosion goes off ? Why are the other firemen saying things like 'stand back- it's about to blow up ' And why does the lady say tthat the FD told her hat they were going to ' bring the building down' ?
Why are you surprised when I say that I think bad elements in the FDNY were involved in 9/11 when I have powerful evidence like this at my fingertips ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58h0LjdMry0
 
Last edited:
If this video upsets you guys too much just watch it between 4 minutes and 5 minutes 20. Who can explain the fireman who says don't worry about it'. Why does he seem to know what is happening when the explosion goes off ? Why are the other firemen saying things like 'stand back- it's about to blow up ' And why does the lady say tthat the FD told her hat they were going to ' bring the building down' ?
Why are you surprised when I say that I think bad elements in the FDNY were involved in 9/11 when I have powerful evidence like this at my fingertips ?

You've never read the full text of what these people said.

These are cherry-picked quotes and simile, hyperbole and metaphor and a shortage of other words in the English language for a day like no other for the participants.
 
1. Video of South Tower collapse from inside the North Tower lobby 100 feet away. No explosives sounds .
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NzSxSUb0Kk

2. Inside North Tower when South tower collapses 100 feet away. No explosives sounds.
From the “Miracle Survivors”
http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/sept11/2003/n_9189/
Sixteen people survived inside the collapse of the World Trade Center, and they were all in Stairwell B of the North Tower, in the center of the building. The survivors were spread out between floors 22 and 1. A step or two slower meant death, but so, too, did a step or two faster. Captain Jay Jonas and five of his firefighters from Ladder Six, based in Chinatown, had been on the 27th floor of the North Tower when they heard a rumble, felt the staircase sway, watched as the lights flickered off and on. A captain from another company let Jonas know the cause of the disturbance: The South Tower had just collapsed.

3. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds. The wind is the overpressure from the pancaking floors that toppled the exterior columns hundreds of feet.
… That was when the wind started, even before the noise. “No one realizes about the wind,” says Komorowski. The building was pancaking down from the top and, in the process, blasting air down the stairwell. The wind lifted Komorowski off his feet. “I was taking a staircase at a time,” he says, “It was a combination of me running and getting blown down.” Lim says Komorowski flew over him. Eight seconds later—that’s how long it took the building to come down—Komorowski landed three floors lower, in standing position, buried to his knees in pulverized Sheetrock and cement.
… On stairwell B, after the noise of collapse—one fireman said he heard each floor come down, like a drum roll—the narrow space was quiet and almost completely dark.

4. Inside North Tower stairwell B when South tower collapses 100 feet away. No explosives sounds.
From “The Mirace of Company Ladder 6
http://911research.wtc7.net/cache/wtc/analysis/theories/acfd_miraclecompany_6.htm
… While paused in the stairwell for another moment’s rest, something they never thought could happen, did.
John Jonas: “We heard that rumble that nobody’s ever heard before — a 110-story building coming down. And there was a fellow on the 27th floor, another captain, and I looked at him, and I said, ‘Is that what I thought it was?’ He says, ‘Yeah.’ He says, ‘The other tower just collapsed.’

5. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds. The wind is the overpressure from the pancaking floors that toppled the exterior columns hundreds of feet.
Billy Butler: “And that’s when everything hit.”
Stone Phillips: “And when you say, that’s when everything hit. What happened?”
Richie Picciotto: “The noise started again.”
Mike Meldrum: “You heard the rumble. You could feel the rumble.”
Their tower was now disintegrating
. Hundreds of thousands of tons of cement, steel, and glass began to melt away. And Ladder 6 was still in the stairwell.
Matt Komorowski: “The first thing I really felt was the incredible rush of air at my back. And maybe I felt it before everybody else, because I was the last guy.”
Stone Phillips: “Like a gust of wind, behind you.”
Matt Komorowski: “Gust of wind. Wind tunnel. It was the most incredible push at your back, that you can feel.”
Stone Phillips: “A rumbling sound, this gust of wind? And then what happened?”
Sal D’Agostino: “When I hit the fourth floor landing, I remember the plaque on the door. And that’s when the building started shaking. And you heard the rumble. And I said, ‘Oh, here we go. This is it for me.’”

6. Inside the North Tower stairwell B when the North Tower collapses atop them. No Explosives sounds.
Mike Meldrum: “I remember covering up, and saying, ‘This is it.’ And, you know, my kids, my wife. You know, my family. And it rumbled and rumbled. And it was pitch black. And then the next thing I know, I remember the dust starting to clear some.

7. AFTER the North tower collapses atop them, Jonas hears explosions, rumblings.(same firefighter as #9)
John Jonas: “And we were hearing explosions. We were hearing rumblings right after this happened. And where I was there was like a little hole in that double sheet rock wall and I could see out and all I could see is twisted I-beams and steel. Like, just a big maze of wreckage. …

8. Inside the North Tower when 2 nd plane hits South tower sounds like an explosion
Sal D’Agostino: “We were in the lobby when the second plane hit. And Captain Jay was at the command post. And you could hear a rumble and an explosion. And from the windows in the World Financial Center across the street, the reflection of the explosion came off of that, came off of those windows.”

9. AFTER the North Tower collapse a loud noise is described by Jonas as an explosion.
… John Jonas: The only time she got flustered in the whole thing was maybe about 20 minutes after the collapse we heard a secondary explosion.

There are many more descriptions like this, but adding to them will not convince those who ignore facts that contradict what they wish to believe.

1. There are no explosives sounds at the time of collapses of the two towers, only rumblings.
2. Loud noises at other times distant from the collapse are described as explosions.
3. There is no explaining away the unmistakable deafening multiple >160db explosions that would have been heard and described by those present inside both towers during the collapses.
4. No explosives sounds at the time of collapse = no explosives.


_________________________________________________________
You can’t reason someone out of something that they were never reasoned into.

Somewhere around the middle of the World Trade Center, there was this orange and red flash coming out. Initially it was just one flash. Then this flash just kept popping all the way around the building and that building had started to explode. The popping sound, and with each popping sound it was initially an orange and then a red flash came out of the building and then it would just go all around the building on both sides as far as I could see. These popping sounds and the explosions were getting bigger, going both up and down and then all around the building.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110192.PDF New York Times

Stephen Gregory -- Assistant Commissioner (F.D.N.Y.) We both for whatever reason -- again, I don't know how valid this is with everything that was going on at that particular point in time, but for some reason I thought that when I looked in the direction of the Trade Center before it came down, before No. 2 came down, that I saw low-level flashes. In my conversation with Lieutenant Evangelista, never mentioning this to him, he questioned me and asked me if I saw low-level flashes in front of the building, and I agreed with him because I thought -- at that time I didn't know what it was. I mean, it could have been as a result of the building collapsing, things exploding, but I saw a flash flash flash and then it looked like the building came down.
...
[It was at] the lower level of the building. You know like when they demolish a building, how when they blow up a building, when it falls down? That's what I thought I saw.
...
He said did you see anything by the building? And I said what do you mean by see anything? He said did you see flashes? I said, yes, well, I thought it was just me. He said no, I saw them too.
...
I know about the explosion on the upper floors. This was like at eye level. I didn't have to go like this. Because I was looking this way. I'm not going to say it was on the first floor or the second floor, but somewhere in that area I saw to me what appeared to be flashes.


http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110008.PDF New York Times


http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/oralhistories/explosions.html

Journalist Pete Hamill:“We heard snapping sounds, pops, little explosions, and then the walls bulged out, and we heard a sound like an avalanche.”[New York Daily News, 9/11/2001]

Firefighter Keith Murphy, who is in the lobby of the North Tower:“[T]he first thing that happened, which I still think is strange to me, the lights went out.… I had heard right before the lights went out, I had heard a distant boom boom boom, sounded like three explosions.… At the time, I would have said they sounded like bombs, but it was boom boom boom and then the lights all go out.… I would say about 3, 4 seconds, all of a sudden this tremendous roar.”[City of New York, 12/5/2001]

Firefighter Craig Carlsen hears “explosions coming from building two, the South Tower. It seemed like it took forever, but there were about ten explosions.… We then realized the building started to come down.”[City of New York, 1/25/2002

Firefighter Thomas Turilli, who is in the lobby of the North Tower:“[A]ll of a sudden you just heard like it almost actually that day sounded like bombs going off, like boom, boom, boom, like seven or eight, and then just a huge wind gust just came… It just seemed like a huge explosion.”[City of New York, 1/17/2002]

Paramedic Kevin Darnowski:“I heard three explosions, and then we heard like groaning and grinding, and Tower Two started to come down.”[City of New York, 11/9/2001]

Police officer Sue Keane, who is an Army veteran, is located in the north WTC tower:“t sounded like bombs going off. That’s when the explosions happened.… It started to get dark, then all of a sudden there was this massive explosion.”[Hagen and Carouba, 2002, pp. 65]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom