Darth Rotor
Salted Sith Cynic
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2006
- Messages
- 38,527
SG: Fruit of the poison tree, regarding only the article, not your "again" bit, which you are correct in assessing as a road to nowhere.Thanks for the additional links.
Consider the problem with the claim made about Naval Air Station, Jacksonville, Florida, and the words used, sorry, the hyperbole used.
To recap:
Sorry, that dog does not hunt.Page after page of voters with this address, Naval Air Station, Jacksonville, hundreds, thousands of soldiers and sailors targeted to lose their vote. Go to Baghdad, lose your vote.
1. The assumption that Rove considers persons living at NAS Jax a threat in the next election, or in past elections. Think about that, for just a moment. Which way do active duty members tend to vote, according to "conventional wisdom?" Also, how is Rove going after blacks on NAS Jax, if they live in the barracks? By name? Maybe he has people providing him data via a DoD data base, complete with ethnic classification. (That is a privacy act violation, but of course, that consideration probably would not stop many politicians if they were up to no good.)
Some military members change state voting affiliation when moving to Florida, and maintain that address for years to take advantage of no state income tax in FL. (I have quite a few friends who did that.) Some of these sailors may be stationed in CA now, or WA, or VA, but vote absentee, and are legal residents of FL, and have FL driver licenses, FL residence, and so on. Screening for race? By voter record? I don't see it, and maybe that is not what is implied. Most of us have absentee ballots in hand at least a month before voting day, from my own experiences with a lot of absentee voting, and detect problems months ahead of the election.
Screening to remove from FL rolls, when that district voted more Rep than not in 2000 and 2004?
Is Rove assumed to be an idiot, but also a brilliant conspiracist?
Note the red up there by the Georgia Border? That is where NAS Jax is. (If I can find a better map, I will.) The blue county in the Middle of Texas? Where Austin is.
ETA: Better map. COmpare it to the USA map, and note that Navy folk tend to live in Duval, Clay, and St John's County when are assigned to NAS Jax and NS Mayport.
The assertion does not stand up, as most of these sailors get massive encouragement to register to vote from the chain of command, and to fill out the absentee ballot forms months in advance to allow for the vagaries of mail. When they run into trouble, the chain of command, and the legal office, are there for help. I've done this before. I ran more than one squadron level program to make sure everyone registered, and had their absentee balloting paperwork completed no less than 60 days out. (Whether or not they voted was their problem.) Funnily enough, about one in seven would truculently refuse to even register, in my experience, which used to exasperate me to no end.
Using an NAS Jax address as a way to get people off of the roles is a weird way to stifle uniformed voters who tend to vote your way, don't you think?.
But it goes beyond that. Quite a few sailors there are not Florida residents. (The inverse of what I discussed above.)
Let's move on to all of the contractor and GS people at NAS Jax, in their multitudes. They do not live on the base, so their addresses would be in whichever county or town where they live. Non issue for purposes of this discussion.
NAS Jax is home to aircraft squadrons, rework facilities, (see the tab local commands at the NAS Jax link). No soldiers, (or perhaps a dozen Army Liaison folks), yes medical facilities, and virtually no Marines. At most, you could expect up to 300-500 (max) Navy personnel from NAS Jax to be in Iraq at a given time. The bulk of them being:
(I ETA'd my number up a bit, 300-500) to account for a fair share of Jax Seabee assignment, based on some info from the Navy to Congress on how many SeaBees total are deployed to Iraq, which is around 1000, and estimating a fair share contribution from Jax. Hundreds of naval medical personnel were deployed to Iraq in support of Marine forces, as well as over 1,000 active and reserve Navy Seabees responsible for construction support.) Page 3 of this document, which includes 2006 FY accounting for Iraq operations. http://www.finance.hq.navy.mil/fmb/07pres/highbook/SECTION_II.pdf)
Civil Engineers (see the Seabee links at NAS Jax site.)
A few HQ sorts for Air Command and Control HQ's in the Mid East, most of whom are not in Iraq, and in a variety of Naval HQ's in the PG, not in Iraq.
Medics and docs. That number might raise the number higher, if a max med effort were coupled with a max seabee effort, but most would be IA's anyway. So much for the Navy people in Iraq from NAS Jax.
The Jax based P-3 squadrons in the Mid East are deployed in their sailor and aircrew hundreds, either as squadrons or dets. They don't base out of Iraq, but out of Bahrain, Qatar, UAE, Digeo Garcia, and even out of the Med or Pac airfields to support Iran and Afghanistan operations.
No "lose your vote in Iraq" for them.
The Helicopter Squadrons at NAS Jax deploy on CV's, in the Gulf, and are not in Iraq. No soldiers, no Marines, sailors. The combat SAR role is, at the moment, in the hands of USAF, Marines, and Army in Iraq. The over the shore combat SAR from CV's is not a factor as of this writing. (Time, fuel, distance.)
So, where are these thousands of soldiers disenfranchised voters in Iraq?
Quite simply, they don't exist, from that zip code, and are in a zip code that tends to vote GOP.
How about you reconsider the hyperbole, in the presented article? A load of factual innacuracy, at the very best, and complete bollocks from my jaundiced perspective, and experience.
Since many, hell most, of the people who work on NAS Jax live elsewhere, in the counties surrounding NAS Jax, that zip code reflects strangely on what this tactic allegedly is trying to do. Click to the NAS Jax web site, but this time go to services and housing to get a sense of housing, and the 2-24 month waiting list for married quarters. It is sparse.
To recap: these counties voted more for Bush than against in 2000 and 2004. (There was quite a bit of talk about votes in the area not counted in 2000, but no need to derail.)
Furthermore, I am of the opinion, from your article, that the reporter may have misinterpreted the intent. What I expect was going on, legal or otherwise, in that Zip Code, was a "get out the vote" effort since a valid assumption would be that more, not less, of the sailors (young, in the barracks or in scarce base housing) needed encouragement to vote, given the young being less likely to vote (the barracks sailors tend to be young, older ones live off base) and in need of "reaching" to energize on election day.
So, there you have it, either your author is right, and Rove an idiot trying to cut off at the knees people who are shown to be likely to vote for his boys, or the author doesn't know what he is talking about on that point, but is trying to raise a "he hates the troops" spectre with his hyberbole.
My two cents.
ETA: Maybe he only got that part wrong, and everything else right. Given the slant, I am skeptical.
DR
Last edited: