Matthew Best
Penultimate Amazing
Letterby is definitely innocent!
She wouldn't necessarily need to be present at the time of death to be the cause. One of the two methods she used to murder babies was overdosing them with insulin. She would be able to inject insulin into them, or into an IV (if being used) and be at the other end of the country when the baby died.
In reality, there is little doubt that she did what she was found guilty of... How else can you explain why -
1. The unexpected illnesses (6) and infant deaths (7) started happening shortly after she started working at the children's ICU?
2. She was always on duty when each incident took place?
3. When she was removed from duties in June 2016, the suspicious incidents and deaths stopped?
She was also caught in the act, or shortly after, several times by parents and colleagues.
She wouldn't necessarily need to be present at the time of death to be the cause. One of the two methods she used to murder babies was overdosing them with insulin. She would be able to inject insulin into them, or into an IV (if being used) and be at the other end of the country when the baby died.
In reality, there is little doubt that she did what she was found guilty of... How else can you explain why -
1. The unexpected illnesses (6) and infant deaths (7) started happening shortly after she started working at the children's ICU? 2. She was always on duty when each incident took place? 3. When she was removed from duties in June 2016, the suspicious incidents and deaths stopped?
She was also caught in the act, or shortly after, several times by parents and colleagues.
By court rules, Letby's defence counsel had to be on a par with that of the prosecutor's. Thus we had silks Nick Johnson for the Crown and Ben Myers for the Defence. Myers is a top drawer KC. Has got many of his clients off.
Letby was first arrested 2018 and then twice more. In all that time she could have built up a defence. Before the trial there would have been many Case Management and Directions prehearings. These would include allowing the other party full discovery of the evidence and documents. In addition, it would have been agreed what the 'issues' were. These refer to points of contention. There is no point bringing up issues everybody is in agreement with. Letby was equally allowed to bring her own expert witnesses and to know what the other expert witnesses for the prosecution was going to say. Letby did have expert witnesses but in the event Myers for Letby and her lawyers either decided it was too risky for them to testify and be cross-examined or even that the expert witness agree with the Crown expert witnesses! The other possibility is that Justice James Goss, the judge, refused to allow them on the grounds of irrelevance or trivia. For example, they might have been arguing the obvious (this might be an appeal point) regarding the use of spreadsheet statistics.
With respect to cause of death, had the neonatal unit and the executive management bothered to read the death certificate reports and final toxicology results, it would have found seriously suspicious high levels of synthetic insulin in the blood of at least one of the babies. This was where Dr. Brearey and the Chester Polcie had their 'Eureka Moment' breakthrough.
Dr Dewi Evans is the 'gun for hire', as described scathingly by silk Myers in his summing up. So the jury were quite free to prefer not to accept Dr Evans' testimony. Dr Sandie Bohin, the other expert witness, gave testimony that was utterly bloodchilling, about how incredibly painful the babies' deaths must have been with unnatural screaming. She testified that neonatals just do not scream.
Justice Goss told the jury that the expert witnesses were for the court, not advocates for the prosecution. He directed that they could determine by looking at a pattern, i.e., if they found Letby guilty on one, they could take the view the same applied to others. (This could be a point of appeal.). However, we saw the jury take over 100 days to reach verdicts and they were undecided on six of the charges, so they clearly weighed up each case on their individual merits. The only defence witness called was the plumber, whose testimony wasn't even related to a day when a death or assault took place. Unfortunately, Letby's whole attitude was 'prove it' - 'you can't prove it', believing that the jury would see her as just being picked on to cover the doctors' own backs. After all, she had been the poster girl for the new neonatal unit fundraiser. She knew she had fooled people into thinking she was a kindly nurse who loved babies.
Agree. These babies did not die of natural causes, their deaths were caused by human intervention.
- Babies do not get air into their bloodstream unless someone injects them with air.- Babies do not suffer insulin overdoses unless someone injects them with insulin.
- Babies diaphragms are not crushed unless a person crushes them. Same for those babies who became very ill but did not die. If Letby didn't do it, then another person must have - a person who was on the same shift as Letby for every one of the deaths and assaults during the period 8 June 2015 to 24 June 2016. The problem with that idea is the ward manager established that no staff member other than Letby was on the shift at the time every death and assault took place.
There is one case that is particularly chilling. The case of Child G on 7 September 2015. The child, a girl, collapsed and did so again on two other occasions in the following three weeks. She was taken to another hospital, but five days after she came back, she collapsed again, 15 minutes after Letby had been feeding her. She survived, but is now severely disabled as a result of what happened to her. The child was witnessed projectile vomiting massively. The doctor said that he could not find a natural cause for the drastic vomiting. Later, at trial, an expert witness doctor concluded that the only viable explanation was that the baby was force fed too much milk down. It was later discovered that Letby had deliberately altered the baby's temperature on her observation chart to make it seem like it was already unwell before it collapsed, and she also falsified the time of the baby's collapse to make it seem like it coincided with when a colleague gave the baby a milk feed.
This shows shew knew exactly what she was doing. Letby must have known she was coming under suspicion, and tried to point the finger at a colleague.
It is not just beyond any reasonable doubt that Letby murdered these babies, it is an absolute cold-blooded certainty!
Letterby is definitely innocent!
Letterby is definitely innocent!
Sorry, that was just me being my normal spelling Nazi.
There are lots of ways to get air into the blood stream. One way is certainly through vascular access devices. It does not require air to be actively injected, a disconnect with low venous presures can result in air being sucked in, a well known phenomenon. Drug pumps can suffer disconnects or leaks and pump air into the blood, which is why they are supposed to have bubble detectors, but there is always the chance someone just muted an alarm by accident. Another way is mistaking the NG feeding tube and an iv tube and flushing the iv line with air instead of the feeding line.
Over ventilation and resuscitation may result in alveolar rupture or lung trauma with air entering the circulation.
Air embolism is well known to occur through misadventure, it does not only occur with deliberate injection of air into the circulation. It should be noted that post morem examination which is the most reliable way to diagnose air embolism failed to do so in any of the cases. all the cases of air embolism were post hoc diagnoses by the police 'expert' reviewers. One of the key peices of evidence was their interpretation of x-rays. Normally interpretation of x-rays would be done by a paediatric radiologist, not by persons out of clinical practice for many years.
https://www.scienceontrial.com/post...wn-the-case-law-on-the-reliability-of-experts
For further comment. I do not agree with all that is said but references to relevant research are given.
Babies diaphragm's are crushed unintentionally. They are notoriously easy to crush. Sometimes they are born crushed. It is very easy to overfeed a premmy and splint the diaphragm causing a respiratory arrest. It would certainly be very easy to kill or cause acute respiratory disturbance in a neonate that way. The problem is that this is essentially a retropective conclusion. Assuming Letby killed the child, how could she do so without leaving evidence - by over feeding.
The porosecution have avoided directly using statistics, but have implicitly used them. There was an excess of deaths so lets find ways these could have been unnatural. the issue of overfeeding and splinting a diaphragm is well know, it can be manged by aspirating the NG tubeto empty the stomach. This does not appear to have been done and the diagnosis was not made at the time.
In part this is why unlike other cases of homicidal serial killer nurses Letby is accused of using so many different ways of killing, bacause a method has to be constructed retrospectively to fit the facts on the assumption that she killed every child who died on her shift. At least statistically there should be some entirely natural deaths!
There is no evidence that Letby falsified records. The prosecution claimed that she did so, and it is necessary to their case that she did so, otherwise events would have been incompatible with their hypothesis. One example of falsified records given was Letby not recording on an observation chart something that she did record in the written nursing record. That is not falsifying a record. It is poor record keeping. Equally it is clear other nurses filled in records after events, timing the as if contemporaneous, which was falsifying records. Letby may well have falsified records, but there is no evidence she did so.
This is simply untrue. Intravenous insulin in a neonate would act very quickly; wihin minutes. Indeed almost certainly the psychpathology is Letby wanted to be involved in the excitement of dealing with a suddenly sick child. I don't think she was interested in killing them, she just wanted to make them sick. I suspect she was a sociopath with no empathy who didn't care about whether the children lived or died. Not being present would defeat the whole object of her activities.
Neither of the infants given exogenous insulin died. It is unusual for this type of serial murderer to change technique. It is said that there were two nurses on duty on both occasions Letby and one other. No one observed Letby giving any unauthorised injections and no contaminated syringes etc. were recovered. One criticism of the unit would be that they got back the results showing the babies had been given exogenous insulin and didn't notice them.
1-3) All those things were said about Lucia de Berk for years before it was funally realised that she couldn't have caused the deaths she was convictrd of.
And on your last paragraph, what direct evidence was there in this case. From following it all the evidence was either circumstantial or Roy Meadows level misuse of statistics.
The problem is that you define the unexpected illnesses and deaths by her presence. Deaths occurred before she started, when she was not on duty, and after she stopped working. A key problem in forensic science is suspect centred interpretation. The question I asked, and an appeal might be asking is whether all deaths on the unit were analysed with the analyser blind to the presence of Letby. If only those deaths when Letby was present were analysed, we cannot conclude whether the only suspicious deaths occurred when Letby was present. Remeber all these deaths including those that had undergone post mortems were initially viewed as natural deaths.
There is no suggestion trhat at the time the parents viewed what Letby was doing as suspicious, they did not raise concerns at the time. One problem is that no one saw Letby in the act. Certainly if you then ask the parents 'we think Letby killed your child did you see anything of concern', then it is not surprising that they subsequntly view actions as being suspicious. But some of what they describe as being suspicious could not have been the acts that killed the child.
Letby stopping working coincide with the unit changing from a level 2 unit (looking after premmy's and non-surgical sick neonates) to a level 1 unit - a SCBU essentially not allowed to look after sick babies. Since the population changed to a much less at risk poulation at the same time that Letby moved it is almost impossible to attribute the drop in deaths to Letby.
https://www.childrenscolorado.org/d...-care-unit/nicu-family-resources/nicu-levels/
A US reference but UK definitions are similar.
The advocates only present the case in court. It is the solicitor that would have to do all the reviewing of paperwork, organising second opinions etc. It is the inequality between a prosecution service with a police investigatory service and a local solicitor that is the issue. The huge quanity of documents would have been a challenge to any but the largest of law firms. You would probably have needed a company with both criminal defence specialists and medical negigence specialists to properly manage the case. It is unclear the defence had the funding to employ expert witnesses to examine the cases (nor as I alluded to that they would have been available - one problem is that since expert witnesses such as Meadows have been denigrated experts are increasingly unwilling to appear in court). The use of Sandie Bohin is a good example. The prosecution had to get a paediatrician from Guernsey (which has no NICU), to give an expert opinion. She has worked in neonates, but not since 2008, and currently does mainly general paeds.
I think it is difficult to entirely tcall these either exoert witnesses or neutral, even if the intention are that they should be. Given that they were approached by the police to find something suspicious, and only later would they become expert witnesses effectively validating their previous work as reviewers for the police. The expert witnesses should not have been the same as the professionals employed by the police to review the medical records.
ETA As mentioned previously neither of the infants with insulin poisoning died. so your comment about death certificates and insulin is in error.
There are lots of ways to get air into the blood stream. One way is certainly through vascular access devices. It does not require air to be actively injected, a disconnect with low venous presures can result in air being sucked in, a well known phenomenon. Drug pumps can suffer disconnects or leaks and pump air into the blood, which is why they are supposed to have bubble detectors, but there is always the chance someone just muted an alarm by accident. Another way is mistaking the NG feeding tube and an iv tube and flushing the iv line with air instead of the feeding line.
Over ventilation and resuscitation may result in alveolar rupture or lung trauma with air entering the circulation.
Air embolism is well known to occur through misadventure, it does not only occur with deliberate injection of air into the circulation. It should be noted that post morem examination which is the most reliable way to diagnose air embolism failed to do so in any of the cases. all the cases of air embolism were post hoc diagnoses by the police 'expert' reviewers. One of the key peices of evidence was their interpretation of x-rays. Normally interpretation of x-rays would be done by a paediatric radiologist, not by persons out of clinical practice for many years.
https://www.scienceontrial.com/post...wn-the-case-law-on-the-reliability-of-experts
For further comment. I do not agree with all that is said but references to relevant research are given.
Babies diaphragm's are crushed unintentionally. They are notoriously easy to crush. Sometimes they are born crushed. It is very easy to overfeed a premmy and splint the diaphragm causing a respiratory arrest. It would certainly be very easy to kill or cause acute respiratory disturbance in a neonate that way. The problem is that this is essentially a retropective conclusion. Assuming Letby killed the child, how could she do so without leaving evidence - by over feeding.
The porosecution have avoided directly using statistics, but have implicitly used them. There was an excess of deaths so lets find ways these could have been unnatural. the issue of overfeeding and splinting a diaphragm is well know, it can be manged by aspirating the NG tubeto empty the stomach. This does not appear to have been done and the diagnosis was not made at the time.
In part this is why unlike other cases of homicidal serial killer nurses Letby is accused of using so many different ways of killing, bacause a method has to be constructed retrospectively to fit the facts on the assumption that she killed every child who died on her shift. At least statistically there should be some entirely natural deaths!
There is no evidence that Letby falsified records. The prosecution claimed that she did so, and it is necessary to their case that she did so, otherwise events would have been incompatible with their hypothesis. One example of falsified records given was Letby not recording on an observation chart something that she did record in the written nursing record. That is not falsifying a record. It is poor record keeping. Equally it is clear other nurses filled in records after events, timing the as if contemporaneous, which was falsifying records. Letby may well have falsified records, but there is no evidence she did so.
Dr. Arthurs, a radiologist, who gave expert witness, took X-Rays of Child A and Child B. He said whilst it was normal to see air int he bowels, he said it was totally unnatural to see the embolisms lined up parallel to the babies' spines. He had never seen that before.
The doctor who examined the crushed abdomen said it was of the same severity of someone who had been crushed in a car accident at great speed. She did falsify records. For example, coming in early but then only signing in later, is just one instance, when she claimed she could not have been present as the signing in record showed her arrival as being 15 minutes later.
Neither synthetic insulin administration or air bubble injection are accidental.
Whilst most of us have no idea of what either of these feel like, we can all imagine how incredibly painful being overfed on milk for someone with a tiny stomach must have been. Letby precluded this by telling the changeover nurse that the baby had had an extended stomach to make it seem as if it was something that developed gradually and that she would be well away from the hospital when the baby finally died.
Letby had her powerful trade union behind her. They succeeded in helping her win her grievance case (but thankfully, she never set foot in a neonatal ward again). She had the Neonatal Unit manager backing her, as well as the Nursing Chief, together with the Ian Harvey chap, to whom Letby was the golden fundraiser girl. In addition, she had the backing of Tony Chambers, who threatened seven doctors who expressed reservations about Letby's presence on the ward, with being reported to the GMC, with all the stress that entails. Trades Unions are incredibly strong with some of the best legal teams around (for example, Thompsons). They have no shortage of funds. Letby will have been well-represented, that is for sure.
The prosecution and the police are not allowed to hide or withhold evidence. She will have got a dossier of the entire case well in advance.
De Berk's conviction was found to be unsafe because Richard Gill, professor in Statistics found that there was an error in how some of the statistics had been calculated. Letby's conviction didn't centre around statistics. The Chester Police made in it clear in their programme Operation Hummingbird that each individual baby had their own individual discrete team of detectives, who were all china-walled from each other. Thus the case were build up individually n their own merits. If there was an issue with 'statistics' then the Defence had every opportunity during the trial to challenge them. Circumstantial evidence is just as powerful as prima facie evidence. Perfectly acceptable in criminal law. Unfortunately, there is a perception amongst people that 'circumstantial' = 'guesswork'. No. One of the strongest tools of a lawyer/barrister is the timeline or chronology. That is circumstantial but shows a clear logical sequence, whether it be for a defendant alibi or for the prosecution. An FBI authority (forget the name) said the most important part to solving a crime is working out what happened immediately before.
Roy Meadows, in the Sally Clarke case was reprimanded and disciplined for going beyond his remit (later reinstated). This is because in calculating the probability of two children both dying of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) made the ridiculously stupid error of assuming the two boys (Clarke's sons) were each random members of a population. For example, if there is a 50% chance of a baby being a girl or a boy, then say you have a girl (50%) and then another girl, then you can say the probability of this happening is .50 x .50 = 0.25 or 25%. What Meadows failed to factor in is the genetic element in that two close relatives often have the same predisposition to a medical condition. For example, say there is a 1% chance of any one random member of the population having, say Huntingdon's Chorea, it would be quite improper to apply that to two close relatives, if one of them as Huntingdon's, because if your close relative has Huntingdon's then your chance of developing it rockets extortionately to near 50%.
But the Letby case wasn't based on probability theory, other than to illustrate to the jury how the trends of babies suddenly collapsing or dying, correlated very strongly to Letby's presence. But that would not be sufficient for a jury to convict and it would not be reasonable to disallow these statistics from the trial.
Each case has to be judged on its own individual merits. Sally Clarke was a mother of the two sons. Completely different from a nurse randomly selecting neonatals that came in her path.
Letby had her powerful trade union behind her. They succeeded in helping her win her grievance case (but thankfully, she never set foot in a neonatal ward again). She had the Neonatal Unit manager backing her, as well as the Nursing Chief, together with the Ian Harvey chap, to whom Letby was the golden fundraiser girl. In addition, she had the backing of Tony Chambers, who threatened seven doctors who expressed reservations about Letby's presence on the ward, with being reported to the GMC, with all the stress that entails. Trades Unions are incredibly strong with some of the best legal teams around (for example, Thompsons). They have no shortage of funds. Letby will have been well-represented, that is for sure.
The prosecution and the police are not allowed to hide or withhold evidence. She will have got a dossier of the entire case well in advance.
This is an example of how people who are not experts fail to realise Meadows was actually correct. The question was about SIDS, by definition SIDS excludes a familial genetic component, so Meadows was actually correct in his response to the question asked. The problem was the question asked was inappropriate to the case under trial.
More broadly, speaking to friends who are paediatricians, after Meadows they are unwilling to appear as expert witnesses. This is why the prosecution expert witnesses are a doctor who has been retired for ten years and never worked as a neonatologist, and a doctor who has not done neonatology for several years and works in Guernsey (for those unfamiliar this means that there are about ten children (slight exaggeration) per paediatrician on the island). Both of whom are professional medico-legal opinions - experts for hire.
Almost certainly it was impossible for the defence to get an independent professional review.