Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

What's highlighted is speculation. We can work out ourselves, Blue Mountain, that taking a sample from a single pneumonia patient who hasn't been shown to be suffering the ill effects of a "novel" virus is not the way to construct a genome sequence. And they decided on this sequence BEFORE any other samples were looked at.

I can supply informed speculation from my career as a computer programmer. A programmer's job is to use something called a programming language to write programs and get a computer to do something the programmer wants it to do (known as output.) For example, here's a little program that implements the Fizz Buzz game for values 1 through 100:

Code:
#!/usr/bin/perl -w
use strict;
foreach my $n (1 .. 100) {
    my $sw = 0;
    # Print "Fizz" if n is divisible by 3
    $sw = 1, print "Fizz " if ! ($n % 3);
    # Print "Buzz" if n is divisible by 5
    $sw = 1, print "Buzz " if ! ($n % 5);
    # Print the number if n isn't divisible by 3 or 5
    print "$n " if ! $sw;
    print "\n";
}

This code is then put into a special class of program known as an interpreter to run it, or to a compiler to produce an intermediate object that will be used to create the final program.

The point I'm trying to make here is you can't just take any random sequence of characters and words and feed them to an interpreter or compiler: all you'll get back is a bunch of errors. As we say in the trade, "Garbage in, garbage out."

Ditto for a genome. The ATGC base-pair sequences in the genome comprise source code. These are fed into a cell, where the sequences tell the cell to create messenger RNA (mRNA—where have we seen that before?) that's read by a ribosome (akin to a computer interpreter) that eventually creates a protein (output.) Feed a bunch of garbage DNA sequences into this process and you won't get any usable proteins out of it.

It's all smoke'n'mirrors, it's all computer fabrication, based on the hypothetical not the real.

Most certainly not. As I've just shown, feed garbage into a computer and you get garbage out. Feed garbage DNA into a cell and you'll probably get nothing. The SARS-Cov-2 virus does things, namely taking over the cell's reproductive machinery to produce more viruses.

What we know is that covid doesn't have a distinctive set of symptoms and some people who test positive have no symptoms at all.
People who come down with COVID are indeed ill, and to date about 5 million people have died from it. While it's true there isn't a distinctive (dare I say, definitive) set of symptoms—it resembles influenza and even a bad cold—people are getting sick and are dying from it. We use things like PCR testing to determine exactly what it is that people who present with symptoms are sick with.

How do we know that the genome they've come up with is for a "novel" coronavirus, it could be any old virus.
We have the genomes of other viruses, and can compare a virus found in the wild against this database of known viruses. This is how we know SARS-Cov-2 similar to the original SARS virus: a lot of the base pairs line up, but there are sufficient differences to give it a new name. In addition, the disease caused by the new virus isn't as harsh as the original SARS was, which had a tendency to kill its host before it had a chance to be transmitted to a new one. That's why it died out so quickly.

You appear to know nothing about genetics, DNA, RNA, or molecular biology, which probably accounts for why you entertain such crazy ideas about SARS-Cov-2 and COVID-19.

From paper by Dr Mark Bailey and Dr John Bevan-Smith
I'll see your paper and raise you 148,000 papers on SARS-Cov-2 and 233,000 papers on COVID-19. After you've acquired at least an M.Sc. in virology, genomics, or molecular biology and can show that more than a handful of these papers are materially incorrect, I'll consider that perhaps Baily and Bevan-Smith are on to something. Until then, I'll side with the massive consensus among scientists in the appropriate disciplines that this virus exists, is making people sick, and is killing them.
 
As I've just shown, feed garbage into a computer and you get garbage out.


I may have also seen this in some member's footer, but it bears reminding and makes me wonder if Petra's ancestry includes a member or two of Parliament at the time.

"On two occasions, I have been asked [by members of Parliament], 'Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?' I am not able to rightly apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question."
-- Charles Babbage (1791-1871)



You appear to know nothing about genetics, DNA, RNA, or molecular biology, which probably accounts for why you entertain such crazy ideas about SARS-Cov-2 and COVID-19.

IMHO, I've never seen such undeceptive appearance.
 
I can supply informed speculation from my career as a computer programmer. A programmer's job is to use something called a programming language to write programs and get a computer to do something the programmer wants it to do (known as output.) For example, here's a little program that implements the Fizz Buzz game for values 1 through 100:

Code:
#!/usr/bin/perl -w
use strict;
foreach my $n (1 .. 100) {
    my $sw = 0;
    # Print "Fizz" if n is divisible by 3
    $sw = 1, print "Fizz " if ! ($n % 3);
    # Print "Buzz" if n is divisible by 5
    $sw = 1, print "Buzz " if ! ($n % 5);
    # Print the number if n isn't divisible by 3 or 5
    print "$n " if ! $sw;
    print "\n";
}

This code is then put into a special class of program known as an interpreter to run it, or to a compiler to produce an intermediate object that will be used to create the final program.

The point I'm trying to make here is you can't just take any random sequence of characters and words and feed them to an interpreter or compiler: all you'll get back is a bunch of errors. As we say in the trade, "Garbage in, garbage out."

Ditto for a genome. The ATGC base-pair sequences in the genome comprise source code. These are fed into a cell, where the sequences tell the cell to create messenger RNA (mRNA—where have we seen that before?) that's read by a ribosome (akin to a computer interpreter) that eventually creates a protein (output.) Feed a bunch of garbage DNA sequences into this process and you won't get any usable proteins out of it.



Most certainly not. As I've just shown, feed garbage into a computer and you get garbage out. Feed garbage DNA into a cell and you'll probably get nothing. The SARS-Cov-2 virus does things, namely taking over the cell's reproductive machinery to produce more viruses.


People who come down with COVID are indeed ill, and to date about 5 million people have died from it. While it's true there isn't a distinctive (dare I say, definitive) set of symptoms—it resembles influenza and even a bad cold—people are getting sick and are dying from it. We use things like PCR testing to determine exactly what it is that people who present with symptoms are sick with.


We have the genomes of other viruses, and can compare a virus found in the wild against this database of known viruses. This is how we know SARS-Cov-2 similar to the original SARS virus: a lot of the base pairs line up, but there are sufficient differences to give it a new name. In addition, the disease caused by the new virus isn't as harsh as the original SARS was, which had a tendency to kill its host before it had a chance to be transmitted to a new one. That's why it died out so quickly.

You appear to know nothing about genetics, DNA, RNA, or molecular biology, which probably accounts for why you entertain such crazy ideas about SARS-Cov-2 and COVID-19.


I'll see your paper and raise you 148,000 papers on SARS-Cov-2 and 233,000 papers on COVID-19. After you've acquired at least an M.Sc. in virology, genomics, or molecular biology and can show that more than a handful of these papers are materially incorrect, I'll consider that perhaps Baily and Bevan-Smith are on to something. Until then, I'll side with the massive consensus among scientists in the appropriate disciplines that this virus exists, is making people sick, and is killing them.

Blue Mountain, as 16th century Italian philosopher Giordano Bruno said:
"It is proof of a base and low mind for one to wish to think with the masses or majority, merely because the majority is the majority. Truth does not change because it is, or is not, believed by a majority of the people."

I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence. To create a genome sequence I believe the claims by the critics of the mainstream narrative that you need an identified virus and we don't see that.

There is no one debunking the paper done by these two guys. Why not? What they put forward sounds authoritative, doesn't it? It doesn't sound like nonsense. Anything put forward that at least seems authoritative needs to be debunked otherwise we have a grave risk of people being misled by "dangerous misinformation". Why do we only see debunking of stuff I could debunk myself?

I follow the debunking trail, I have no interest in how many thousands of papers have been produced. I only "trust" when I'm forced to such as going into surgery. Otherwise, I only accept information as given because I feel I have no reason to doubt it or I'm not really bothered. When I am bothered I don't "trust" because of numbers of people saying something, I follow the debunking trail because I think that's a far better method than relying on "scientific consensus" or similar. Power influences everything and it's well-known that Big Pharma influences scientific studies - if you don't get that you are very, very naive. Even when I believe the scientific consensus I still follow the debunking trail because I think we must always look at both sides.

Microbiologist, Christine Massey, has organised a FOI campaign to health authorities and governments about isolation of the virus and according to the specified criteria, all health authorities and governments have admitted they are not in possession of such proof of isolation. In that case, what needs to happen is that those supporting the mainstream narrative must argue that isolation according to the specified criteria is not required for isolation to occur. No one has done that.
https://truthcomestolight.com/the-non-existent-virus-an-explosive-interview-with-christine-massey/

Please do not keep throwing at me numbers of papers or anything to do with numbers indicating something must be true. Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing. And nor does numbers of people who've allegedly died from covid. I've already pointed out that the excess mortality spike in April 2020 in continental Europe and the UK with inexplicable variations according to covid hypothesis between neighbouring countries very much favours the hypothesis that the excess spike was caused by aggressive drug trials. We also see that mortality of alleged covid sufferers tends to be greatly concentrated in very old people suffering co-morbidities. We also see that statistics that seem to support efficacy of the jab actually support both lack of efficacy and danger by making the status of "vaccinated" refer only to those who had their second jab at least 2 weeks before. Statistics need to be analysed carefully. Without careful analysis numbers can be made to show the complete opposite of reality ... apart from other problems with "numbers" produced such as validity of the test used to produce them.
 
Last edited:
In reality, you have provided no "grounds" to debunk. You have merely provided incredulous opinion that you and other contrarians don't approve of the original method for suspecting a novel virus, for what IS a novel virus. Your "opinion" can only be self-debunked. Scientifically, ANYTHING out of the ordinary CAN be considered suspect, so your "opinion" is extremely prejudiced against facts, but it is nevertheless your ignorant opinion.

But where's the evidence of anything out of the ordinary? They told us there was a "cluster" of 44 patients with pneumonia of "unknown origin" but they provide nothing to say there was anything unusual about these pneumonia patients.

And you read that exactly how Bailey wanted you to - ignorantly. The Chinese source cited is a periodical synopsis of current events (at the time). I guess Bailey correctly assumed people like you wouldn't notice that the article's title begins with "Notes from the Field:". Do I need to explain what that means regarding the intricacies and specifics that are involved with the topics discussed?

Please provide the scientific paper that shows that a new virus has emerged that uses material from the alleged cluster of 44 patients. Please provide that scientific paper. If you are going to refer to papers that use different patients then there's a big question mark, isn't there? Why and how would they be using OTHER patients, not the patients that they say gave rise to the suspicion of a "novel" virus.

Relying on your unquestioning gullibility, Bailey makes her claims unchallenged, as the cited article contains nothing to refute them. To spell it out for you - that's because THE ARTICLE IS JUST A SNIPPET TO UPDATE - not the actual study. The Sanger sequencing, Illumina sequencing, and nanopore sequencing, are all clinically precise, controlled and executed via laboratory procedures to ensure accuracy and validity of information. "Crude" samples are not used at these points, but once again, Bailey relies on your devoted mindlessness to accept her misinformation. Well done!
How do they get from the crude samples to the refined samples? Where's the data?


The only circular reasoning is Bailey's - hoping you continue your endless cycle of accepting garbage as gold. Once the sequencing was determined, other cases needed to match that sequencing in order to be considered identical cases. It is no coincidence that everyone that was similarly ill with no other identified pathogen had that sequence, nor that people identified to NOT have that sequence of a pathogen, also did not have that illness. That part is basic deductive reasoning. Perhaps you should begin there.
It is arriving at the sequencing that is completely under question. The steps have not been shown to do it.
 
So anyway, the SARS-CoV-2 genome has been isolated and sequenced, and has been demonstrated to cause COVID-19.

[/thread]
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Rinse.

Repeat.

Sorry, my educationally challenged accuser of witches, but you must provide the answers I requested, before I provide any more answers to you. The fact is, once you can provide correct answers to my request, you will have gleaned the knowledge to understand what your misconceptions currently are.

Furthermore, you have told Blue Mountain that
I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence.

Those are not mutually exclusive subjects. Regardless, please explain what you understand about going from a virus to a genome sequence, as I don't believe you actually understand it at all. Once you do THAT correctly, you need to explain why you think laboratories all over the world have not done it properly. You also need to explain how the data from China, even if it WERE inconsistent with the rest of the consistent worldwide data, would invalidate that worldwide data. HINT: It wouldn't (but China would have some questions to answer).


You also told Blue Mountain:
Why do we only see debunking of stuff I could debunk myself?

You are speaking only for yourself. Why you refuse to see what is obvious to others is not their problem.
 
Blue Mountain, as 16th century Italian philosopher Giordano Bruno said:
"It is proof of a base and low mind for one to wish to think with the masses or majority, merely because the majority is the majority. Truth does not change because it is, or is not, believed by a majority of the people."
There is also danger in ignoring a scientific consensus. To quote the twentieth century scientist and philosopher Carl Sagan, “But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.”

I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence. To create a genome sequence I believe the claims by the critics of the mainstream narrative that you need an identified virus and we don't see that.
No, you don't see that! Just because you refuse to believe something exists in no way means it doesn't. And thanks for admitting you know nothing about genomic sequencing. Your ignorance is leading you profoundly astray.

There is no one debunking the paper done by these two guys. Why not? What they put forward sounds authoritative, doesn't it? It doesn't sound like nonsense. Anything put forward that at least seems authoritative needs to be debunked otherwise we have a grave risk of people being misled by "dangerous misinformation". Why do we only see debunking of stuff I could debunk myself?
The paper is the summation of the entire conspiracy theorists' thinking on the SARS-Cov-2 virus and the COVID-19 pandemic. It starts with the conclusion that the virus is fake and the pandemic is a fraud, that the entire study of virology has been fooled by a fake virus, and that virology itself is not scientific.

Despite the fact it sounds authoritative, the paper, which has not been published in any journal whatsoever, starts out parroting the conspiracy theory that there's a "globalist agenda" (quote taken directly from the paper) involving Bill Gates, the World Economic Forum, and the Great Reset to destroy democracy. It continually puts "pandemic" and "novel" into scare quotes because it questions their existence. It makes the assumption that because there were meetings prior to the outbreak to increase world preparedness for such an event, they were actually planning meetings to spring a fake pandemic on the world. It also touches on nanoparticles in vaccines.

The paper is littered with unscientific terms such as "globalist," "fraud," "preposterous," "song," "hype," and "so-called."

It also include such howlers as "Most would be surprised to learn that the “virus” has never been found inside a single human or shown to be the cause of any disease."

As for the debunking trail, if I publish a sciency-sounding paper on academia.edu that concludes 2+2=a potato, do you think there would be much interest in debunking it? Same here; I get the impression that most scientists, even if they're aware of this paper, simply don't think it's worth their time addressing it. I may at some point sign up for this site and see if there have been papers added to it addressing this pair's claims.

I follow the debunking trail, I have no interest in how many thousands of papers have been produced.
And that is where you fail. On one side you have two cranks with a paper published on a for-profit site with no standards for peer review. On the other side are hundreds of thousands of papers that you seem to think are irrelevant.

I only "trust" when I'm forced to such as going into surgery. Otherwise, I only accept information as given because I feel I have no reason to doubt it or I'm not really bothered. When I am bothered I don't "trust" because of numbers of people saying something, I follow the debunking trail because I think that's a far better method than relying on "scientific consensus" or similar. Power influences everything and it's well-known that Big Pharma influences scientific studies - if you don't get that you are very, very naive. Even when I believe the scientific consensus I still follow the debunking trail because I think we must always look at both sides.
Yes, science is messy and can be influenced by outside factors. This is where consensus comes in: if 95% of scientists in a field say X and 5% say Y, I'll side with the X until Y can come up with really good evidence their side has the correct interpretation.

Microbiologist, Christine Massey, has organised a FOI campaign to health authorities and governments about isolation of the virus and according to the specified criteria, all health authorities and governments have admitted they are not in possession of such proof of isolation. In that case, what needs to happen is that those supporting the mainstream narrative must argue that isolation according to the specified criteria is not required for isolation to occur. No one has done that.
The non-existent Virus: an Explosive Interview with Christine Massey

The home page of truthcomestolight.com features a quote by David Icke. Not a good start. It links heavily to other COVID-19 conspiracy sites, climate change denial sites, and fawning articles about the trucker convoys. Basically it's an echo chamber telling you what you want to hear.

I may at some point look at the article to see if there's any substance to it.

Please do not keep throwing at me numbers of papers or anything to do with numbers indicating something must be true. Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing.
If fifteen doctors tell you you have tendonitis and one tells you it's cancer, do you go in for cancer treatment? At some point you need to give weight to the numbers.

And nor does numbers of people who've allegedly died from covid. I've already pointed out that the excess mortality spike in April 2020 in continental Europe and the UK with inexplicable variations according to covid hypothesis between neighbouring countries very much favours the hypothesis that the excess spike was caused by aggressive drug trials. We also see that mortality of alleged covid sufferers tends to be greatly concentrated in very old people suffering co-morbidities. We also see that statistics that seem to support efficacy of the jab actually support both lack of efficacy and danger by making the status of "vaccinated" refer only to those who had their second jab at least 2 weeks before. Statistics need to be analysed carefully. Without careful analysis numbers can be made to show the complete opposite of reality ... apart from other problems with "numbers" produced such as validity of the test used to produce them.

Planigale is addressing your "aggressive drug trials" claim. Also, were these drug trials being conducted all over Asia and Europe in the time frame you're talking about?
 
Last edited:
But where's the evidence of anything out of the ordinary? They told us there was a "cluster" of 44 patients with pneumonia of "unknown origin" but they provide nothing to say there was anything unusual about these pneumonia patients.
You mean, aside from the fact they couldn't figure out why the patients had pneumonia in the first place. "Unknown origin" and all that.

Please provide the scientific paper that shows that a new virus has emerged that uses material from the alleged cluster of 44 patients. Please provide that scientific paper. If you are going to refer to papers that use different patients then there's a big question mark, isn't there? Why and how would they be using OTHER patients, not the patients that they say gave rise to the suspicion of a "novel" virus.

How do they get from the crude samples to the refined samples? Where's the data?

It is arriving at the sequencing that is completely under question. The steps have not been shown to do it.

The information you seek is in the hundreds of thousand of scientific papers that you refuse to accept because you instead believe one paper produced by a pair of conspiracy theorists.
 
I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence. To create a genome sequence I believe the claims by the critics of the mainstream narrative that you need an identified virus and we don't see that.

As you say you do not understand gene sequencing. Your first error is that you do not need an identified organism to create a gene sequence. Gene sequencing is now a standard method for identifying unknown bacteria and viruses, some of which are not possible to grow in pure culture. So that is one conceptual error that is causing you problems.

https://bmcbioinformatics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12859-017-1901-8

Microbiologist, Christine Massey, has organised a FOI campaign to health authorities and governments about isolation of the virus and according to the specified criteria, all health authorities and governments have admitted they are not in possession of such proof of isolation. In that case, what needs to happen is that those supporting the mainstream narrative must argue that isolation according to the specified criteria is not required for isolation to occur. No one has done that.
https://truthcomestolight.com/the-non-existent-virus-an-explosive-interview-with-christine-massey/

Christine Massey is not a microbiologist.
If you want to find scientific evidence you read the scientific literature, not send out FOI requests. The place where the work would be done is not public health departments or health ministries. She specified her own criteria, which she made up and are not those agreed by others. At least one organisation responded that they had isolated the virus in pure culture from patient material. Christine Massey just refused to accept this. It appears that unless she saw the virus with her own eyes she would not accept this.

Every standard of proof that applies to every other infection has been met for Covid-19. If you deny the existence of Covid-19, you might equally deny HIV, Ebola, Influenza (remember most viruses were 'identified' with less evidence than there is for covid-19.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7239045/

This paper reports the isolation of the virus from a patient including into pure culture. Including electron microscopy showing the novel corona virus.

So another assumption of yours that is incorrect.

Please do not keep throwing at me numbers of papers or anything to do with numbers indicating something must be true. Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing. And nor does numbers of people who've allegedly died from covid. I've already pointed out that the excess mortality spike in April 2020 in continental Europe and the UK with inexplicable variations according to covid hypothesis between neighbouring countries very much favours the hypothesis that the excess spike was caused by aggressive drug trials.

I have previously asked you to give the definition of an aggressive drug trial and how it differs from other drug trials. I have also pointed out the trial included a control arm who received no trial drugs so it would be clear if the drugs caused excessive deaths (ir reduced deaths). You arbitrarily dismiss the excess of deaths seen at the time the virus was surging, and there was a surge of admissions to hospitals with an acute respiratory syndrome, with deaths from acute respiratory failure. Instead attributing the deaths to drug trials, but with no evidence (and the trial results are published) that there was any excess mortality associated with the trials or that the number of excess deaths was smaller than the number of people recruited into trials.

We also see that mortality of alleged covid sufferers tends to be greatly concentrated in very old people suffering co-morbidities. We also see that statistics that seem to support efficacy of the jab actually support both lack of efficacy and danger by making the status of "vaccinated" refer only to those who had their second jab at least 2 weeks before. Statistics need to be analysed carefully. Without careful analysis numbers can be made to show the complete opposite of reality ... apart from other problems with "numbers" produced such as validity of the test used to produce them.

If you want to actually reference the statistics, then the numbers can be discussed, but since you dismiss numbers, I think the reality is whatever the numbers actually showed you would ignore them and stick to your prejudice.
 
Microbiologist, Christine Massey, has organised a FOI campaign to health authorities and governments about isolation of the virus and according to the specified criteria, all health authorities and governments have admitted they are not in possession of such proof of isolation. In that case, what needs to happen is that those supporting the mainstream narrative must argue that isolation according to the specified criteria is not required for isolation to occur. No one has done that.
https://truthcomestolight.com/the-non-existent-virus-an-explosive-interview-with-christine-massey/

Christine Massey is NOT a microbiologist! She holds an undergraduate degree (B.A.) from the University of Ottawa and a Master’s degree (M.A.) from Simon Fraser University... in psychology!

If you can't tell the difference between a microbiologist and a psychologist, then its no wonder you have trouble understanding anything. Planigale is better qualified to pontificate on microbiology than Massey!
 
So anyway, the SARS-CoV-2 genome has been isolated and sequenced, and has been demonstrated to cause COVID-19.

[/thread]

It's also been imaged. There are SEM images of the virus attacking human cells. And if it wasn't Covid, then there is some other unknown killer that has been targeting those who test positive for SARS-COV-2 and show the symptoms of COVID-19. In numbers that haven't been seen for about a century.

[IMGW=640]https://i.snipboard.io/mtDVzI.jpg[/IMGW]

Look at the 2020 plot in particular. And similar plots are around for other countries.
 
Blue Mountain, as 16th century Italian philosopher Giordano Bruno said:
"It is proof of a base and low mind for one to wish to think with the masses or majority, merely because the majority is the majority. Truth does not change because it is, or is not, believed by a majority of the people."
It is proof of gross ignorance to think that an overwhelming consensus of scientists, arrived at by rigorous use of the scientific method, is analogous to the religious dogma of the 16th Century Roman Catholic Church.

I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence.
So explain that mechanism, in your own words.

To create a genome sequence I believe the claims by the critics of the mainstream narrative [scientific consensus] that you need an identified virus and we don't see that.
Fixed part of that for you.

You're just another conspiracy theorist, no different than any flat earther or Apollo denier, who wants everyone to think you're special because you know more than everyone else about a subject of which you have no meaningful comprehension.
 
Last edited:
Please do not keep throwing at me numbers of papers or anything to do with numbers indicating something must be true. Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing.

Thanks for confirming that you did not put much thought in any of your posts. :( I am unsure who is wasting more time: We, reading your completely worthless posts or you writing them....
 
Thanks, idjits.

Taxpayers are set to foot an almost $2m bill for the police response to widespread anti-vaccination protests that shut down parts of Canberra earlier this year, AAP reports.

ACT Chief Police Officer Neil Gaughan said policing efforts cost $1.9m so far and the demonstrations are continuing.

Gaughan said the protests were expected to take place each weekend in the lead up to the federal budget on 29 March.

“We’ve been having protests since 12 December in the territory, and they really haven’t stopped,” he told ABC radio on Wednesday.

“With the continuance of the protests, I anticipate numbers to increase.”

Discussions on whether the costs would be covered by Canberra taxpayers or nationally was yet to be determined.

Talks are set to take place between the ACT and federal governments on how costs would be handled.

Gaughan said about 500 protesters were still in Canberra and the surrounding region.

ACT police along with their NSW counterparts are monitoring the protests.

While police have described the demonstrations as largely peaceful, 23 arrests have been made.

The largest protest took place in February, when more than 10,000 people marched on Parliament House, demonstrating against Covid-19 vaccines and vaccination mandates.

Gaughan said it was not known whether upcoming demonstrations would be similar, but big gatherings are expected on federal budget night.

“The thing that aggrieves me the most, we haven’t had the ability or the opportunity or the resources to do what I consider to be normal policing,” he said.

“It doesn’t just affect me, it affects my national colleagues, who have given me substantial resources to deal with these protests over the two-month period.”

Protesters shut down major roads in Canberra during the demonstrations, targeting media organisations, along with Parliament House and city centres.

Large numbers camped out on the lawns outside the National Library before they were kicked out and moved to a campground in Canberra’s north, which became a makeshift headquarters.

A stand-off then ensued between protesters and police when they were told to leave because the site was needed for the Canberra Show.

source
 
You mean, aside from the fact they couldn't figure out why the patients had pneumonia in the first place. "Unknown origin" and all that.


Petra’s objection seems to be that because they didn’t know what caused the pneumonia, investigating the cause was “unscientific”.
 
The Bailey/Bevan-Smith paper

At the core of Petra's assertions here is the paper by Dr Mark Bailey and Dr John Bevan-Smith: THE COVID-19 FRAUD & WAR ON HUMANITY. (The original is at academia.edu, but requires one to sign up to the site before it allows downloads.) It's fairly recent, having been published in November last year (2021.)

I'm asking for assistance in reviewing (or at least looking at) this paper. I simply don't have the time to learn enough about DNA, RNA, genomics, microbiology, virology, PCR, and pandemic modelling to say what they got right and where they may have gone wrong. Certainly I disagree with the conspiracy parts, and it appears that the publication of thousands of papers on the virus and COVID-19 make their conclusions incorrect. But at the moment I can't conclusively say, "Here's what you got wrong, and here are papers that show that."

Dr Mark Bailey describes himself as "a microbiology, medical industry and health researcher who worked in medical practice, including clinical trials, for two decades." He holds Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery degrees (equivalent to an MD in North America,) a Postgraduate Diploma in Musculoskeletal Medicine from the University of Otago in Christchurch, and a Master of Health Sciences degree. While I note none of those degrees show a specialty in microbiology, he may have studied it as part of his master of health sciences degree.

The other author, Dr. John Bevan-Smith, describes himself as "a business owner, author and researcher, who has undertaken research for the Waitangi Tribunal Te Rōpū Whakamana i te Tiriti o Waitangi/The Ministry of Justice Te Tāhū o te Ture." Searching further, I found here that he "holds a PhD in English and a First Class Honours degree in History from the University of Auckland. His particular interests include deconstruction and the discursive formation of meaning." In this context, he can provide input on how the media reports on things, and perhaps even how scientific papers can be truthful or misleading.

Part One of the paper is straight-up conspiracy thinking. It has a few footnotes that I haven't taken time to investigate more closely. The tail end of Part One and all of Part Two take a deeper dive into their ideas that the isolation of the SARS-Cov-2 virus, genomic sequencing, PCR. and the pandemic outbreak are all based on bad or fraudulent science, and as a result they conclude the entire pandemic is a massive scientific blunder and political fraud.
 
At the core of Petra's assertions here is the paper by Dr Mark Bailey and Dr John Bevan-Smith: THE COVID-19 FRAUD & WAR ON HUMANITY. (The original is at academia.edu, but requires one to sign up to the site before it allows downloads.) It's fairly recent, having been published in November last year (2021.)

I'm asking for assistance in reviewing (or at least looking at) this paper. I simply don't have the time to learn enough about DNA, RNA, genomics, microbiology, virology, PCR, and pandemic modelling to say what they got right and where they may have gone wrong. Certainly I disagree with the conspiracy parts, and it appears that the publication of thousands of papers on the virus and COVID-19 make their conclusions incorrect. But at the moment I can't conclusively say, "Here's what you got wrong, and here are papers that show that."

Dr Mark Bailey describes himself as "a microbiology, medical industry and health researcher who worked in medical practice, including clinical trials, for two decades." He holds Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery degrees (equivalent to an MD in North America,) a Postgraduate Diploma in Musculoskeletal Medicine from the University of Otago in Christchurch, and a Master of Health Sciences degree. While I note none of those degrees show a specialty in microbiology, he may have studied it as part of his master of health sciences degree.

The other author, Dr. John Bevan-Smith, describes himself as "a business owner, author and researcher, who has undertaken research for the Waitangi Tribunal Te Rōpū Whakamana i te Tiriti o Waitangi/The Ministry of Justice Te Tāhū o te Ture." Searching further, I found here that he "holds a PhD in English and a First Class Honours degree in History from the University of Auckland. His particular interests include deconstruction and the discursive formation of meaning." In this context, he can provide input on how the media reports on things, and perhaps even how scientific papers can be truthful or misleading.

Part One of the paper is straight-up conspiracy thinking. It has a few footnotes that I haven't taken time to investigate more closely. The tail end of Part One and all of Part Two take a deeper dive into their ideas that the isolation of the SARS-Cov-2 virus, genomic sequencing, PCR. and the pandemic outbreak are all based on bad or fraudulent science, and as a result they conclude the entire pandemic is a massive scientific blunder and political fraud.







This

P A R T O N E

THE GLOBALIST AGENDA

Make no mistake, we are currently being assailed by a worldwide fraud of such scale
and malevolence that it threatens our very existence as we know it on this planet.

should be reason enough to instantly stop reading this heap of bile.

In the end, most covidiots are also hateful brownshirts or even full fledged neo-nazis.
 
Last edited:
Please do not keep throwing at me numbers of papers or anything to do with numbers indicating something must be true. Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing.

They may mean nothing to you, but that says more about your ignorance of metrics, collation and statistical analysis than it does about the value of measurement, believe me.

Take the claim that MMR vaccines cause autism spectrum disorder. When a Danish study examined the medical records of a quarter million people who had had the MMR vaccines, and a quarter million who had not, and compared the rates of autism diagnosis between the two groups, they found that the rates of diagnosis were statistically identical. In other words, there was zero evidence for the claim that MMR vaccines cause autism. If the MMR shots had even a small influence on autism, it would have shown as an increase in diagnosis rate for the vaccinated group. But there was no difference. Whatever the cause or causes of autism, the MMR vaccines have **** all to do with it.

The response of one prominent anti-vaccine activist, when confronted with the results of the study, was to angrily say, "I don't give a ****!". That was a pathetic, but unsurprising response consistent with his unwillingness to even consider that he could be wrong. But the numbers utterly disproved his claims. He rejected them, however, because the construct he had built around himself made him feel special and important. Within it, he knew that he was smarter than everyone else and an heroic crusader against a cartoonish evil empire. When evidence took that away, he saw it as a personal attack against his ego - his feeling of superiority. What's most pathetic is that he obviously couldn't give less of a **** about finding what really causes autism unless it makes him feel special.

Whether you reject numbers because you suffer from dyscalculia or simply because they don't tell you what you want to hear, the data is no less real.
 
Last edited:
I really understand nothing about genomic sequencing but the bit I can understand is going from a virus to a genome sequence. To create a genome sequence I believe the claims by the critics of the mainstream narrative that you need an identified virus and we don't see that.

Not really, but that's beside the point. A lot of coronaviruses have been sequenced, and while the virus that causes Covid19 was clearly some kind of coronavirus, it was different enough to be classified as something new. Novel means new.

Now that you know that, you can stop putting "novel" in scare quotes.

Numbers mean nothing to me, OK? Absolutely nothing.

Obviously.

However, since understanding numbers (particularly used statistically) are important for understanding science, then you are going to have a hard time determining whether any papers/studies are scientific or not.

Now that you know that, you can stop claiming that one paper is more scientific than another. Or you could seek some education. It's up to you.
 
Seen on a bumper sticker . . .

But Did You Die?

Now we've seem some stupid anti-vax memes and tweets and facebook idiocy, but this struck me as cement-headed as it gets. Many who view this stupidity likely know someone who has died, is suffering from long COVID, or the various pulmonary, neurological and organ issues associated with contracting the virus.

So, is this person merely stupid, willfully ignorant, mentally ill, or just trolling? Or maybe all of these?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom