Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

Notes from the Field: A Novel Coronavirus Genome Identified in a Cluster of Pneumonia Cases — Wuhan, China 2019−2020
https://weekly.chinacdc.cn/en/article/id/a3907201-f64f-4154-a19e-4253b453d10c

"On January 3, 2020, the first complete genome of the novel β genus coronaviruses (2019-nCoVs) was identified in samples of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) from a patient from Wuhan by scientists of the National Institute of Viral Disease Control and Prevention (IVDC) through a combination of Sanger sequencing, Illumina sequencing, and nanopore sequencing. Three distinct strains have been identified, the virus has been designated as 2019-nCoV, and the disease has been subsequently named novel coronavirus-infected pneumonia (NCIP)."

Can you not see how unscientific this is? First there is no reason to suspect a novel virus - 44 cases of pneumonia without clear indications of something unusual about these 44 cases doesn't make a "cluster"
This is getting very tiresome. 44 cases of pneumonia in patients where the cause is unknown or is not readily determined is the very definition of a cluster!

and how do you identify any particular virus in bronchoalveolar lavage samples from a single patient?
It's right there in quote! "... through a combination of Sanger sequencing, Illumina sequencing, and nanopore sequencing." Yes, the sequence was obtained from samples taken from a single patient. Now it sounds like a pretty small sample size, but the same note goes on to say:

Tan said:
Several complete genome sequences of 2019-nCoVs were successfully obtained and released recently via www.gisaid.org to provide a first look at the molecular characteristics of this emerging pathogen, and all related information has also been reported to the World Health Organization (WHO). Several rapid and sensitive detection tests have been developed by China CDC and will be applied to the prevention and control of this 2019-nCoV outbreak.
The phrase "Several rapid and sensitive detection tests have been developed" implies the scientists later tested additional individuals and found the same virus present in them.

It is absurd in the extreme. There are no controlled experiments going on here in the alleged isolation of the virus. Where are the samples from the patients allegedly not suffering infection?
How do you know there was no "controlled experiment" here? And just what do you mean by "controlled experiment"?

The whole problem with virology is that they don't take samples from non-infected people and compare them and they add loads of stuff to their cultures which obviously can have an effect on the organisms they're testing.
And you know this how? Is it from some idiot bloviating in a video, or have you actually done a deep study on virology and determined this is the case?

If you can be bothered Sam Bailey exposes this lack of controlled experiment in her latest video.
https://odysee.com/@drsambailey:c/the-truth-about-viruses

No, I won't be bothered. I do not do argumentum ad videoæ. Instead, I recommend you go over to Reddit and spend some time reading posts in Tales from Tech Support (my specialty) or Just Rolled into the Shop, to see what happens when clueless people attempt to work on things they aren't skilled in.
 
Until someone provides evidence for those 44 patients with pneumonia in Wuhan to be regarded as a "cluster" - and I would have thought someone among all you apologists of the mainstream narrative would have done it by now - the suspicion of a "novel" virus is unscientific.
A: We have proof that John Doe is the killer here on this video.
B: Prove that's not a doppleganger in that video!
A: The victim's blood has been found on Doe's clothing.
B: Prove that's not a doppleganger in that video!
A: The murder weapon was found in Doe's car.
B: Prove that's not a doppleganger in that video!
A: Doe has confessed.
B: Prove that's not a doppleganger in that video!
 
The SARS-CoV-2 has been isolated, sequenced, and demonstrated to cause the illness COVID-19. Multiple times. Posters denying this are denying reality.
 
x-ray or cryo, the structures can't be beat

Many of the proteins that are part of this virus have been purified and their structures solved, a point that I have made before. There is a structure of the main protease bound to the key ingredient of Paxlovid, for example.

"Abstract
The unprecedented scale of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has catalyzed an intense effort of the global scientific community to unravel different aspects of the disease in a short time. One of the crucial aspects of these developments is the determination of more than three hundred experimental structures of SARS-CoV-2 proteins in the last few months. These include structures of viral non-structural, structural, and accessory proteins and their complexes determined by either X-ray diffraction or cryo-electron microscopy. These structures elucidate the intricate working of different components of the viral machinery at the atomic level during different steps of the viral life cycle, including attachment to the host cell, viral genome replication and transcription, and genome packaging and assembly of the virion. Some of these proteins are also potential targets for drug development against the disease. In this review, we discuss important structural features of different SARS-CoV-2 proteins with their function, and their potential as a target for therapeutic interventions." ScienceDirect
Arya R. et al., Journal of Molecular Biology Volume 433, Issue 2, 22 January 2021, 166725.
 
Last edited:
Many of the proteins that are part of this virus have been purified and their structures solved, a point that I have made before. There is a structure of the main protease bound to the key ingredient of Paxlovid, for example.

(respectful snip)

ScienceDirect
Arya R. et al., Journal of Molecular Biology Volume 433, Issue 2, 22 January 2021, 166725.

Thanks for the input, Chris, but in Petra's mind a random YouTuber or internet crank is just so much more reliable than a group of scientists who've spent their lives working on this stuff and get it published in peer-reviewed journals. :(
 
A path was followed to determine that a novel virus emerged that the world needed to be turned upside down for and I'm showing that that path is unscientific. It started, unscientifically, with an alleged "cluster" of 44 patients. Where did it go from there?

Even if you grant that the cluster is not what it was purported to be, and/or was dealt with unscientifically, there is still a vast amount of other, later evidence supporting the existence of the novel coronavirus, which is the evidence you are ignoring.

Don't ignore evidence; it is unscientific, especially when the amount of evidence is vast.
 
So the Christine Massey cited by Petra and her fellow travelers is neither a microbiologist nor a psychologist, but a soi-disant biostatistician and inveterate nutjob in the tradition of General Jack T Ripper.

I apologize for my error.

And I apologise for mine too. Its even worse than I thought - Christine Massey is a Flake bar who has no qualifications at all!
 
Just stopped into this thread to see where it's gone...and...

Okay...

The claim now is that COVID-19 doesn't exist? Who can believe this in 2022? I could see if this was 1894, but we have microscopes, and DNA/RNA sequencing, and all kinds of medical advances which make it possible not only to identify viruses, but photograph them - in color - and dissect them to understand the makeup of their structures, and we can sequence them.

This isn't even news any more.

The idea that medical information is faked or suppressed is comical. Just look at the last two years. EVERY counter-claim about COVID-19 and alternate treatments has been shut down like the sad clown-show it is.

The COVID CTists aren't even trying any more. They're as bad as the Bigfoot crowd now.

The thing I love most is this forum has a science board where the virus thread is a productive source for useful information thanks to those who post there being qualified medical professional, and scientist. I don't post in that thread because I have nothing intelligent to add. Here I'm a reformed CTist doing my time and penance point calling current CTists on their BS. And ALL of the COVID-19 CTs are BS, and really pedestrian, kindergarten-level CTs at that.
 
The claim now is that COVID-19 doesn't exist?


The claim now seems to be that there shouldn’t be any evidence that COVID-19 exists because investigating the cause of a cluster of unexplained cases of pneumonia was “unscientific”.
 
Just stopped into this thread to see where it's gone...and...

Okay...

The claim now is that COVID-19 doesn't exist? Who can believe this in 2022? I could see if this was 1894, but we have microscopes, and DNA/RNA sequencing, and all kinds of medical advances which make it possible not only to identify viruses, but photograph them - in color - and dissect them to understand the makeup of their structures, and we can sequence them.

(respectful snip)

With regards to the highlighted, a couple of people who wrote a paper titled The COVID-19 Fraud & War on Humanity [pdf]. One of the authors is a qualified medical doctor who's been practicing in New Zealand for over twenty years. The other has a Ph.D. in English.

The paper claims viruses don't exist, any genomic sequencing is suspect due to massive contamination (and because viruses don't exist,) PCR can't be used to identify viruses (because they don't exist!) and electron microphotographs are merely artists' impressions.
 
With regards to the highlighted, a couple of people who wrote a paper titled The COVID-19 Fraud & War on Humanity [pdf]. One of the authors is a qualified medical doctor who's been practicing in New Zealand for over twenty years. The other has a Ph.D. in English.

The paper claims viruses don't exist, any genomic sequencing is suspect due to massive contamination (and because viruses don't exist,) PCR can't be used to identify viruses (because they don't exist!) and electron microphotographs are merely artists' impressions.

Yeah. but Mark Bailey and John Bevan-Smith are both nutcases
 
Even if you grant that the cluster is not what it was purported to be, and/or was dealt with unscientifically, there is still a vast amount of other, later evidence supporting the existence of the novel coronavirus, which is the evidence you are ignoring.
The mere fact that vaccines were developed which drastically reduced cases of severe illness and death in the vaccinated compared to the unvaccinated is conclusive proof that both the virus, and the disease it produces, exist. That anyone could fool themselves into a position where they are obliged to deny such simple and incontrovertible facts beggars belief.
 
With regards to the highlighted, a couple of people who wrote a paper titled The COVID-19 Fraud & War on Humanity [pdf]. One of the authors is a qualified medical doctor who's been practicing in New Zealand for over twenty years. The other has a Ph.D. in English.

The paper claims viruses don't exist, any genomic sequencing is suspect due to massive contamination (and because viruses don't exist,) PCR can't be used to identify viruses (because they don't exist!) and electron microphotographs are merely artists' impressions.

That's just embarrassing on every level.

And who the hell gets a Ph.D. in English? I'm embarrassed I have an AA in English because I got it by accident.
 
Natural Health exercise for them in need of it:

Fail


Story at-a-glance

Facebook has admitted in a court of law that its fact checkers are not asserting facts but, rather, First Amendment-protected opinions
Steve Kirsch, founder of the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund, recorded a phone call with a fact checker from PolitiFact, showing just how ignorant the fact checker is about the facts, and how unwilling she is to look at the data
Edited by jimbob: 
Rule 4


https://articles.mercola.com/sites/...cid=20220310_HL2&mid=DM1130773&rid=1429931863
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I follow the debunking trail, I have no interest in how many thousands of papers have been produced. I only "trust" when I'm forced to such as going into surgery. Otherwise, I only accept information as given because I feel I have no reason to doubt it or I'm not really bothered. When I am bothered I don't "trust" because of numbers of people saying something, I follow the debunking trail because I think that's a far better method than relying on "scientific consensus" or similar. Power influences everything and it's well-known that Big Pharma influences scientific studies - if you don't get that you are very, very naive. Even when I believe the scientific consensus I still follow the debunking trail because I think we must always look at both sides.

Microbiologist, Christine Massey, has organised a FOI campaign to health authorities and governments about isolation of the virus and according to the specified criteria, all health authorities and governments have admitted they are not in possession of such proof of isolation. In that case, what needs to happen is that those supporting the mainstream narrative must argue that isolation according to the specified criteria is not required for isolation to occur. No one has done that.
https://truthcomestolight.com/the-non-existent-virus-an-explosive-interview-with-christine-massey/

Going back to this claim, another thought struck me, which was this: Petra claims to be following the debunking trail, right? Petra was the one who introduced this FOI request claim into the debate. Petra further claimed that no-one had given a proper answer to these requests, and that none of the authorities contacted were in possession of such proof of isolation.
The later claim from Petra, that she was unaware of the response from Sinai that I quoted, shows she had not, in fact, 'followed the debunking trail' at all. In actual fact, she had not read the responses to the FOI requests herself at all, and consequently was not aware that there had been a specific and factual response, and that the response explained clearly why the information requested was not available.
Moreover, the linked interview with Massey grievously misrepresents the responses that were received, and omits the fact that Massey was asked to clarify her request, but failed to do so.
In summary, then, Petra has gullibly and unquestioningly swallowed the dishonest narrative spun by Massey, and not actually checked it at all- and then arrived on this site to insist the complete opposite.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom