Church's 'offensive' anti-atheist billboard is banned by advertising watchdog

Rrose Selavy

Stranded in Sub-Atomica
Joined
Sep 11, 2004
Messages
3,395
Ok I know this is the Daily Mail but couldn't find much elsewhere.
SA ad watchdog bans "empty headed" Atheist poster.
You can see the poster in the link.


A church advertising campaign that depicted atheists as stupid has been banned by a watchdog in South Africa.
Officials ruled a billboard that suggested non-believers considered their existence to be accidental was likely to be found offensive.
The advertisement, which had been erected beside a church in Johannesburg, was pulled down following the ruling by South Africa's Advertising Standards Authority.


The offending poster showed a picture of a man holding his hands against his temples in thought above the line 'An atheist is a man who believes himself to be an accident', famously attributed to British poet Francis Thompson.
It was erected last year in a prominent position on the property of the Rivers Church in the Sandton suburb of Johannesburg.
However, the ASA noted that it was obliged to consider the advertisement's content after it received a complaint from a non-Christian member of the public.
Laying out its judgement on the matter, the authority stated that the complainant, Eugene Gerber, felt offended by the suggestion he was stupid.
The ruling stated: 'In essence, the complainant submitted that the billboard offends him as an atheist as he does not consider his existence to be an accident.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...anned-advertising-watchdog.html#ixzz1jic3ZdsE
 
This is exactly the sort of "attack" ad that would be inappropriate as a Holiday display -- the kind of ad that atheists try to put up at Holiday displays in the US every year.
 
so what would be an equal and fair response ?
how about a man holding a head full of crap with the line, "this mans religion was invented by iron age Jews and based on bronze age science"
think the xtians would be ok with that ?
:D
 
Not offensive, stupid. Or empty-headed as described but why ban it?
 
I didn't get it at first. The guy complained the ad implied atheists were stupid. The ASA judgement said they believed he was offended because he doesn't believe himself to be an accident. I couldn't see why that would upset an atheist.

It was only when I followed the link and saw the poster that it fell into place: the Daily Mail quote didn't say that the guy in the poster has an empty head.

I think it was right that the ad was ruled offensive, but I really don't think the ASA understood why it offended.
 
Well, I do consider my existence to be an accident.

The sign does not offend me.

If they said I eat babies I would be offended.
 
I didn't get it at first. The guy complained the ad implied atheists were stupid. The ASA judgement said they believed he was offended because he doesn't believe himself to be an accident. I couldn't see why that would upset an atheist.

It was only when I followed the link and saw the poster that it fell into place: the Daily Mail quote didn't say that the guy in the poster has an empty head.

I think it was right that the ad was ruled offensive, but I really don't think the ASA understood why it offended.

Agreed, I find the empty head offensive not the word accident.
 
That's not offensive at all. One's existence is accidental. And the flat-top head is a good place to put your cup of coffee when your hands are full.
 
Ok I know this is the Daily Mail but couldn't find much elsewhere.
SA ad watchdog bans "empty headed" Atheist poster.
You can see the poster in the link.




Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...anned-advertising-watchdog.html#ixzz1jic3ZdsE
Being an atheist myself I have to agree with the billboard. Evolution could have taken several directions being a random process. Anything could have happened but here we are human beings.

The billboard is right but not in the way the church thinks it is.

I don't think humans came about by accident I know we did.
 
Yeah, it's not so offensive. I suppose the empty head graphic is the only potentially offensive part of the ad (and I suspect intentionally so).

The quote itself is actually thought provoking. Our existence is quite accidental. An open minded theist might actually stop and think about the assumptions he's been making about his existence. When I was a believer, this sort of thing would make me stop and think, and eventually I realized how artificial the foundation of my belief was.
 
I don't agree with the law that says advertising can't offend anyone, but I do think the 'accident' bit is an implication that evolution=accidental, which just isn't accurate. However, who knows what they're really on about.

In America we get to enjoy billboards that imply that a kid who isn't raised to believe in God is likely to shoot you and that ask us why we hate America. I think these sorts of signs actually benefit us, because it's so easy to prove they're lies, with ourselves as examples.
 
The sign does not offend me.

Furthermore, even if I were offended, I don't believe I have a "right" to not be offended. The right to free expression outweighs the desire to not be offended. There should be no law against blasphemy just are there should be no law against saying rude things about atheists. I'm willing to tolerate the latter to enjoy the former.
 
Being an atheist myself I have to agree with the billboard. Evolution could have taken several directions being a random process. Anything could have happened but here we are human beings.

The billboard is right but not in the way the church thinks it is.

I don't think humans came about by accident I know we did.

Evolution has a random element (genetic variation), but natural selection is not random, so evolution itself is not a random process, which is why organisms are predictably adapted to the environment in which they evolved. You are right that evolution could have taken other terms, for instance our evolution would have been greatly affected if there hadn't been a mutation that weakened the jaw muscles of our hominid ancestors over a million years ago. I admit to being pedantic on this topic due to so many creationists looking for 'aha!' moments.
 
Evolution has a random element (genetic variation), but natural selection is not random, so evolution itself is not a random process, which is why organisms are predictably adapted to the environment in which they evolved. You are right that evolution could have taken other terms, for instance our evolution would have been greatly affected if there hadn't been a mutation that weakened the jaw muscles of our hominid ancestors over a million years ago. I admit to being pedantic on this topic due to so many creationists looking for 'aha!' moments.

But I think it's random in the sense that if we should find another planet similar to Earth where life evolved independently, we probably would not find the same species as on Earth. They might use the same DNA and/or RNA just as all life forms on earth use, but the sequences would be different.
 
Well, I do consider my existence to be an accident.

The sign does not offend me.

If they said I eat babies I would be offended.

Um, yeah. What on earth is offensive about that sign, including the image? I don't get it at all.

It's actually generally accurate; atheists do tend to be humble about their origins. We already know that Christians think they're superior to everyone and every thing on earth, so why shouldn't they say so on a bulletin board?

But then, I'm one of the ones who thought the atheist holiday sign was just fine too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom