Blue Mountain
Resident Skeptical Hobbit
What's highlighted is speculation. We can work out ourselves, Blue Mountain, that taking a sample from a single pneumonia patient who hasn't been shown to be suffering the ill effects of a "novel" virus is not the way to construct a genome sequence. And they decided on this sequence BEFORE any other samples were looked at.
I can supply informed speculation from my career as a computer programmer. A programmer's job is to use something called a programming language to write programs and get a computer to do something the programmer wants it to do (known as output.) For example, here's a little program that implements the Fizz Buzz game for values 1 through 100:
Code:
#!/usr/bin/perl -w
use strict;
foreach my $n (1 .. 100) {
my $sw = 0;
# Print "Fizz" if n is divisible by 3
$sw = 1, print "Fizz " if ! ($n % 3);
# Print "Buzz" if n is divisible by 5
$sw = 1, print "Buzz " if ! ($n % 5);
# Print the number if n isn't divisible by 3 or 5
print "$n " if ! $sw;
print "\n";
}
This code is then put into a special class of program known as an interpreter to run it, or to a compiler to produce an intermediate object that will be used to create the final program.
The point I'm trying to make here is you can't just take any random sequence of characters and words and feed them to an interpreter or compiler: all you'll get back is a bunch of errors. As we say in the trade, "Garbage in, garbage out."
Ditto for a genome. The ATGC base-pair sequences in the genome comprise source code. These are fed into a cell, where the sequences tell the cell to create messenger RNA (mRNA—where have we seen that before?) that's read by a ribosome (akin to a computer interpreter) that eventually creates a protein (output.) Feed a bunch of garbage DNA sequences into this process and you won't get any usable proteins out of it.
It's all smoke'n'mirrors, it's all computer fabrication, based on the hypothetical not the real.
Most certainly not. As I've just shown, feed garbage into a computer and you get garbage out. Feed garbage DNA into a cell and you'll probably get nothing. The SARS-Cov-2 virus does things, namely taking over the cell's reproductive machinery to produce more viruses.
People who come down with COVID are indeed ill, and to date about 5 million people have died from it. While it's true there isn't a distinctive (dare I say, definitive) set of symptoms—it resembles influenza and even a bad cold—people are getting sick and are dying from it. We use things like PCR testing to determine exactly what it is that people who present with symptoms are sick with.What we know is that covid doesn't have a distinctive set of symptoms and some people who test positive have no symptoms at all.
We have the genomes of other viruses, and can compare a virus found in the wild against this database of known viruses. This is how we know SARS-Cov-2 similar to the original SARS virus: a lot of the base pairs line up, but there are sufficient differences to give it a new name. In addition, the disease caused by the new virus isn't as harsh as the original SARS was, which had a tendency to kill its host before it had a chance to be transmitted to a new one. That's why it died out so quickly.How do we know that the genome they've come up with is for a "novel" coronavirus, it could be any old virus.
You appear to know nothing about genetics, DNA, RNA, or molecular biology, which probably accounts for why you entertain such crazy ideas about SARS-Cov-2 and COVID-19.
I'll see your paper and raise you 148,000 papers on SARS-Cov-2 and 233,000 papers on COVID-19. After you've acquired at least an M.Sc. in virology, genomics, or molecular biology and can show that more than a handful of these papers are materially incorrect, I'll consider that perhaps Baily and Bevan-Smith are on to something. Until then, I'll side with the massive consensus among scientists in the appropriate disciplines that this virus exists, is making people sick, and is killing them.From paper by Dr Mark Bailey and Dr John Bevan-Smith