[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
AN ALTERNATE THEORY OF COVID-19

It is argued here that the alleged Corona-19 pandemic of Biblical proportions is not the result of a single coronavirus and its mutations, but rather the result of a much more complicated perfect storm or events and consequences.

It is submitted that Covid-19 viruses may gain most of any morbidity they possess not from their inherent lethality, but from mass psychosis and a nocebo effect.

The nocebo effect is the opposite of the placebo effect. If people feel better after being given a pill without active ingredients, that is called a placebo effect.

On the other hand, if a person feels worse after given false news that they are likely to die, that is called a nocebo effect. This apparently can happen with voodoo curses, for example, wherein people might die of heart attacks or accidents due to panic.

Propagandist Joseph Goebbels stated that if you repeated anything often enough, people would begin to believe it, and the narrative of a uniquely (The word "novel" was stressed) virulent covid coronavirus was repeated over and over.

No, he didn't.

Many acquaintances with compromising factors such as heart disease or diabetes have been scared to the point of being wide-eyed as they discussed the spread of Covid-19.

It would not be surprising if some people experiencing cold symptoms such as coughing and sneezing could be scared enough to begin to hyperventilate and be placed on ventilators.

Unsupported assertion. Got evidence for this?

Another point is that many people on their last legs, dying of colon cancer, congestive heart failure, or whatever, "die today" of diarrhea and dehydration from what doctors and nurses call C. diff (see-diff, Clostridium difficile bacteria), which doesn't often affect doctors and nurses, but mainly people whose immune systems are compromised, or whose "good" bacteria have been killed by antibiotics.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-con ... c-20351691

Citation needed for the claim that patients dying of c. difficile are having Covid listed as a cause of death.

Do their death certificates say that the cause of death was dehydration, diarrhea, or C. difficile? No, usually the death certificate states the primary cause...except, apparently, in an election year, where novel Coronavirus-19 was listed as the cause of death for people on hospice care in nursing homes. Should we accept without question the coincidence that the Covid hype began right after the major media campaign to impeach and convict Trump over allegations of a Putin connection failed, and that it the covid narrative was not driven by political operatives trying to embarrass and weaken Trump?
An election year?
In every country in the world? Including those that do not have elections?
Once again, your almost total ignorance of the world outside America is showing through.

FactCheck confirmed that hospitals got a large government bonus when they reported covid as a contributing factor in deaths, whereas they don't for C. diff, although they have removed the article stating that it is now obsolete.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/fac ... 000638001/

Please list the amount of the bonus paid to hospitals in the UK, Brazil, India, China and Austria- just for starters.

If hospitals were paid to report C. diff as a death co-factor, fearmongers could report millions of C. diff deaths and a panic-porn-driven, "if it bleeds, it leads" press could have another field day.

But they aren't, and this is just silly.

Former Guardian investigative reporter, Kit Knightly (below) and several highly-credentialled statisticians have shown that there have not actually been any "excess deaths' due to Covid-19, so it is argued here that there is no global plague, but instead a global mass movement and mass psychoses related more to political and social sciences than to biological science, a sensationalist press, and a combination of medical-related interests including pharmaceutical giants.

This claim has been disproven.
https://healthfeedback.org/claimrev...ultiple-inaccurate-and-misleading-statements/

Kit Knightly is a lying idiot.
https://www.thejournal.ie/factcheck-admit-covid-19-false-5276375-Nov2020/

30 facts you NEED to know: Your Covid Cribsheet | Principia Scientific Intl. (principia-scientific.com)

Tom Palven

https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/principia-scientific-international/
Overall, we rate Principia Scientific International (PSI) a strong conspiracy and Pseudoscience website promoting anti-vaccine propaganda and frequent misinformation regarding climate change.

To summarise: blinkered, paranoid, unevidenced bilge.
You're welcome.
 
Even if one were to accept the dubious surmise of misreporting, if it and the "nocebo" effect were substantial, would that not mean that the majority of deaths would be among the vaccinated, and that few if any would occur among the defiantly unvaccinated?

I mean, let's expand the conspiracy to include the idea that hospitals not only fudge the cause of death but do it on the basis of vaccination status, that still only works if you actually die. If Covid were not a killer, I'd expect the ratio of vaccinated to unvaccinated deaths to be about the same, even without the "nocebo" effect, and with the Nocebo effect, it seems unlikely it would rise to the spectacular levels we're seeing now.

Yet this does not seem to be the case. Even if we were to accept the highly dubious (to be polite) notion put forth, we are stuck with the apparent fact that people vaccinated against Covid tend not to die at the same rate as those unvaccinated. Even if they're cheating on the cause of death, they can't conceal that difference! After all, they can't fudge the cause of death if you don't die at all. If Covid is not the killer, we're stuck with the strange suggestion that vaccination against Covid protects us from death by a variety of other causes!

If you were to accept the Palven hypothesis, you'd run right out and get vaccinated, since it's obvious that whatever is in that stuff, it's a miraculous anodyne.
 
Last edited:
No, he didn't.

So, what's an accurate translation of how Goebbels phrased it?

My statement that "Many acquaintances with compromising factors such as heart disease or diabetes have been scared to the point of being wide-eyed as they discussed the spread of Covid-19," is just a personal observation.
 
By the way, CE, I'm not sure just what your mention of other risks to life has to do with anything, but it has a small flaw, at least in the US.

Here in the US, at least, there are considerable efforts to warn people about the danger of smoking, drinking, etc. Cigarettes must have a health warning label, laws nearly everywhere set an age minimum for tobacco purchase, smoking is banned in various places, etc. Alcohol warnings are also quite common. TV public service ads abound. Most states have motorcycle helmet laws, headlight laws, passenger laws, extra licensing requirements, etc.

And of course with regard to food and drugs, while it may be true that the supermarket and the advertisers promote them, plenty of people in plenty of places do not. You can't go on the internet these days without tripping over alternative health sites, and even relatively straight news sites include advertising for clickbait sites selling the latest food and medical fads, telling us that this meat will kill us and that drug is poison and we should detoxify our chakras with grape seed extract or something.

These efforts may not be effective, but to say nobody is doing it is not the case.
 
I couldn't agree more.

Aw. Not even a little more? Just the other day, I read somebody saying that he agreed "110%" with something.

After all the typing, speaking, and cutting/pasting you expended posting your grand unified theory of covid, can't you manage, say, 120%? Cmon, squat and strain!

You'll feel better afterward.
 
BS, bruto, the way the fascists are trying to literally get into our lives ("Take that insertion into your body or else!") is unprecedented and you know it.

Nope. Wrong yet again.

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)00267-1/fulltext

Plenty of historical precedent for compulsory vaccinations.
Presented with the evidence that, sometimes, it is necessary and it works.

More evidence of your complete wrongness:
The Nazis actually opposed mandatory vaccinations:
https://jacobinmag.com/2021/09/vaccine-mandates-covid-pandemic-german-nazi-inoculation-policy

If you're going to Godwin the thread, at least take the trouble to get your facts right.
 
So, what's an accurate translation of how Goebbels phrased it?

He didn't say it.
The quote has been attributed to him, but there is no actual primary source, and it doesn't even seem likely he would have said it.
https://www.bytwerk.com/gpa/falsenaziquotations.htm

My statement that "Many acquaintances with compromising factors such as heart disease or diabetes have been scared to the point of being wide-eyed as they discussed the spread of Covid-19," is just a personal observation.

And as such can be ignored without a second thought. Your anecdotes are worthless.
 
Using the Greek alphabet, so that one of the several terms used for variants can be made into an anagram in English, as part of the Evil Plan To Do Evil Things Because Evil?
Ludicrous.
Utterly ludicrous. :rolleyes:

It's imagining that the world works like a comic book.
 
Go to the supermarket and what you will find is at 90% risky to your health. Nobody is trying to protect you from it, on the other hand you get bombarded with advertising for it in your hypnotube. Nobody is trying to protect you from smoking, drinking, motorcycling, skydiving etc.

Please link to a current British TV advert for smoking.
Please post a picture of a packet of cigarettes that does not have a health warning, complete with graphic photo of smoking-related disease, that is currently on sale in the UK.
Alternatively, admit you were talking out of your nether regions, yet again.

Please specify which of the wide variety of fruits, vegetables, low-fat yoghurts, green teas and mueslis I often purchase are risky for my health.

Oh, and please tell me why this doesn't exist:
https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/alcohol-support/calculating-alcohol-units/
And this: I'm sure this is real too:
https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/quit-smoking/nhs-stop-smoking-services-help-you-quit/
Oh look! More stuff you don't believe in!
https://bikesafe.co.uk/

Anyway, I thought you were all about personal choice?
Don't you also oppose untruthful propaganda?
Weird....:rolleyes:
 
He didn't say it.
The quote has been attributed to him, but there is no actual primary source, and it doesn't even seem likely he would have said it.
https://www.bytwerk.com/gpa/falsenaziquotations.htm

From what I can gather, you are right, Goebbels didn't say it, although the conventional wisdom says he did.

And the conventional wisdom is that a coronavirus and its spinoffs have become a plague of Biblical proportions.

Coincidence?
 
From what I can gather, you are right, Goebbels didn't say it, although the conventional wisdom says he did.

And the conventional wisdom is that a coronavirus and its spinoffs have become a plague of Biblical proportions.

Coincidence?

That's not how anything works.

Coincidence?
 
Originally Posted by Tom Palven

It would not be surprising if some people experiencing cold symptoms such as coughing and sneezing could be scared enough to begin to hyperventilate and be placed on ventilators.
Yes it would.

I missed this gem in Tom's wall-o'-nonsense. Yes, it most certainly would be surprising. In 31 years as a porter in ERs and ICUs, I knew when I saw someone on a ventilator that I'd very possibly be back soon with a morgue stretcher. They don't ventilate people for cold symptoms.
 
Last edited:
Indeed.

Care to dispute any specific points in the theory?

Well, none of your links work, so we can't compare your obvious spin to what was actually written in the sources.

Take, "FactCheck confirmed that hospitals got a large government bonus..."

That's like saying, "cities that are severely damaged by hurricanes get a large government bonus". Calling it a "bonus" is manipulative language, but that seems to be one of your favorite tools. And care to talk about the fact that the vast majority of hospitals in the world don't use the U.S. for-profit healthcare system? You still depend on provincial thinking that ignores the rest of the world.

The "mass hysteria" hypothesis is as stupid and desperate as it ever was. It still requires willful ignorance of the massive scientific consensus - it still requires us to accept that you are smarter than the world's medical scientific community. It's like arguing that the Apollo landings are only believed, including by physicists and engineers, because of "mass hysteria". Basically, you've struck out so many times that you're swinging farther and farther afield, and are currently trying to hit the ball from the visiting team's second toilet stall.
 
BS, bruto, the way the fascists are trying to literally get into our lives ("Take that insertion into your body or else!") is unprecedented and you know it.
While I might well agree on the principle though not at all on the example, I am unsure what that has to do with my post, regarding the fact that what you said simply isn't true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom