[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
Imagining that posters in this forum "hate" the conspiracy peddlers here is a case of big-time, numero uno Psychological Projection. I don't hate any of these people.


I believe it. Good on ya.

I should have 'some' here are haters, although it is all just in fun, surely.

Without looking very far, we have this.


It's okay to hate some people.



It's okay. I like being evil.



What Tippit said still applies, to some here.
 
projection!


No, the point was that totalitarians would ditch the first amendment, so that, for example, they could jail the thousands of doctors they want to silence. In lieu of that power, Biden gave FB a list of doctors' and other names for silencing, gleefully celebrated by some in this room.


The fact that the totalitarian minded are now being exposed (by their own words) is a credit to the free speech they would happily stifle..

Note that university was perhaps the main bastion (and purpose) of the free exchange of ideas, and campus totalitarians are working 24/7 to stifle free speech on campus. They smash and burn stuff when voices they dislike speak on campus.


So "projection"...?

I think that sounds clueless, and way more like projection on your part.

Why do you want to silence thousands of doctors doing their job during this so called pandemic ?
 
Last edited:
No, the point was that totalitarians would ditch the first amendment, so that, for example, they could jail the thousands of doctors they want to silence. In lieu of that power, Biden gave FB a list of doctors' and other names for silencing, gleefully celebrated by some in this room.
Your first amendment does not apply to 95% of the entire planet, but you think it somehow does because...reasons. You goobermint can do whatever it likes because you elected it. What part of democracy do you fail to comprehend? Could "they" jail thousands of doctors? Of course not. Because "they" do not rule every country.

So yeah. You are projecting your imaginary gooberment on everyone else.

No idea why you do that, but it is patently false every time you do it.
 
We have that already, it's called a court of law. Libel and Slander are actionable (that means you can be sued for a lot of money for you slow people). If someone can show financial, physical, or psychological harm due to misinformation spread by a person or on a media platform they can be awarded compensation.

We're not talking about Libel or Slander. We're talking about Chinese Communist Party-like censorship on google search, youtube, and numerous social media platforms.

This is why you cannot yell fire in a crowded theater, or sell milk laced with mercury claiming it will cure cancer. This is why a tabloid cannot make claims an actor is gay without documentation...

Lol. Selling milk laced with mercury isn't Libel or Slander, it's poisoning/food tampering. Yet selling vaccines with mercury as a preservative - perfectly acceptable. Oh, wait, it's Ethylmercury don't you worry, which is 100% harmless (so you, and the other pseudo-skeptical clowns here claim, with 100% certainty). Does this mean I can sell milk laced with Ethylmercury to increase the shelf life? I'll wait for your collective heads to explode.

...and this is why social media platforms cannot allow people to post lies about a virus, or treatments for a virus, or vaccines for a virus.

First of all, we live in an uncertain world. Many aspects of medicine are probabilistic. Much of it is a balance between risk and reward. Furthermore, some people's perceptions of risk or reward may differ, depending on the disease and the treatment. You presumably (emphasis on presumably, for this crowd) have a brain between your ears capable of critical thinking, and you also have this thing called personal responsibility.

Freedom of speech, which has been in western society since at least the Magna Carta, relies on each individual and their capacity for critical thought to determine whether any specific claim is true, false, or something in between. When you go down the slippery slope of authoritarian censorship, you remove the ability of individuals to consume information about topics for which the truth isn't necessarily certain, and force them to consume only information which has been officially certified. This not only potentially deprives people of life-saving information when it comes to medicine, but it also opens up the catastrophic risk of official misinformation, where "authorities" may in some cases prescribe drugs or treatments with very bad outcomes where the science and its consequences are not fully understood.

Given free speech, I can assume that many claims are outright lies and view them skeptically, but benefit from controversial truths. Given top-down authoritarian censorship, I have no choice but to trust in the skepticism of authorities who, history has shown time and time again, deserve no such trust.
 
Last edited:
I believe it. Good on ya.

I should have 'some' here are haters, although it is all just in fun, surely.

Without looking very far, we have this.










What Tippit said still applies, to some here.

I don't hate conspiracy theorists. I hate people who sell out their nation and then hide behind the protection if provides. There's just considerable overlap between traitors (ie Trump supporters) and certain classes of conspiracy theorists.
 
We're not talking about Libel or Slander. We're talking about Chinese Communist Party-like censorship on google search, youtube, and numerous social media platforms.

What the matter, the cool kids kicked you out of the club?

Private companies, under the US Constitution, can set their own terms of service. "We have the right to refuse service" is a sign you will find in any business window. At the moment nobody has a right to use the internet, and when one logs onto a private web service such as Google, Youtube, or other social media platforms one must agree to their "TERMS OF SERVICE", which few people read. This means I can't post bare breasts or erect penis photos on Facebook, Instagram, or elsewhere. This also means that I cannot post pro-holocaust memes, or racist garbage, and I can't spread misinformation about health issues during a pandemic.

It's not communist, it is red-blooded American capitalism in red, white, and blue. A government law forcing Google and Youtube to carry is something Communist China already does.

So you are clearly advocating for communist rule.


Lol. Selling milk laced with mercury isn't Libel or Slander, it's poisoning/food tampering.

Before the progressive era under Teddy Roosevelt Mercury was a common additive in "health elixirs", and then the fun police of the US Government forced them to stop with all kinds of regulations stating you had to prove something was safe to use and did what you claim it says it did BEFORE taking it to the market. The monsters.

Before the progressive era there was no such thing as food poisoning, and by using your reason the very concept of food poisoning is nothing more than a leftist construct... or does your logic reach that far?

Yet selling vaccines with mercury as a preservative - perfectly acceptable. Oh, wait, it's Ethylmercury don't you worry, which is 100% harmless (so you, and the other pseudo-skeptical clowns here claim, with 100% certainty).

The mercury thing is a proven, over-documented lie. If you believe this line of theory you are either a liar or stupid or both.

Does this mean I can sell milk laced with Ethylmercury to increase the shelf life? I'll wait for your collective heads to explode.

Can you prove it's safe? Can you use Ethylmercury to preserve dairy products? Or are you just talking out of your backside, again?


First of all, we live in an uncertain world.

When was this never true?

Many aspects of medicine are probabilistic.

When was this never true?

Much of it is a balance between risk and reward.

And? When was this never true?

The first thing you're taught in biology is that you don't get something for nothing.

Furthermore, some people's perceptions of risk or reward may differ, depending on the disease and the treatment.

This is why you always get a second or third opinion on big medical issues. This is why you can't listen to people who are not doctors (people with a PhD and MD in their titles). This is when you need to know the difference between a doctor and a specialist.

You presumably (emphasis on presumably, for this crowd) have a brain between your ears capable of critical thinking, and you also have this thing called personal responsibility.

I do. My job requires me to deal with the public. On an average day I will come into contact with 66 people, often more. These people come from all over the state, and all over the world. Some have just got off a long airplane flight, and others will be taking a long airplane flight after I meet them.

So I wear a mask, a nice M94, and I'm vaccinated.

It is my basic human responsibility to take as many precautions to prevent spreading COVID-19 in an environment where doing so can have far reaching impact across the state, country, and globe.

I don't like wearing a mask but I do because I'm responsible.

Freedom of speech, which has been in western society since at least the Magna Carta, relies on each individual and their capacity for critical thought to determine whether any specific claim is true, false, or something in between.

And what kind of internet conditions were available in 1066?

Also, what happened when someone posted something on the town square bulletin board critical to the King, or the local lords?

This is not about free speech. This is you whining about social media policies, and as private AMERICAN companies they can do whatever they want. There are plenty of message boards across the internet where socially inbred folks can post all kinds of anti-vaccine crap.


When you go down the slippery slope of authoritarian censorship, you remove the ability of individuals to consume information about topics for which the truth isn't necessarily certain, and force them to consume only information which has been officially certified.

Again, nobody has a right to Youtube or any other social media platform. And thank God.

This not only potentially deprives people of life-saving information when it comes to medicine, but it also opens up the catastrophic risk of official misinformation, where "authorities" may in some cases prescribe drugs or treatments with very bad outcomes where the science and its consequences are not fully understood
.

People, thanks to Obama, have access to doctors. All the big medical schools and research institutes have websites. Nobody is being blinded to "the truth" because in the end it comes down to decisions you make with your doctor...unless you live in Texas and you need an abortion...

Given free speech, I can assume that many claims are outright lies and view them skeptically, but benefit from controversial truths. Given top-down authoritarian censorship, I have no choice but to trust in the skepticism of authorities who, history has shown time and time again, deserve no such trust.

Whelp, you clearly don't know history, or politics, or political ideology, or the limits of the government placed by the US Constitution on what it can do in regulating private industry, which Google and Youtube and the others happen to be.
 
So, Ministry of Truth then.

Out of curiosity, would you object to someone who used a social media platform to talk about how the cure for cancer was actually to take iodine pills ad that people should stop taking their chemotherapy, for example? What about someone who said that AIDS isn't real ad people should stop their courses of antivirals? Or someone who stated that they cured their ebola with crystals and reiki and therefore we should throw away all medication? How about someone who advocated bloodletting as a treatment for haemophiliacs?

To what degree do you think people should be allowed to spread dangerous medical garbage online? Is there a line to you?
 
Just got back from a color tour on the south shore of Lake Superior. In addition to the amazing fall colors, we stopped at some small county history museums and visitor centers where masking was required, not requested or even discouraged as in other venues like gas stations or diners or stores. So when we were in those museums etc., it was comforting to be among the other smart people. The dumb people, like the waitress who made me repeat my order four times because she "couldn't hear me" were just dumb people who thought they were smart.

But the biggest laugh of the trip was a text from one of my daughters informing me that my crazy catholic, supplement-peddling, anti-vax SiL had to get vaccinated in order to keep her real job. I had a few Leinies toasting that imbecile's one smart decision this year.
 
. Freedom of speech, which has been in western society since at least the Magna Carta, relies on each individual and their capacity for critical thought to determine whether any specific claim is true, false, or something in between.

Ah good, someone else who doesn’t know Magna Carta.

1. There isn’t anything about freedom of speech in Magna Carta 1215.
2. There isn’t anything about freedom of speech in Magna Carta 1297.
3. Magna Carta didn’t apply to ‘western society’, but to a small number of rich people who were strong enough to challenge the king of England.
4. There wasn’t freedom of speech in England for a long time after that. In fact, there was a lese-majeste style law put on the statute book for England and Wales in 1850… and though unenforced it is still there!

She really did die in vain.
 
Ah good, someone else who doesn’t know Magna Carta.

1. There isn’t anything about freedom of speech in Magna Carta 1215.
2. There isn’t anything about freedom of speech in Magna Carta 1297.
3. Magna Carta didn’t apply to ‘western society’, but to a small number of rich people who were strong enough to challenge the king of England.
4. There wasn’t freedom of speech in England for a long time after that. In fact, there was a lese-majeste style law put on the statute book for England and Wales in 1850… and though unenforced it is still there!

She really did die in vain.

It's remarkable how little most people know about the MC - particularly its limitations and how so many think it was some liberating documents for the 'little people'.
 
It's remarkable how little most people know about the MC - particularly its limitations and how so many think it was some liberating documents for the 'little people'.

What I remember about MC from school around 1960 was that it broke the iron grip of the King on the aristocracy. Revolting Lords. It was the start of decentralizing all power from the throne.
 
Magna Carta to support the anti-vaxxer freedom of speech BS

... Freedom of speech, which has been in western society since at least the Magna Carta, ...

Freedom of speech? Exactly where in the text is it spelled out?

Let me guess - you never read the Magna Carta.

So how does the Magna Carta support anti-vaxxer conspiracy theories?

Your knowledge of the Magna Carta, like that of science.
 
So, Ministry of Truth then.

How do you feel about the MSM, Tippit? Do you believe that what they publish and broadcast is fair and accurate?
If not, would you like there to be some kind of mechanism to hold those media channels to account?

In the UK, there's a watchdog called Ofcom. It is independent of the government, and has legal powers to enforce standards of journalism. These relate to fairness and accuracy, as well as things like inappropriate content (eg pornography) and hate speech. Members of the public are free to complain about any article or programme they feel is false or biased.

https://www.ofcom.org.uk/tv-radio-and-on-demand/broadcast-codes/broadcast-code

One of the (many) things that puzzle me about those on the fringe is that they simultaneously complain about the media being biased and spreading lies, but also oppose any attempt to stop the media being biased and spreading lies.

Tippit: what is your solution to this problem?
 
It's Latin, so it sounds special. That's all most of them know, or want to know.
No, there's this idea amongst the Rightists that the Magna Carta is the document that gave the English freedom from the tyrannical monarchy. This is based on the most superficial and motivated understanding of what it was and what it represented. Like all of the most effective lies, it skirts near the truth. But it doesn't actually get there.
 
No, there's this idea amongst the Rightists that the Magna Carta is the document that gave the English freedom from the tyrannical monarchy. This is based on the most superficial and motivated understanding of what it was and what it represented. Like all of the most effective lies, it skirts near the truth. But it doesn't actually get there.

I am very familiar with the Magna Carta-citing crew.
Most of them have never read the relevant parts, and have no idea about its history. They cite the name, and possibly the Article, and nothing more, because they think it sounds cool. It's akin to the FOTL nonsense- it's legalese, not actual law. Most of them don't understand it at all, but they feel learned and important by being able to say something Latin-y.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom