bruto
Penultimate Amazing
So a hitherto unseen kind of vaccine is added to the list of things called vaccines (as defined in one place), and horror of horrors, someone has to change the wording? Stop the presses! Call the chudch militant! Purebloods unite against the jabber in the woodpile!
I recall a regular feature in The New Yorker in which conflicting reports of the same event are presented with the heading "Which paper do you read?"
Which dictionary do you read?
I note that the definition in my 1958 edition of Van Nostrand's Scientific Encyclopedia (and really, it even says "Scientific" right on the jacket!) starts out "A preparation which on injection will induce an active immunity in the body." The subsequent explanations, while ignorant of RNA vaccines, do not contradict that basic definition.
The 1963 Columbia Encyclopedia is silent except for a brief mention of cowpox for "vaccination."
My 1918 First New International Dictionary (and what could be more authoritative than that, eh? If you find a current word there, you know damned well it was built to last!) defines "vaccine" first as a specific cowpox inoculation and second as "In general, any substance for preventive inoculation." The definition for "inoculation" is long and largely concerned with cowpox, but loose enough to allow for growth, I think.
The OED and its little brother the OUD are surprisingly redundant. A vaccine is defined as a substance used in vaccination, and vaccination is defined as the use of a vaccine. Most of the subsequent material refers to cowpox and the inoculation for it. I think there, also, we could find a little wiggle room.
Taber's Encyclopedic Dictionary from 1973 or so leans toward Bubba's taste though I suspect it might have changed by now. The list of specific vaccines is long but the definition does not leave a lot of room for RNA messenger vaccines.
The 1998 DK Illustrated Oxford Dictionary, however, comes up with "A preparation used to stimulate the production of antibodies and procure immunity from one or several diseases." Plenty of room here.
Doctor Johnson is silent on the subject, not surprisingly since his great dictionary went to press in 1755. The three-part definition for "immunity" is entirely non-medical.
I'm sure I could find more loose marbles to strew in the path of lexicographical and hematological purists, but I think a person without a vax to grind might get the idea that traditionally, a "vaccine" is whatever the medical community decides fits the operational model of what a vaccine is meant to do. When new things arise, words are coined, definitions change, and most, if not all of us, find a way to cope.
Of course one can argue about whether it's any good, but I think only a nitpicking trivialist would bother to argue about what it is.
I recall a regular feature in The New Yorker in which conflicting reports of the same event are presented with the heading "Which paper do you read?"
Which dictionary do you read?
I note that the definition in my 1958 edition of Van Nostrand's Scientific Encyclopedia (and really, it even says "Scientific" right on the jacket!) starts out "A preparation which on injection will induce an active immunity in the body." The subsequent explanations, while ignorant of RNA vaccines, do not contradict that basic definition.
The 1963 Columbia Encyclopedia is silent except for a brief mention of cowpox for "vaccination."
My 1918 First New International Dictionary (and what could be more authoritative than that, eh? If you find a current word there, you know damned well it was built to last!) defines "vaccine" first as a specific cowpox inoculation and second as "In general, any substance for preventive inoculation." The definition for "inoculation" is long and largely concerned with cowpox, but loose enough to allow for growth, I think.
The OED and its little brother the OUD are surprisingly redundant. A vaccine is defined as a substance used in vaccination, and vaccination is defined as the use of a vaccine. Most of the subsequent material refers to cowpox and the inoculation for it. I think there, also, we could find a little wiggle room.
Taber's Encyclopedic Dictionary from 1973 or so leans toward Bubba's taste though I suspect it might have changed by now. The list of specific vaccines is long but the definition does not leave a lot of room for RNA messenger vaccines.
The 1998 DK Illustrated Oxford Dictionary, however, comes up with "A preparation used to stimulate the production of antibodies and procure immunity from one or several diseases." Plenty of room here.
Doctor Johnson is silent on the subject, not surprisingly since his great dictionary went to press in 1755. The three-part definition for "immunity" is entirely non-medical.
I'm sure I could find more loose marbles to strew in the path of lexicographical and hematological purists, but I think a person without a vax to grind might get the idea that traditionally, a "vaccine" is whatever the medical community decides fits the operational model of what a vaccine is meant to do. When new things arise, words are coined, definitions change, and most, if not all of us, find a way to cope.
Of course one can argue about whether it's any good, but I think only a nitpicking trivialist would bother to argue about what it is.