Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

That was all I concentrated on in the brief time I alloted to myself, but it was enough to make the entire study suspect to me. Judging by this tiny sample, I am confident any peer review will be able to find a plethora of additional faults.

There's a lot of cherry picking going on in that policy paper. For another example comparing hospitalizations with SAEs, many/most that didn't require hospitalization.

That said, they are right in one aspect. There is no good risk/benefit analysis for the age groups teens/20's. Largely because the numbers are so small for either vaccinations or infections. It would take a really large N to evaluate. And even so it would be observational with confounders galore. Anti-vaxxers are touting this paper as some sort of proof vaccines are really killing folks. Much more than Covid-19. And that's nonsense. The paper doesn't actually indicate that. But people read into stuff whatever fits their beliefs.
 
There's a lot of cherry picking going on in that policy paper. For another example comparing hospitalizations with SAEs, many/most that didn't require hospitalization.

That said, they are right in one aspect. There is no good risk/benefit analysis for the age groups teens/20's. Largely because the numbers are so small for either vaccinations or infections. It would take a really large N to evaluate. And even so it would be observational with confounders galore. Anti-vaxxers are touting this paper as some sort of proof vaccines are really killing folks. Much more than Covid-19. And that's nonsense. The paper doesn't actually indicate that. But people read into stuff whatever fits their beliefs.


Firstly, thanks for your insight. I would like to add that the highlighted part is true for everyone, including skeptics. However, the difference, in my opinion, is that skeptics tend to acutely know this, and generally try to honestly critique their own conclusions (preferably prior to announcing them). The result being, skeptics remain much more open to convincing evidence that can change/alter their stance(s) than those mentally crippled by their own egos.
 
Last edited:
Firstly, thanks for your insight. I would like to add that the highlighted part is true for everyone, including skeptics. However, the difference, in my opinion, is that skeptics tend to acutely know this, and generally try to honestly critique their own conclusions (preferably prior to announcing them). The result being, skeptics remain much more open to convincing evidence that can change/alter their stance(s) than those mentally crippled by their own egos.

Yeah. Something I learned early in my engineering career when coming up with a new approach to a design. There's a strong motivation to think one has just discovered a better way to do something. But most often there are flaws in the approach or it would have already been in use. I learned to explore all the ways my thinking and approach could be in error before putting a lot of effort into the new design. Saved me a lot of time pursuing doomed ideas.
 
The Expose and the NEJM

The Expose "A new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine has concluded that the mRNA Covid-19 injections destroy the natural immune system. The study backs up months of work conducted by the team here at The Expose analysing official Government data in which we uncovered severe immune system degradation among the vaccinated population that worsens by the week, suggesting the vaccinated are developing some new form of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. It also supports further analysis of official Government data that suggests Covid-19 vaccination takes approximately 5 months to kill...If they were, then we would be seeing vaccine effectiveness (immune system performance) close to 0%. But the New England Journal of Medicine study proves the effectiveness is breaking the 0% barrier into negative “effectiveness”. And real-world data supplied by the UK Government, unfortunately, shows the exact same thing,"

Wikipedia reported "The Exposé was created in November 2020 by Jonathan Allen-Walker..." Health Feedback is unimpressed with Mr. Allen-Walker. The link in The Expose goes to a letter to the editor of the New England Journal of Medicine. That letter said in part, "Both the BNT162b2 vaccine and previous infection were found to confer considerable immunity against omicron infection and protection against hospitalization and death. The rapid decline in protection against omicron infection that was conferred by vaccination and previous infection provides support for booster vaccination."

Anyone who has read my contributions to the Covid-19 threads in the Science/Math/Medicine/Technology sub-forum can guess what my initial reaction was to reading the article in The Expose. My first thought is that the NEJM article is being grossly mischaracterized in at least one way, namely the fact that protection regarding hospitalization remained strong. Yet statistics is not my strongest suit, and I don't know what to make of the 0% barrier business (see Figures 1A and 1B). Would anyone like to comment further on any aspect of this issue?
 
Last edited:
If I read it correctly, they are saying the antivaxxers who either survived or avoided covid get the last laugh??
 
So somebody read a letter summarising a study of children which showed how the protection vaccination confers declines over time, and suggested this supports giving them boosters, and interpreted it as saying that vaccination "destroys the natural immune system"? Have I got that right?

To save anyone else having to click on The Expose, this is the letter it links to:

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2209371
 
So somebody read a letter summarising a study of children which showed how the protection vaccination confers declines over time, and suggested this supports giving them boosters, and interpreted it as saying that vaccination "destroys the natural immune system"? Have I got that right?

To save anyone else having to click on The Expose, this is the letter it links to:

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2209371

You could only say such a thing if you didn't have a clue how vaccines actually work.
 
Less than zero

It is telling that the author(s) of the article in The Expose left out Figures 1E and 1F, which contradict the thesis put forward. It is why some of the curves (Figures 1A and 1B) dip below zero that has me puzzled.
 
It says "each curve starts at the median date of the first dose". So although that's labelled zero effectiveness maybe there's some effectiveness already from the doses given earlier, and it eventually falls below that to actual zero?

IANAS.
 
Here is request to withdraw the article

https://osf.io/m58yh/

From the abstract:
In our opinion, this article contains several assumptions and misinformation that we highlight. We believe that a rapid analysis of the key points and the misinterpretations that they contain are sufficient to invalidate the relevancy of the article and therefore we ask the editor to revise their opinion on the publication of the article.

Yeah, no **** Sherlock.
 
Here is request to withdraw the article

https://osf.io/m58yh/

Note that the journal editor rejected the request to withdraw and formally published the April preprint article. Also, the editor had previously put out a call for papers on adverse mRNA effects.

https://retractionwatch.com/2022/08...lly-at-risk-from-covid-19-vaccines-retracted/
In February, the editor-in-chief of Food and Chemical Toxicology published an editorial calling for “Papers on potential toxic effects of COVID-19 vaccines.”

It's a sad story that says something about that particular journal.
 
Florida's idiot Surgeon General promotes misinformation . . . again.

Florida's Surgeon General recommended against mRNA vaccines for those under 40.
Twitter temporarily took down a post by Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo on guidance against COVID-19 vaccines for those under 40. The move comes as medical experts and scientists criticize the Florida Department of Health recommendations for being based on weak data that never saw peer review.

Dr. Kristen Panthagani, an emergency medicine resident at Yale who has written widely on COVID-19 vaccination data, noted the analysis appeared to be a Microsoft Word document which listed no authors and had not faced any kind of peer review.

“They looked at death certificates, and any death that had an ICD 10 code under ‘Other forms of heart disease’ (ICD I30-I52) was included,” Panthagani said in a social media post.

“1. ICD-10 codes are not necessarily accurate or specific. 2. There isn’t a clear rationale why they included these specific ICD-10 codes vs other cardiac-related codes (i.e. ischemic heart disease is not included?). 3. “Cardiac arrest” is included, which simply means ‘the heart stopped’ and can be the terminal event for many different diseases, not just cardiac issues. Overall, it is a somewhat random list defined not by a hypothesis, but by the arbitrary structure of hospital billing. In short, this list is too broad to be meaningful, excludes some cardiac issues but not others, and most of the diagnoses are far more likely to be caused by other ongoing disease processes rather than vaccination.”

Holden Thorp, editor-in-chief of the Science family of medical journals, called the analysis a “bogus study.”

This moron could become the U.S. Surgeon General should DeSantis be elected POTUS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom