Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

adfontesmedia


:dl:


Seting your Hyperbole (hyperbole is all you have) aside....



FOIA

govt documents:


China Failed to Provide Key COVID Info, Fauci Agency Records Show.

From same article:

We received 90 pages of records from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) that show the State Department and Dr. Anthony Fauci’s agency, the U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), knew immediately in January 2020 that China was withholding COVID data, and this was hindering risk assessment and response by public health officials.

The records also show that, nearly two years before the coronavirus outbreak, the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) sent “experts” from the NIH-supported P4 lab at the University of Texas Medical Branch to train Wuhan Institute of Virology lab technicians in lab management and maintenance due to the Wuhan lab’s shortage of trained staff. The same April 2018 cable noted that an official from EcoHealth Alliance “plans to visit Wuhan to meet with Shi [Zhengli].”

We obtained the records through our Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit for records of communications, contracts and agreements with the Wuhan Institute of Virology (Judicial Watch, Inc. v. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (No. 1:21-cv-00696)). The lawsuit specifically sought records about NIH grants that benefitted the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
 
Last edited:
Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton said he believes the 90 pages of communication records between the NIH and the Wuhan lab show that Dr. Anthony Fauci’s agency, NIAID, has been “hiding information on China’s failure to provide essential data on COVID-19.”

The U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) also sent “experts” from the NIH-supported P4 lab at the University of Texas Medical Branch to train Wuhan Institute of Virology technicians in “lab management and maintenance” – nearly two years before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic – the records obtained by Judicial Watch through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit show.

Authored by Isabel van Brugen via The Epoch Times

Back to your only source.
 

Do you have any factual reason to doubt this source, especially as you are always telling us not to dismiss an article just because of the source?

From same article:
The records also show that, nearly two years before the coronavirus outbreak, the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) sent “experts” from the NIH-supported P4 lab at the University of Texas Medical Branch to train Wuhan Institute of Virology lab technicians in lab management and maintenance due to the Wuhan lab’s shortage of trained staff.

What, in your own words, do you believe to be the significance of this information?
 
The Lab Leak Conspracy Theory is probably toast!

Bubba said:
Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton said he believes the 90 pages of communication records between the NIH and the Wuhan lab show that Dr. Anthony Fauci’s agency, NIAID, has been “hiding information on China’s failure to provide essential data on COVID-19.”
The U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) also sent “experts” from the NIH-supported P4 lab at the University of Texas Medical Branch to train Wuhan Institute of Virology technicians in “lab management and maintenance” – nearly two years before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic – the records obtained by Judicial Watch through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit show.


First things first - my source

NPR (national Public Radio)
Bias: Middle (scores -0.22 on a scale of -42 to +42)
Reliability: Reliable, Fact Reporting (scores 52 on a scale of 0-64)

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsa...food-market-in-wuhan-as-pandemic-origin-point

"Over the weekend, an international team of scientists published two extensive papers online, offering the strongest evidence to date that the COVID-19 pandemic originated in animals at a market in Wuhan, China. Specifically, they conclude that the coronavirus most likely jumped from a caged wild animal into people at the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market, where a huge COVID-19 outbreak began in December 2019.
Scientists who weren't involved in the research papers are calling the new data "very convincing" and a "blow" to the lab-leak theory — that the virus somehow escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which does research on coronaviruses. In reaction to the papers, they say the newly published data is tipping the scales toward wildlife sold at the market."
​

The papers are preliminary. They still need to be reviewed by outside scientists. But if the analyses turn out to be accurate, the new data paints an incredibly detailed picture of the early days of the pandemic. Photographic and genetic data pinpoint a specific stall at the market where the coronavirus likely was transmitted from an animal into people. And a new genetic analysis estimates the time, within weeks, when not just one but two spillovers occurred. It predicts the coronavirus jumped into people once in late November or early December and then again few weeks later.

So now, for the first time, the timing of the earliest known coronavirus infections coincides almost exactly with the timing of the outbreak at the seafood market, which began in early December and likely involved hundreds of people working or shopping at the market. That outbreak also spilled over into the surrounding community, as one of the new studies shows.
​

Someone with more expertise in virology may want to correct me if I am wrong, but AIUI, viral geneticists are able to look at the a series of subsequential genome sequences and pinpoint with some accuracy the starting point of a viral outbreak, and if my understanding of what they are saying is correct, they have found the timing of the viral outbreak coincides with the dates the photos were taken in the Wuhan live animal market (as determined by EXIF date and GPS Data) which would mean the outbreak predates any possible lab leak.
 
Authored by Isabel van Brugen via The Epoch Times

Back to your only source.

Surely a guy who proved that the Elites have toyed with their staggering powers by causing places with like names to line up on maps must be right about everything.
 
Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton said he believes the 90 pages of communication records between the NIH and the Wuhan lab show that Dr. Anthony Fauci’s agency, NIAID, has been “hiding information on China’s failure to provide essential data on COVID-19.”

https://www.nationandstate.com/2022...ing-covid-19-data-in-jan-2020-documents-show/

First of all, the second part of your post was not included in the quote, as the proposed objectives by the author are pure conjecture, thereby irrelevant. Your source makes its other claims based on FOIA releases of certain emails, and provide this truth:

Embassy officials in the email said they were concerned that a “lack of epidemiological data” hindered better risk assessment and response by public health officials.

Yet, from this, and other information that supports that quote, the author concludes:

“The slow-rolling and stonewalling by Fauci’s agency on China, gain of function, and its COVID response generally is pure obstruction,” Fitton said.

Now, as gain-of-function was the gist of the conjectured 2nd part of your quote, it remains irrelevant. However, to claim Fauci's COVID response to be obstruction is absolutely proven false per the article's own statement. When you show concern "that a 'lack of epidemiological data' hindered better risk assessment and response by public health officials", you ARE doing your job to gather the necessary information to provide the best response to the situation. Your source obviously can blatantly say up is down without any of their muppet followers realizing, or at least questioning, their absurd conclusions.
 
You mean, aside from the fact they couldn't figure out why the patients had pneumonia in the first place. "Unknown origin" and all that.



The information you seek is in the hundreds of thousand of scientific papers that you refuse to accept because you instead believe one paper produced by a pair of conspiracy theorists.

I just want the paper that shows isolation from one of the 44 patients. All we seem to have is the "Side-Notes" page on CDC China. Why would this information be in a Side Notes page in the first place but surely if it's going to be placed there there should be a link to the paper. What it says in this Side Notes page is that the genome sequence was created from bronchoalveolar lavage samples from one of the 44 patients. This is unscientific in the extreme.

I want to show in a STEP BY STEP manner that the science is wrong so we have to go from one step to the next, OK? First, I have shown clearly that the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific because we have been given no evidence to speak of a "cluster" of pneumonia patients or any reason to specify "of unknown origin".

The next step is isolating the virus from one of those 44 patients. Where is the process FROM ONE OF THESE PATIENTS? Why is what we're told on a Side Notes page on the China CDC website complete and utter garbage?
 
I just want the paper that shows isolation from one of the 44 patients. All we seem to have is the "Side-Notes" page on CDC China. Why would this information be in a Side Notes page in the first place but surely if it's going to be placed there there should be a link to the paper. What it says in this Side Notes page is that the genome sequence was created from bronchoalveolar lavage samples from one of the 44 patients. This is unscientific in the extreme.

I want to show in a STEP BY STEP manner that the science is wrong so we have to go from one step to the next, OK? First, I have shown clearly that the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific because we have been given no evidence to speak of a "cluster" of pneumonia patients or any reason to specify "of unknown origin".

The next step is isolating the virus from one of those 44 patients. Where is the process FROM ONE OF THESE PATIENTS? Why is what we're told on a Side Notes page on the China CDC website complete and utter garbage?

Page 2 on the CT bible: Thou shalt make unreasonable demands and should they be met for some reason thou shalt handwave until dawn!
 
I just want the paper that shows isolation from one of the 44 patients. All we seem to have is the "Side-Notes" page on CDC China.
Do you have a link for this "side notes page on CDC China?" I've searched this thread and the previous one for the text "side notes" and the post I'm quoting is the very first mention of it.

...

First, I have shown clearly that the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific because we have been given no evidence to speak of a "cluster" of pneumonia patients or any reason to specify "of unknown origin".
No, you have the rantings of a couple of well-educated people who have fallen for a conspiracy theory. I suspect the reason the Bailey/Bevan-Smith paper hasn't seen much traction among serious scientists is they take a look at the abstract, where they rant about

Bailey/Bevan-Smith said:
a war on humanity by organisations such as Anser, Fors Marsh, and Palantir that conduct the scam through Big Pharma, with its backers and enablers, including the World Economic Forum, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, the WHO, technology conglomerates, the mainstream media, complicit governments, and COVID “pirates” such as UNC Chapel Hill and Imperial College London ... governments continue to use this imaginary disease to terrorise and imprison their citizens ...
(bolding mine) and immediately write them off as crackpots.

If I get sufficiently motivated, I'll send emails to a sampling of scientists in the appropriate fields and ask them for their critiques of the tail end of part 1 and all of part 2.
 
I just want the paper that shows isolation from one of the 44 patients.


You’re forgetting your own argument. You claim that investigating the cause was “unscientific” because there wasn’t sufficient evidence. Isolating the virus would come after investigation, not before.
 
You’re forgetting your own argument. You claim that investigating the cause was “unscientific” because there wasn’t sufficient evidence. Isolating the virus would come after investigation, not before.

If you are always truthful you never have to remember what you have previously said.
 
Calling COVID-19 "imaginary" is about as ******* stupid as it gets. It's like standing on the beach and looking out on the ocean and saying, "See! Totally flat!".
 
You’re forgetting your own argument. You claim that investigating the cause was “unscientific” because there wasn’t sufficient evidence. Isolating the virus would come after investigation, not before.

Yes, but you're forgetting who you're addressing. In the topsy-turvy world of PetraScience, the conclusion comes first, before the investigation, and the evidence is a poor third.
 
I just want the paper that shows isolation from one of the 44 patients. All we seem to have is the "Side-Notes" page on CDC China. Why would this information be in a Side Notes page in the first place but surely if it's going to be placed there there should be a link to the paper. What it says in this Side Notes page is that the genome sequence was created from bronchoalveolar lavage samples from one of the 44 patients. This is unscientific in the extreme.

I want to show in a STEP BY STEP manner that the science is wrong so we have to go from one step to the next, OK? First, I have shown clearly that the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific because we have been given no evidence to speak of a "cluster" of pneumonia patients or any reason to specify "of unknown origin".

The next step is isolating the virus from one of those 44 patients. Where is the process FROM ONE OF THESE PATIENTS? Why is what we're told on a Side Notes page on the China CDC website complete and utter garbage?
There is a vast quantity of evidence that shows the novel coronavirus to be real that has nothing to do with the 44 patients. You're illogically focused on those 44 to the exclusion of vast quantities of excellent evidence.
 
There is a vast quantity of evidence that shows the novel coronavirus to be real that has nothing to do with the 44 patients. You're illogically focused on those 44 to the exclusion of vast quantities of excellent evidence.

By ignoring the mountains of evidence that exist in objective reality, one can then obsess in the shadowy valley of CT.
 
Just for clarity, to see if I quite understand: at an early stage, when it began to be noticed that there was an unusual cluster of pneumonia cases which might indicate something new was going on and this deserved investigation, the number of patients identified happened to be 44. There were of course many more soon identified and by now there have been ten million times that number of infections. So, just in case I misunderstood, is it Petra's view that the pandemic is not real unless the Covid-19 virus was isolated from one of those arbitrary 44 cases?
 
First, I have shown clearly that the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific because we have been given no evidence to speak of a "cluster" of pneumonia patients or any reason to specify "of unknown origin".

The terms you put in scare quotes have all been explained to you, yet you still use scare quotes. Why is that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom