Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

Very interesting. It was always held that Letby acted alone. Are the police trying to spread the blame? It’s perplexing.
If the accusation was that she had acted with the help of others, the charges would not be manslaughter but accessory to murder.

Most likely (as others have already stated) they are accused of ignoring the warnings about Letby.
 
Police have now sent files to the CPS re further possible crimes by Letby. More than a dozen more.

Detectives investigating child killer Lucy Letby have passed a file of evidence to prosecutors alleging she murdered and harmed more babies.

The Mail understands there are more than a dozen potential offences included in the file, which the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) last night confirmed would be examined to see whether she should be charged with more crimes.

That process is expected to take several weeks and involve consultation with the most senior legal brains in the country, including Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions, and Lord Richard Hermer KC, the Attorney General.

symbol



 
This is hilarious:

Reacting to news that a file of evidence had been passed to prosecutors for consideration of new charges today, Mark McDonald, Letby's lawyer, said: 'We will cross every bridge when we get to it but if Lucy is charged I know we have a whole army of internationally renowned medical experts who will totally undermine the prosecution’s unfounded allegations.' ibid.
 
In related news, Karen Kneller, the disgraced head of Criminal Cases Review Commission (heavily criticised for bungling of Andrew Malkinson case amongst other matters) has resigned.
 
Stephanie Davies, the coroner’s officer who first reviewed the deaths of babies at the Countess of Chester hospital for Cheshire police in 2017 now believes Lucy Letby has suffered a miscarriage of justice.

Her review, was told it was key to detectives deciding to commence an investigation into the former neonatal nurse.
 
I haven't yet watched it but here's the Guardian review of last night's ITV documentary:

I have just spend the last hour watching this documentary (I have access to ITVX via a relative in England using a VPN and her postcode)

It comprehensively demolishes the prosecution cases for every single method it is alleged that she used to murder them.
 
I haven't yet watched it but here's the Guardian review of last night's ITV documentary:

There's nothing new here, although the journalist tries to 'big it up' with well-tried phrases such as 'growing' as in 'growing disquiet;' as a variation from the usual 'growing concern' or 'a growing number of experts'. Truth is, only 70 people turned up for the 'mass demonstration' in Liverpool. From what I can gather of the documentary, it is one old school chum, disgraced former nursing officer, Karen Rees and former RHRCP head, Modi, both of whom are in danger of receiving a 'warning' from Lady Thirlwall as to their conduct over safety concerns. Rees made a poor showing at Thirlwall, being more entrenched in her Doctors ~vs~ Nurse view of the world rather than any safety concerns. She claimed at the time of Thirlwall that her lawyers had advised her to distance herself from Letby's crimes but now it seems she is back to try to vindicate her 'standing by' the convicted killer. Some kind of cognitive dissonance to try to resolve the distance between her belief, throughout the baby deaths, of Letby being a scapegoat of the doctors and opposing her being removed from duty to work 'in a degrading back office' (which is nonsense, as Letby was continuing to earn good money from this 'demeaning' office work as well as astonishingly, having access to all the risk registers and reviewing what was on them) and supporting a return of Letby to the NNU. Plus, everyone was told she was on secondment, socialised as normal, so there was no real detriment to Letby at all, as Rees now wants to portray.

As for the old school chum, she claims that writing down one's darkest thoughts was a technique encouraged by a peer-to-peer counselling course they underwent at school. That's a variation on former GUARDIAN incumbent, Felicity Lawrence who claimed that the post-it notes written by Letby was at the advice of the rehabilitation HR bod, a total fabrication, as the notes were written long before Letby was a suspect and under the HR bod. Letby herself said she had always scribbled stuff down. I am sceptical a counselling course would encourage anyone to write down their darkest thoughts, as claimed. I was on a counselling course when I was a volunteer for a charity for stressed out parents, Parentline. The training course was based on the usual standard sociological principles as founded by Rodgers. It was demonstrated that when a caller at the end of the line expressed 'dark thoughts' , such as suicide, the average person fails to 'hear' it and goes on to talk about other things. The training helped us to pick up the 'dark thoughts' and not ignore it. That is not the same as encouraging a parent to think a dark thought. The claim Letby was encouraged to write about killing babies 'on purpose' is ridiculous and predicated on a misunderstanding by the former school chum, if that is what she really believes. In any case, the court being shown the post-it notes was a minor part of the eight-month trial; they were not told to think anything of them one way or the other. The jury could make of the post-it notes what they would, having heard Letby's own testimony about them.

The other thing is, what is keeping this story alive is that Letby now has an expensive PR agency representing her (Maltins), which leads to the question, who is paying for all of this careful image-building? Plus, the story gets clicks so it pays journalists such as Peter Hitchens, Phil Hammond and the guys on the GUARDIAN to keep writing about it as a 'growing' concern.

But here's the thing: Why hasn't Lucy Letby waived legal privilege to her new barrister, Mark MacDonald? Normally, when a client changes solicitors, the legal privilege should also automatically pass on. Unless...Letby has refused to waive legal privilege. There can only be two or three of several reasons for this, because for it to go to the CCRC or CoA, a waiver of legal privilege will certainly be mandatory. Firstly, Ben Myers' reasons for not calling the fifteen or so defence expert witnesses (you recall, she only called a plumber) waiting at hand, in particular, Dr. Hall, who expressed disappointment at not being called, could be because (a) their testimony under cross-examination would largely have to agree with the prosecution's independent expert witnesses, or (b) Letby indicated she was guilty, which debarred Myers from representing her as 'innocent'. There is also the possibility (c) Letby herself refused to allow any defence expert witnesses, being in charge of the case, for reasons best known to herself. The upshot is, as long as Letby refuses to waiver legal privilege - and MacDonald seems very happy with this - MacDonald can carry on presenting her as 'innocent' without breaking Bar Standards.
 
Last edited:
I have just spend the last hour watching this documentary (I have access to ITVX via a relative in England using a VPN and her postcode)

It comprehensively demolishes the prosecution cases for every single method it is alleged that she used to murder them.
And shows how one major witness lied in court.
 
Are you able to articulate your reasoning for supporting a convicted child harmer?
So much straw.....
I have already ennumrated the problms with the Letby case in this very thread. Naturally you have ignored these inconveniences.....
 
Last edited:
Are you able to articulate your reasoning for supporting a convicted child harmer?
She may well actually BE a child harmer, or she may not.... BUT the evidence she was convicted on was utter bollocks. As one of the interviewees correctly points out, some of the evidence she was convicted on wasn't even strong enough to get someone fired, let alone sent to jail.

And now, its clear that one key witness got things wrong, and has changed their own theory of the crime. And another key witness perjured themselves in the witness box.
 
Are you able to articulate your reasoning for supporting a convicted child harmer?

Here's a summary of the ITV documentary by a poster on the other forum I belong to.

I'll sum up the documentary for those who can't or don't have the time to watch it in full. The argument is that the prosecution case rested on four pillars which are all extremely shaky:

1. Letby was always there when things went wrong. An expert statistician has examined this and found that the document produced at trial showing Letby was present for 24 adverse incidents completely omitted data for a number of other adverse incidents which occurred during the same period at times when Letby was not working. The prosecution had simply cherry picked the incidents where she was on duty and omitted everything else.

2. Letby had written confessions. Letby's close friend stayed that this was a technique for dealing with stress that they were both taught at college and that she knew Letby still practiced. Writing down her dark thoughts as a way to process them. The documentary also states that she was advised to continue to do that by a therapist who was working with her following her suspension.

3. There is evidence that Letby caused air embolisms to kill babies. The expert witness who stated this has apparently changed his mind about it since the trial and has submitted a new report to police, though he maintains Letby did it and has only changed his mind about how. The expert in neonatal pathology whose paper was used to construct the theory has said that it is based on a flawed understanding of his work and that intravenous injection of air would not produce the symptoms identified.

4. Letby killed babies by injecting them with insulin. This was apparently the most damning evidence and was based on tests performed on babies which showed a spike in insulin levels. A chemical engineer and an expert in neonatal pathology have been studying this and believe the spikes can be attributed to naturally produced insulin binding to antibodies present within neonates. The tests which were presented as evidence, meanwhile, are known to give erroneous readings and are specifically stated on the lab's own website not to be suitable for investigations. One expert who examined the tests said they wouldn't even have fired Letby from her job based on them, let alone locked her up for life.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom