• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Clever Monkeys

arthwollipot

Limerick Purist
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
102,714
Location
Ngunnawal Country
Nice phone: Bali’s thieving monkeys can spot high-value items to ransom

Study finds macaques go for tourists’ electronics and wallets over empty bags and then maximise their profit


At the Uluwatu temple in Bali, monkeys mean business. The long-tailed macaques who roam the ancient site are infamous for brazenly robbing unsuspecting tourists and clinging on to their possessions until food is offered as ransom payment.

Researchers have found they are also skilled at judging which items their victims value the most and using this information to maximise their profit.

Shrewd macaques prefer to target items that humans are most likely to exchange for food, such as electronics, rather than objects that tourists care less about, such as hairpins or empty camera bags, said Dr Jean-Baptiste Leca, an associate professor in the psychology department at the University of Lethbridge in Canada and lead author of the study.

...

After spending more than 273 days filming interactions between the animals and temple visitors, researchers found that the macaques would demand better rewards – such as more food – for higher-valued items.

Bargaining between a monkey robber, tourist and a temple staff member quite often lasted several minutes. The longest wait before an item was returned was 25 minutes, including 17 minutes of negotiation. For lower-valued items, the monkeys were more likely to conclude successful bartering sessions by accepting a lesser reward.

This seems to me to be quite sophisticated behaviour. Not being very good at searching such things I was unable to find the paper this article cites, even searching the lead author's name in Google Scholar. Can anyone do better than me?
 
This link work?

https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=t6MWLEgAAAAJ&hl=en#d=gs_md_cita-d&u=%2Fcitations%3Fview_op%3Dview_citation%26hl%3Den%26user%3Dt6MWLEgAAAAJ%26cstart%3D20%26pagesize%3D80%26citation_for_view%3Dt6MWLEgAAAAJ%3AJ_g5lzvAfSwC%26tzom%3D420


Social influence on the expression of robbing and bartering behaviours in Balinese long-tailed macaques

Authors
Fany Brotcorne, Anna Holzner, Lucía Jorge-Sales, Noëlle Gunst, Alain Hambuckers, I Nengah Wandia, Jean-Baptiste Leca
Yes it does. Thanks. It's behind a paywall, but I can read the abstract at least.

ETA: It doesn't appear to be the same article. This describes the social influence on the RB behaviour, but the abstract doesn't mention the value of the stolen items. Is this perhaps a case of a journalist noticing a minor point in the paper, that the paper wasn't actually about, and publishing as though it is the most important point?
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Here's the Conclusion:

Token-robbing and token/reward-bartering are cognitively challenging tasks for the Uluwatu macaques that revealed unprecedented economic decision-making processes (i.e. valued-based token selection and payoff maximization) in a large monkey population living in an anthropogenically impacted habitat. This spontaneous, population-specific, prevalent, cross-generational, learned and socially influenced practice may be the first example of a culturally maintained token economy in free-ranging animals. The present naturalistic research setting represents a unique opportunity to study field economics and explore macroeconomic phenomena in non-human primates in environmental conditions that are more externally and ecologically valid than those provided by the traditional token exchange paradigm. Further experimental research on the Uluwatu macaques should make future cross-species comparisons of economic decision-making and symbolic tool use more relevant from an evolutionary perspective and may ultimately lead to a better understanding of the origins of autonomous monetary systems in humans [29].

Fascinating.
 
This is incredible!

It might be to be an adaptation after the lockdowns everywhere meant their tourist feeding them dried up, except it looks like it started years before.

ETA: it's easy to see how this evolved. Macaque steals tourist item, tourist tries to lure them back with food.
 
Last edited:
I'm skeptical just because it's so tempting to believe at face value (the paper).
But they've got 5-6 months to get some more data. "Cheeky monkeys" eh? Good on them.
What I do know when we return, regarding the many once populated "wild animal attraction" plazas etc. ... we're ******.
[emoji1]
 
So what is their preferred high-valued food payment? In case you really need your phone back fast ...
 
So what is their preferred high-valued food payment? In case you really need your phone back fast ...
I suspect "bananas"... is a trap. [emoji1]

Hell, what do ya got? Huh?
What's in the bag?
Hey! Don't run away!
What's in the purse? WHAT'S IN THE PURSE??? [emoji15][emoji20][emoji15]
 
The clever monkeys steal the food. Stealing valuable objects is useless for a tourist that has no food to give.
 
This is incredible!

It might be to be an adaptation after the lockdowns everywhere meant their tourist feeding them dried up, except it looks like it started years before.

ETA: it's easy to see how this evolved. Macaque steals tourist item, tourist tries to lure them back with food.
Some years ago the park in Merrion Square in Dublin had a squirre, a grey with a white patch on his tail, quite distinctive, who learned to pose for tourist photos.
He'd perch on a large chunk of granite, near the Wilde statue, and stand still there in exchange for food.
 
I remember on my first trip to the US, my hosts took me to La Brea Tarpits and I saw my first squirrel. I approached to take a photo and hcmom said "careful, it might have rabies".

You can bet I stopped in my tracks.
I don't think a human has ever gotten rabies from a squirrel and squirrels themselves hardly every acquire it.
 

Back
Top Bottom