[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
I honestly do not know what else to say to that bit but "wow." :jaw-dropp I mean, you honestly cannot see how ass-backward to actual science that is, can you? So blinded by your own need to poison the well that science provides for us to drink from, you really will say that it's up to each individual to test what is fact for themselves...and accuse me of some "new religion"? My gosh, man, you're not doing anything more original than the same old humdrum religion thing folks have been doing for time out of mind- what you're talking about, with your "up to each individual to falsify hypotheses" nonsense, is prayer, not science.

On the contrary, I am pointing out what actual science really is. It's testing new hypotheses, or the hypotheses of others, using new experiments or reproducing the experiments of others. If you can't reproduce the experiment for whatever reason, then you are operating outside the realm of falsifiability, and in the realm of faith and trust, which is precisely what peer-review and meta-analysis is. This is not to say that peer-review never confirms actual science - it does, all the time. It is to say that peer-review with all of its attendant biases, coupled with the inherent selection biases and conflicts of interest surrounding the for-profit medical science industry with its emphasis on proprietary drugs and procedures illuminates a way which, in many cases, is far from the best way for a healthy society.
 
On the contrary, I am pointing out what actual science really is. It's testing new hypotheses, or the hypotheses of others, using new experiments or reproducing the experiments of others. If you can't reproduce the experiment for whatever reason, then you are operating outside the realm of falsifiability, and in the realm of faith and trust, which is precisely what peer-review and meta-analysis is. This is not to say that peer-review never confirms actual science - it does, all the time. It is to say that peer-review with all of its attendant biases, coupled with the inherent selection biases and conflicts of interest surrounding the for-profit medical science industry with its emphasis on proprietary drugs and procedures illuminates a way which, in many cases, is far from the best way for a healthy society.

That's just, like, your opinion, man. :dc_unhappy:
 

I'm a 50-something Brit. We're close to 90% vaccinated. That chart shows in my age group there are 2 vaccinated people catching Covid-19 for every 1 unvaccinated person catching it.

But there are 9 vaccinated people for every 1 unvaccinated. If the vaccines didn't work there ought to be a 9 to 1 ratio. But it's only 2 to 1. For every unvaccinated person becoming infected there are 2 vaccinated people who become infected plus another 7 vaccinated people who don't.


I have no idea what you are talking about. Your age group shows 5399 unvaccinated and 76119 vaccinated "cases". The columns to the right show the ratio per 100.000. It's more than twice for the "fully" vaccinated.
 
Last edited:
Serious illness/death from catching Covid 19 is a clear and present danger, especially for someone my age (68). As far as I can see the hypothetical risk you're talking about exists almost entirely in the fevered imaginations of rabid antvaxxers.

Now you just stop that! My hero or heroine CE* lives in fear and likes it!

* There's some uncertainty.
 
No worry, they will fix it

https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/red-voice-media/

Do you deliberately not cite your sources because you know how biased and untrustworthy they are?

When you go to the Daily Mail article that Red Voice re-reports (that's some stellar journalism, right there) they include the part where they say that the condition is very rare.

So a small portion of the eligible population is being told to take the other vaccine because of a rare side effect that may be affecting that group. Older people are not being steered away from the Moderna vaccine.

So what's your point, Bubba? Some five million people have died from COVID-19. How many have been affected by the heart inflammation issue?
 
Here is a clue for you. Any hypothesis that isn't falsifiable, isn't scientific, and any hypothesis which cannot be practically tested and the associated experiments reproduced by common individuals is therefore not practically falsifiable. . . .

Bait and switch.
 
Here is a clue for you. Any hypothesis that isn't falsifiable, isn't scientific, and any hypothesis which cannot be practically tested and the associated experiments reproduced by common individuals is therefore not practically falsifiable.

Well, that's the Higgs Boson stuffed.

Unless you have an LHC in your basement? :eye-poppi
 

I'm a 50-something Brit. We're close to 90% vaccinated. That chart shows in my age group there are 2 vaccinated people catching Covid-19 for every 1 unvaccinated person catching it.

But there are 9 vaccinated people for every 1 unvaccinated. If the vaccines didn't work there ought to be a 9 to 1 ratio. But it's only 2 to 1. For every unvaccinated person becoming infected there are 2 vaccinated people who become infected plus another 7 vaccinated people who don't.


I have no idea what you are talking about. Your age group shows 5399 unvaccinated and 76119 vaccinated "cases". The columns to the right show the ratio per 100.000. It's more than twice for the "fully" vaccinated.

Well done, you have actually found some official data.

However the NIMS population estimates have issues - overestimating the unvaccinated population in the working age groups.

https://www.theguardian.com/theobse...th-claims-about-unvaccinated-case-rates-covid

But even when you look at that data for serious illness.

[IMGW=640]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FAYaUC1VUA8pLQJ?format=png&name=900x900[/IMGW]

or death

either at 28 days

[IMGW=640]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FAYaXeUXMAIXQhn?format=png&name=900x900[/IMGW]

or 60 days after a positive Covid test result

[IMGW=640]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FAYabO3VgBAyk6f?format=png&name=900x900[/IMGW]

you can see that the vaccine is providing a significant protection (in fact these graphs are understating it - see the Guardian link above for a discussion about using the NIMS population estimates vs the ONS population estimates to assess the unvaccinated populations.

Graphs from Wk38 version of https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccine-surveillance-report so data for wks 34-37
 
I have no idea what you are talking about. Your age group shows 5399 unvaccinated and 76119 vaccinated "cases". The columns to the right show the ratio per 100.000. It's more than twice for the "fully" vaccinated.

Yes, my apologies. Completely failed to engage brain before responding. There's clearly something more interesting than a simple numbers game going on there and it now reminds me it was actually explored in a recent episode of the More or Less statistics podcast.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000zkzq

Ironically it starts by mentioning the same base rate fallacy I stumbled over. But then it goes on to say the problem is the difficulty of accurately estimating the number of unvaccinated people. We know the numbers vaccinated , but we don't know the total population so accurately. The figure used is based on the numbers registered with doctors, but that tends to overestimate as it includes a proportion of double counting as people move around and register with more than one doctor, and others will have left the country. The larger the number of vaccinated people, the more these errors are magnified. If you use Office of National Statistics estimates for the total population instead, you get results suggesting the cases in unvaccinated people is about double that in vaccinated people. Interesting show.
 
Well, that's the Higgs Boson stuffed.

Unless you have an LHC in your basement? :eye-poppi

It's not "stuffed", it means that you must necessarily take the claims made by the scientists working with the hadron collider on faith, because you can't practically reproduce their experiments. The reproduceability of scientific experiments via the scientific method is the only thing that holds fallible human scientists and their claims to account.
 
This spoiler just quotes more context.
Here is a clue for you. Any hypothesis that isn't falsifiable, isn't scientific, and any hypothesis which cannot be practically tested and the associated experiments reproduced by common individuals is therefore not practically falsifiable. The overwhelming majority of medical science falls under this category, requiring tens of millions of dollars in capital and lab equipment to properly reproduce experiments for its proprietary drugs and procedures. You are merely an acolyte of the new religion, pseudo-science, which given the limitations of peer-review and meta-analysis (selection bias, confirmation bias, conflict of interest, and many more problems) means that you are placing almost religious faith in the claims of a tiny few "scientists", and those presumably qualified to review their studies.

The laundry list of class action lawsuits over toxic failed drugs and procedures proves this. Peer review is far from perfect, and scientists are corruptible, fallible human beings.

I honestly do not know what else to say to that bit but "wow." :jaw-dropp I mean, you honestly cannot see how ass-backward to actual science that is, can you? So blinded by your own need to poison the well that science provides for us to drink from, you really will say that it's up to each individual to test what is fact for themselves...and accuse me of some "new religion"? My gosh, man, you're not doing anything more original than the same old humdrum religion thing folks have been doing for time out of mind- what you're talking about, with your "up to each individual to falsify hypotheses" nonsense, is prayer, not science.

On the contrary, I am pointing out what actual science really is. It's testing new hypotheses, or the hypotheses of others, using new experiments or reproducing the experiments of others. If you can't reproduce the experiment for whatever reason, then you are operating outside the realm of falsifiability, and in the realm of faith and trust, which is precisely what peer-review and meta-analysis is. This is not to say that peer-review never confirms actual science - it does, all the time. It is to say that peer-review with all of its attendant biases, coupled with the inherent selection biases and conflicts of interest surrounding the for-profit medical science industry with its emphasis on proprietary drugs and procedures illuminates a way which, in many cases, is far from the best way for a healthy society.

That's just, like, your opinion, man. :dc_unhappy:

Well, that's the Higgs Boson stuffed.

Unless you have an LHC in your basement? :eye-poppi
Here is a clue for you. Any hypothesis that isn't falsifiable, isn't scientific, and any hypothesis which cannot be practically tested and the associated experiments reproduced by common individuals is therefore not practically falsifiable. The overwhelming majority of medical science falls under this category, requiring tens of millions of dollars in capital and lab equipment to properly reproduce experiments for its proprietary drugs and procedures. You are merely an acolyte of the new religion, pseudo-science, which given the limitations of peer-review and meta-analysis (selection bias, confirmation bias, conflict of interest, and many more problems) means that you are placing almost religious faith in the claims of a tiny few "scientists", and those presumably qualified to review their studies.


According to Tippit, none of the following counts as science:
  • E2 = (pc)2 + (mc2)2
    (special relativity, atomic bomb, nuclear power, etc)​
  • Rμν - ½Rgμν + Λgμν = (8πG/c4)Tμν
    (general relativity, modern cosmology, GPS, etc)​
  • iℏ(∂Ψ/∂t) = ĤΨ
    (quantum mechanics, transistors, magnetic resonance imaging)​
  • recombinant DNA technology
    (medical tests, most insulin, vaccines, most US hard cheese)​
  • diffraction crystallography
    (structure of DNA, materials science and engineering)​
  • et cetera, et cetera
 
It's not "stuffed", it means that you must necessarily take the claims made by the scientists working with the hadron collider on faith, because you can't practically reproduce their experiments. The reproduceability of scientific experiments via the scientific method is the only thing that holds fallible human scientists and their claims to account.
I don't know about you, but I would have thought that the idea of reproducibility means that somebody can reproduce the experiments, not that I must do so myself. Otherwise, you know, we'd be pretty far behind. I got the wheel not long ago, but I'm still a bit fuzzy on thermionic emission, and my vacuum pump broke down, so we must take heterodyne radios on faith.
 
I don't know about you, but I would have thought that the idea of reproducibility means that somebody can reproduce the experiments, not that I must do so myself. Otherwise, you know, we'd be pretty far behind. I got the wheel not long ago, but I'm still a bit fuzzy on thermionic emission, and my vacuum pump broke down, so we must take heterodyne radios on faith.

I wonder if he doubted if planes could fly and built one himself before getting aboard?
 
According to Tippit, none of the following counts as science:

  • E2 = (pc)2 + (mc2)2
    (special relativity, atomic bomb, nuclear power, etc)​
  • Rμν - ½Rgμν + Λgμν = (8πG/c4)Tμν
    (general relativity, modern cosmology, GPS, etc)​
  • iℏ(∂Ψ/∂t) = ĤΨ
    (quantum mechanics, transistors, magnetic resonance imaging)​
  • recombinant DNA technology
    (medical tests, most insulin, vaccines, most US hard cheese)​
  • diffraction crystallography
    (structure of DNA, materials science and engineering)​
  • et cetera, et cetera

That's an uncharitable and inaccurate accusation, not to mention unsurprising coming from you. First of all, that is a diverse list where you have mixed some theoretical sciences with mature technologies. It's not that they don't count as science, it's that some of them don't represent practical science to the extent that some of them cannot be practically falsified. Have you personally conducted any experiments testing the theory of special relativity? If so, congratulations, you're probably a theoretical physicist. If not, you're just parroting the claims of others on the internet. That doesn't mean you aren't discussing science, it means you lack any independent means to verify any of the claims or test any of the theories being submitted. This doesn't disqualify them as science, but it does introduce doubt to the degree that the claims being made aren't practically falsifiable. Furthermore, just because you made a list, doesn't mean that science can explain everything about those subjects, as there are a great many unknowns. For instance, just because Jonas Salk created the polio vaccine in 1953, doesn't mean we know everything about immunobiology in 2021. This certainly hasn't stopped people like you from acting like you do.
 
I wonder if he doubted if planes could fly and built one himself before getting aboard?

Every time I step on a plane I doubt whether not it will fly me safely to my destination, but I act on my faith in aeronautics anyway. The fact that I've also born witness to the repeated experiments of plane flights is also reassuring. Yet, I have no scientific claims to parrot about aeronautics. Computer science is a different story.
 
I don't know about you, but I would have thought that the idea of reproducibility means that somebody can reproduce the experiments, not that I must do so myself. Otherwise, you know, we'd be pretty far behind. I got the wheel not long ago, but I'm still a bit fuzzy on thermionic emission, and my vacuum pump broke down, so we must take heterodyne radios on faith.

It does mean that, but it also means that for those experiments that you cannot practically reproduce for yourself, that you should necessarily be more skeptical of published results.

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. - Clarke's 3rd law.
 
It does mean that, but it also means that for those experiments that you cannot practically reproduce for yourself, that you should necessarily be more skeptical of published results.

"More" skeptical is fine to a point.

"Entirely skeptical even in the face of strong evidence for and dubious/circumstantial evidence against" is a whole other realm.

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. - Clarke's 3rd law.

That's a literary trope describing a more realistic response of less advanced peoples. It is for the benefit of fellow writers.

It has nothing to do with the discipline of scientific inquiry.
 
Last edited:
That's a literary trope describing a more realistic response of less advanced peoples. It is for the benefit of fellow writers.

It has nothing to do with the discipline of scientific inquiry.

I'm well aware of the context for that quote. It's relevant to my specific claim that anyone who cannot practically falsify a scientific theory essentially qualifies as a "less advanced person".

You can pick up an iPhone, press a few buttons, and a pizza may show up at your door a few minutes later. You may even have some vague ideas about how it worked. But for all intents and purposes, it's magic to most people, less so to people like me.
 
Last edited:
According to Tippit, none of the following counts as science:
  • E2 = (pc)2 + (mc2)2
    (special relativity, atomic bomb, nuclear power, etc)​
  • Rμν - ½Rgμν + Λgμν = (8πG/c4)Tμν
    (general relativity, modern cosmology, GPS, etc)​
  • iℏ(∂Ψ/∂t) = ĤΨ
    (quantum mechanics, transistors, magnetic resonance imaging)​
  • recombinant DNA technology
    (medical tests, most insulin, vaccines, most US hard cheese)​
  • diffraction crystallography
    (structure of DNA, materials science and engineering)​
  • et cetera, et cetera

That's an uncharitable and inaccurate accusation, not to mention unsurprising coming from you.
It's an entirely accurate observation.

You wrote:
There is no science but those hypotheses that you can directly reproduce, individually.
You may regret writing such a foolish claim, but you did write it.

First of all, that is a diverse list where you have mixed some theoretical sciences with mature technologies.
The mature technologies I listed were applications of the theoretical sciences I listed.

It's not that they don't count as science, it's that some of them don't represent practical science to the extent that some of them cannot be practically falsified.
Your foolish claim, which I quoted above, did not limit itself to practical science. If you intended to limit the scope of your foolish claim, you should have done so. Even with that limited scope, your claim would have been foolish.

Have you personally conducted any experiments testing the theory of special relativity?
Well, let's see. I guess I've tested that theory by plugging a lamp into an AC outlet to consume electricity generated by nuclear power. I have also viewed photographs of Hiroshima and Nagasaki as they appeared following a dramatic public test of special relativity.

If not, you're just parroting the claims of others on the internet.
No, because I understand the science of special relativity well enough to realize nuclear power plants and atomic bombs are tests of special relativity.

You shouldn't assume others have no more understanding of science than you yourself.
 
I'm well aware of the context for that quote. It's relevant to my specific claim that anyone who cannot practically falsify a scientific theory essentially qualifies as a "less advanced person".

You can pick up an iPhone, press a few buttons, and a pizza may show up at your door a few minutes later. You may even have some vague ideas about how it worked. But for all intents and purposes, it's magic to most people, less so to people like me.

How did you verify that semiconductors are even real?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom