[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why you #☆¿%× elitist!

....I...urge Governments to restrict anti-vaxxers in every way shape and form to limit the damage they can do to my body.

That'll just create a 2-tier society! Upper-class vaccinator snooties up above lower-class freedom-lover patriot good guys!

And this just in: The president of new Zealand, that brazen grinning strumpet-wannabe, was already asked if that's what she wanted, AND SHE COME RIGHT OUT N SAID, "YEP!"

They're coming for us!

Mr. Tippit sir, can I borrow some ammo?
 
So frightened of an iddy-biddy widdle needle, these snowflakes, these safe-spacers threaten with boolets.

I wonder if they realize their kind aren't the only ones that are armed, not that these cowards are really going to do anything about it.
 
Last edited:
Clinger, study the Drosten paper and its rebuttal. Everybody who does so can only cringe at your latest post.

Some people are really good at cringing. It's a skill you can perfect through practice, especially if you fully dedicate yourself to cringing by neglecting all other skills.

From your previous cringing, I assume you refer to
Corman Victor M, Landt Olfert, Kaiser Marco, Molenkamp Richard, Meijer Adam, Chu Daniel KW, Bleicker Tobias, Brünink Sebastian, Schneider Julia, Schmidt Marie Luisa, Mulders Daphne GJC, Haagmans Bart L, van der Veer Bas, van den Brink Sharon, Wijsman Lisa, Goderski Gabriel, Romette Jean-Louis, Ellis Joanna, Zambon Maria, Peiris Malik, Goossens Herman, Reusken Chantal, Koopmans Marion PG, Drosten Christian. Detection of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR. Euro Surveill. 2020;25(3) : pii=2000045. https://doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.3.2000045​

I also assume you are cringing in chorus with Pieter Borger et al, lead author of a group of 22 who wanted Eurosurveillance to retract the Corman et al paper cited above.
Frank Visser said:
The main spokesman of the ICSLS group is Dutch creationist (of the Young Earth variety) and geneticist Pieter Borger (aka Peter Borger, aka Peer Terborg), author of the book Darwin Revisited: Or How to Understand Biology in the 21st Century. Earlier this year, Borger wrote an article about SARS-CoV-2, claiming it was just a weak version of SARS-CoV. It was published in The American Journal of Biomedical Science and Research, a predatory journal without scientific merit (under the rubric "Mini review"). Borger doesn't really believe in evolution, but rather in degeneration (after divine creation has set things up). Since October 2019, Borger works for the Wort & Wissen Studiengemeinschaft, a creationist society.
I am not competent to wade into this brouhaha pitting the authors of an influential paper against a young earth creationist, "a molecular geneticist, a former 3D artist, a toxicologist, a pathologist, a sequencing expert, an urologist, a biochemist, a microbiologist, a director of an infectious disease ward, an internist/cardiologist, a radiologist, a microbiology and immunology emeritus professor, a microbiologist, a clinical chemist, an environmental chemist, a radiologist, a geneticist/immunologist, a general practitioner, a consultant-neurologist, a molecular biologist, a social scientist and a virologist."

I do note, however, that the Corman et al paper does not appear to have been retracted, and (as I write) has been cited 1780 times.

Just for grins, I will also quote one of Borger et al's "MAJOR CONCERNS WITH THE CORMAN-DROSTEN PAPER":
Pieter Borger et al said:
According to BBC News [4] and Google Statistics [5] there were 6 deaths world-wide on January 21st 2020 – the day when the manuscript was submitted. Why did the authors assume a challenge for public health laboratories while there was no substantial evidence at that time to indicate that the outbreak was more widespread than initially thought?
Corman et al sure got that wrong, didn't they?
 
Last edited:
Y'all actually might try to understand what the "paper" says, and what the rebuttal says. Instead of parroting what you find on wikipedia without any original thought.

Good luck.
 
Y'all actually might try to understand what the "paper" says, and what the rebuttal says. Instead of parroting what you find on wikipedia without any original thought.

Good luck.

Frank Visser's PCR-Gate: A Storm in a Petri Dish? explains what the paper and rebuttal say, in language that scientifically literate non-specialists should be able to understand.

ETA: For those whose expertise extends beyond cringing, but don't want to bother reading Visser's fairly long explanation, here is (the gist of) Eurosurveillance's response, based on a five-month review by five external experts the journal asked to evaluate the request for retraction:
The consulted experts confirmed that the Corman et al. article was scientifically adequate for its purpose and for the limited data and material available at this early stage in the COVID-19 pandemic. Any laboratory deciding to use the primers and protocol suggested in this article would ascertain the assay for its fitness for purpose and compliance with local quality and accreditation requirements; this is what has happened worldwide since the publication of the article. With more data and evolving knowledge, laboratories have since further improved the initial method, as per usual practice.

In conclusion, after a thorough investigation in which we collected scientific advice from various sources, including several external reviewers, the editorial team—unanimously supported by its associate editors, except for those who were involved as co-authors—has decided that the criteria for a retraction of the article have not been fulfilled.
 
Last edited:
We know the false positivity rate is far lower than that. The false positive rate depends on the prevalence in the population. If there is no Covid and you have a false positivity rate of 1 in 100k, and perform several hundred thousand tests, you'd expect to get a handful of positive results. The false positive rate would be 100% as they would all be false.


Australia has had periods where there have been hundreds of thousands of consecutive negative results, which means that the false positivity rate is no more than parts per million.

It's not quite that simple. There are apparently issues with the "cycle threshold" for PCR which enable the results to be gamed. For instance, there were symptomatic people who had been recently infected but cleared the virus, and even people who were asymptomatically infected and cleared the virus, but they will often test positive even though the virus has been sterilized, according whether the cycle threshold is set high enough.

We want to know whether or not people are contagious, not whether there is detectible deactivated virus in their bodies, and PCR fails at this, and/or can be gamed to obtain a desired result.
 
I may be wrong (often am) but it was my impression that the issue with resistant bacterial strains and antibiotics is that it selects for variants, not that it creates them, and that it happens only if you've already contracted the disease, not if you haven't. Bubba's source sounds as if it suggests that partial immunity actually makes the viruses mutate in ways they would not ordinarily, and that seems dubious.

Actually, I think bruto is perfectly on-target- the bit he quoted from Bubba's post is both total BS and eye-rollingly stupid, because it's the usual characterization as a normative process of one that is not. The mutations do not happen as a response to "pressure on the virus to mutate"- their survival as populations (as with your antibiotic-resistant infections) is a result of having mutated, but the mutations themselves are random. As bruto says, there's no group of viruses running around yelling "quick! Think of something! I know- mutate!" and then becoming super-viruses as an act of will, or by some direction. They don't become mutations in order to survive, they survive (and reproduce) because they are mutations.

Fair enough. I was being perhaps excessively generous, as I usually am with obviously non-scientific claimants, and allowing a little conflation between selective pressure and mutations. The mutations will happen either way, after all, so it's really just how likely they are to survive and spread. I was thus allowing the "pressure on the virus to mutate" bit to stand under the generous assumption that it was speaking on the level of strains that become widespread enough for information on them to reach the public.
 
We submit to you that Covid-19 viruses may gain their lethality from mass psychosis and the nocebo effect.
I've just learned that my friend's wife has died of COVID-19. She was in her late 40s and they have a teenage daughter. If only she'd known that COVIID-19 only exists if you believe in it, like ******* fairies.

The rules here are 'attack the argument'. Well your argument is ******* stupid.

German propagandist Joseph Goebbels said that if you repeat anything enough times, most people will start to believe it...
So when you lied about seeing Anthony Fauci featured in news media all over the world you shouldn't have given up so easily. You should have repeated it over and over until it became as real as the high speed rail service between London and Liverpool.
 
I think it's a depopulation program.

It's been six months and the vaccines aren't depopulating the planet yet.

How long do we have to wait?

How many months before you admit you were wrong? ...move on to some new conspiracy theory and pretend you never said any of this, like Bubba with Trump's reinstatement?
 
So frightened of an iddy-biddy widdle needle, these snowflakes, these safe-spacers threaten with boolets.
Oh, make no mistake, I hate needles and injections and bodily invasions of any sort. I just hate it. But I was top of the queue for the vax. And will be top of the queue when a booster rocks up. Despite my dislike of such. I am not daft enough to do myself harm (or others) because of some irrational fear of science. At this point in my life, I have plastics and metals inserted in my body. Can't say I enjoyed the experience, but had I not, I would be dead. So I can put up with the extension of life. Suits me better than being dead.
 
It's been six months and the vaccines aren't depopulating the planet yet.

How long do we have to wait?

How many months before you admit you were wrong? ...move on to some new conspiracy theory and pretend you never said any of this, like Bubba with Trump's reinstatement?

Nutjob reset. Over and over and OVAH!!
 
Oh, make no mistake, I hate needles and injections and bodily invasions of any sort. I just hate it. But I was top of the queue for the vax. And will be top of the queue when a booster rocks up. Despite my dislike of such. I am not daft enough to do myself harm (or others) because of some irrational fear of science. At this point in my life, I have plastics and metals inserted in my body. Can't say I enjoyed the experience, but had I not, I would be dead. So I can put up with the extension of life. Suits me better than being dead.
Oh sure, I'm not all that fond of blood draws and such, but I get over it after the initial prick. The pricks I'm talking about are these faux tough guys threatening violence over a simple, near-painless injection that has been demonstrated over and over and ovah to be effective in combatting COVID-19. First they threaten the general welfare with their noxious anti-vax propaganda, then with threats of violence.

Such wimpy snowflakes.
 
Oh sure, I'm not all that fond of blood draws and such, but I get over it after the initial prick. The pricks I'm talking about are these faux tough guys threatening violence over a simple, near-painless injection that has been demonstrated over and over and ovah to be effective in combatting COVID-19. First they threaten the general welfare with their noxious anti-vax propaganda, then with threats of violence.

Such wimpy snowflakes.

Look on the bright side. On one of my medical misadventures I had one of those NDE/OOBE things on the slab. It was hilarious.
 
Every time someone claims PCR Covid-19 tests have been rigged to produce false positives, it reminds me...

In the summer of 2020 I got sick, with a cough, fever, severe body aches, and just about every other symptom associated with Covid-19 at the time. I thought I had Covid. My doctor thought I had Covid. By the time I was able to be tested (tests still took some time to get an appointment back then) I was hoping it was Covid, because it hadn't gotten any worse over 10 days so it looked likely I would escape with a moderate case and then have some immunity.

Only problem was, my Covid tests kept coming up negative. Even then, my doctor thought they might be false negatives. But weeks later, we finally discovered I had a different disease.

There was the perfect opportunity to add to the case numbers, gin up some more hysteria, pop out another false positive test result. But the test didn't deliver. It insisted on a truthful result that wasn't what anyone wanted or expected instead. Go figure.
 
Last edited:
Every time someone claims PCR Covid-19 tests have been rigged to produce false positives, it reminds me...

In the summer of 2020 I got sick, with a cough, fever, severe body aches, and just about every other symptom associated with Covid-19 at the time. I thought I had Covid. My doctor thought I had Covid. By the time I was able to be tested (tests still took some time to get an appointment back then) I was hoping it was Covid, because it hadn't gotten any worse over 10 days so it looked likely I would escape with a moderate case and then have some immunity.

Only problem was, my Covid tests kept coming up negative. Even then, my doctor thought they might be false negatives. But weeks later, we finally discovered I had a different disease.

There was the perfect opportunity to add to the case numbers, gin up some more hysteria, pop out another false positive test result. But the test didn't deliver. It insisted on a truthful result that wasn't what anyone wanted or expected instead. Go figure.

[CT mode]Ah, but you are obviously a cousin of the guy who started the conspiracy and therefor are a shill doing it for the money.....[/CT mode]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom