Communication from the Dead??

attaboy

Scholar
Joined
Mar 23, 2011
Messages
119
BACKGROUND

Background on sister Lois as it may apply to the following account:

My beautiful and wonderful sister Lois died peacefully of colon cancer on 11-15-12. She'd had a death wish for some years largely due to the distress she was in over the poor treatment she received from her only children, her two sons. She was as fine a lady as I've ever met, and to my knowledge, always took the high road in every aspect of her life.
Most of her life she had an interest in ghosts. How deep that went I never truly knew possibly because since I teased her a lot about it, she never did reveal to me the extent of her interest. However, during her end time, when I would visit her, I noticed nearly all the time on TV, that a show on ghost hunting and/or hauntings was playing. Its quite possible, I feel, that her interest in these topics and perhaps other areas of the paranormal, was more extensive than I realized. I'm sorry now I didn't discuss this further with her.

The last time I saw her was on 11-14-12, the day before she died. I arrived at 4 AM after a seven hour drive and was told by her son Kevin that she was not doing well and had stopped eating since Saturday. But when I went into the bedroom she was awake, quite alert, and in good spirits. She smiled and said words of being pleased when I told her I would bring her lobster later in the day. But she soon got tired and I told her I was tired also from the drive down. I told her I would sleep awhile and we could talk more later. But when I woke 3 hours later I could see she had failed considerably in just that short time. By now she was in what I'll describe as a coma-like state and was never able to talk again. Hospice informed me she was in the process of shutting down and could pass any time. Just before leaving late that night I whispered a lot of things in her ear. One thing I told her was that I hoped she could find a way to come back.

Note that the Elaine mentioned in the account below was her very dear and devoted friend. Elaine and I were also co-executors of her estate.

ACCOUNT OF WHAT HAPPENED ON 12-2-12

Note that the start of writing down this account was on 12-3-12, ~ 18 hours after the start of the event, and may not be precisely accurate.

Early in the day of Sunday 12-2-12, I'd had talks with both my co-executor Elaine, and nephew Kevin. Much of this had to do with getting her apartment ready to turn over to the building manager. I'd say the last talks came between 1 and 2 PM and following the last talk, I shortly came to have a brief but extreme grief episode. It was easily the most extreme grief episode I'd had in over a week, and possibly rivaled any I'd had since she died. Not long after that episode, I started playing the piano and a point soon came where I heard three evenly spaced sounds that were perhaps a little less that one second apart. Each sound was like that of the ring that comes when someone wraps a knife on a beverage glass (like at a wedding reception) and seemed to be coming from the kitchen, 25 feet away. But on investigation I could see nothing and even looked outside the house. The sound sequence repeated itself every 3 to 5 minutes. The sound seemed to be coming from the kitchen ceiling light fixture.

At this point I got thinking I probably have some kind of electrical situation, I called a trusted electrician I've known for years to get his opinion. He asked if this all happened near a smoke alarm. I told him No, and a dying battery in a smoke alarm was the only thing he could think of that might cause the ringing. So I felt some kind of electrical problem was unlikely.

A point soon came where I went back to the piano and started to play again. And as I did, the sound sequence came again. But it seemed to be louder with an insistence about it as if to say “Stop playing and pay attention”. I once more went into the kitchen and soon noted the sounds ( which now returned to the original tone volume) were moving and now seemed to be coming from a point near the ceiling that was about a yard away from the light fixture and in the direction of the family room. So it seemed that while the position of the sound stayed near the ceiling, it was moving. The sound also was now duller. So I walked over to a point that was directly under from where the sound was perceived to be last coming from, and waited for the sound to reoccur. To my shock, it now sounded from a point about 20 feet away from me near the piano and close to the stairs leading down to the foyer. Not long after this I went into the bedroom to take my usual afternoon nap which turned out to be a 3 hour nap. But before I went to sleep I heard the sound sequence again and it seemed to be coming from the kitchen, a distance of ~ 50 feet away. This was the last time I heard the sound. At this point I could think of no cause for the sound without invoking the paranormal.

After finishing the writing this account on 12-6-12, its occurred to me that a reader might ask “How could I just lie down and take a nap after what just happened?”. To that I'd have to say I had this feeling that there was nothing to fear, and at this point befuddlement was what I was mostly feeling. Also it was close to my usual nap time, and I was probably quite fatigued over what happened. I realize this is all hard to believe and something I would find ridiculous to believe if I'd read it about someone else. So I may engage the best lie detector person I can find to lend credibility to my story.
 
Without further investigation, it's impossible to know what you heard. I assume you were at your sister's place, correct? Had you spent much time there, enough so that you might have heard this sound if it had a natural cause? From your description, it sounds like you were the only one in the house and the only one that heard the sounds, correct?

I think without investigating further, ascribing a possible supernatural cause to the sound is premature. Could it have been a neighbor's wind chime, for example? You've clearly stated that you were (naturally) deeply grieving, so probably not in the best state of mind to properly look into this. I think given everything, it is much too premature to even speculate that you were getting some kind of "communication from the dead." Have you been back to the place since then?
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry for your loss. It sounds like it's affected you deeply.

While it'll be impossible to say with any certainty what you heard, one possible explanation is that auditory hallucinations are commonplace, and doubly so during moments of stress or grief. So much so that psychologists, neurologists and grief councillors consider them a normal part of the grieving process.

I wish you well.
 
May I please add my own condolences, attaboy?
I myself have had auditory hallucinations and know just how compelling they are.
All the best!
 
Without further investigation, it's impossible to know what you heard. I assume you were at your sister's place, correct? Had you spent much time there, enough so that you might have heard this sound if it had a natural cause? From your description, it sounds like you were the only one in the house and the only one that heard the sounds, correct?

I think without investigating further, ascribing a possible supernatural cause to the sound is premature. Could it have been a neighbor's wind chime, for example? You've clearly stated that you were (naturally) deeply grieving, so probably not in the best state of mind to properly look into this. I think given everything, it is much too premature to even speculate that you were getting some kind of "communication from the dead." Have you been back to the place since then?

This happened at my home, a seven hour drive away from her former home. I have lived here fifteen years and was the only one in the house. My home is distant enough from my only near by neighbor that sounds from that source can be ruled out in this case. I would like to point out that I am a retired PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist, and not prone to believing stories like the one I've told here.
 
I'm sorry for your loss. It sounds like it's affected you deeply.

While it'll be impossible to say with any certainty what you heard, one possible explanation is that auditory hallucinations are commonplace, and doubly so during moments of stress or grief. So much so that psychologists, neurologists and grief councillors consider them a normal part of the grieving process.

I wish you well.

Thanks for your condolences.
 
This happened at my home, a seven hour drive away from her former home. I have lived here fifteen years and was the only one in the house. My home is distant enough from my only near by neighbor that sounds from that source can be ruled out in this case. I would like to point out that I am a retired PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist, and not prone to believing stories like the one I've told here.

So then you know that you're not likely to get much support here for the idea that the noise you heard was your sister attempting to communicate with you. Several people have offered the most likely cause: auditory hallucinations. What does your "PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist" self tell you?
 
So then you know that you're not likely to get much support here for the idea that the noise you heard was your sister attempting to communicate with you. Several people have offered the most likely cause: auditory hallucinations. What does your "PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist" self tell you?

I knew I wouldn't get much support here which is one of the reasons I posted here. I was hoping for, and have already gotten, some alternate non-paranormal explanations for what I experienced. I was also hoping to get some ideas on how I could investigate this incident.

As for "What does your "PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist" self tell you?", I didn't think I'd need to explain that. Scientists are not as likely to believe something without proof and many paranormal phenomena are not well proven, ie - I'm not easily given to believing something unless there is solid proof. Also, I feel if one has what is termed a spiritual nature, they are more likely to believe in a paranormal explanation for strange events that are hard to explain.
 
Condolences on your loss.

Indoor acoustics can sometimes make it incredibly difficult to determine the location of a high-pitched sound. High pitches bounce extremely well from hard surfaces like walls, ceilings, and uncovered floors. Being unable to locate the sound's origin, or thinking it came from different places as you moved around the house, is actually pretty normal.

Squeaks and clinks and beeps can come from vibrations (you were playing the piano the first few times), or from electronics (smoke alarms, unset clocks on appliances), both of which are sometimes very hard to locate. Your description of the sound as resembling the clink of cutlery on a wine glass makes me wonder if glasses on a rack or in a cupboard are close enough together to clink when you play the piano or walk around the house.

If the sounds persist, and if your investigation persists, you will undoubtedly find the explanation before long. I'd recommend taking 1-2 other persons with you, so you can each stand in separate spots and compare ideas about the direction of the sound's origin. Don't also forget to look up and down (not just for devices near the ceilings or the floors, but other stories, and in the attic or basement).

My house has five smoke alarms downstairs. The batteries go out altogether too often, and the beep is quite annoying. It is almost impossible for me to tell which of them is beeping without soliciting my family to stand in different rooms waiting for the next beep. The last time this happened, it took us over an hour (with much arguing), until we finally thought to go into the attic, where a long-forgotten smoke alarm was beeping forlornly in its original packing box, sending the annoying sounds through the heating ducts to spread through the house. Because we could recognize the pitch and duration as being a smoke alarm, we knew to keep looking, and generally how to eliminate possibilities. Otherwise it might have been a real poser.
 
Last edited:
My sympathies to you, attaboy. I am sorry for your loss.

I once had a sort of similar experience.

My mother called me over to her house to help her investigate a beeping sound that was driving her crazy. She is hard of hearing and wears hearing aids, and this high pitched rythmic tone kept coming through her hearing aids and was very distracting to her.

I came in and also heard the sound. It was three or four faint "chimes" followed by a pause, then three or four "chimes" again. I looked all over the house, checked all the smoke alarms. I thought it sounded a lot like an alarm tone on a watch or small travel clock, and thought perhaps it was something like that stuffed in a drawer or bag or in a closet or something, so I spent a good while poking around in drawers and closets and the like. I would go to where I thought it sounded like the noise was coming from, but when I got there, it sounded like the noise was coming from a different part of the house.

Frustrated, after a while, I went outside to go have a smoke. It then became quite apparent what the noise was.

There was some construction going on a few streets over, and the sound was actually the "beep beep beep" of a piece of equipment going backwards. Picture a bucket loader or bobcat scraping a driveway. It goes forward for 3 or 4 seconds, then backs up for 3 or 4 seconds.

The sound inside the house was quite muffled. Im guessing some combination of wind, the sound coming through insulated walls or glass windows or air vents, and our own brains trying to think up what the sound could be that made us think it was something else.
 
Condolences on your loss.

Without independent confirmation or the discovery of a physical explanation (as some have suggested) my guess would be an audio hallucination.

I have personally experienced "my wife calling" on occasion. Sometimes under circumstances where she was too far away to actually do it. These are as real as Real to me when they happen.

(My wife claims it is my dead mother calling to me from the Great Beyond but why would my Mum imitate my wife? :boggled:)

The biggest Unknown in science is what's between our ears. ;)
 
This happened at my home, a seven hour drive away from her former home. I have lived here fifteen years and was the only one in the house. My home is distant enough from my only near by neighbor that sounds from that source can be ruled out in this case. I would like to point out that I am a retired PhD scientist, a virtual non-spiritual atheist, and not prone to believing stories like the one I've told here.


Let me add my condolences also. My only brother died four years ago and I well remember the sense of loss.

I was staying at his house both before and after he died (he had been in ICU for seven very painful -- for him and for his family -- weeks at the time of his death).

I must say that even if I had heard what you heard while I remained in his house, my first conclusion would not have been that this was a message from my sibling. If I couldn't have found the cause of the sound, I would have put that down to my failing, not to a supernatural cause.


xterra, who is also a retired PhD scientist and a non-spiritual atheist.
 
I was wrong, and am embarrassed!

On Saturday 1-5-13, I realized the reason for the sounds I heard did not come from a paranormal source. Please don't ask what the reason was so as to save me any further embarrassment. Let's just say it had to do with my lack of familiarity with some newly acquired equipment.
I apologize for needlessly involving all of you in this thread, and I thank you for the many kind condolences.
 
No need to apologise attaboy. You were grieving and in distress, which doesn't help clear thinking.
Anyway, losing a loved one will easily make the most rational of people start hoping just a little that there really is an afterlife and that their loved one isn't gone forever. That's why, after a death, so many people start thinking they're getting messages from the departed and even hallucinating their voices.

I can assure you that you have the sympathy of every one of us.
 
I'd also like to add my condolences and say that I'm pleased you've found the solution to the mystery. Please don't feel any embarrassment, most of us if we are honest has at some time considered, if only briefly, a supernatural explanation for something to which we later found a perfectly prosaic explanation. The right combination of circumstances can slide through the armour of the most rational brain, under your circumstances it is particually understandable.
 
There is no reason to apologise. You've not embarrassed yourself at all, merely demonstrated that you are just as human as the rest of us.
 
My condolences on your loss, Attaboy. As for feeling embarrassed, there's absolutely no reason for that feeling. In fact I admire your courage and honesty in making your admission.
 
No need for apologies or embarrassment, and well done for working out the real cause. Please accept my sincere condolences for your loss.
 
On Saturday 1-5-13, I realized the reason for the sounds I heard did not come from a paranormal source. Please don't ask what the reason was so as to save me any further embarrassment. Let's just say it had to do with my lack of familiarity with some newly acquired equipment.
I apologize for needlessly involving all of you in this thread, and I thank you for the many kind condolences.

Please don't apologise for that, attaboy!
Finding explanations for what happens in this marvelous world of ours is why I enjoy this forum so much.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom